Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 62071 (PNJ)
MOHAN LAL v. UT OF CHANDIGARH AND ORS.
CWP/1313/2018 · 2025-02-05
Sureshwar Thakur, Vikas Suri
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62071 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 62071 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"##$ ! %!& !"$##$
'" ()'# ** *+
()'# *,+**
! "#$%
"$&'
($ )
#
%#$*$&'
($
)
+
, $&'
($ -# $.$$%$%&'
($
)
/ 0000 * *+
-#
+ #
## $- &#
#
& $ )
# 1$#
)*
$ +23243+5& 6 7 8+9:&-#
# $ %%$ $#
(
%$ +5
) # #$$#*$%%%$(# * &433;&7#
$)
)
$ <# (# * =:#$ > ( # $ $%
)#
#
$%
.# $
)$*$$*
# ))($%
$%%
#*&## *$%%)%$ ?# (# * @ ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
.&/%.0.&12 %! 4 # #$$# *$
#$
( # #$$#*$%%%$(# * 433;&-#
&-$ ( #$
A#-
% ' $ *$$*
# *$
#
#$$% )
# $*
, #
= $%($
-$
(
#
(
(
%$% & #
($* $ ' $)% $$%($
) % * )#
& & #
$% '( # (& ) #
*$ .$%$& #$$##
*$ .$%$ > ( # $$%($
& #
%#$#
($ (
$? (
B
@$ 1
# (# * &#
) #
%% ) $%%
*
/
' #
)#
*$ .$%$&#
#$ )% -
$
C 8++9/4843+9& (#$%% #
$ #
*$ .$%$# % $
%
(#
) #
(
$ #
)
*$ .$%$$$% *$ # %
# .$%$)
$ ) # ( 9 #
$) &#
*$ .$%$
% ' #$ # $%($
#$
)% $$ $% ) # ) D6 (' ))( )E (%$ +5
)# (# * ' -
)# $ (
&#
)% $$ $% ) # # ) D6 (' ))( # $ %%$ $# > ( # (%$*
)#
& '#$$ ( )$ $*% )
) ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
( $# )
#
1
$&## $ %%$7
: %%
(# *
;
( &# $-
(
* )% $$# $
5 #
' (
)#% (
* (
#
(' $%($%
$%($% '8$8'#
= ($ 1$# *$$ $ (% (%$ 7:
)%$ ,
)# (# * &(%$ -#
) (
*
6$( #
$)
! "
#$
%& '
'
F %$ ;
)# #$$#*$%%%$(# * 433;& $% % '$& $ (#& # $ (%$ $% (
*
6$(
#
$)
! "#"#$""
%
&
! !! !
' ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
'
'
! %(
)*
+
%, 2 #
#& # 7$: (%$ #$' ))
$* *
#
# * &( #
# #
$
'
6$( (%$ & $# $
% '$&)
$1 # $(
' & $# '
*
%$
#
% * )#
( $%(
)
*# (
*
$#
&$# #
-#(#-$' -$ '$% ( $# * )# *$. )# $%($
( # $ $%($
-$*$ #
3/+44332 %$% -# # $ )# $%($
&# #
$)
6$( $* * # (# * &# -$' -$ '$% ( (#&#
% * )#
( $%(
*
* #
) *%3&0.%425 60.% 6/7*&78 )
% -
) ,
! $""! . / '
%
$""
%
! # 0$""
# 0$""1# 0$""2 # 0$""3# 0$""4 5
)
% -
)
ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
! )
%B
-%%
%% ) $%(
@ *%3&0.%495 6&0.%:4.5 6/7&78 5
! +
# 0$""
%
# 0$""1 # 0$""2# 0$""3# 0$""4, +3
$ % ( # #
$
' '
($ # (# * -
'$% ( &$#
% '$* &$(##
*
* # $(# * &-
% (
* #
(#*$.)
#
%%
)#
&#
.$%(
++
% #
=$* (( # * ( ' -#(# -$ (
( # #$$# *$
#
$433; ' &#
##
' ( #
( #$
4332#
(
% # (
%
# * &#
#$%
-##
(% # * (' &$ ($* (
( # #$$#*$
&#
$433;&-$ $% 1
*
# ' %
)433; ' &( $%
)#
(%$ &#
)
*$ ?
(
B
@&#$)$>#- %% =$* &#$ $# ' % $
3+3+433/&
3+3+4339&
3+3+4335$
3+3+433F& #
(# $ ># - %%
* 1$%) )
- #
%(
# (
*
$# +4 - ' % #
& -#
(
* (% # * ( ' & $ ($* (
( # ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
#$$#*$
#
$433;$#
##
-$ % $$' #
$433;& -#
*
) # 7$: )
$ (
* *$ #
* ? (
B
@&#-##
(%
# ' %$
3+3+433/&
3+3+4339&
3+3+43+3$ 3+3+43++
- ' & ( (
)%( -# # $ $* &$# -## $* )#
&# ((# ' %&$
3+3+433;
((# '
%$
3+3+4335&
3+3+433F&$
3+3+4332&#
-# # $ ( *$ $((
*%# & # # *
(
* $
+, E #$ $ *$ & ( # 7$: )($
& $
(
* . '8$8'? (
B
@&
( $ $$
*$% & #
6 #$ $:
# $%($$) # ( $ %$ #G# $*
(
*(% # * (' $
($* (
( $(#433; :
#
$3+3+433/&3+3+4339&3+3+43+3 $3+3+43++&#
(
* % $ $ ' & $((
)
$*
% $$' #
$3+3+433;&3+3+4335& 3+3+433F$3+3+4332&$# #
$*
(%$
? (
B
@ +/ -($ $ (
(
*
#
&
(% *$ $% ' &#$# -$$%
% $$' # ' %)
#
$3+3+433/&)
#
$ 3+3+4339& )
#
$ 3+3+4335 $ )
#
$ 3+3+433F& ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
#
#
(
* $% $) $
6$((
&
# )$(&#$#
$$
)' %& $# *$ # $
)# $))
)#
% (
(
** (
(
& *$.
