Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 60925 (PNJ)
KULDIP KUMAR SHARMA v. FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA AND ORS
CWP/11613/2018 · 2025-01-13
Vinod S Bhardwaj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 60925 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 60925 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"#"$%&&'
(% )*(& +, +&
-----
!" #$ %& '(#)*
+%#& '(#)* "
,,,,, , +&.&/ 012
*#$$-* # ./ # 01 * +#$ ##-& # ) #& 2- #$1) 2#$)2'(#$-3*)%$$))%)-#%1#3$$ #* # 45..4# 01*6(%'(& #) #&#$1#$$3-*##$) 01* # 2 )1-*#$1*#) 2#$)2'(#$-3*7/8 ))%)-#%1# ##$* )/9# 01* ##-- (& # ) # 2- * '3 )$ 01* VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
""
%$)*( *#*: * '() " #) ####+# " ;<=.79# 3#2 ##+# " ;< =73#*#)&#) )2 ##& ( >#* # # 3# % # ))( # /=& 01 * * ##-&#?'*(*#-)*3*#(? ( *# '3 ) * *%- @%#1 ) AA9447 0#- #-& 3# #((#$$1 20$)*(%# 3-**(?*(*#- )*3*#(?3##?'01*94=&01# *#$(%-)0#- #0%A#(?# *%02 # #)) #'*))(*#(*3##*2)() (?# *)(?3##?'01#*#$(%- )0*# (' (?&**#$$00$)#1$ (#% * 3*$ ##- 3# $# #) # *
#: : #*3##-/7=*( *#* %)) )2 # (# #( 0$2 # ( # 2 (#$ $#' )2 4A .A 3*(* 3# %$1 #' 01 * (2 #%*1 * 2# # 2 # * #$ ) * )2/A=A*( *#3*$*3# #$ # #0*# AA& # 22 3# (% # * $'$ ) / # * #( ) *
#:& ##- 3*(* (*(? * 3*# (? * 0# ) 8 (? ')(# 01 2#$-)*(?# *#-)(?*( *# **# #?'*)(?$1#*#$ (%- # 3*% 8 *1(#$ ')(# # *# * VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"="
*#-3#)*#*#**#(?*# 0 *( 01*(( #))&:-)*#*# *#3#0$)*2 (%(**#-$$101#*#$ (%-)0#-# *#*3*#(?(*(? 01*223 (' %- * (%20(1 ) * 0% #$# 1 (' 2%(**:-#*/=* )%* ( *# ' # @%#$1 *1(#$ ')(# # ==&*3#*#-4A&3**3# #$& * 2'2 ) 3*# (? # (#$ 3# 2# 01 * ##-"*
#: # ' * 2# %2 # =5=A 3# ' % * %
-%$# /9 ) 2 ) 2#: #$1 * ( *# 1 *3' 3# 2# -# - * #(*)3*#4A'*##-"*
#:3##$ ' 3*22# %2 # 97A&*#2)(*#-&# *#'*%-*# (#$ )(*# 0#?&*3'&3*$* *# 0 #3# # *#* #$1 ) 2#$ )2 '( #$-3* # ))% ) 7/8 ) * -#%1& * ##-"*
#: *# 0$))3*#2#$1) %(2(#$013#-) # )3 1# 3* (%2%$#' ))(* ( *#**# *%0#0#*#)* 2)2#: #$1#-#*
$#($#( 01**:% -2) *B0$%2%) #*2#)
& #;/<79=( *#3** 2$1#' 3*#)(*#-#-%)*#2( &# VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"A"
###23%$ #2% (2#*#'#)* :% -2# *%!"
!
