Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 62928 (KAR)
GANGAMMA W/O LATE GUNDAPPA GANDGE AND OTRS v. VIJAYKUMAR S/O LATE GUNDAPPA AND OTRS
RSA/200060/2014 · 2025-10-10
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62928 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62928 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$##
%%
&%' (
! "#$
%
&'
%
#$
%
('
% #$
))
%
#$
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
)
#*
+
))
"#$
%
#$
) %
% #$
,
"%% + -). % '!')'(
%
&
%
%
% #$
%
(
% #"
) %/
%
&
%
- 3 -
#"
( % %
% #"
! %
%
#
,
"
% +
(. % + -! +
'' +
%
!( '
')
+
+
)' ''(
!'&'
+ % $ +
++
+ + %
0
$#
" 0
12 34567829 :23789 442; 6: <6;29 => 512 ?8:?332::<?; 92<28985: @17 1A2 B?2:567829 512
- 4 -
3783?CC285 <68968D: 89 923C22: C2892C29 => 512 7?C5:
=2;7@ @12C268 512 4;6856<<:0 :?65 :22E68D 512 C2;62< 7< 4C5656786:923C229
+7C 512 :E2 7< 378A2862832 512 4C562: C2 C2<2CC2957:42C5126CC8E=2<7C25125C6;7?C5
) 12<F6;>5C226::?892C
"
"+
"
+
%
%
"
+
"
+ )"
+ (
" %" ++ ++
( 12<35:;2968D575123:2C2:?892C
82 ?894489D2:17@8 : 4C747:65?:19 @6<2=>8F27<8DFF12>1951C22:78:8F2;> %6G> E?FC 22;E8544 89 :ACG 12 4C2:285
- 5 -
4;6856<<: @17 C2 512 @6<2 89 316;9C28 7< %6G>E?FC 2;92C :78 7< 4C747:65?: ?8944 89D2 <6;29 512 4C565678 :?65 3;6F68D 515 ;; 512 :?65 :3129?;2 4C742C562: C2 512 G7685 <F6;> 832:5C; 4C742C562: 12 4C2:285 :?65 6: <6;29 ;;2D68D 515 92<28985 7 @17 6: 5121?:=897<4;6856<<7)89<512C7<4;6856<<:89 6: 3568D 9A2C:2;> 57 5126C 6852C2:5 89 1: D6<529 782 832:5C; 4C742C5> 68 <A7?C 7< 92<28985 7! 12 4;6856<<: 1A2 ;:7 378528929 515 92<28985 7 1:
51C7@8 7?5 512 4;6856<<: <C7F 512 FC65; 17F2 89 4;6856<<:1A23;6F29F68528832@12C268F68528832 7<:!!' $2316:@C929575124;6856<<:124;6856<<: 1A2<6;295124C2:285:?65::2C568D51592<289857 @: 6837F425285 57 2H23?52 512 D6<5 9229 68 <A7?C 7< 92<28985 7! 89 12832 512 4C2:285 4C565678 :?65 6: <6;29
! 8 C232645 7< :?FF78: 512 92<28985:
52892C29 442C832 89 :57?5;> 928629 512 2856C2 A2CF285:F92685124;6852<28985:57(78512
- 6 -
3785CC>3;6F29515512C26:872H6:528327<G7685<F6;> 89 512 :?65 :3129?;2 4C742C562: C2 875 512 G7685 <F6;> 832:5C;4C742C562:1292<28985:;:7378528929515 68:7<C : ?CA2> 7!( ) 6: 37832C829 65 6: 512 :5C22918 4C742C5> 7< 92<28985 7 89 512C2<7C2 6: 875A6;=;2<7C4C565678
& 7515124C562:4?C:?8557<CF68D7<6::?2: =>5125C6;7?C5;29687C;89973?F285C>2A69283268 :?447C57<5126C3785285678:;6856<<:68;;2HF6829<7?C @6582::2: : : 57 ( 89 C2;629 78 ) 973?F285:
FCE29:
H:57)1292<28985:2HF68295@7 @6582::2:::8989C2;62978
H:89
12 5C6; 7?C5 78 44C6:; 7< 7C; 89 973?F285C>2A6928328:@2C296::?27:8968512 <<6CF56A2 89 6::?2 7) 4C5;> 68 512 <<6CF56A2 89 @16;2 8:@2C68D ::?2 7!
