Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 62924 (KAR)
AMEERVALI S/O KHASIM SAB v. MAHABOOB SUBHANI
RSA/200387/2022 · 2025-11-28
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62924 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62924 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#"$""
%%
&'$( )
! "##
$ %
&
'#
! (
" #
$ # )
%
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
## # # % *#
##
+ # * * *# * !+
+ !% #
, # #'
%# ,
## *'
,*
$" $#
,* %
-./ 011203 ./ 45 6-2 728297096 42.9: 0::;.2<27 45 6-2 =>7:?296 097 72@;22 70627 + 10//27 .9 A $37 A!+ !% A9 6-2 8.32 A8 29.A;
.<.3 *>7:2 097 * .97-09>; /.66.9: 06 09<. $8A;
/-A;6 B6-2 .;/6 11233062 A>;6C% 45 D-.@- 6-2 .;/6 11233062 A>;6 D-.32 033AD.9: 6-2 011203 8.327 45 6-2 130.96.88 ;2/1A97296 -2;2.9 /26 0/.72 6-2 =>7:?296 097 72@;22 70627 + ! 10//27 .9 A!+ A9
- 3 -
6-28.32A86-2.<.3*>7:2097*09<.$8A;/-A;6B6-2 ;.03 A>;6C% 097 @A9/2E>29635 72@;227 6-2 />.6 72@30;.9:
6-2 130.96.88 6A 42 6-2 AD92; A8 6-2 />.6 1;A12;6.2/ 097 @A9/2E>29635 .//>27 12;?09296 .9=>9@6.A9 ;2/6;0.9.9: 728297096 011233096 -2;2.9 8;A? .962;82;.9: D.6- 6-2 1A .A9A86-2130.96A<2;6-2/>.61;A12;6.2/
-2 04A<2 />.6 .9 A!+ 8.327 45 6-2 130.96.88 /22F.9: ;23.28 A8 72@30;06.A9 097 .9=>9@6.A9 097 ;2@6.8.@06.A9 A8 ;2@A;7/ A8 ;.:-6 .9 ;2/12@6 A8 3097 420;.9: 5A ?20/>;.9: ! 0@;2/ :>960/ 097 3097 .9 5A ! ?20/>;.9: ! 0@;2/ ! :>960/ /.6>0627 06 0;@-09>;.330:209<. ! -2@0/2A86-2130.96.88./6-066-2/>.6/@-27>32 1;A12;65 ./ A;.:.90335 -237 097 1A 27 45 -./ 806-2; F9AD9097@033270/A?405??0990 A072 04
2 -07 ;23.9E>./-27 -./ ;.:-6/ .9 80<A>; A8 -./ 2372; /A9 0?=09/04 D-A D0/ 60F.9: @0;2 A8 6-2 0880.;/ A8 6-2 80?.35 .9 6-2 @010@.65 A8 2372; /A9 -2 ;2<29>2 ;2@A;7/ D2;2 2962;27 .9 6-2 90?2 A8 -./ 4;A6-2; 0?=09/04 9
- 4 -
6-27206-A8806-2;A86-2130.96.88-./4;A6-2;0?=09/04 D0/ ;2/.7.9: D.6- 6-2 130.96.88
2 D0/ >9?0;;.27 097 ;2?0.92740@-23A;7>;.9:-./3.826.?2#30.96.88D0/60F.9:
@0;2 A8 -./ 92@2//.6.2/ .9 6-2 @010@.65 A8 7>65 4A>97 5A>9:2;4;A6-2;972;6-2@.;@>?/609@2//0.70?=09/04 2G2@>6270:.867227$
.4090?0%.9;2/12@6A86-2/0.7/>.6 1;A12;65 097 723.<2;27 6-2 1A .A9 A8 6-2 /0?2 .9 80<A>;A86-2130.96.88A9.96.88./.9120@28>3 1A .A909729=A5?296A86-21;A12;652<2;/.9@26-29 -A>:-6-2130.96.88-07/A>:-68A;-./90?26A422962;27 .9 6-2 ;2<29>2 ;2@A;7/ 6-2 0>6-A;.6.2/ 72@3.927 6A 2962; -./90?20/6-2:.867227D0/9A60;2:./62;277A@>?296 -06 6-2 728297096 ./ 6-2 AD92; A8 07=0@296 3097 097 ./ 9A6 @A9@2;927 095D05 D.6- 6-2 />.6 /@-27>32 1;A12;65 .9 095 ?0992;
AD2<2; -2 ./ 0662?16.9: 6A .962;82;2 D.6- 6-2 120@28>3 1A .A9 097 29=A5?296 A8 6-2 />.6 /@-27>321;A12;65A86-2130.96.88
2./@30.?.9:;.:-6A<2; 6-2/>.6/@-27>321;A12;65A96-21;262G6A8090:;22?296 A8 /032 .9 -./ 80<A>; 0332:2735 2G2@>627 45 6-2 130.96.88
- 5 -
A9/6;0.9.9: 6-2 130.96.88 6A 011;A0@- 6-2 A>;6 /22F.9: ;23.28A872@30;06.A9097.9=>9@6.A928297096A9;2@2.16A8 />??A9/ 6-A>:- 01120;27 6-;A>:- 6-2 @A>9/23 097 72/1.6242.9:1;A<.727/>88.@.296A11A;6>9.6.2/-0/9A68.327 D;.6629/6062?296
#30.96.882G0?.927-.?/2380/#'0972G-.4.627 !! 7A@>?296/ ?0;F27 0/ G/# 6A #!!
