- 1 - !! "! # $!%!$$ $ &' &()* '& !!)) ! " #$% &'' '( &'' ( ()*** ! $ + ! " #& , !% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & !) & !*! ( ) !*! # !+ !* % & & $ $& '( & '( ! !* - & &&& +!!!+**-( & )-*& ) #%. && & & &( /$ #/$ % 01230 405 674458 9: ;9:45< =18 7<69::91> ?940 405 @1>:5>4 1= 405 ;578>5< @12>:5; 7AA5789>3 =18 B140 405 A78495:949:47C5>2A=18=9>7;<9:A1:7; ! 05 A549491>58 B59>3 7@@2:5< 1) 9> 8965 1! !* - 1= '73?7< 1;9@547491> >1? A5><9>3 9> 1 ! * ! #1 ;< 1 !+ !* % 1 > 4 0 5 = 9; 5 1 = ;5 78 > 5 < 9D9; $2<35 7>< $& '73?7< 9: :55C9>3 41 E27:0 405 @8969>7; A81@55<9>3: 9>949745< - 3 - 7379>:4 096 =18 405 1==5>@5: A2>9:07B;5 2><58 5@491>: + ! ! !+*7><*-857<?9405@491> 1=><97>5>7;1<5 )-*#=18:0184F.% 895= =7@4: 1= 405 @7:5 785 4074 85:A1><5>4 1 B59>3 405 9>=1867>4 =9;5< =98:4 9>=1867491> ?940 '73?7< A1;9@5 :47491> 1> * !* - :4749>3 4074 059: 85:9<9>3?94009:?9=57><@09;<85>9>7>37:2;9D9;;7351= 407>9 47;2C 7>< 09: 012:5 9: :942745< 9> 1+! 0585 9: 7> 1A5> :A7@5 >578BG 7>< 05 9: 9>A1::5::91> 1= 405 :765 :9>@5 6185 407> * G578: ?0585 05 @1>:482@45< 7 @1?:05< 7>< ?7: 7;:1 :4189>3 09: @81A: B124:9H61>40:578;95841=9;9>31=405=98:49>=1867491> 05 07: 7;:1 @1>:482@45< 7 ?7:08116 7>< 419;54 > !!* - 74 ** A6 7@@2:5< 1: 41 =1869>3 4056:5;D5: 9>41 2>;7?=2; 7::56B;G @765 7>< :47845< @;7969>3 405 A18491> 1= 405 ;7>< 1> ?09@0 405 9>=1867>4 07<@1>:482@45<405@1?:05<7><:4185<09:@81A:(05> 405 9>=1867>4 E25:491>5< 40598 0930 07><5< 7@4: 7;; 405 7@@2:5< ?940 7> 9>45>491> 41 @16694 405 1==5>@5 - 4 - 7::72;45< 096 ?940 07><: 05G =9:45< 7>< :;7AA5< 405 @16A;79>7>4 (05> 405 ?9=5 1= 405 9>=1867>4 @765 41 9>458D5>59>405 6744584057@@2:5<1427><287>37 185 A2:05< 058 7:9<5 7>< @8969>7;;G 9>496745< 41 47C5 7?7G 40598 ;9=5 05 7@@2:5< 07D5 7;:1 B812304 405 $ 7>< <561;9:05< 405 @1?:05< 7>< 7;:1 7 A18491> 1= 405 012:5?09@0?7:9>405A1::5::91>1=4059>=1867>405G 7;:1 @8969>7;;G 9>4969<745< 41 @72:5 40598 <5740 7>< 41 B288G 4056 9> 405 :79< A;7@5 9= 405G <785 41 9>458=585 ?94040598093007><5<7@4:059>=1867>4:4745<407405 07< B55> 41 '73?7< 1D58>65>4 01:A947; =18 4857465>4 7>< 405857=458 411C 4857465>4 74 7>37:2;9 D9;;735 5 :5>4405=98:49>=1867491>4081230A1:4412A589>45><5>4 1= 1;9@5 5;737D90585=185 40585 9:<5;7G 9>=9;9>3405 =98:4 9>=1867491> 05 9>=1867>4 85E25:45< 405 A1;9@5 41 8539:458 405 @7:5 7>< 419>949745;537;7@491>>405B7:9: 1=405=98:49>=1867491>89651! !