68 512 82D56A2 12;9 515 92<28985: 1A2 <6;29 57 4C7A2 515 >7!( ) 6: 512 :5C229184C742C5>7<92<289857 - 7 - I 2<28985 7 %6G>E?FC 1?:=89 7< 4;6856<<7)<6;29C2D?;C442;687!( '@16;2 92<28985 7 89 7512C 92<28985: <6;29 3C7::$442;: B?2:567868D;;75F2857<:1C268:7<C:?CA2>7!( ) @1631 6: 652F 7 7< :?65 :3129?;2 4C742C562: 12 442;;527?C53783?CC29@651512<68968D:89C2:7868D: ::6D829=>5125C6;7?C578:2B?285;>512442;89 3C7::$442;:@2C296:F6::29 J 16:442;6:<6;29=>92<28985:57(16: 442; 378<682: 57 652F 7 =2C68D ?CA2> 7!( ) 1292<28985:3;6F515516:652F7"!( )F2:?C68D &' 3C2: 6: 512 =:7;?52 4C742C5> 7< 8DFF @17 6812C6529 512 4C742C5> <C7F 12C F7512C %22CFF 89 512C2<7C2652F76:875A6;=;2<7C4C565678 ' 16:7?C5A6927C92C9529('(9F65529 512 442; 89 <7CF?;529 512 <7;;7@68D :?=:5856; B?2:56787<;@ - 8 - 12512C512C6;7?C56:G?:56<6296817;968D515 512 ;89 =2C68D >7!( ) 6: 875 512 5C22918 4C742C5>7<92<289857K 12512C512G?9DF28589923C224::29=>512 7?C5:=2;7@C2B?6C26852C<2C2832K 2C9 512 ;2C829 37?8:2; 442C68D <7C 512 92<28985: 89 512 ;2C829 37?8:2; 442C68D <7C 512 4;6856<<: 16: 7?C5 1: =2:57@29 65: 8H67?: 378:692C5678 57 512 G?9DF285: C2892C29 => =751 512 7?C5:=2;7@16:7?C51:;:7F2563?;7?:;>2HF6829 512 4;2968D: 68 512 4;685 89 @C65528 :552F285 89 2A692832;2568=>=7515124C562: )*+)*,*-./0120-3*-)3451/0-)*436738/+29 -.)017- 12:17C5476855158229:378:692C56785512 189:7<516:7?C56::57@12512C4;6856<<:C228565;29 <7C :1C2 68 ?CA2> 7!( ) 8 4C565678 :?65 512 68656;=?C9286:;@>:785124;6856<<:5792F78:5C52512 - 9 - 2H6:528327<?896A6929G7685689?<F6;>895128?3;2?: 1268656;=?C9286:785124;6856<<:5792F78:5C52515 512:?65:3129?;24C742C562:C2512G7685<F6;>832:5C; 4C742C562: ;6856<<: 512F:2;A2: 1A2 4C79?329 512 C2A28?2C237C9:42C56868D57;;512<7?C652F: H6: 68 C2:4235 7< ?CA2> 7!( ) 62 652F 7 7< :?65 :3129?;2 4C742C562: @1631 6: 9F65529;> :58968D 68 512 8F2 7<8DFF 92<28985 7 <: 42C4;6856<<:0 A2C:6786<652F76:;:7G7685<F6;>832:5C;4C742C5> 65 @: 683?F=285 78 512 4C5 7< 512 4;6856<<: 57 4C79?32 C2;2A85 973?F285C> 2A692832 57 92F78:5C52 515 652F 7 @: ;:7 7@829=> 7C6D68; 4C747:65?:?8944 7C ?89440: <512C H3245 =;9 A2CF285: 68 512 4;685 512C2C2=:7;?52;>87973?F285C>2A69283299?329=> 512 4;6856<<: 57 :?=:585652 515 652F 7 6: ;:7 G7685 <F6;>832:5C;4C742C5> ) 12 <35 515 652F 7 6: <7?89 57 =2 2H3;?:6A2;> :58968D 68 512 8F2 7< 92<28985 7 8DFF5124C2:?F456786:515516:4C742C5>6: - 10 - 512 :5C22918 4C742C5> 7< 92<28985 7 8 3;7:2C 2HF685678 7< 3C7::$2HF685678 7< 65 6: 3;2C;> 2A692855154;6856<<7)@176:2HF6829:1: 9F65529 68 ?82B?6A73; 52CF: 515 652F 7 @: 7C6D68;;> 7@829 => %22CFF @17 6: 8782 7512C 518 512 F7512C 7< 92<28985 7 8DFF 16: 6: 875 :5C> 9F6::678 16: 9F6::678 D72: 57 512 C775 7< 512 3:2 89 65 6: 512 3783;?:6A2 