7A@>?296/ ?0;F27 0/ G/# 6A #!! #30.96.88 03/A 2G0?.927 6DA D.692//2/ .9 />11A;6 A8 -./ @0/2 0/ #'/ 097 ! 28297096 92.6-2; 8.327 D;.6629 /6062?296 9A; @;A//2G0?.9276-2D.692//2/-2;.03@A>;68;0?276-2 8A33AD.9:1A.968A;.6/@A9/.72;06.A9 '-26-2;6-2130.96.881;A<2/-2./296.63276A6-2 ;23.28C/@30.?27.96-2130.96H '-06A;72;A;72@;22H
-2 ;.03 A>;6 8A>97 6-06 6-A>:- 6-2 130.96.88 -0/1;A7>@27!!7A@>?296/.9@3>7.9:7227A8:.86-2-0/ 9A6 1;A7>@27 7A@>?296 6A /-AD -AD 6-2 -./ A?405 ??0?0990 A 072/04 0970?0=09/04 0@E>.;27 6-2
- 6 -
/>.6 1;A12;65 0/ .6 @;2062/ @3A>7 A<2; 6-2 7227 A8 :.86 1;A7>@2706G#!!.96-204/29@2A8;232<0966.6327227/ @@A;7.9:35 7./?.//27 6-2 />.6 2.9: 0::;.2<27 6-2 130.96.88 -0/ 1;282;;27 6-2 ;2:>30; 011203 .9 A $37 A!+ !% -2 .;/6 11233062 A>;68;0?276-28A33AD.9:1A.96/8A;.6/@A9/.72;06.A9 '-26-2; 6-2 130.96.88 1;A<2/ 6-06 6-2 4;A6-2; A8 6-2 130.96.88 -0/ 2G2@>627 0 :.86 7227 .9 -./ 80<A>; :.86.9:6-2/>.6/@-27>321;A12;6.2/.9-./80<A>;H
'-26-2;6-2130.96.881;A<2/6-066-2728297096./ .962;82;.9:D.6--./1A .A909729=A5?296A86-2 />.6/@-27>321;A12;6.2/H
! '-26-2; 011233096 130.96.88 1;A<2/ 6-06 6-2 =>7:2?296 097 72@;22 A8 6-2 6;.03 @A>;6 ./ 9A6 .9 0@@A;709@2D.6-30D097.6./12;<2;/2H
'-26-2; 011233096 130.96.88 1;A<2/ 6-06 6-2 .962;82;29@2A86-./@A>;6./<2;5?>@-92@2//0;56A 6-2=>7:?29609772@;22A86-26;.03@A>;6H
'-06A;72;A;72@;22H
+ 9 ;2011;2@.06.A9 A8 6-2 2<.729@2 6-2 .;/6 11233062 A>;6 09/D2;27 1A.96 A/ 6A .9 6-2 088.;?06.<2 097 @A9/2E>29635 033AD27 6-2 011203 097
- 7 -
72@;227 6-2 />.6 2.9: 0::;.2<27 45 6-2 /0?2 6-2 728297096./428A;26-./A>;6 ( 20;927 @A>9/23 8A; 6-2 011233096 60F.9: 6-./ A>;6 6-;A>:- 6-2 ;2@A;7 />4?.6/ 6-06 6-A>:- 6-2 011233096 728297096-0/9A68.327D;.6629/6062?296.6D0/ .9@>?4296 A9 6-2 130.96.88 6A -0<2 1;A<27 6-2 @0/2 .9 0 ?0992;F9AD96A30D .9@26-2130.96.88-0/9A61;A7>@27 6-27A@>?296/A86.6322.6-2;A8-./806-2;A;A8-./4;A6-2; 6-2;.03A>;6-0/;.:-6357./?.//276-2/>.6D-.@-A>:-6 9A66A-0<24229;2<2;/27456-2.;/611233062A>;6
