Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 62922 (KAR)
HYDERABAD KARNATAKA EDUCATION SOCIETY v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203118/2025 · 2025-12-09
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62922 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62922 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" # $%
&$'!$!$
(!)
! " # $ %
&
%
'
%
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
(
%
"
#
$ &
' )
&
*
))
+ % ' &
%
,
, ! $
- 3 -
-././01-2 003/-.4 356/7/18 .0 9- 6 5-::-- /1 2-:;-3.0<561=9-62/1840(7-6:>2/18)632-: 8>1.6:?6@/189--18261.-=5-6:-942-:;01=-1.0/1 .?-4-62A')<026;-2/0=0< 4-62:/:9-<02-.?/:0>2. :--B/18<0550C/182-5/-<:,
!" #
$%&'" ('') *
+
*#, -#* . -621-= 30>1:-5 <02 .?- ;-././01-2: .6B/18 .?/: 0>2. .?20>8? .?- 2-302=: :>97/.: .?6. 01 61= 6<.-2 -D-3>./01 0< .?- 5-6:- =--= 94 .?- 2-:;01=-1..6.- /1 <6@0>20<.?-;-././01-201A'A.?-;-././01-2?6: 9--1/1-D35>:/@-;0::-::/0161=-1E047-1.0<:6/=62-6
?- 561= C6: =-7/:-= <02 .?- ;>2;0:- 0< 301:.2>3./01 0< 3055-8- 61= 655/-= -=>36./0165 /1:./.>./01:
- 4 -
?6. 652-6=4 .C0 9>/5=/18: 2>11/18 0< ?627634 61= -82--055-8-0< 2.:3/-13-61=077-23-62-?0>:-= /1.?-;02./0101:6/=;20;-2.4-:>97/.:.?6..?-2-C6: 6 :>/. </5-= 94 3-2.6/1 --26116 -..6
2>:. #<02 :?02. F
2>:.G&/10AA61=0356/7/18 2/8?. ./.5- 61= /1.-2-:. 0@-2 .?- :6/= ;20;-2.4
?- :6/= :>/.: C-2- =/:7/::-= -/18 6882/-@-= .?-
2>:. ?6= ;2-<-22-= 6 2-8>562 6;;-65 /1 0A C?/3? 65:0 367-.09-=/:7/::-= -/186882/-@-=.?-
2>:.?6=65:0 ;2-<-22-= 2-8>562 :-301= 6;;-65 9-<02- .?/: 0>2. /1 0)) C?/3? /: 65:0 =/:7/::-= -/18 6882/-@-= .?-:6/=
2>:.?6:;2-<-22-=6:;-3/655-6@-;-././01/1 #/@/5& 0 C?/3? /: :./55 ;-1=/18 301:/=-26./01 ( ?/18: :.00= .?>: .?- 2-:;01=-1. 0 94 .?- /7;>81-=02=-2=6.-=))?6::0>8?..06::/8161 -D.-1.0<(632-:0<561=<027/18;62.0<:6/=A632-: 8>1.6:/140(/1-D-23/:-0</.:;0C-2>1=-2-3./01
- 5 -
) 0< .?- 6216.6B6 61= -@-1>- 3. A'( <02 .?- ;>2;0:-0<301:.2>3./010<F26E60>=?6G
-621-= 30>1:-5 <02 .?- ;-././01-2: .?-2-<02- :>97/.:.?6..?-;-././01-2?6:6;2--D/:./182/8?..0:--B -D.-1:/01 0< .?- 5-6:- C?/3? C6: 8261.-= 01 )A'A 6<.-2-D;/240< 4-62:
?-;-././01-230>5=10.:--B.?- -D.-1:/01 0< 5-6:- /1 @/-C 0< .?- ;-1=-134 0< 5/./86./01 C?/3? /: :./55 ;-1=/18
?6. .?-2- C6: 10 10./3- 0< 614 16.>2- C?6.:0-@-2 -/.?-2 .-27/16./18 .?- .-16134 02 3655/18 >;01 .?- ;-././01-2 .0 @636.- .?- ;2-7/:-:
