- 1 - !"#" $%# $%# % & ' ! " # $ % & '# % " Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #% ' ("!" & ' !! !!) ' ' )! * )*(*#! ( % + ' , , -% -% , -% ./01 23. 4.252567.089 :6;78.< 5. 5=3 6;02 6>.07?.72<./1.0/7123.0.84671.72@.57=8.0>.1A523 7625:.151762:368.26.72.0/44./0/7:.2306;=3:6;78.< 60/44./0.1574.0867 ! 358A0524.252567 58 B5<.1:3/<<.7=57=23.601.0 4/88.1 @C 23. /07/2/D/ 2/2. 1?575820/25>. 05@;7/< .</=/>5 B60 83602 E9 57 44<5:/2567 6)*(*#! ( - 3 - A3.0.57 84.:5B5: 150.:2567 A/8 =5>.7 26 23. 4.252567.08 26 :67851.0 23. 0.40.8.72/25678 8;@?522.1 @C 23. /44<5:/72 1/2.1 ! ( ( )! ( /71 ) )! ( /2 77.F;0.8* /71 0.84.:25>.<C /=/5782 ;7B5<<.1 >/:/7246826B.:671/0C:366<88582/720/1. ;71.0 23..7.0/<.052/84.023./1152567/<8.<.:2567<5821/2.1 ! )77.F;0.A523/<<:678.G;.725/<@.7.B528 .F:.42 ?675260C @.7.B528 ;023.0 150.:2567 A/8 =5>.7 23/2 2358 .F.0:58. 83/<< @. 167. A52357 / 4.0561 6B 230.. ?67238B06?23.1/2.6B0.:.5426B:64C6B23.601.0 " 36;=3 2358 601.0 A/8 4/88.1 67 )! * 23. 40.8.72 A052 4.252567 58 B5<.1 67 ! ! ! /<?682 /B2.0 67. C./0 2A6 ?67238 A5236;2 :6?4<C57= 23. 601.0 4/88.1@C23. H 6A <./07.1 5=3 6;02 6>.07?.72 <./1.0 /44./057= B60 23. 4.252567.08 A6;<1 >.3.?.72<C :672.71 23/2/84.023.6>.07?.72601.01/2.1 H! "23. :;26BB 4.0561 A/8 ?.72567.1 57 23. 8/51 6>.07?.72 - 4 - 01.023/223.:/7151/2.8836A75723./1152567/<<582/0. 26@.B5<<.1;42623.7625B5.146828A5235785F?67238B06? 23. 1/2. 6B B57/< <582 60 ;426 23. B5<<57= ;4 6B /<< 23. />/5</@<. <.B2 6>.0 46828 A35:3.>.0 58 ./0<5.0 /71 23. 0.<.>/72 4602567 6B 23. 6>.07?.72 01.0 58 .F20/:2.1 57 23.=06;7186B23.A0524.2525673.<./07.15=3 6;02 6>.07?.72 <./1.0 A6;<1 :672.71 23/2 57 23. 5782/72 :/8. B57/< 7625B5:/2567 6B 8.<.:2567 <582 A/8 4;@<583.1 67 ! H! )/71/1152567/<<582A/87625B5.167 ! ) .7:. @C 23. 25?. 6B :67851.057= /7C /44<5:/2567 85F ?67238 25?. A/8 </48.1 /8 4.0 23. 6>.07?.72 01.0 3.0.B60. 23. 0.84671.72 3.0.57 A/8 762 :67851.0.1 B60 8.<.:25672623.7625B5.14682/713.7:.40/C.12358 6;02 26 8.2/851.23.601.04/88.1 @C 23. 57 44<5:/2567 6)*(*#! ( . ./07.1 5=3 6;02 6>.07?.72 <./1.0 /44./057= B60 4.252567.082/2. 0.52.0/2.8 23. =06;718 ;0=.1 57 23. 4.252567 /71 :672.718 23/2 57 2.0?8 6B 23. 6>.07?.72 01.0 /1152567/< <582 6;=32 26 3/>. @..7 - 5 - 40.4/0.1A5235785F?67238B06?23.1/2.6B7625B5:/25676B B57/<8.<.:2567<582 '.3/>.4.0;8.123.601.04/88.1@C23.57 44<5:/2567 6)*(*#! ( 3. A35<. 4/8857= 5?4;=7.1 601.0 3/8 2/D.7 762. 6B 23. B/:2 23/2 :/7151/2;0. 6B :/7151/2. /2 <6! 5. 5I/C/D;?/0 /C/DA/15 A/8 :/7:.<<.1 /71 3.7:. /;26?/25:/<<C :/7151/2./2<6"5.23.0.84671.723.0.57A6;<1@. 4</:.1 57 <6! /71 358 7/?. A6;<1 3/>. @..7 :67851.0.1/7123.8/?.A/82/D.7762.6B574/0/=0/43H 6B23.5?4;=7.1601.0 )3.3/8/<862/D.7762.6B23.B/:223/252 58 23. :/8. 6B 23. /44<5:/72 23/2 857:. 23. 7/?. 6B 05 5I/C/D;?/0 /C/DA/15 58 6?522.1 B06? 23. 8.<.:2567 <582 23. /44<5:/72 A36 58 4</:.1 /2 <6" /;26?/25:/<<C @.:6?.823.7.F2:/7151/2.;71.0<6! 7>5.A6B23. B/:223/22A646828/0.0.G;50.126@.B5<<.1B5082468258 B5<<.1 @C ?2 A.23/ /<5=/0/ /71 /8 23. 7/?. 