* $
7:
) # ># - %% & #
# # # ($%% '#
(
(
-&( $# * ) $ # ($%''8$8'# >#
)#
& $# #
*$
#$'
) # >#& #
$ $#$#$* ((# ' %7: (
(
& #
*% #$ # -$ (
% # >#( #
$433;
433F&
($%% -# #$* $ $ # ' %&$-)
#
$ 43+3$43++ +9
*
$% & -# # )$(*
) #
(
% # >#$# ( #
$433;
(
*
)
*#$* $ $# * (' &
-# # $)$(*$%
(
$ )
*# ( )($
# $(
(
(
&-#
#$$%% $ % (( ( (
# >#
) #
& # -#
$.
#
&#$# $$%%
% (( ( (
-$
$%%
#
$433,#
) &%
' (
# $ ($* $( #
(
(
&-#(##
- '
&#
$ $#$#
#$*% #
-$
*
$( '8$8'# >#
)#
&
(' )
*
(
*$( #
$* (
(
&'8$8 '# >#
)#
& -# # 7$:$ 6 -## ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
( #
$#
*$ % &#
&$$ $
' #
*#
)$# -$(
% # >## $)$($% (
* (
$ )
*# $#$$ )#
&-#
# $.$ *$ &#$# -$
# >#(
%
#
$43++ +; *%$' % #
$ $#$# (%
) # $* )#
&# ' %)
#
$433;& -$$ 1 %
)# $))
)# D% (
**
&-#
# '
#>#&#)#
*
$%
#
(
1 % &#
$* &# ((# ' %)
43+3$)
#
$43++&#
#
(%
)# $* )#
&# ' %)
# 433;&#
# 7$:)#$# $
(%
)# $* )#
# $' %&-$$ %
) # ) #>#$# * -# # $))
)# D% (
**
' # ># $G
$% *
(
* $ &#$# $ ' % ($* $--#
# $))'# $ $(
(
+5 E #$ $ *$ &
-# *$ )$( $#
' ( &
( # $)&-$$% 1
*
$( $# $( )#
& ) # (
*
))( - ' & (
#
' ( *$ )$( ( # $)&-$ ' $( # (
$- # (
*
$#
$%
-# $ )
# $ $(
' (
($*
( # (
*
$# ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
%$% #
#$ (
(% #$# $ $$( ) # $* )#
# ' %)
#
$433;& -$$ 1 %
) # # $))
)# D% (
** '
'# >#(
(
&
# $
(% $ 1 % )#
&#$#
% '$*
)
#>#&#$*$ # &# -$ $-$ #
##
*% &$$$% -$
# *%
+F # * & (
' #
&
($* $ # (
*
$#
&
>) # (%
# ' %)
#
$433; ' &-# # $
(%
*$ #$'
$. # 7$: *
(#&#
)
-$
)$
)$$ 1$ #
)
#>) #$ (%
&
# $ $((
&# %$(
(%
#$#
#
#$
$$% 1$%) )
* (
$ ?
(
B
@# >#(
(
+2 #
)#
)
*#
)
) ? (
B
@&#$ $ *$ #
#$%%)
*
-#(#) $
7$:& (
* $'%% $ (
' (
43
1 %&-# # #
%( )# (# * &#
- # >#- %% &-#
$ # %$*$$%
(
7:
)
( &$*(#$&#
#
(
*
'
-#$# % &
#$#
# $%
' %$ #
%) $# $% (
* )%% $('$
%$% &$* ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment
$% 1 -$ 1
$ # (
*
$#
&##
## 7$:
(
*$'$(
$%%(
(
- ' &(
$% 1
(
)#
(
$? (
B
@&# $%$% #$
$. # (
*
$#
%$% #
# $. ) $ #
# $%
(
7:&#-# $%%(
(
&
$( #
' ( 1$#
(' $)$(
7:
$)$(
7:&
$- # (
(
&'8$'#
*? (
B
@& $# *$. # *
)) )
*$
( $%
&#
1
1$# &$& $
4+ $) *$#&#
* # $- &$& # $* $%%
-
%$% &# *
$ +23243+5
6 7 8+9:1$# $ $ &-#$)# *$$* # ))($%
&-#,-
.)
*
$ $%%
# *$%%)%$ # (# * #
4* *+ 5
4,+** 5 $##$
#% # 7/7;.19!2<. ! " < 7/7; /.30
" < ITHLESH KUMAR 2025.02.07 11:26 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this order/judgment