- 1 - ! "!#!! ! $%&'$( )*'$)) + !" #$$ %& ' ( && &'$ $ $$& &$ $ " ' & & !" #$ % $&'& $ ) '( & $$ *" %( $ % ( " %( ! %( $ & Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' !*! ! !+! !$&& , %$ ( $ %$ ( + ! & !-- $% + !( - $ ! & $$ ' & ' & $$ & & '& & . #! %$& . ( /0 122033145 60748 199:;0< = 74 209713 1;0 %$ (=+ !=45/0>730=>5/0301?40<<<757=413 7;5?795 14< 0;;7=4; :<80 %$ ( 1316:?187 7; 7@2:84748 5/0 9=@@=4 A:<8@045 <150< !*! !" 21;;0< 13=48 B75/ 209713 1;0 %$ ( =+* ! B/0?0745/0122033145199:;0<= B1;9=4C7950<>=?5/0 =>>0490;2:47;/1630:4<0?0957=4;!--*-%(%4( => 5/0 4<714 $0413 =<0 -! %>=? ;/=?5 D$,( 14< 0957=4; - 14< => 5/0 $?=50957=4 => /73<?04 >?=@ 0E:13 >>0490;95! %>=?;/=?5D$ 95,(B/730 - 3 - 19F:755748 199:;0< =; 14< " 74 209713 1;0 %$ ( =+* ! /0 >195; => 5/0 91;0 74 6?70> 1?0 5/15 5/0 C7957@$ 180< *G01?;3=<80<5/0>7?;574>=?@157=41; 20?E$ 18174;5199:;0<=; 5=133087489=@@7;;7=4 => 5/0 =>>0490; 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4; !- --%( *-%(%4( B0957=4 "+=>$14<0957=4;"- 14< => 5/0 $ 95 4C0;578157=4 B1; :4<0?51H04 >50?74C0;578157=49/1?80;/00591@05=60>730<18174;5 199:;0< = 14< ;2375:2 9/1?80 ;/005 B1; >730< 18174;5 199:;0<=;14<"57;;5150<5/15199:;0<=;14< 1?016;9=4<74814<5?7137;;5733204<74818174;55/0@ 5 7; 5/0 9=450457=4 => 5/0 2?=;09:57=4 5/15 199:;0< =; 14< :;0< 5= ;75 74 >?=45 => 5/0 /=:;0 => $ 501;748 14< /1?1;;748 /0? 6G 1;H748 /0? 2/=40 4:@60?14<74<:9748/0?5=@1??G199:;0<= 99:;0< = ;51?50< 9?7@74133G 7457@7<15748 /0? 5= 91:;0 /0? <015/ 7> ;/0 ?0>:;0< 5= 199=@214G /7@ 6=:5 5= " @=45/; 01?370? 5= >73748 => 5/0 9=@237145 199:;0< =; - 4 - 14<74;7;50<5/0C7957@5=9=@0B75/5/0@5=/1C0@013; 74 1 /=503 /0G 5==H /0? >=?9763G =4 1 @=5=?9G930 14< 199:;0<= 9=@@7550<?120 4 *!!5/0C7957@ B1;745/0/=;27513;7490/0?;7;50?B1;1<@7550<5/0?074 55/1557@0199:;0<=; 14<91@05/0?014<1;H0< 5/0C7957@5=199=@214G5/0@/04;/0?0>:;0<5=<=;= 199:;0< =; 14< /1C0 <?1880< 14< H7<41220< /0? B75/ 14 7450457=4 5= 9=@@75 ;0E:13 1;;1:35 4 5/0 40E5 <1G5/0;7;50?=>5/0C7957@<70<745/0/=;2751314<5/?00 <1G; 3150? 133 5/0 199:;0< =; 5= 279H0< :2 F:1??03 B75/ 5/0 C7957@ 14< /0? 21?045; 1;;1:350< 14< 91:;0< 5/0@ 74A:?70; /0?0>=?0 75 7; ;5150< 5/15 199:;0< = 9=@@7550< 20405?157C0 ;0E:13 1;;1:35 =4 5/0 @74=? 87?3 ?020150<3G 6G 9?7@74133G 7457@7<15748 1;;1:35748 14< 91:;74874A:?70; " >50? 74C0;578157=4 9/1?80 ;/005 91@0 5= 60 >730<18174;5199:;0<=; 5=99:;0<= B1;5?70<74 209713 1;0 %$ ( =+ ! 4 5/0 @01457@0 - 5 - 199:;0< =; 14< " B0?0 13;= 122?0/04<0< 14< 5/0G B0?05?70<742097131;0%$ (=+* ! 4 209713 1;0 %$ ( =+ ! 5/0 2?=;09:57=40E1@740<$; 5= 8=5@1?H0<E;$ 5= $ 14<7<0457>70< ; 5=+74;:22=?5=>75;9=450457=4 /0 199:;0< <0470< 133 5/0 749?7@7415748 @150?713; 1C1731630=4?09=?