"
"
#
"
$%&
' #
#
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"/"
" #
!" # $ !"% &# '!(" ' )
* + ,- ./
0!"#$'!"%&#(!(" 1$2
$
#
"
" #
"
(
"
#
"
)*+
" $%&
'
'
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"4"
$))),,- '
'
$))),,- =
$#(#$$#( *:% -2*2#) -
34/ //*5
06
7
/
!8"
# 1$1
$
"
# .+ ),// 0 !,
1 2 3 4 (
5
#" 6
'
3 24
"
2 7 8 1
7 ) 9 2
( 1 ).-/*
.-)./*./)/:9 6 (
;
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"7"
5 6
# 8
'
'
#
<
5
(
): )+
=
"
>
3(9!9" 7
(
0 ? @@@
):
"
): ;
+
#
" .+),// 0 !, 72A5B8 72A5B8
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"9"
A
* ( *# * @%1 ))( *# ( #2#$( -*#* #3% #?
%- * #0( ) * & 01 * ##- *2$) # *(& * ##- (%$ *#' 0 $ )) 01 # 2#$$ $#0$1 $1 ) # %'1$## *#('1)*#(%#$*#-#$%-**#' 0 ))( )2 * ##- * )%* ( *# * ##- (# %*#0% 2###1( )*(#$*# 3 #(* # 6$##*##$0)%* #3*1* 1 * ( #0% * #(* ) * (#$ *# 0 2# (& * $#0$1 ) *
#:"##- 3# # # 3* *# ) *
/
- * #0'& %$ ) * " # ) # %02 *# # 22# %2 ) (*#- # =A (#- )' (*#- 3# ' % * * - # (*#-"*& * #0 *2$) )2 %1 )2AA$$* #)*2*(2#%*1*# (% #22)'-*(*#-"*#* (* )#* ) * )2 * 220 ) * 22 *# * 3##'#$#0$#* (3*%*22# %2) VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"."
(*#-*3## *2#-#)* (##0*#* #23##$' %*'#
- *# -'3*(*3#% % $1(' 01*AA -%$# #2#$ @%1 3# *#) ( %( 3* * #(# #$$ * ( - * 3 ) * # 3 6#2 * ( ) * # # %1("6#2*# 33##$6 *2 0--# #%1$# ' (&* # %( #1 ' ( #$ @%1 # ./A 3# '%#$$1%02 01*@%1))(3*#$$*(*#-$'$ #-#*3*$ 0' ($% -(#%-)$) 9&&=5"#((%)2##)*(?*#' # ) * @%1 %02 01 * @%1 ))( '- * (*#-)2##)*(?6#( #% !"
:;5;<#6;=.;<;
6
" 6 '
58 8
(
'58 86 )%%& )))- ,:/<-+<%%%C
2)/).)*.D<
<#
6
'<
)/)..%)*
'
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
""
' < :*
0
<##
6
./)..%)*
86
<#
65
86
E)* #F 6 A A G#384 =
+).%):,).%):.:).%):
*)).%):
1 .%):
G)384 5# 86 ( ! 6
!
6
! #
' B0!< )3)-/ 4 7 ( 86
D !7 3G 4A 87 3C4 ;
8 7 38 4
'< ' .:).%):
!F
' 58
)%%& 8 2 7 38 4 58
)))- ,:/<-+<%%% C
' 2 )/).)*.D< VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
""
<# 68 27 384 A A G#384
' 1 86 A AG#384
'<
./)..%)*
'
' :*
0
' 6!D)*
<##
68 ./)..%)*
< 86
###
!<) A
A G)384
58
86
?< ) E D
1.%):
'< '
'E#(D)% 'E
. E
'< ./)..%)* 1 .%):
/%,- *,:,,% C
* '<
< VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
""
'
'
A AG)384
" 58 ( .%$.%)* 86 ! 6 6 E :- .%$.%)* 7 38 4 58
'
8
'
' 6
'
*)).%): 6#
6
' ::+,+$
58
(
' 6 '
'
7 38 4
6
6 E:- .%$.%)*
D
7 38 4 7 (
' 6 2 6
6 E:- .%$.%):
?<
9E ' '#
'
'
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"="
8A AG###384 #D 8
#
#
7
' ( 7 38 4 2D 9 ' 6 7 38 4A AG###384
#
A A G)384 +).%): ,).%): .:).%): 8 2 7 38 4 A
A G###384
+).%): 0 G
7 384
G###384
A AG#384 ' ' )*).%):
' 86 ' # 86
'<
6 #
6
"
8 27 384 A A G###384
"
"
86 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"A"
8 27 384
< 6
'
' 6
1 7 3C4 58
2
' (
H2 +%%D< "
" G7I *..%):)%..%):3B08< )%3AA4
6
!<. 8 27 38458
0
' -).%)*1 .%):
' ' 6
50 )$D)+)%.%):7 38 4G
02G( 6
" 2
8 '
2 6
50
6 +).%): ,).%): 8 2 7 384
" 6
'
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"/"
6
7;
7 ( )%).%): E 0 6
7 384
!<. "
6
"
"
<
" :
)*).%): !<.
