Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 5987 (KAR)

SRI. PATIBANDLA ANAND KUMAR A/O LATE P P SASTRY v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/103676/2024 · 2025-01-08

J M Khazi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

1 !"#$# %&'( ! "#$$ $%! !$!%& ' ( ! "#$$ $!$ !$!%& ' )! !$ $ * ) !!$ %&' 2 ! ! ( ! # #$ $ $!$ !%& + ) $!% $ %* ' $ ! , ' ! & ' ! % % $ #$ $ $ $ & ' $ ! -% . ! & ## ( $ ! # & $ -%$ ! # $ ! (! $ ! 3 /((. * )0((.* 1232345167894:61:66:3;51<:7:==>71<47:5< 9:?1 @3A1< 2937 B1232345 >5<16 623=A1 :5< 4@ 291 457232>2345 4@ 5<3: 68 1=2345 ' 6 24 C>:79 291 =4DBA:352 <:21< ' :5< 35 64& $ 61;372161< E1@461 617B45<152 4 @46 291 4@@15=17 B>5379:EA1 >5<16 1=23457 % :5< % 4@ 291 5@46D:2345=2:5<1=23457 $ #$ $ $ $ & :5< ' 4@ 91F 9:?1 :A74 74>;92 @46 :5 46<16 <1@611G35; 291 E:5H :==4>52 4@ A3B A2165:21 1E2 4A>23457 ?2 2< E1:635; = 4& ## 8329 >5I:E :5< 35< :5H$ 1A:9:5H: 6:5=9 :5< = 4# & 8329 1<16:A :5H$ 3<F:6:5F:B>6: 6:5=9:5<B:777>=946<167:7<11D1<@32 5 7>BB462 4@ 291 B1232345$ 291 B1232345167 9:?1 =45215<1< 29:2 291 =4DBA:352 :5< :61 @:A71 91 4 =45215272916135<4542=457232>21:5F4@@15=1:5<:77>=9 A3:EA124E1C>:791<16>7:A4@291=4DBA:35284>A<61?1:A 29:2291:AA1;1<26:57:=2345E128115617B45<15247:5< :5< 291 B1232345167 8:7 8329 61;:6< 24 291 @35:5=3:A @:=3A3231729:28:7E135;B64?3<1<EF7A3BA2165:211E2 4A>23457?22<)00@4679462*24291=4DBA:35:52$ 893=9<417542=457232>21:5F4@@15=1917:3<26:57:=2345 37=3?3A355:2>61:5<9:7E115;3?15:=63D35:A:5;A1EF291 =4DBA:35:52 8329 : D:A:@3<1 352152345 91 716?3=1 :;611D152<:21< 1J1=>21<EF7532FD:AA 35:5=1:5H)00@4679462*35@:?4>64@61?1:A 29:2 291 :5< 291 B1232345167 9:?1 =:B:=32F 24 =4526:=2 :5< <37E>671 291 :D4>52 35 @:?4>6 4@ 617B45<152 4 9161 :61 54 7B1=3@3= :AA1;:23457 :;:3572 291 B123234516791:AA1;:23457D:<135291=4DBA:352<417542 =457232>21:5F4@@15=1:5<2913521523454@617B45<1524 :BB1:67 24 E1 711H35; 61@>5< 4@ 291 :D4>52 91 :AA1;:2345735291=4DBA:352<417542:226:=2291B64?373457 5 4@ 1=23457 % :5< % 4@ 291 5@46D:2345 =2 :5< 1=23457 $ #$ $ $ $ & :5< ' 4@ 91 35?1723;:235; 4@@3=16 9:7 ;3?15 61C>3732345 @46 @611G35; 291 E:5H :==4>52 4@ $ 893=9 61C>3617 72645; 7>7B3=345 611G35; 4@ 291 :==4>52 84>A< :D4>52 24 :@@1=235;291A3@14@B123234516735216D74@623=A14@291 457232>2345 4@ 5<3: 9161 :61 54 72645; 7>7B3=34>7 =36=>D72:5=17248:66:522917:D1 1232345167 :61 B64@177345:A7 91 :AA1;:23457 D:<1 35 291 =4DBA:352 61A:217 24 D4512:6F 26:57:=2345 711H35; =61<32 @:=3A32F EF 617B45<152 4 2 9:7 ;3?15 : =63D35:A :5;A1 17B45<152 4 9:7 542 @4AA481< 291 B64=1<>61 D:5<:21< >5<16 1=2345 )* 6 1232345167 :61 9:?35; ;44< =:71 45 D16327 :5< 915=1 291 B1232345 57>BB4624@291=:714@291B1232345167$A1:651< =4>571A 61B61715235; 291D 9:7 61A31< >B45 291 @4AA4835; <1=373457 6 )3* :6<:635; 72:214@:6F:5: )* )33* A:;9 72:214@22:66:<179K67 ) * )333* 913A:1E:723:5 7(:8:9:6:IK56 ) * )3?