?6. .?-63./010<2-:;01=-1.0 /12-:-2@/18.?-:6/=-D.-1. 0<(632-:0<561=<02.?-;>2;0:-0<301:.2>3./010<26E6 0>=?6 /: 301.2624 .0 .?- ;20@/:/01: 0< 56C 36>:/18 ;2-E>=/3-.0.?-2/8?.:0<.?-;-././01-2:-13-:--B:<02 6550C/180<.?-;-././01 ' -621-= ==/./0165 =@036.- -1-265 /1 <>2.?-2613-.0.?-:.6.-7-1.0<09E-3./01</5-=.6B-:.?/: 0>2..?20>8?.?-.-27:0<.?-5-6:-682--7-1.;20=>3-=
6. 11-D>2-( .0 .?- :.6.-7-1. 0< 09E-3./01 ?-
- 6 -
:>97/.:.?6..?-5-6:-682--7-1.6=7/..-=54-1.-2-=/1.0 01)A'A<026;-2/0=0< 4-62:?6::.00=-D;/2-= 946<5>D0<./7-?-:>97/.:.?6./1.-27:0<356>:-#<&6. ;68- 0 0< .?- 5-6:- =--= /. C6: :;-3/</36554 61= 36.-802/36554682--=.?6.01-D;/240<.?-5-6:-;-2/0=.?- 5-::--:?6552-:.02-.?-561=.08-.?-2C/.?.?-301:.2>3./01 76=- .?-2-01 .0 .?- 5-::02 C/.?0>. 356/7/18 614 307;-1:6./01 -<-22/18 .0 :6/= 356>:- :?- @-?-7-1.54 :>97/.: .?6. C?-1 6=7/..-=54 5-6:- 10. ?6@/18 9--1 -D.-1=-= 6: 682--= .?- ;-././01-2 ?6: 10 #
.0 76/1.6/1 .?- ;-././01 ?- :>97/.: .?6. .?- ;-././01-2 36110.356/76149-..-22/8?.9>..02-3081/H-.?-.-27:
0< .?- 5-6:- /1 .-27: 0< C?/3? .?- 561= 61= .?- 9>/5=/18 ?6::.00=@-:.-=C/.?.?-.6.-61=.?-.6.-/:6.5/9-2.4 .0=-65C/.?.?-:6/=;20;-2.4/1.?-7611-2B10C1.056C ?6.
.?- /7;>81-= 02=-2 /: .?-2-<02- ;6::-= /1 <>2.?-2613-.0:6/=2/8?.0<-7/1-1.=076/1 ::>3?10 /55-865/.4 361 9- <0>1= /1 .?- 02=-2 ;6::-=-13- :--B: <02=/:7/::650<;-././01
- 7 -
) -62=-2>:-=.?-2-302=:
?-2- /: 10 =/:;>.- 0< .?- <63. .?6. .?- ;-././01-2 003/-.4 C6: /1=--= 8261.-= 5-6:- <02 6 ;-2/0= 0< 4-62: -<<-3./@- <207 )A'A 1 <>2.?-2613- .0 .?- :6/= 5-6:- .?- ;-././01-2 003/-.4 :.6.-= .0 ?6@- ;>. >; 301:.2>3./01 <02 .?- ;>2;0:- 0< 2>11/18 -82-- 61= ?627634 055-8-
?-2- /: 65:0 10 =/:;>.-0<.?-<63..?6.3-2.6/1
2>:.?6=65:0356/7-=2/8?. 0@-2.?-:6/=;20;-2.4C?/3?/::./55;-1=/18301:/=-26./01 A
- .?6. 6: /. /:
?- <63. 2-76/1: .?6. .?- ;-././01-2C6:/1=>3.-=/1.0.?-6<02-:6/=561=/1.-27:0< .?-6<02-:6/=5-6:-=--=
?0>8?.?-:6/=5-6:-=--=?6: 10.9--1-D.-1=-=61=102-I>/:/./01:--B/18-D.-1:/01/: 65:0 76=- .?- ;0::-::/01 0< .?- :6/= 561= 61= .?- 9>/5=/18 -@-1 6: ;20@/=-= >1=-2 682--7-1. 36110. 9- .6B-1C/.?0>.=>-;203-::0<56C
1.?6.@/-C0<.?-76..-2<0550C/18,
- 8 -
/& ?-C2/.;-././01/: //& ?- 02=-2 =6.-= )) ;20=>3-= 6. 11-D>2- /::>-= 94 2-:;01=-1. 0 /: I>6:?-= ///& 0.C/.?:.61=/18 I>6:?/18 0< 11-D>2- 6: 690@-.?-2-:;01=-1.6>.?02/./-:62-6.5/9-2.4 .0 /1/./6.- .?- ;203--=/18: /1 63302=613- C/.? 56C :--B/18 @636./18 61= ?61=/18 0@-2 .?- @6361. ;0::-::/01 0< .?- 5-6:-= 561= /1 63302=613-C/.?56C /@& -././01-2: 62- 65:0 6. 5/9-2.4 .0 :--B :>3? 2-7-=4/135>=/18:--B/18-D.-1:/010<5-6:- /< ;20@/=-=61=;-27/::/95->1=-256C
!*+ ($!$) '
,, (J
,