9F6::678 @1631 6: <5; 57 512 4;6856<<:0 3;6F 7A2C 652F 7 4C742C5> 8 3;7:2C 2HF685678 7< 512 <68968D: C237C929 => 5C6; 7?C5 78 ::?2 7 516: 7?C5 @7?;9 <689 515 512C2 6: 87 4C742C 44C2365678 7< 2A692832 89 512 5C6; 7?C5 1: ;:7 875 2HF6829512:255;294C747:656787<;@51568656;=?C928 6: ;@>: 78 512 4;6856<<: 68 512 4C565678 :?65 57 92F78:5C52515512:?65:3129?;24C742C562:C2512G7685 <F6;> 832:5C; 4C742C562: 16;2 92<28985: 1A2 D6A28 ?4 5126C 3;6F 68 C2:4235 7< 7512C 51C22 4C742C562: 65 6:
5126C:4236<633;6F68:7<C:652F76:37832C829515 656:512:2;<3B?6C294C742C5> :5C229184C742C5>7<5126C - 11 - F7512C92<289857 8DFF124;6856<<:1A68D <6;29 57 4C79?32 973?F285C> 2A692832 57 :?=:585652 515 516: 652F 7 @: ;:7 7C6D68;;> 7@829 => 26512C 4C747:65?:?89447C?89440:832:57C89512<35 515 652F 7 @: 2H3;?:6A2;> :58968D 68 512 8F2 7< 8DFF ;; ;78D 8968 =:28327< C2=?55; 2A692832 =>5124;6856<<:5737?852C516::4235516:7?C56:7<512 A62@ 515 =751 512 7?C5: C2 :@>29 => 512 9F65529 C2;5678:164 =25@228 4;6856<<: 89 92<28985: 89 =751 5127?C5:1A23783?CC285;>2CC2968DC8568D:1C268512 :2;<3B?6C294C742C5>7<8DFF17?D18DFF 6: C247C529 57 =2 929 89 512 37?8:2; 442C68D <7C 92<28985:6:::2C568D515:121:2H23?529C2D6:52C29 D6<5922968<A7?C7<7827<12C9?D152C$68$;@512:69 476856:7<87378:2B?2832 832656:8756329515652F 7 6: 512 :5C22918 4C742C5> 7< 92<28985 7 512 4;6856<<: 37?;9 875 1A2 F6856829 4C565678 :?65 68 C2:4235 7< 652F 7 17?D1 4;6856<<: C2 28565;29 <7C :1C2 68 7512C 4C742C562: =751 512 7?C5: 1A2 - 12 - 3783?CC285;> 2CC29 68 DC8568D :1C2 68 C2:4235 7< 652F 74C742C5>@16;25122A69283278C237C937?4;29@651 5129F6::6782;636529685123C7::$2HF6856787<4;6856<< 7 ) 2HF6829 : 3;68312: 512 565;2 7A2C 652F 7 4C742C5> 832 9?D152C$68$;@ 9F65: 515 652F 7 @: 7C6D68;;> 7@829 => %22CFF 89 <?C512C :6832 512C2 6: 87 96:4?52 515 92<28985 7 6: 512 9?D152C 7< %22CFF 512<68968D 7<=751512 7?C5: 68 DC8568D :1C2 68 652F 7 4C742C5> :?<<2C: <C7F 42CA2C:65>337C968D;>512:?=:5856;B?2:56787<;@6: 8:@2C296851282D56A2 ( +7C 512 <7C2D768D C2:78: 516: 7?C54C73229: 574::512<7;;7@68D "6 12:23789442;6:;;7@29 "66 12 G?9DF285 89 923C22 68 C7:: 442; 68 7!( '9529 ')4::29=>5127?C5 7< 99; 6:5C635 89 2::678: ?9D2 5 69C 89 512 G?9DF285 89 923C22 7< 512 5C6; 7?C5 68 7)' ''( 9529 !'&' 4::29 => 512 - 13 - 7?C5 7< 99; 2867C 6A6; ?9D2 5 69C F4 5 ?C9$C212C2=>F796<629 "666 12 4C2;6F68C> 923C22 DC8529 => =751 512 7?C5: 68 C2:4235 7< 512 :?65 <6;29 => 512 4;6856<<: :589: 96:F6::29 68:7<C : 652F 7 ?CA2> 7!( ) F2:?C68D & 3C2: 7@2A2C 512 4C2;6F68C>923C22DC8568D! (I51:1C2574;6856<<:
89 231 68 ! &51 :1C2 7< 92<28985 7 68 7512C 652F: 7< :?65 :3129?;2 4C742C562: :589: 378<6CF29
"6A <<63257 9C@512 F796<629 4C2;6F68C>923C22 337C968D;>
+: &##' $
6:57;7(