* 3I:F>D:6!9:3K67 72:214@172 15;:AK67) * )?* 32179>D:6(9: 72:214@:65:2:H: :5<67) *& )?3* :6:EI32:>6 72:214@>5I:EK56 ) * )?33* :=935!:6; 72:214@22:66:<179:5< 56) * )?333*:A329:2>6?1<3K67 72:214@22:6 6:<179:5<56) *' )3J* 63:;>A:?:5=9:63<9:6:4K67 7 2:214@:65:2:H:K56) *# )J* 7:21A5;3511635;2<K56 72:21 4@ :65:2:H: K 56) * 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 7 & 1:651<!7>ED3221<72:21D1524@4EI1=23457 72:235;29:2291B123234537542D:352:35:EA1:5<617B45<152 4%2:2172645;AF4EI1=2@46;6:5235;29161A31@774>;92 35291B12323454B64B16:5<61:745:EA1;64>5<71J372724 ;6:5229161A31@17B45<1524=4DBA:35:52372914@ 6:E9:5I:5: 61:23457 ?2 2< :5< 6173<152 4@ 6:E9:5I:5:4>9:6<::9:H:63:5;:546<16241J215< 291 716?3=17 4@ 291 46;:537:2345 :=6477 :65:2:H: :5< 24 4B15 518 E6:5=917 35 :AA 291 <37263=27$ 617B45<152 4 46;:537:23457 8161 35 511< 4@ @>5<7 ==46<35;AF$ 32 :BB64:=91< 61B6171521< EF B1232345167 91F :77>61< 24 B64?3<1 =4AA:216:A @611 A4:5 24 617B45<152 4=4DB:5F:5<?163@31<291<4=>D1527 91F:77>61<;6:5235;=4AA:216:A@611A4:54@& 64617:5<@>653791<74D1@46;1<<4=>D1527:5<D:<1: @:H1 :;611D152 :5< ;42 4B151< : 7=648 :==4>52 5<16 29191:<=61<32357>6:5=1$1;:A9:6;17$2:DB>2F$14 10 8 :B32:A A:2@46D =9:6;17$ 3=1571 9:6;17 :5< >3A<35; 1B4732 451F @46 4B1535; 4=312F E6:5=917 :2 :AA1798:6:D :5< (:F:5:;:6$ 15;:A>6>$ B1232345167 =4AA1=21< $$ :5< =91:21< 617B45<152 4 @216 61:A3735; 29:2 291F 9:?1 E115 =91:21<$ 617B45<152 4 @3A1< =4DBA:352 :71< 45 32$ =:71 37 61;372161< :5< 35?1723;:2345372:H15>B51 3?1H::5<6:?115:$@46D16 361=24674@9:?1:AA4221<79:6178329L&A:H9735 291 5:D1 4@ 83294>2 B:F35; 291 :D4>52 4@ L& A:H9779:61724291=4DB:5F915>DE164@B123234516 484>A<1JB3617445:5<291=4DB:5F83AAE135:=23?1:7 B162914DB:5317=2 2 291 23D1 4@ 51;423:2345$ B1232345167 B64D371< 24 B64?3<1 : A4:5 4@ ' 64617 @64D :5< <361=21< 617B45<1525>DE1624@>6537961C>361<<4=>D1522964>;9 1D:3A2@>62916<361=21<4B1535;4@7=648:==4>5283294>2 B64?3<35;:5F7:5=2345A12216@64D2911A31?35;291 846<7 4@ B1232345167$ 617B45<152 4 9:7 26:57@1661< : 242:A 7>D 4@ @64D 291 :==4>52 4@ 6:E9:5I:5 9 =61:23457 63?:21 2< 24 291 :==4>52 4@ >5<16 291 91:<7 % =61<32 357>6:5=1$ A1;:A =9:6;17$ 72:DB <>2F$ 518 =:B32:ABA:2@46D=9:6;179135?1723;:234574@:6=45<>=21< 61?1:A 29:2$ B1232345167 :61 35?4A?1< 35 291 =4DD377345 4@ 2914@@15=1<361=2AF 9115236126:57:=2345E128115291B:62317:61 2964>;9 45A351 1?16:A 1D:3A7 7152 24 617B45<152 4=4DB:5F :5< 9:27:BB D177:;17 =A1:6AF 35<3=:217 291 352152345 4@ B1232345167 24 =91:2 617B45<152 4 1232345167 :61 @:A71AF =A:3D35; 29:2 617B45<152 4 9:7 73;51< 291 :AA1;1< :;611D152 1232345167 9:?1 =61:21< @:A71 <4=>D1527 91F 9:?1 542 :2 :AA 7>ED3221< :5F B64B47:A 24 @46 7:5=234535; A4:5 :5< 9:?1 542 B64?3<1< :5F 7:5=2345 A12216 91 B123234516 9:?1 7152 <>BA3=:21 <4=>D1527 24 617B45<152 5>DE16 284 2964>;9 1D:3A 2 37 A1:652 29:2 291 B1232345167 :61 9:E32>:AAF 35?4A?1< 35 ?:634>7 =63D35:A =:717 B15<35; 35 <3@@16152 =4>627 91F 9:?1 @3A1< 2937 B1232345 =45=1:A35; D:2163:A @:=27 10 17B45<15279:?1:A74=4AA1=21<:D4>52>5<16 291 91:< E>3A<35; <1B4732$ E>2 45 15C>36F 8329 291 =45=1651< 485167$ 32 37 61?1:A1< 29:2 291F 9:?1 542 :2 :AA =452:=21< 291 E>3A<35; 485167 9161 37 =:71 D:<1 4>2 :;:3572 291 B1232345167 37A1:<35; 2937 450EA1 4>62$ 291F 9:?1 71=>61< 72:F 46<16 4573<1635; 291 71634>75177 4@ 291 :AA1;:23457 D:<1$ 291 E:5H :==4>52 4@ B123234516 37 @64G15 @ 291 352163D 46<16 37 542 ?:=:21<$ 29161 84>A< E1 1?16F =9:5=1 4@ B1232345167 ;12235; 291 :==4>527<1@611G1<:5<74>;92@46<37D377:A4@291B1232345 ' 1:6<:6;>D15274@E42973<17:5<B16>71<291 61=46<7 # 91 >5<37B>21< @:=27 :61 29:2 617B45<152 4=4DBA:35:52 37 291 4@ 6:E9:5I:5 61:23457 63?:212<:5<6173<1524@6:E9:5I:54>9:6<::9:H:63 :5;:546<16241J215<291716?3=174@29146;:537:2345 :=6477 :65:2:H: :5< 24 4B15 518 E6:5=917 35 :AA 291 <37263=27$ 617B45<152 4 46;:537:23457 8161 35 511< 4@ 11 @>5<7 2 37 :AA1;1< 29:2 893A1 E648735; 45 291 5216512$ 617B45<152 4 =:D1 :=6477 61B6171521< EF B1232345167$893=9B64I1=21<3271A@:7:45%E:5H35;35:5=1 46B46:2345 )* =6477 291 2:EA1$ 291 B1232345167 B64D371< 24 ;12 : =4AA:216:A @611 A4:5 4@ & 64617 @64D :5< =4AA1=21< : 242:A 7>D 4@ $$ >5<16 <3@@16152 91:<7$ 35=A><35; 4B1535; 4@ 7=648 ==4>52 :5< :A74E>3A<35;<1B4732352917>D4@$ $@464B1535; E6:5=917:2:AA1798:6:D:5<(:F:5:;:615;:A>6> ?15 294>;9 291 B1232345167 <3< 542 7948 291 7:5=2345 A12216 @64D $ E1A31?35; 291 846<7 4@ B1232345167$ 617B45<152 4 9:7 =61<321< 291 :E4?1 :D4>5224?:634>7:==4>527:7<361=21<EF291B1232345167 17B45<152 4 9:7 :A74 :AA1;1< 29:2 1?15 294>;9 291 :;611D152375421J1=>21<$291B1232345167:61B64I1=235;:7 294>;9 :;611D152 37 1J1=>21< :5< 9:?1 =61:21< @:H1 <4=>D1527 5 15C>36F$ 617B45<152 4 @4>5< 29:2 291 B1232345167 :61 9:E32>:AAF 35?4A?1< 35 7>=9 4@@15=17 :5< 12 29161@46161C>1721<291B123234516724B:FE:=H291:D4>52 :5<4529136@:3A>61@3A1<291=4DBA:352 481?16$ 35 291 B1232345 291 B1232345167 9:?1 =A:3D1< 29:2 37 542 : 545%E:5H35; 35:5=1 46B46:2345 46 : :5H$ E>2 32 37 : <1E2 =:B32:A 716?3=1 B64?3<1622:H17@35:5=1@64D327D1DE16A15<35;B:625167 894 :61 E:5H7$ @35:5=1 357232>23457 :5< :A2165:21 <1E2 BA:2@46D7 1232345167 9:?1 :A74 B64<>=1< 716?3=1 :;611D152 <:21< E128115 2< :5< 89161323761@1661<24:7:E>735177@:=3A32:2467 B16291216D74@291:;611D152$323761C>361<24@>65379:AA 291 35@46D:2345 4@ 291 