6
.*).%): <
" :7; 7 384 )...%): 3B0 8<#3AA4 #
7 384 )...%):
.:).%): *)).%): 6 6
6 7 384
" E
.:).%): ( 6
"
7 ( )%..%):
" 7; .:).%):
*)).%): 3B0 8<.3AA4 (
" VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"4"
6
7 384D
=
" )%..%):
#
7 384 G###384 58
"
..%%%7
8
7 384 58
" 7 ( ,-.%)* *)-.%):
0
0. " 6 ' *)).%): 7 ( B0 8<).3AA4 #
G###384 '
6
< 6
6<A AG)384
'58
#
A A G#384
( VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"7"
" < 6 6
58
A AG###38 4 6 G###38 458
6
.%)) 7 38 4
'D !<.
6
7 38 4
<7 <%<
#
A AG)384 *%D*)).%): 0
A AG###38 4 58
7 38 4
'D
D
86 *)).%):
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"9"
#
8 2 7 38 4
.%)*<): ))D.%)* ).D.%)*3B08<.3AA4 86( 01.%):
7 (
..).%):3B08<*<AA4
'<'
8 2 7 384 )$-.%)* ' A A G384
D
86
D
86
D
7 (
'
A A G) 384 8 2 7 38 4
A A G#384 6 6 E:- .%$.%): '
( 7 38 4
'
DA AG#384 A AG###384 86 3 * B0 !<)4
D6
D
' VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"."
86
J 4
)-*#0'&%02 01*%$*##$$ *()*3 %$1#?( #($% - *(?*#'-0') 01*##-##$)2# )((1 ( 3# #$ ()(#$$1 *# * ##- ; <*# #$*%-*#$$1('1 #0%*#-( &*3'& * *2$) * 2* ) C#%#1& A*#*3 ' $# * # # * # 3 0- % $1*(*#-#-# **#-)*) (?3#% *#' 0 ' #-# * 01 * @%1 ))( #) ()(#$$1(-#$$* )#%$01*2* *( $#' 7
)%*( *#()*-%$# #2#$ @%1& # (1 *) 3# %$ * %02 * 0:(&3*(*3#%02 4A(#)%$( # *)& * ) %*2 # ./ 3## #-# * 2- %*2 ) 2#$ )2 '( #$-3* )%$$ ))%)-#%1 9
#%1 ##$ #-# * # ) %*2 3# ) 01 * * $$# %*1 A/ #$-3**%$2#1##$ # .9/ #$*#-3# #$-# #-#*4/#3$$#/ #$ 3## *#$45..43*01* VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
""
)%*23##$1 2 ) )2 D#$1) 2#$)2 '( #$-3* )%$$ ))% ) -#%1E *# ) D2#$ )2 '(#$-3*7/8))%)-#%1E . '3
# A4 #$-3* * %$2#1'3 # .A73#*#)) 01 *3*(*%(*'33# 2 01# #$ # /9
)%*( *#*'(( )* #-' 01* #) #;#))<
-%$#&.7# *# * ( % # (0 % * -%$# *# 0 2(%$%$1)$$3 %%1)*#-*# 0 %$16 *01#$$*#%*0%*%02)* 3 $#(?- 2 * (*#- ) 2## ) A 0#- 3# #0$* ( # ) #$$ * %02 )2 * 8 *1(#$ ')(# ) * (?