<74/7;;5150@045:4<0?0957=4 => ?$ 6:5 /1; 4=5 30< 14G 0C7<0490 74 ;:22=?5 => /7; <0>0490 - /0 ?713 =:?5 1>50? 51H748 745= 9=4;7<0?157=4 133 5/0 @150?713; =4 ?09=?< 91@0 5= 5/0 9=493:;7=4 5/15 5/0 2?=;09:57=4 7; ;:990;;>:3 74 2?=C748 5/0 8:735 => 5/0 199:;0< >=? 5/0 =>>0490; 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4; !- - *- %( %4( => $ 14< 0957=4; - 14< => 5/0 $ 95 &=B0C0? /0 B1; 19F:7550< >=? 5/0 =>>0490 2:47;/1630:4<0?0957=4=>$99:;0<=;14<" B0?019F:7550<=>1335/0=>>0490;0748188?70C0<6G5/0 9=4C7957=4199:;0<= /1;2?0>0??0<5/7;122013 - 6 - * &01?< ?7 14<H7;/=?0 ==6 301?40< 9=:4;03 >=? 5/0 122033145 14< ?7 =213H?7;/41 1<1C 301?40< &78/ =:?5 =C0?4@045 $301<0? >=? ?0;2=4<045 = 51500;2=4<045=5/=:8/;0?C0<B75/5/04=5790/1; ?0@1740<:4?02?0;0450<$0?:;0<5/0@150?713;=4?09=?< 4 C70B => 5/0 ?7C13 9=450457=4; :?80< 6G 5/0 301?40<9=:4;03>=?6=5/5/021?570;5/02=7455/15B=:3< 1?7;0>=?@G9=4;7<0?157=47; G 14;B0? 5=5/0 16=C0 2=745 7; 745/0 .>>7?@157C0, >=?5/0>=33=B748 + 5 7; 5/0 9=450457=4 => 5/0 2?=;09:57=4 5/15 16=:5 5= " @=45/; 01?370? 5= >73748 => 5/0 9=@231745 199:;0<= /1<H7<41220<5/0@74=?87?314<9=@@7550< 20405?157C0 ;0E:13 1;;1:35 &0 3150? 30>5 /0? 401? /0? - 7 - /=:;0 4 *!! 5/0 ;7;50? => 5/0 C7957@ B1; 1<@7550< 5= 5/0 /=;27513 14< 15 5/15 57@0 199:;0< = 91@0 5= 5/0 /=;27513 <?1880< 5/0 C7957@ 14< H7<41220< /0?74;2750=>?0;7;51490@1<06G5/0>15/0?=>5/0C7957@ 74905/0;7;50?=>5/0C7957@<70<=45/0;1@0<1G745/0 /=;275134=9=@2317459=:3<60>730<&=B0C0?757;;5150< 5/15 1>50? H7<4122748 5/0 C7957@ 87?3 199:;0< = /1< 9=@@7550< 20405?157C0 ;0E:13 1;;1:35 6G 9?7@74133G 7457@7<1574814<1;;1:35748/0?6=:55B=<1G;5/0?01>50? 5/0?0B1;1F:1??03605B0045/05B=>1@7370;/0199:;0< B0?0 631@748 C7957@ 14< /0? >1@73G @0@60?; 5/15 5/0 C7957@/0?;03>/1;9=@@7550<B?=48B/7305/021?045;=> 5/0 C7957@ 631@0< 5/0 199:;0< 5/15 /0 7; ?0;2=4;7630 >=? 5/0 7497<045 /0?01>50? 5/0 >7?;5 74>=?@157=4 91@0 5= 60 3=<80<=4 !+!18174;5199:;0<=; 5=13308748 9=@@7;;7=4=>=>>0490 !$ 5/0C7957@14<$I5/0>15/0?=>5/0 C7957@/1C0<02=;0<60>=?05/0=:?5$7;5/0<=95=? B/=0E1@740<5/0C7957@87?314<81C0>7413=2747=41;20? - 8 - E$ " 199=?<748 5= B/79/ 5/0?0 B1; 4= 0C7<0490 => ?09045;0E:137450?9=:?;0&=B0C0?757;20?5740455=4=50 5/155/0C7957@B1;0E1@740<6G5/00<7913 >>790?=43G =4!+!701>50??087;5?157=4=>5/0 /00C7<0490=>5/0C7957@<7;93=;0;5/15@14G1 57@0; ;/0 B1; 74;7;50< 6G 199:;0< = 13=48 B75/ 199:;0<=5=199=@214G/7@14</0/1<2?=@7;0<5= @1??G/0?57;/0?9=450457=45/15?020150<3G;/0B1; ;:6A0950< 5= 188?1C150< 20405?157C0 ;0E:13 1;;1:35 6G 199:;0< = 14< ;/0 0C04 9=@231740< 75 5= /0? >15/0? :5;5?14803G4=9?7@74139=@231745B1;3=<80<18174;55/0 199:;0< &=B0C0? 