Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 59184 (PNJ)
KAMAL KUMAR SALLY v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS
CWP/15546/2015 · 2025-01-30
Vinod S Bhardwaj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 59184 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 59184 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!! "
#
$ $
"
$! RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
%&'()'*+,+(-.#""
./
" 0"
" 1111
!!"#$% ! &'
( )*'' +, - .!$%%. /--$%%/
) $%"/.$% ## $%-%-$% -
01*Sr. Panel Counsel for respondent No. !!"#$% ! &*2 13'for respondents No.$4 !!"#$% !for respondents No. $ 25''
**0 6" !!"#$% !for respondent No.4 $%"/.$% ##$%-%-$% - 7777 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
0"
2 "3 4
8 ( '229* '(2' 9*(*' 3 53220*528 3 0* 3 9* ( : 2/--$%%/';<50
5 *=*' '
; +, 2 !!"#$% !';&2'&*2
''3 *= > ;
8 3 2( * = *'
' + ;=
;, ' 0 3 2'3 +, 5*' // + 2 $" %$%%!, + ;5*' // ;,(*' ( ' ? % % $%%/5 * 2 5@ ' '' 3 (32
A *' (A 3 =
6 5' 0 35 $-%- /- 23*' 2 ' 2 6- : '( RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
=*23''('' 2'3 6 5' 5 ( 5 ( =
5 2' 2'3 0 3 5 ' 2 5 A 3 ( * : +, 8 ' : 3 =
%$%4 /-/ * '( !"## "
"
!"##$ % "
B =
( B>(' 5' 8 =
' 32' 2'3B > (' 5' ( ( 2'32 *' 5' 3 ( '3 '3''('' ( 2 5 '' 5*8 2'3 5' ( '2*0 5*''' 5 * 8 5*' * 3 =
5 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
' '5( :* / % %. /."8 ' : *
&' ( "
"
" (
(
&' ( !"##
" )
* )" "
+ ) , ,)
!"## &' -
" ). " ,
, &
!"##'
"
" / 0
" & *
'
A *' * *4 $$%%-( 0 3 5 5*' C 5*' // :5''2'3(0 % % $%%"' 2'3( RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
5*' // 8 ' : * 12 ( 30 &'
112445) +,
,
1 666 666 666 1&' (
0 &'
"
-
0 07 #
" /! 8" # 9
"
)/!)1::5
&'
#
&'&' !
0 &'&')
" -
250140244;
) )
" -
-
&" ' &' ( < "-
)250 140244;) ) 7
- RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
& ' ( ,
#
,
&
' ( ,
"& '
" -
7
0 &' &' (
250140244;) )
)
< " - )
)
-
&" ' (
"-
#
(
"-
)
5*' // 2'3(0 * 0 35 $%%" 5 2 ' 2 ' 5*' * 3 =
2'3 5' (*'5 3 2 2'32 '' 5*'(*23 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
5 3 25*' // 2 2$" %$%%!8'( ( 3) ( 22:2'3 8 ': ' 5226 "/# %%"$%%. 2'22 =
6 5' 5 : *
( "
0
( 8
8 (
&
'(!"##$. #)
" !"##$. &' ! )
<
- ( ,
2514244;! 24=50=; ,
, !/ ( < -
)
, / RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
(!"##
>
" <
&' # 3 (" " ? (
. " " (
"
# -
)
" @
*
&' ) "
" -
" !"## $ . ( "
, /!! " -# %) )
@
82 (** ) =
( @'66 !!?$%%4 $%%/ B 3) 6 5' 5 ' @2 35 * ( 2 '' 5' 8 ' $%%/ * RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
. #$AB . -$$%"01;0;C244=
. 311244: . @
( $2=5:C"
= . 244
# D #) E ) 2 D 244:
%
!"##$ %
" ) "
)"
B
,
!