* -=184057B1D5 :79<1==5>@5:?7:8539:4585< - 5 - 05 A1;9@5 411C 2A 405 9>D5:4937491> 7>< =9;5< F. 85A184 :4749>3 4074 40585 785 >1 6745897;: 41 :2B:47>49745 405 @1>45>491> 1= 405 9>=1867>4 85378<9>3 @1669::91>1=4051==5>@5BG4057@@2:5<059>=1867>4 =9;5< A8145:4 A549491> 9> 405 =186 1= 1BI5@491>: 41 405 F. 85A184 05 :?18> :474565>4: 1= 405 9>=1867>4 7>< 09: ?9=5 ?585 85@18<5< > 405B7:9:1=405:765405897; 1284 A81@55<5< 41 47C5 @13>9J7>@5 =18 405 7B1D5 :79< 1==5>@5: D9<5 18<58 <745< **!* @@18<9>3;G 1 !+ !* =18 405 7B1D5 :79< 1==5>@5: ?7: 8539:4585< B5=185 405 ;578>5< <<;9D9; $2<35 7>< $& 407>9 4 9: :4745< 4074 7=458 =1867491> 1= '73?7< 47;2C 7>< 5:47B;9:065>4 1= 9D9; $2<35 7>< $& 1284 74 '73?7< 1 !+ !* 9: 487>:=5885< 41 405 :79< 1284 7>< 85>26B585< 7: 1 !*! 578< 89 7;;1;9 09D87I 9<<7876 ;578>5< @12>:5; =18 405 A549491>58 578>5< 930 1284 1D58>65>4 ;57<58 =18 85:A1><5>4 1 9: 7B:5>4 1 - 6 - 85A85:5>47491>9:783265>49:47C5>7:>9; - > D95? 1= 405 89D7; @1>45>491>: 2835< BG 405 ;578>5<@12>:5;=18B140405A78495:405A19>44074?12;< 789:5=186G@1>:9<587491>9: !"#$% G7>:?58414057B1D5A19>49:9> =18 405=1;;1?9>3 !! + 4 9: 405 @1>45>491> 1= ;578>5< @12>:5; =18 405 A549491>5840747=7;:5@16A;79>4@76541B5=9;5<7379>:4 405A549491>58?9401247>GB7:9:059>@9<5>407<47C5> A;7@5 1> !*!* - 405 =98:4 9>=1867491> @765 41 B5 ;1<35< 1> * !* - D5> 401230 40585 9: <5;7G 1= 6185 407> 1>5 61>40 405 :765 9: >14 5HA;79>5< 05 A1;9@57=4589>D5:4937491>=9;5<F.85A1841?5D581>405 B7:9: 1= 405 :?18> :474565>4 1= 85:A1><5>4 1! - 7 - @13>9J7>@5 ?7: 47C5> 7>< 405 @8969>7; @7:5 ?7: 8539:4585<BG405897;1284 ) 4 9: 405 @1>45>491> 1= 405 @16A;79>7>4 4074 7@@2:5< 1: 41 =1869>3 4056:5;D5: 9>41 2>;7?=2; 7::56B;G @765 7>< :47845< @;7969>3 405 A18491> 1= 405 ;7><1>?09@04059>=1867>407<@1>:482@45<405@1?:05< 7>< :4185< 09: @81A: 1> !*!* - 74 ** A6 4 9: 7;;535< 4074 7@@2:5< 07D5 2:5< $ =18 <5:481G9>3 405 :05< @81A: 7>< A18491> 1= 405 ?7;; 05G 07D5 7;:1 7::72;45< 405 9>=1867>4 7>< 09: ?9=5 7>< @8969>7;;G 9>4969<745< 41 47C5 7?7G 40598 ;9=5 D5> 401230 :2@0 :58912: 7;;537491>: 785 67<5 405 =98:4 9>=1867491> ?7: @76541B5;1<35<1>;G1>* !