2 8>;6-2; />4?.6/ 6-06 6-2 011233096 -07 9A A11A;6>9.65 A8 1;2/296.9:-./@0/2-2D20F92//A86-2728297096A>:-6 9A66A-0<242296-2:;A>978A;6-2.;/611233062A>;6 6A 72@;22 6-2 />.6 -06 ?2;2 ;2<29>2 ;2@A;7/ @A>37 9A6 @A982; 095 6.632 -2 :.86 7227 9A6 42.9: ;2:./62;27 @A>37 9A6 -0<2 4229 ;23.27 >1A9 45 6-2 .;/6 11233062 A>;6 -2;28A;2 -2 />4?.6/ />4/6096.03 E>2/6.A9 A8 30D DA>37 0;./2 8A; @A9/.72;06.A9 097 /22F/ 8A; 033AD.9: A8 6-2 011203
- 8 -
20;927 @A>9/23 8A; ;2/1A97296 01120;.9:
6-;A>:- 6-2 <.72A @A982;29@2 />4?.6/ 6-06 6-2 =>7:?296 09772@;2210//27456-2.;/611233062A>;6@099A642 8A>9780>36D.6-0/6-2;2./9A;24>66036A6-22<.729@2327 .9 45 6-2 130.96.88 -2;2 ./ @A9/./6296 097 >97./6>;427 296;.2/.96-2;2<29>2;2@A;7/0976-2;2./9A;20/A99A6 6A;235>1A96-2/0?2-060/6-2>9;2:./62;27:.867227 ./ 12;?.//.432 >972; 6-2 12;/A903 30D/ :A<2;9.9: 6-2 10;6.2/ 6-2 /0?2 9227 9A6 42 ;2:./62;27 A />4/6096.03 E>2/6.A9A830DDA>370;./28A;@A9/.72;06.A9
29@2/22F/ 8A;7./?.//03A86-2011203 & 20;712;>/276-2;2@A;7/
#30.96.88-0//A>:-68A;;23.28A872@30;06.A9097 .9=>9@6.A9 @30.?.9: 6A 42 6-2 AD92; A8 6-2 />.6 /@-27>32 1;A12;65.962;?/A8:.867227$
.4090?0%2G2@>62745-./ 4;A6-2;0?=09/04A9&D-.@-./1;A7>@27097 ?0;F27 06 G#!! 0/2 A8 6-2 130.96.88 ./ 6-06 6-2 />.6 /@-27>321;A12;65A;.:.90335423A9:276A-./806-2;A?405
- 9 -
??0990 A 072/04 D-A .9 6>;9 -07 :.<29 .6 6A -./ 2372; /A90?=09/04D-A ./ 4;A6-2; A8 6-2130.96.88 -06 -./ 4;A6-2; D0/ 40@-23A; D-A .9 6>;9 -07 2G2@>627 6-2 :.86 7227 06 G#!! #30.96.88 -0/ 03/A 1;A7>@27 ;2<29>2 ;2@A;7/ 06 G# 6A #!!