& # %02 01 * %0 22AA
)%* ( *# * #-%2 ) * #0% 2$#1)*$##-#*##-*
#:2((' ( *3#*#(%#$(% #)*( # *
#:3#$1# %'1))(> &####2)#$$-#3#' % *
#: ) 2 ) 2 #$1 # # ## ) %*2 3# '%#$$1 # * 3# 22 ) (*#- 0- @% #-#*##-*
#:*@%1( -*#*# 0# #-#*)%*)(#$2# 01* VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
""
%$ ) * * # 99= # 01 * %3**() *#1$1*6)#1 # %*2*# 6#( #% !" )
..+D..- # ' .,%).%)$ 3 0 !</4
K .+D.,%,.%)+3 0 !< )*4
-$& .$%).%)/ 3 0 !<)+4
. ;
0
.%)*<)$ D
5 #8 27 A AG <###38 4
%+%).%):%,%).%): .:%).%):*)%).%):
'
0< ),%..%)$ ! VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
""
' ./)..%)*
.:%).%): )%:. )%:. ,))"
2)/./*./D<
8 2 A
8 2
' '
' %+%).%):
8 2 B"
8 2
8 2
. #
"
D
* ; 8 2
'
8 2
''
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"="
8 2#
8 2 # 8 2
8 2 2-$;
#
>
L!F 2! K.%)%3$4-/* 2F ! < 7' 5 ;K ),,)3*4 21 ./%
0
?< L!F 2! )
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"A"
! "
"
"
$%& ' # <
#
"
#
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"/"
( L6#6),,+3)4+)-?1 ),,$ 3/4 +$ G 8 6 ' ),,) 3)4 -)$ 34? 1 ),,/ 3/4 :-%
$
"
"
#
"
(
"
#
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"4"
"
)*+ 9
MB N 2F !
<
7' 5 ; $
"
#
.+ ),// 0 !,
1 2 3 4 (
5 #"6
'
324 "
2 7 8
1 7 # 9 2
(
1 ).-/*
.-)./*./)/:96 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"7"
(
; 5
6
# 8
'
'
#
<
5
(
):)+
=
"
>
! ),/* 3*4 ;2 +/ 0
?< 9
):
"
): ;
9 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"9"
MB N :
7 AA G
8 2
' 8 2 8 2 ' 6
'
8 2
' $ 6 8 2 7 G '
+ )*%,.%.*J
( *# (2$#( * #0' # & # %$2#1 #)) #' ) .= 3# )$ 3* * ( 03 * $ ) * 'F"#"'F * $ ) *
#: 3# ()(#$$1(%$$ %# 3#6$# #3*1###$*#' 0 2 % 0* * * $'# 6#( ) * # #)) #'# *%! )
./%/.%.* >
>
? VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"."
G <# 38 4 5 8
.%%$.%)*
*)%).%): 3
4
.%)*<.%)$
'A AG<
###38 4
'
8 =
%+%).%):
%,%).%):
2
2
8 2
7 38 4
A AG<
###38 4# D
'
"
..)).%): 7
8 6 (
G
7 3F 4
5#2 6
! 0 2<*
3 0 2<) O 2<.