* -49::4745<4074 =98:4 9>=1867491> ?7: 9>9497;;G :5>4 41 405 1==9@5 1= 405 2A589>45><5>41=1;9@55;737D94081230A1:4?09@09: :79<41B5405857:1>=18405<5;7G24>1409>307:B55> A;7@5< B5=185 405 1284 41 :2B:47>49745 405 :765 05 @1AG1=405=98:49>=1867491>8539:4585<B5=185405'73?7< A1;9@5:47491>?7:<745<* !* - - 8 - : A58 405 =98:4 9>=1867>4 405 9>=1867>4 7>< 09: ?9=5 411C 4857465>4 74 '73?7< 1D58>65>4 01:A947; 7>< 405857=458 9> 7>37:2;9 24 40585 785 7B:1;245;G >1 65<9@7; 85@18<: 41 :2B:47>49745 409: @1>45>491> >405 1405807><9>D5:493749>31==9@5807<A81<2@5<405?12>< @5849=9@745 <745< +*!!* + 85;749>3 41 405 9>=1867>4 9::25< BG <69>9:48749D5 65<9@7; ==9@58 1662>94G 57;40 5>458 '737?7< @@18<9>3 41 ?09@0 405 9>=1867>4 07< >14 :2:479>5< 7>G 5H458>7; 9>I2895: ?05> 05?7:5H769>5<1>!!* -74 !A6 * 059>D5:493749>31==9@587;:1A81<2@5<405@1AG 1= 405 :A14 6707J78 :79< 41 07D5 B55> <87?> 1> * !* -951> 405 D58G >5H4 <7G 1= 8539:4589>3 405 & : A58 409: 6707J78 40585 ?585 >1 :93>: 1= @1669::91> 1= 7>G 1= 405 1==5>@5: 7: :4745< BG 405 9>=1867>49>405=98:49>=1867491>?0585949:@1>45>491>1= 405 9>=1867>4 4074 7@@2:5< 07D5 B812304 $ 7>< <561;9:05< 405 @1?:05< <5:481G5< 405 @81A 7>< 7;:1 <561;9:05< 7 A18491> 1= 405 ?7;; 1= 9>=1867>4.: 012:5 - 9 - <5=9>945;G 40585 :012;< 07D5 B55> :165 487@5: :93>: 41 :2B:47>49745405:765 05 F. 85A184 :2B69445< BG 405 9>D5:493749>3 1==9@58 9: :2AA1845< BG 405 :474565>4: 1= 7B124 =9D5 ?94>5::5:9>@;2<9>34059>=1867>4:A58405:474565>4: 1= 7;; 405:5 ?94>5::5: >1 9>@9<5>4 7: :4745< 07< 47C5> A;7@5 7>< 40585 785 >1 6745897;: 41 :2B:47>49745 405 @1>45>491> 1= 405 9>=1867>4 7: :4745< 9> 405 =98:4 9>=1867491> 1?5D58 405 :474565>4: ?585 <745< **!* - ?05857: 405 9>@9<5>4 94:5;= 9: <745< !*!* - ! <69445<;G 405 9>=1867>4 85:A1><5>4 1! =9;5< 1! !* + :55C9>3 67><7418G 9>I2>@491> 7379>:4 405 7@@2:5< B5=185 405 897; 1284 05 @1AG 1= 405A;79>49:>14A81<2@5<B5=18540512841?5D587: A5840518<58<745<**!* )405:79<:294@76541 B5 <9:69::5< BG A7::9>3 18<58: 1> 1 =9;5< =18 85I5@491> 1= 405 A;79>4 2><58 18<58 + 2;5 1= - 10 - 1851D58 94 9: 1B:58D5< 4074 40585 9: >1 85;95= =18 <5@;789>3 405 89304: 1= 405 A;79>49== 9: :12304 =18 9>405 :294 532;78 7AA57; 9> 1! !