74 E$ >7?;5 74>=?@157=4 C7957@ ;5150< 5/15 B/04 5/0?0 B1; 1 F:1??03 605B004 5/0 5B= >1@7370; /0? >15/0? /1< 74>=?@0< 5/0 2=3790 B/= /1C0 91@05=/0?/=:;014</1C051H045/09=@231745 5 7; 20?574045 5=4=50 5/15 $; 14< /1C0 ;5150<5/15199:;0<= 1;;1:350<$ ?020150<3G14< ;/0 B1; 0C04 1;;1:350< B75/ 1 H47>0 6:5 5/0 ?713 =:?5 19F:7550< 5/0 199:;0< >=? 5/0 =>>0490 2:47;/1630 :4<0? - 9 - 0957=4=>$/00C7<0490=>$5/0>15/0?=> 5/0C7957@<=0;4=574;27?09=4>7<0490745/0@74<=>5/0 =:?55=9=4504<5/15/7;@74=?<1:8/50?B1;H7<41220< 14< ;:6A0950< 5= 20405?157C0 ;0E:13 1;;1:35 6G 199:;0< = ?020150<3G&0/1<4=551H0414G1957=418174;55/0 199:;0<>=?@=45/;5=805/0? ;20?5/0>7?;574>=?@157=4E$ 5/0C7957@ ;5150;5/15;7490199:;0<= /1<2?=@7;0<5=@1??G/0? 14< >173; 5= 9=@23G B75/ 5/0 2?=@7;0 ;/0 /1; >730< 5/0 9=@231745/0C7957@<:?7489?=;;0E1@74157=4;2097>79133G ;5150;5/15199:;0<= /1<87C04/0?1@=6730/14<;05 14< 1;H0< /0? 5= 9133 /7@ ;7490 ;/0 B1; 5/?015040< 6G /7@ ;/0 :;0< 5= 9133 /7@ =C0? 2/=40 5 7; 20?574045 5= 4=505/155/0C7957@B1;180< *G01?;14<5/0199:;0< B1; ! G01?; ?=@ 5/0;0 >195; 14< 97?9:@;51490; 75 9144=560;17<5/155/02?=;09:57=47;;:990;;>:3742?=C748 5/0 8:735 => 5/0 199:;0< 60G=4< ?01;=41630 <=:65 /0 74=?<74150<031G743=<87485/0>7?;574>=?@157=413;=?17;0; ?01;=41630<=:65745/0@74<=>5/0=:?516=:55/091;0 - 10 - @1<0 =:5 6G 5/0 2?=;09:57=4 /0 6040>75 => <=:65 B733 /1C05=600E504<0<5=5/0199:;0< "/1C08=405/?=:8/5/07@2:840<A:<8@045=> 9=4C7957=414<=?<0?=>;045049021;;0<6G5/0?713=:?5 B/79/ /1; 2?=900<0< 5= 9=4C795 199:;0< = B/730 19F:755748199:;0<=;14<"784=?7481335/0;0831?748 749=4;7;504970;14<13;=5/074=?<74150<031G743=<87485/0 >7?;574>=?@157=40C041>50?19F:755748199:;0<= >=?5/0 =>>04902:47;/1630:4<0?0957=4=>$4<0?;:9/ 97?9:@;51490; 1@ => 5/0 =2747=4 5/15 5/0 199:;0< 7; 3716305=6019F:7550< 4 C70B => 5/0 16=C02?=900< 5= 14;B0? 5/0 16=C0 2=745 74 5/0 D1>>7?@157C0, 14< 2?=900< 5= 21;; 5/0 >=33=B748 %7( /0?7@7413220137; %77( /07@2:840<A:<8@045=>9=4C7957=4<150< !*! ! 14< =?<0? => ;0450490 <150< !+! ! 21;;0< 74 23%$ ( - 11 - =+ ! 6G 5/0 301?40< <<757=413 7;5?795 14< 0;;7=4; :<80 %$ (1316:?1877; %777( /0 122033145 199:;0< 7; 19F:7550< >=? 5/0 =>>0490; 2:47;/1630 :4<0? 0957=4; !" - *-%( %4( => 5/0 4<714 $0413 =<0 -! 14< 0957=4; - 14< => 5/0 $?=50957=4 => /73<?04 >?=@ 0E:13 >>790; 95! %7C( 1736=4<7>14G=>5/012203314514<5/15 =>/7;;:?0570;;514<91490330< %C( 7401@=:457>14G<02=;750<7;=?<0?0<5= 60 ?0>:4<0< 5= 5/0 122033145 199:;0< =4 <:07<0457>79157=4 087;5?G 7; <7?0950< 5= ;04< 619H 5/0 ?713 =:?5 ?09=?<; 13=48 B75/ 9=2G => 5/7; A:<8@045 >=? 74>=?@157=4 14<400<>:31957=4 ,* $!!) # 7;5= 3= $