B421523:A E4664816 24 291 :5H 2 79:AA 61@16 291 =>724D167 24 291 :5H 35 :==46<:5=1 8329 2911A3;3E3A32F=632163:B64?3<1<EF291:5H279:AA=61<3246 <1B473235:==4>52<173;5:21<@46=4AA1=23457$:AA291D451F 29:2D:FE1=4AA1=21<61=13?1<EF3245E19:A@4@291:5H 832935291:5HB617=63E1<<:F74@=4AA1=2345 13 22917:D123D1$291B1232345167=45215<1<29:2 617B45<1524<3<5429:?129161C>37321<4=>D1527:5< =61<327=46124:?:3A291@35:5=1:77372:5=1@64D291E:5H35; 357232>2345 :5< 29161@461 32 9:7 :BB64:=91< 551J>61%372911D:3A61=13?1<@64D24;129168329 =4B317 4@ :;611D152 :5< A3:E3A32F :;611D152 8329 : <361=234524;12291D73;51<:5<=4>6316291D24237 :<<61771< 24 B123234516 4 8329 291 =4BF 24 617B45<152 4 @ 291 61C>172 4@ 617B45<152 4 @46 @35:5=3:A :77372:5=1@64D8:7542=4573<161<EF2917:3<:5H :5< 3@ 37 542 : 46 E:5H :7 BA1:<1< 35 291 B1232345$ 2915 89F 291 A12216 :2 551J>61% 84>A< E1 377>1< 7 32 : <4=>D152 =45=4=21< EF 291 B1232345167 :7 :AA1;1<EF617B45<1524M 551J>61 $ 893=9 37 291 716?3=1 :;611D152 E128115 :5< 37 :A74 =4526:6F 24 291 =452152345 4@ B1232345167 29:2 37 542 : 912916617B45<15249:<B64D371<@35:5=3:A:77372:5=1 @64D 2964>;9 46 29161 8:7 : =457157>7 14 E128115 291D 24 :?:3A 291 @35:5=3:A @:=3A32F @64D <361=2AF$37:D:221624E135?1723;:21<22917:D123D1$ 617B45<152 4 9:7 :AA1;1< 29:2 294>;9 B1232345167 9:?1 =4AA1=21<:7>D4@$ $248:6<7E>3A<35;<1B4732@46 712235; >B E6:5=917 :2 :AA1798:6:D :5< (:F:5:;:6$ 291 7:D137542=61<321<24291:==4>524@291E>3A<35;485167 5 @:=2$ 291 E>3A<35; 485167 9:?1 1JB61771< 29:2 291 B1232345167 9:?1 542 :BB64:=91< 291D 24 6152 4>2 29136 B61D3717 AA 29171 :7B1=27 =61:217 <4>E27 :7 24 291 E45:@3<174@291B1232345167 9161 37 7B1=3@3= :AA1;:2345 D:<1 EF 617B45<152 429:2B12323451679:?1@>653791<@46;1<<4=>D1527:5< ;42 1J1=>21< 291 :;611D152 9161 37 :A74 : 7B1=3@3= :AA1;:2345 29:2 73D3A:6 =63D35:A =:717 :61 B15<35; :;:3572 291 B1232345167 91 35?1723;:2345 74 @:6 =45<>=21< 61?1:A 29:2291B12323451679:?1>23A371<291:D4>52<1B47321<EF 617B45<152 4 24 291 B16745:A >71 91 35?1723;:235; 4@@3=16 9:7 542 @4>5< 291 4@@3=1 4@ B1232345167 :2 291 ;3?15 :<<617712323451649:7:E7=45<1<:5<937:66172:5< 15 35?1723;:23453751=177:6F91:AA1;:23457D:<1:;:3572291 B1232345167 :61 ?16F ;6:?1 2 61C>3617 29464>;9 35?1723;:2345:5<@35<35;7:724291=4DBA3=32F4@B1232345167 35 291 =63D1 35 C>172345 9161@461$ 32 37 542 : =:71 @46 C>:7935; 291 =63D35:A B64=11<35;7 :;:3572 291D 91 <1=373457 61A31< >B45 EF 291 B1232345167 :61 542 :BBA3=:EA1 24291@:=27:5<=36=>D72:5=174@291B617152=:7146291 :E4?161:745729374>62374@291=4573<161<4B3534529:2 B1232345167 :61 542 15232A1< @46 291 61A31@7 74>;92 35 291 B1232345 & 5291617>A2$291B1232345@:3A7:5<:==46<35;AF$ 291@4AA4835; 632 B1232345 @3A1< EF 291 B1232345167 37 <37D3771< +,' & (