* ) B5=185 89>@9A7; 5>9189D9;$2<357><$&407>9?7:7;:1@76541 B5 <9:69::5< 1> * *!* ) <69445<;G >1:5@1><7AA57; 9:A85=5885<7379>:4405:765 4 9: >14 405 @1>45>491> 1= 85:A1><5>4 1! 4074 05 07: :12304 =18 <5@;787491> 1= 09: 89304 1D58 405 <9:A245<;7><747>GA19>41=4965D5>14058?9:540585 785 7B:1;245;G >1 6745897;: A;7@5< B5=185 405 1284 41 <9:@;1:5 @1669::91> 1= 405 1==5>@5 BG 405 7@@2:5< (05> 405 =98:4 9>=1867491><15:>1467C5124 @7:5 7379>:4 405 A549491>58: 7>< ?05> 9>D5:493749>31==9@5807:=9;5<405F.85A184A81<2@9>3405 6745897;:?09@0<561>:487454074405857857B:1;245;G>1 6745897;: 5D5> 41 :01? @1669::91> 1= 405 1==5>@5 <1 >14=9><7>G857:1>4185I5@4405F.85A184 =9;5<BG4059>D5:493749>31==9@58D5>401230405:?18> :474565>4: 1= 405 9>=1867>4 7>< 09: ?9=5 ?585 85@18<5< - 11 - BG405897;1284405:474565>4:1=B140405:5?94>5::5: 785E2945@1>487<9@418G41405=98:49>=1867491>=9;5<74405 9>9497; :4735 ><58 :2@0 @98@26:47>@5: 405 :79< :?18> :474565>4:?12;<>145>7B;5405897;12844185I5@4405 F. 85A184 7>< 41 47C5 @13>9J7>@5 1= D78912: 1==5>@5: 7: 7;;535< 0585 785 >1 6745897;: 41 @1>:494245 7>G1==5>@5@1669445<BG4057@@2:5<5H@5A4:5;=:58D9>3 7>< @1>487<9@418G :474565>4: 1= 405 9>=1867>4 7>< 09: ?9=5 0585=185 76 1= 405 1A9>91> 4074 405 @8969>7; A81@55<9>3: 9>949745< 7379>:4 405 7@@2:5< 785 9> @;578 7B2:5 1= A81@5:: 1= 405 1284 7>< 405 :765 9: ;97B;5 41 B5E27:05< G7445>491>?7:<87?>BG405;578>5<@12>:5; =18405A549491>584140518<58<7845<! !*! A7::5< 9> 8969>7; 549491> 1 * ) !* BG 409: 1284 ?05852><58 405 A549491> 4074 ?7: A85=5885< BG 7@@2:5< 1: 41+7><?7:@76541B57;;1?5<7><405@8969>7; A81@55<9>3:7379>:44056?7:7;857<GE27:05< - 12 - 1>:9<589>37;;405:5=7@4:7><@98@26:47>@5: 761=4051A9>91>4074405A85:5>4A549491>9:;97B;541B5 7;;1?5< @@18<9>3;G 7>:?58 405 7B1D5 A19>4 9> 405 F 7><A81@55<5<41A7::405=1;;1?9>3, 05@8969>7;A549491>9:7;;1?5< 05 @8969>7; A81@55<9>3: 9>949745< 7379>:4 405 A549491>58 7@@2:5<1)9>1 !+ !* 1>405 =9;51=;578>5<9D9; $2<357><$&1284'73?7< =18 405 1==5>@5: A2>9:07B;5 2><58 5@491>: + ! ! !+*7><*-857<?9405@491> 1=405><97>5>7;1<59:0585BGE27:05< !+* &$$) % 9:41 ;1 '