- 1 - !!" !# $ "%"&""! ""&& '() * ! "# $ % & ! ! ' ( ) *" ! +! "# ! ! ' ( ,! ! "# $ % ) - # # (& Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) ! *%& ) .& ) /& ) '! ( # #* #* 0# ) ) ! ) '! ! ! ! ( ! ""# ) 1 ! ) '!( ! 2 '!! %! 345 .667.8 45 9487: .;.4<5= =37 '>:;?7<= .<: .@.A: :.=7: # #* #* 6.557: 4< B 0# /C =37 ::4=4B<.87<4BA4D48'>:;7.<: .8./>A.;4%9BA 53BA=E=37=A4/><.81& 37 4<F>A7: G8.4?7: ?7= @4=3 . AB.: =A.994G .GG4:7<=B< # # 7@.5@BAH4<;.5.63B=B;A.637A .<: @.5 .;7: # C7.A5 .5 B< =37 :.=7 B9 =37 .GG4:7<= 7 9487: G8.4? 67=4=4B< 577H4<; GB?67<5.=4B< B9 5 #### 9BA=374<F>A4755>5=.4<7:/C34?4<=37AB.:=A.994G.GG4:7<= 37 =A4/><.8 GB<54:7A4<; =37 7<=4A7 7D4:7<G7 B< A7GBA: .@.A:7: =37 GB?67<5.=4B< B9 5 ### .8B<; @4=3 - 3 - 4<=7A75= .= =37 A.=7 B9 0I 67A .<<>? 9AB? =37 :.=7 B9 67=4=4B< =488 A7.84J.=4B< ;;A47D7: /C =37 5.4: BA:7A =37 G8.4?.<=6A797AA7:=376A757<=.667.8577H4<;7<3.<G7?7<= B9=37GB?67<5.=4B< 7.A<7: GB><578 9BA =37 .66788.<= ?.4<8C GB<=7<:7: =3.= =37 G8.4?.<= @.5 7.A<4<; . 5>? B9 5 #### 67A ?B<=3 />= =37 =A4/><.8 3.5 GB<54:7A7: 345 4<GB?7 .= 5 0*# 67A ?B<=3 .<: =37 GB?67<5.=4B< .?B><=;A.<=7:><:7AB=37A37.:5.A7.85B?7.;7A.<:<B .?B><=5 @7A7 ;A.<=7: ><:7A =37 37.: B9 8B55 B9 .?7<4=475 .<: 8B55 B9 4<GB?7 :>A4<; 8.4: >6 67A4B: =37A79BA7 87.A<7: GB><5789BA=37.66788.<=577H5=B7<3.<G7=37GB?67<5.=4B< .?B><=.@.A:7:/C=37=A4/><.8 7.A<7: GB><578 9BA =37 A756B<:7<= B <5>A.<G7GB?6.<C5>/?4=5=3.==37=A4/><.83.5GB<54:7A7: .88 .567G=5 .<: 3.5 .@.A:7: A7.5B<./87 GB?67<5.=4B< .<: =37 5.?7 <77:5 <B 4<=7A97A7<G7 GGBA:4<;8C 37 6A.C5 9BA :45?455.8B9=37.667.8 7.A:=37.A;>?7<=5B9/B=354:75 - 4 - 0 3B>;3 4= @.5 5=.=7: =3.= =37 G8.4?.<= @.5 7.A<4<; . 5>? B9 5 #### />= <B 4<GB?7 6ABB9 @.5 6AB:>G7: 7<G7 =37 =A4/><.8 3.5 =.H7< =37 4<GB?7 B9 =37 G8.4?.<= .= 5 ### 67A C7.A .<: G.8G>8.=7: 8B55 B9 9>=>A74<GB?7.=5 "0#?7:4G.87K67<5759BA.5>?B9 5 ###.<:=375.?7<77:5<B4<=7A97A7<G7 567A=37 7D4:7<G7B9 ( =3767=4=4B<7A5>5=.4<7:9A.G=>A7B9A4;3= 94/>8. .<: =37A7 @.5 . =7<:7A<755 .<: :79BA?4=C .= =37 9A.G=>A7 54=7 5 67A =37 7D4:7<G7 B9 =37 BG=BA 9BA =37 ?.8><4=7: 9A.G=>A7 .<: 57GB<: :7;A77 6.4< =37 :45./484=C @.5 0I /C GB?/4<4<; 9BA?>8. 37 G8.4?.<= @.5 3B564=.84J7: 9BA 94D7 :.C5 37A79BA7 =345 B>A= 94<:5 4= A7.5B<./87=B7<3.<G7=37GB?67<5.=4B<.@.A:7:><:7A=37 37.: B9 6.4< .<: 5>997A4<; =B . 5>? B9 5 #### 5 ### =B@.A:5 8B55 B9 .?7<4=475 .<: . 5>? B9 5 #### ><:7A =37 37.: B9 =A.<56BA=.=4B< 7K=A. <B>A453?7<= .<: .==7<:.<= G3.A;75 7 45 .85B 7<=4=87: 9BA 8B55 B9 4<GB?7 :>A4<; 8.4: >6 67A4B: 9BA =3A77 ?B<=35 4 7 5 0## , L 5 ## 7<G7 =37 =B=.8 GB?67<5.=4B<@B>8:/7.5><:7A - 5 - "+ ,-./012,3/-453 1634/ .4<.<:5>997A4<; 5 #### B55B9.?7<4=475 5 ### 7:4G.87K67<575 5 ### ==7<:.<=G3.A;75 5 #### B55B99>=>A74<GB?7 5 "0# 0 B55B94<GB?7:>A4<;8.4:>6 67A4B: 5 ## 4-+ / 7 * 7<G7 =37 =B=.8 GB?67<5.=4B< @B>8: GB?75 =B 5 # .8B<; @4=3 0I 4<=7A75= 9AB? =37 :.=7 B9 67=4=4B<=488=37:.=7B9A7.84J.=4B< " 7.A<7: GB><578 9BA A756B<:7<= B <5>A.<G7 GB?6.<C 5>/?4=5 =3.= =37 GB?67<5.=4B< .?B><= .@.A:7: /C =37 =A4/><.8 3.5 /77< .8A7.:C :76B54=7: .8B<; @4=3 .GGA>7:4<=7A75= GGBA:4<;8C=379B88B@4<; ! %4& 37.667.845.88B@7:4<6.A=- %44& 37 G8.4?.<= 45 7<=4=87: 9BA =B=.8 GB?67<5.=4B<B95 #.5.;.4<5=.5>?B9 5 ###.@.A:7:/C=37=A4/><.8- - 6 - %444& 37 A756B<:7<= B <5>A.<G7 GB?6.<C 45 :4A7G=7: =B :76B54= =37 7<3.<G7: GB?67<5.=4B<B95 "##.8B<;@4=34<=7A75=.= =37 A.=7 B9 0I67A .<<>? @4=34< B<7 ?B<=3 9AB? =37:.=7B9=345BA:7A- %4D& < 5>G3 :76B54= =37 G8.4?.<= 45 67A?4==7: =B @4=3:A.@ 7<=4A7 .?B><= .8B<; @4=3 4<=7A75=.GGA>7:=37A7B< ".7 '&""!) %! 45=B 8B