4 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"="
8 2 7 38 4
'
7 .))%.%)$ 3 0
!<,4
.%%$.%)+ 3 0 !<)%4
'
8 2
.%%$.%)+3 0 !<)%4
8
6
G
"
'
./)..%)* "
" 3 D2
4
*))..%)*
0 2<:
.:%).%):
)%%&
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"="
"
'
./%/.%.* >
#
3 0 !<:4 B"
2 3 0 !<+4
3 0 !</4
,:/<-+<%%%
" )))-
2 )/).)*.D<
2
)+),+D<
2
)/./*./D<
P
L=
"
"
=
'
(
=
8
B" G<# 38 4
'
8 2 7 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"="
38 4
'
2 $/ 2 $%
5# 34 2 ),-) 3
4
8 2
2 +%3
4
'
'
=
%02 01*2*#*3#*$(% # ) * (? 3* *%- *#- 3# )% # *# *
#: 3# * ##- ;< 3* 3# (*#-- * %'1 %1 # 2##)*(?(3##0% *2(* 3# (*#-"* %
-%$# /9 # 3*
-%$# / ) * # ) # ;#))<
-%$#& .7 ;) 2#: #$1 ( -<3*#*
#:3#(*#-* %
-%$#4;) 2 #$1 ( -< *(& (*#- #-# 0* * 3 )) # # %(* * (# ?
#1 * 2# ) #3# -)%*2*%( *#*:% -2$ %01 *3%$ 0#$(#0$*)#()*(#( VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"=="
*# (#&* $@%2$13% 2$#(*#-*) *#2$#5 )#%$)%*( *##-#* # 01*#%*#0%))%)*-#%1)*&*#$ ) # 0) * $$- ))( % * #12 ) +#%1(&.7*(2#%**% # # )$#)*-#%13*(*3##))2 01*$$#%*1# 3$$>** 3#%0:(2#)(*#$$-G
"/7A) 3*(* 3# #$$3 ' :% -2 # A # * (-* " $#-#%1)#'%)* 3# #
$#( #$ $#( * :% -2 ) * B0$ %2 % * 2# ) + : 5
<
>( *##3:% (&*-*%
"#(#*' (# (# #%$)*$) $$# %*1 * :% ( ((%2(0 # () ((*)$#3# *( %%$-2#)2(##- ):%('$#)($)#%#$:%(# )( # :% (#2*#'#)*# :% -2# *%!"
,
::%* 6E/%++D%)
.)).%%%
.%)%.%%) $ ? 9 (<
F
" VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"=A"
#
6
B 0
6
E 0
B"6
3
4 )*<$/ )*<$, .:*.%%% ( B" 6
#
G
#
B" 6
#
B" '
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"=/"
#
#
#
5
0
( ' '
L
'
B"
9 5
<
<
G ! #
#"6
#"
#"6 ! ) . * : #" )% (
<
0
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"=4"
..+
#
1
'
<
))
#
-<!("8$$>1 1 ' (
)/, ? 9 "
"
#" 6
#
"
*%, # "
0
#
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"=7"
"
#" 6
0 9 ). ( L# O 6 ),,+3)4 +)-? 3),,$4+ -:, A 21 ' -$, ? 91
!
"
D
"
"
( VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"=9"
E
B
"
D
D
"
"
#
D
' 9
"
J VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"=."
A
2$# $#3 3# # 01 * B0$ %2 % * 2# ) 0 -.0
#4;A<43*3#*$ *#20$)*-*%"#(#*' (*# *# #$# 1 0 ( 01 * @%1 ))(& * ($#1 #%*1#3$$#*$$#%*1*-*%3) :% (#$'3(#'*) -)* ($#1#%*1## #$$#(%5#%*1*#'#)*:% -2# *%!"
+(
'
0
#
1 ' <
3 G ! 6 3
4 7 E
A 3 4 .%%+3)4 $//? 3.%%+4.*-* *-,4 /
)(#$2# *:% -2)*B0$%2 %*2#)
3 # !(" 2 ( *# ( * ($#1 #%*1 *# #?
( # %))( 2##$ #'#$#0$ ( #$-3* * 6$## ) * $@% %02 3- # #$ * #-%2 *%-* * %$& * (($% 3*(* # 3$$ )% (# 0 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"A"
) 3* 01 # 3 % * #' # ) * # :% -2 # *%!"