)
"-
55 ( '
A
*' 5 ' 2'3 5* ' 3 +,(' '3' 2' +, 2 '' +,
'' ( 5 * 0 3*' 2 22(* * 3 =
( = '2' 22* RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
( 2$" %$%%!=(*2* = 2'25*' // *22'2 (*22' 3 * ' 3 =
2'3 B >''
B* *2 *' 5*' // ' '3(2'3( 5*' // ( '': ( 3 (*' ' * 2 * (' @2 3(*''5 * 1@2 32'35' 3 2 3 ( 9* @ ' 3 2 '5( 8 3 (*' 2 2' 2'3 25 5 * B* +,' 3 3 '' 3 (''5 @ 322 * * 2'2* 5*' // ' ((*3* '3
A *' * 3 '' 25*' // 5 5 * ( * 55:2'3 0 35 ( (32 52 *523 =
2 ( RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
5' ) ' 3 ( 2 * 5 2'22= 53 *3 '3 0'2 +,* 52 '2'( 2 552
5 *' 05 '2 5 32('' 2'36 5' 5 3* 2 25 3 2 * 3 '2 B * *2 ' 3 @ * * 2'3 3 * *2 3 (*' '' :5 ' *?
32 * @2
' 2 3 2 ) 2)*3) =
6()' B>(''5' =*2 '5 5' 5 2 2'3 ' 5 * 3 @*
2 ( 25 3 6 5' '23* * 2 2'3 6 5' 5 ' 2 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
( '*36 5' 5 D 3 2 5*' 2'3=
*'5' 5 * 2 ' = 5*' /.% 31 2 = 3:'3 2'3 '' 2'3 5' B2''3 5* * 2(?2'36 5' 5 2'3 B > 3 *0 5 * *'(' =
B E* ' 1 2 = * '5 32* 3 *5 5' '2'3 5' ' ' 2' =
BE* 6()'(' * 2*'5 2'''=* 1 2 = ) 2 2 5 5 2 @
2 2'3(( % % /-#* (:2'3( 3* * @2 ( 1@
2= *2 5 31@
2 *2'* @
2( '2 =* ''* @
2' 3 '* RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
'''0*52B;'
* 2 * 2 !"#$%&"'#!())
#
' !('*#+#,-) !!('*# " 8 ': 2 * '( 1 ! ,
" &' #0
&2'# ; @>! )1:=5 & !!1:=5'& < <')" @ @> ! " 7
> @>! )1::4& < <' @
1$ )1::4
, "
- # &
<"-# <'(
@> 1$ )1::4F
"- ,(0
"-
( @><
1 D ) 1:G
1 $ 1::4 =&='
3 =&='09 1 D 1:G&, ' 1$ )1::4) ,
)@><
@> , RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
=1 =1
3 =109
@><
1D )1:G
1$ )1::4 1$ )1::4 ,
22(
@><
>) ,
#
1 $ ) 1::4)
,
!) )
=&='
=1 @>
1D )1:G
1$ )1::4
1 $ )1::4
@><
G
@>
1 D ) 1:G
666 666 666 : (
!,
1 $ ) 1::4 ( @>
RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
"- ( <
( ) ) , @> (
( @> ) )
)
"- ( " 7
)
@>
" 7 "- # (
" 7
+
1 $ ) 1::4
( ) )
"-
> (
@ +
"-
@> 1 D )1:G =1. )1:;!
)1:;! "-
15"H 14 $> <
,
% ,
# )
RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
15
C
#(
# ,
)
0
@
,
)
>
,
B
)
,
( $> <
"
,
F
+
@
)
)
) 0
) ,
)
),
) RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
) ! "-
"-
( " $> <
,
! "- )
>
(
"-
? " B < & '
F3'5 '2*' 5*2 ( ( 2 * 3 2'3 * 25 '*5 ' 2' B * : 222'3 5'''2 22
6 3 5*2 3 *' 3 0*52 * RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
= ' *' 5 *5*2 '''' 0*523*' ( '
8 9*( * 0** ( (( 2'36 5' 5 ': '2 * 1@
2 +5*' // , 30 35 2$" %$%%! '2'3( $%%"8 2'''3 2'3( 5*' //
' '2 ''3 * 2 2' ' 5*' 22 2 3 5' ) 6 5' 5 ( 2'3( 55' ( 5 3 2 ''( ( '' *?'' 5*+(** 3 =
,' = 2 6 5' 5 '3 2'* @2*' '28 =2 '5''3' ( 2 ''3 ' 2 > ' 2''322'355 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
6 5' 5 '' 5 3 2 5 5 2'3 0 3 5 222(*2* = 2'3 2* * 52' : 2'3 5' 2 2 : 3 *?'' 5 * +0 3 5 , = ( (' 2 (' =
('55*5 ''35*' // 30 3 5 ( 3 5 ' 3 3 2 53 35 8*2 '3 ' ( =
3'3 '( 22'3 B>2'35' : 2'3( 55' (*'5 3 2 '' '' 5 *?* * (' :5 * '' 5*''' 5*2 *' 2 3 = 5' 2:
* : '3 2'3 B > (2 2 3 = RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
* ' '' *' 5*'2 2' ' 2 3*5'* 3* *'3*' =
2 5 2 ''( ' 3 *?'' 5 *2 9* '3 23 2* 38 3:'' *' 5*' '' 5*' 3 '3 ' 2*'5*'3 =
' ( ( :5 ''3 *' 8 ' 9* * ( 2'2 5*' // 3 3)2 5**?