6B - 6 - :/7151/2. /2 <6! 5. 5I/C/D;?/0 /C/DA/15 A/8 :/7:.<<.1 /71 0.?6>.1 B06? 23. 8.<.:2567 <582 23. 0.84671.72#/44<5:/72 A36 58 /2 <6" @.:6?.8 23. 8.:671 :/7151/2. 57 23. /1152567/< 8.<.:2567 <582 /71 23.0.B60. 83. 58 0.G;50.1 26 @. 588;.1 A523 23. /446572?.72601.03.3/82/D.7762.6B/<<23.8. B/:2608 5726 :67851.0/2567 /71 I;1=?.728 6B 2358 6;02 57 23. :/8. 6B 0.4602.1 57 /715723.:/8.6B !"#$ 0.4602.1 57 % />57= :67851.0.1 23.8. 2A6 I;1=?.728 /71 :67851.057= >/056;8 1.:585678 0.71.0.1 @C 23. 4.F 6;02 /7 6@8.0>/256758?/1.23/2/;2360525.8/0.0.G;50.126B5<</<< 23. 46828 A35:3 A.0. 7625B5.1 @C :67851.057= 23. :/7151/2.8 B06? 23. /1152567/< 8.<.:2567 <582 '3.7 23/2 @.57=23.<.=/<46852567/71A3.72A646828/0.0.G;50.1 26@.B5<<.1/710.84671.72A/823.7.F2:/7151/2./:2567 6B 4.252567.082/2. 57 762 :67851.057= 23. :/8. 6B - 7 - 0.84671.72#/44<5:/72 58 /0@520/0C /71 23. 8/?. 58 57 >56</25676B025:<.8/716B23. 678252;25676B 715/ ( 3. 6>.07?.72 01.0 0.B.00.1 26 @C 23. 2/2. 3/8@..7.F20/:2.1574/0/=0/436B23.4.25256736;=3 <./07.1 5=3 6;02 6>.07?.72 <./1.0 >.3.?.72<C :672.71.1 23/2 /8 4.0 23. 6>.07?.72 01.0 /1152567/< 8.<.:2567<582580.G;50.126@.40.4/0.1A5235785F?67238 B06? 23. 1/2. 6B 7625B5:/2567 6B B57/< 8.<.:2567 <582 23. /1152567/< 8.<.:2567 <582 A/8 588;.1 67 ! ) /71 ./0<5.0B57/<8.<.:2567<582A/87625B5.167! H! )/71 67 23. </82 1/C 6B :6?4<.2567 6B 85F ?67238 5. ! ) 23. /1152567/< <582 A/8 588;.1 3. :/7151/2;0. 6B :/7151/2. /2 <6! A/8 :/7:.<<.1 57 23. ?67236B.:.?@.0! ) *'3.78;:3@.57=23.46852567/712/D57=762.6B /<< 23.8. /84.:28 5726 :67851.0/2567 /71 857:. 23. 0.40.8.72/25678 8;@?522.1 @C 23. 0.84671.72 67 ! ( ( )! ( /71 ) )! ( A.0. 762 - 8 - :67851.0.1@C23.4.252567.0823.@C23.5?4;=7.1 601.0/<<6A.123./44<5:/2567/71150.:2.14.252567.068! /71"3.0.5726:67851.023.8/510.40.8.72/25678 2A/8 ?/1. :<./0 23/2 23. 8/51 .F.0:58. 836;<1 @. 167. A52357 230.. ?67238 B06? 23. 1/2. 6B 0.:.542 6B :64C 6B 8/51 601.0 782./1 6B 1657= 23. 8/?. 23. 2/2. /4406/:3.1 2358 6;02@.</2.1<C/B2.067.C./0 3. A35<. 4/8857= 23. 5?4;=7.1 601.0 0.B.00.12623.I;1=?.7286B2358 6;020.B.00.18;40//71 572.0?86B23.8/?.8;:3/150.:2567A/8=5>.7.7:. A.16762B571/7CB60:.5723.:672.725676B23.<./07.1 5=3 6;02 6>.07?.72 <./1.0 /44./057= B60 23. 4.252567.082/2. 2 58 23. </48. 67 23. 4/02 6B23. 2/2. 67<C5776240.4/057=23./1152567/<<582A52357/4.05616B 85F ?67238/8 4.0 23. 6>.07?.72 01.0A35:3 /?6;728 26 1.B./257= 23. 05=32 6B 23. 0.84671.72 A36 58 .<5=5@<. .7:. A. 16 762 B571 /7C ?.052 57 23. '052 .252567 26 G;/83 23. 5?4;=7.1 601.0 4/88.1 @C 23. 3. 4.2525671.8.0>.826@.158?588.1857:.23./1152567/<<582 - 9 - A/8588;.16723.</821/2.6B.F450C6B85F?67238/7123. 8/?.A/82/D.7762.6B@C23./71B6023.</48.867 23.4/026B23.4.252567.0805=326B23.0.84671.72:/7762 @.:;02/5<.1/823.0.84671.7258.<5=5@<./7123.8/?.58 :67851.0.1@C23. 7>5.A6B23./@6>.158:;8856723.'052.252567 58158?588.1 .252567.082/2.58150.:2.126:6?4<C23.5?4;=7.1 601.0 4/88.1 @C 23. A52357 / 4.0561 6B 85F A..D8 B06?23.1/2.6B0.:.5426B:.025B5.1:64C6B2358601.0 () & ' # () &%' # 5826,<6,H) 2,%