D)+
"
"
'
"
<
";'
'
"
..+
)/
<
VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"A"
"
5
E
J 4
*#' *# $# %$ ##- 0*#$) ) * ('## *#'-*%-** (%2#'#$#0$( 7
* %$ ) * *# 2*#(#$$1 #-% *# (# ) - 3 #$ ( 01 * @%1 ))( #-#
"*
#: 3*$ ( %(- * @%1 #-# * # *#(#$'# (%2#3(#1)*2'* (#*# 0%$ *2*%$*#0() *#* # #-%23%$ @%"#(#)' (# 2)* ) - ( * @%1 3*#& # * # 99=&**# #$# 1() *#1*6)($#2- #13**
#:&##-*()((# 3#*#* 3# # #$$-# ) 2"## #-# *
#: # 3$$ #-%2 3# #$# *#*$)#-?$#( % *
#: 3#*# 0#(?-% *# %$3# ( )$# #)) #'* )%$3# .=-%*#*3# #$$-#)#1$)#-2##)(?#-#*
#:# *3#% #*3(#%)#%'1$#$1#$ ##' #0% * *#- *#'- ((% %- * ) #(%#$ ($ ) 3#()(#$$1%02 3*#()(($#2#0%*0- $$# -)(#$4A#$#)2*## VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"A"
1#()$-)*#)) #'&*()(()*#)) #'2# % % *%&#'#$ (03*#$$-#&*$&* 0$& * (*#- # * #$ *#' 0 #3 * #2 *#'-0 01* &*3%$ 0 )2 ?- "#-# * 2 #) * (*#$$- *# #$# 1 0 () 9
* -' ((%2#(& * )#( # ( #0' 2# %(' * (# ($#2 #1 #1 3* ##-"*
#: #-# 3*2 $1 # %'1 $# *# 0 #0$* # ' *%&# ))#$%*2(%$ 02 01 * (2 #%*1 # 3* 3# * #(%#$ (% # ) * (?&3*(#1 )((15*#-( &#-## 3*3#2%02)##)) #'01**#**# #? ' * (?
' * (? # *#$ (#$(%$# # (#1 % # #(%#$ *1(#$ ')(# (# 0 #(( # # -% %))( #0$' * ) * 0$1 (#1 % # *1(#$ ')(# #$( *#*3##) #$3# #0 /= # * % #)) #' ) C%& = 3# (%20%**#'6( %(## (#%3*$ (#1-%#')(#)*(?# 3%$ 0*2 *#)&( *#(**# (# %#*1(#$')(#) * (?& *(& * (# 0 *$ $#0$ ) #1 )((15*#- * #'- #? ' * (*#- ) * (?& * (# ($#2###$%') #?')(? 3%$ (##'1#0% VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"A="
# 2#'%#)'1#?-'(*#-30*#' 2$#$1# 23*(?*$1*-0#?'3*$ #)-*(*#-#(*3*((%*##?' (?)2##$(%20# (#B0*$ #((%#0$)*(? *#**# '#* #$$1*0##(#1-%# ')(## )) *('('% (&**# #((#((%#0$1 . *$#3*#'-03$$$ *#*() )( 01 # 3 % # :% (#$ '3 #-# # ($#1( -$2 he High Court would not sit as a Court of appeal to supplant its own decision for that of the competent authorities. I find that no %(*-% *#'02# %#3%$ 2#*# *#'$#)($)#%#$:%(*(#1' ( *# 0 ( 01 * (2 #%* > & * %*2(#0# 0*(?-$1 #( -* -#'1)'(*#-#-#*2
*3#(( -$1 2 * # 01 * $$# %*1 # 45..4& 2 )1- * %*2*#)D2#$)2'(#$-3*7/8))%) +#%1E# *#)
'3-%*1 # /9()2-* #2#*01#))2
/, +&2
.'
F
G**#?-5# % H5
G**
#0$
! H5 VISHAL SHARMA 2025.01.28 16:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document