( 35') 5 ( * 3 2 * 3 + 5 '2 ' '3) , '2=) =
(''' (* 25 3 2 ' 2(2'3 ( ' =*' = 1 2 = 53'''3(*2* * 2 * 3 5 (5 B5 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
3 =
$%%/ 5) 5' ' * @ 2 ' '3 (* * 3 3 * 35 ( ''3 *'''22'3 2 2' 2 (5 2 ' 2 2 552 32* 3'
*5*5 *3 =
3'25 5' ''*5' 5 3 2 ( : '3 2'3 B>= 5*2'322 ' '82'3*5' 5 3 5*'( (5 5*? '' 5 * 5'3 *' 5*' *2 '32 2 5 5 28* 2'2 ( 2' 2'3 5' ? '' 5 *? 3 (*' *2''3 : 28 23'(3( 2'3 *' 5 235*'3? 5*' 23 *?* ( 2 (*'2*3 2( 2'3 5' 82'3* 5 3 5*' '' '' 5 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
* 8 * ' * ''3 *2 *2 25 '3 2 3( 2'3( 5 5'
5*2 ' *' =
3 325 32* 3'5*5'2' 2: =2( 2'2'3 =
2 * 5*2332*(2'32 '
8 (*'0*35 1@5 ** '' 5* *''3@ 2'2'3 5 3 *'' ( '' 5 * 3 2 5 * =
G 8 5 5 * (3''3 2'3' 2
2 3 *' 0*52B;'
* 2* 2 ! "#$ %&"'#!())
#
'.,/#01*2 5 5 =0*52 2 : 231 2= : '' 2'3 3 ( '' * ' 2 '5 280*52( 3 B;'
* 2* :( 2'3 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
2 2 ( 5 : = ( : B;' * 2* '
*2 ''3 ( * ( 5 3 1 2 = 2'3 6 5' 5 * ( : 53 = *) 23 1 2=': (( 2'35' 3*': = =
3( 5 2'3 5' 2'3 * ':31 2=5 3 '5 52@ 1@ 2 : 3 ( 5 3 5*' (*' ' ( = 0** : * *2 31 2=3 /-.
= '3 3 5*2 53*' =
'3 *2'
* 5*2 2 > 2' 5 5 5*' * ( 2'3 (*'5 (*' ' 2'3 * * * RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
5 5 5*' 3 (*' ' 3 5*'3*2'3
(* 3 3 '' *' ( 2 2' 8 5 ' 2 5 5 2'3 32 2 2 1 2=*' '232* *5*' // ( $" %$%%! '( 2 * 3 '' 5*' ' 5*''' '*
8 BG'
* 2 * 2 - ) ! +#,*&2,3#44#5 . 0 22 *2 * 3 *'8 ' 5 0*52: * ;: (
C
C,
* )
#
.+!-) !$67784399:.0
.;<0 =1> 44#5$'' ) -:.0 .;<0 .0 =1,#, "3&#**$- ) !:.0 RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
.;<0.0
"
=1 "453*$2#'& ;&9,&':.0 .;<0=!8'
'33'') #;'?) !$>@)$$':. 0
"
=A
9*'3 56+& 7'&+&+(-, %6' %88(5'9" 8 5'3 2*2' 2 5*' // + ( $" %$%%!,
6' 2 (*' ' 3 : 2@
21@
2? 2 5 1@? 23(*' 9* 2* 3 2 * @
2 2 * * ( * 2* '' '*' 3 2 * 5*' // 8 (''2* 2*3 322 ( 2 3 @* ?2'3 5 '*' 2* '' 9*' 2' 3 * 5*' // +($" %$%%!,''* 2 2 *2*( (2
5*$%-%-$% - @ *( (3 +, RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
5'3* * '' (' 25 2'*2'3* '2
30"
4
#2"
"7!#
% >C 3IC$
%
3IC$ RAJENDER KUMAR 2025.02.13 22:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document