#2;>/03 A8 D-.@- .97.@062 6-2 90?2A8-./806-2;A?405??0990 A072/0442.9: 42;2832@6278;A?6-2520;&++&>16A6-2520;& -2;20862; 6-2 90?2 A8 A92 0?=09/04 0/-0 ./ /-AD9D-A?6-2130.96.88 @30.?27 6A42-./4;A6-2;-2 90?2A8/0.70?=09/040/-0./;2832@6278;A?6-2520;
& ->/ 6-2 ;2<29>2 ;2@A;7/ @A9/./629635 ;2832@6 6-290?2/A8A?405??0990 A072/046-2806-2;
A8 6-2 130.96.88 097 6-2;20862; -./ 4;A6-2; 0?=09/04 0/-0-2;2./9A;24>6603A86-./2<.729@2A8095906>;2 D-06/A2<2;456-2728297096
G#!! ./ 6-2 :.86 7227 45
.4090?0 .9 ;7> 309:>0:2 6-2 6;09/306.A9 A8 D-.@- ./ 03/A 1;A7>@27 06 G#!-0/42292G2@>627450?=09/04.980<A>;A86-2 130.96.88-2.;/611233062A>;6-0/60F299A62A86-2/2
- 10 -
?062;.032<.729@2097;2@A;7/097-0/A1.9276-066-2;2./ 0 1;2/>?16.A9 >972; 2@6.A9 !! A8 6-2 0;9060F0 097 2<29>2 @6 ;2:0;7.9: @A;;2@692// A8 6-2 296;.2/ .9 >932//6-2/0?20;2;24>6627097.96-23.:-6A8728297096 9A6-0<.9:8.3270D;.6629/6062?296A;@;A//2G0?.9276-2 D.692//2/ A; ;24>66.9: 6-2 /0.7 ?062;.03 2<.729@2 6-2 0@@21604.3.65A86-2/0?2@099A6427A>4627
>;6-2; -2 .;/6 11233062 A>;6 ;282;;.9: 6A 6-2 =>7:?296 A8 6-2 12G A>;6 .9 6-2 @0/2 A8
-0/@A?26A6-2@A9@3>/.A96-06 2G2@>6.A9A809>9;2:./62;27:.867227./12;?.//.432>972; 6-212;/A90330D:A<2;9.9:6-210;6.2/.9E>2/6.A9 ! -2@A96296.A9A86-27282970966-06-2-079A A11A;6>9.65 6A 2.6-2; @A962/6 -./ @0/2 A; ;24>6 6-2 2<.729@2 03/A @099A6 42 @A>962909@27 .90/?>@- 0/ ;2@A;7/ .97.@062 6-06 6-2 728297096 -07 01120;27 428A;2 6-2;.03A>;66-;A>:--./@A>9/23-2/>.6D0/8.327A9
- 11 -
&! 097 -0/ 4229 7./1A/27 A9 + ! 28297096 -0/ 9A6 >6.3.I27 A11A;6>9.65 0/ -2 -0/ 92.6-2;
8.327 D;.6629 /6062?296 9A; -0/ @;A// 2G0?.927 6-2 D.692//2/-2/>.6-0/42297./?.//27456-2;.03A>;6 <29.96-20112038.327456-2130.96.88.9A
728297096 -0/ 01120;27 6-;A>:- 6-2 <2;5 /0?2 @A>9/23 -2 /0.7 011203 -0/ 4229 8.327 A9 ( ! 097 .6 -0/ 4229 7./1A/27 A8 A9 + -2;28A;2 6-;A>:- 8A; ?A;26-09520;/6-2011203D0/1297.9:428A;26-2.;/6 11233062A>;6728297096-0/9A6@0;276A60F2095/621/ 2.6-2;6A1;A/2@>62A;6A;24>66-2@0/2A86-2130.96
<29 .9 6-2 1;2/296 011203 D-.@- ./ 8.327 097 1297.9:/.9@2 6.337062728297096-0/?0729A 288A;66A130@2-./@0/2-2;28A;26-2@A96296.A9D-.@-./ <2-2?29635 >;:27 ;2:0;7.9: 728297096 9A6 -0<.9: A11A;6>9.656A728297-./@0/2@099A642@A>962909@27
9A6-2;0/12@6A86-2?0662;./6-066-21;2/296 011203 ./ 8.327 0862; 301/2 A8 + 705/ 03A9: D.6- 09
- 12 -
0113.@06.A9>972; 2@6.A9A86-2.?.606.A9@6<29.9 6-2088.70<.60@@A?1095.9:6-2/0.70113.@06.A96-2;2./9A D-./12;A8095906>;2D-06/A2<2;0/6A095;.:-66.632A;
.962;2/6 D-.@- 6-2 728297096 0332:2735 -0/ .9 6-2 />.6 /@-27>32 1;A12;65 G@216 /606.9: 6-06 -2 D0/ />882;.9:
8;A? A<.7& 7./20/2 097 6-06 -2 320;96 04A>6 6-2 033AD.9:A86-2011203A935D-29-2;2@2.<276-29A6.@2.9 6-2 2G2@>6.A9126.6.A9 9A6-.9: ./8A;6-@A?.9:9<.2DA8 6-204A<29A />4/6096.03E>2/6.A9 A8 30D DA>37 0;./2 8A; @A9/.72;06.A9 + 11203./0@@A;7.9:357./?.//27-2=>7:?296 097 72@;22 10//27 45 6-2 .;/6 11233062 A>;6 ./ @A98.;?27 *' &""( $
./6A 3A! #