- 1 - ! "! #! $ %!#!! $ %! ! !## &'( )* !!% &'( ) * ! " # $ % Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & '("(# ( ) * '('! ( $ +("# $ * # * * %! * * * $ $ ( ) * *$ & ) * ,( , ! ,! - 3 - # $ ,% * '("(!% $ $ ) , * '('! ( $ '("(!% * - " ( * * %! * * $ $ .( ) * $ , , / $ / $ * - 4 - % , / $ * 012 344536 378 9:.22 .;<59=1.7 3:5 >1658 936617? 17 @A52=1.7 =05 <A8?B57= 378 3C3:8 83=58 432258;D=05881=1.73612=:19=3785221.72.A:=378 881=1.736 183: 21==17? 3= 323E3F36D373 >.: 20.:=G=05:1;A736H 0.A?0=0534453612612=58>.:.:85:2C1=0=05 9.7257= .> ;.=0 =05 43:=152 053:8 =05 344536 >.: >1736 8124.23605.C75:.>=05E5019650327.=9036657?58=05 <A8?B57=3783C3:8432258;D=05:1;A7362.>3:32=05 .C75:129.795:758=05<A8?B57=3783C3:80323==31758 >17361=D .=195.7:524.7857= .(12A77595223:D3205 C324639585I'43:=5;5>.:5=05:1;A736 ! 05 83=5 .> 3991857= 17E.6E5B57= .> =05 E501965853=0.>.?5202.7.>1=036:3.03D37F53:57.= 17 8124A=5- =05 .76D 8124A=5 12 C1=0 :5?3:8 =. 613;161=D >32=5758 .7 =05 72A:3795 .B437D 378 5I.:;1=37= 9.B45723=1.7 17 =05 344536 >1658 ;D =05 72A:3795 - 5 - .B437D ;517? * . ! 378 >.: 17385@A3=5 9.B45723=1.7 17 =05 9:.22 .;<59=1.7 >1658 ;D =05 9631B37=29:.22.;<59=.:217 *:.; . # # 53:8 :1 3E578:3 588D 653:758 9.A7256 34453:17?>.:=0534456637=378:137<55EAB3:3=16 653:7589.A7256>.:=05:524.7857=29:.22.;<59=.: ( :1 37E578:3 588D 653:758 9.A7256 34453:17?>.:=0534456637=C1=0366E505B57952A;B1==58 =03=>.:=05E1.63=1.7.>4.619D9.781=1.7232=058:1E5:.> =05 .>>57817? E501965 C32 7.= 0.6817? 37D E3618 8:1E17? 6195725378399.:817?6D903:?5217E.F17?=054:.E121.72.> .=.: 5019652 9= 4:52258 3?3172= =05 8:1E5: 32 C566 32 .C75:.>=05E50196505:1;A7365::5817>32=5717?=05 613;161=D .7 =05 72A:3795 .B437D :525:E17? 61;5:=D =. :59.E5:=0523B505.C75:.>=05E501965:5B317585I' 43:=5 378 17 E15C .> =05 903:?52 65E5658 3?3172= 01B 1= 9653:6D 20.C2 =03= =0.A?0 05 03E17? F7.C658?5 =03= =05 8:1E5: 12 7.= 0.6817? 37D E3618 5>>59=1E5 8:1E17? 6195725 57=:A2=58 =05 E501965 =. 2A90 45:2.7 7 =0525 - 6 - 91:9AB2=37952=0572A:3795.B437D127.=613;65=.43D 9.B45723=1.7 378 .A?0= =. 03E5 ;557 5I.75:3=58 . 362.=059.B45723=1.73C3:858125I.:;1=37=378:5@A1:52 B.81>193=1.7 5>A=17?=052A;B1221.72.>=05653:7589.A7256 34453:17? >.: =05 34456637=+72A:3795 .B437D :1 37<55EAB3:3=16C0165=3F17?A2=0:.A?0=05<A8?B57= 3783C3:8E505B57=6D2A;B1==58=03==05:1;A73617=05 3;25795 .> 37D 5E185795 463958 ;D =05 34456637=+ 72A:3795 .B437D =. 20.C =03= =05 8:1E5: .> =05 .>>57817? E501965 C32 7.= 0.6817? 3 E3618 378 5>>59=1E5 6195795 3= =05 =1B5 .> =05 3991857= :1?0=6D 8591858 =05 B3==5:17>3E.A:.>=059631B37=.>3:329.B45723=1.712 9.795:758 =05 :1;A736 032 >31658 =. 9.72185: =03= =05 85953258C3253:717?2( '45:B.7=005D53:.> 3991857= C32 ) 05 85953258 C32 3?58 D53:2 3= =05 =1B5 .> 3991857= 378 C32 8.17? B5903719 C.:F 3= 38C37=1 1663?5 03E17? 012 .C7 20.4 17 =05 73B5 378 2=D6532G$3103E3713:3?5H05:1;A736032=3F57=05 - 7 - 179.B5 3= =05 :3=5 .> 2 ' 45: B.7=0 C0190 12 5E57 3?3172= =05 179.B5 >1I58 ;D =05 5?36 5:E1952 A=0.:1=D>.:=05D53: )3=2!( '45:B.7=017 2. >3: 32 37A72F16658 63;.A:5:12 9.795:758 03= 343:= =05:1;A736032>31658=.388=05*A=A:54:.2459=A2=3F17? 17=.9.72185:3=1.7.>=053?5.>=058595325832D53:2 32.7=0583=5.>3991857=17E15C.>=0563C63188.C7;D =05 .7H;65 45I .A:= 17 =05 9325 .> !"#$%.362.=05 :1;A736 032 >31658 =. 3C3:8 344:.4:13=5 9.B45723=1.7 A785: =05 9.7E57=1.736 05382 378 23B5 :5@A1:52 17=5:>5:5795 3= =05 03782 .> =012 .A:= 378 2A1=3;6D ;5 B.81>158 378 2.A?0= =. 812B122 =05 344536 ;D 72A:3795 .B437D378366.C=059:.22.;<59=1.7 % 3E17? 053:8 =05 653:758 9.A7256 >.: =05 34456637= 32 C566 32 :524.7857=9:.22 .;<59=.: 45:A258 =05 57=1:5 344536 4345:2 32 C566 32 9:.22 .;<59=1.7 =05 .76D@A52=1.72=03=3:125>.:.A:9.72185:3=1.73:5 %" - 8 - 1 05=05: =05 :1;A73612 <A2=1>158 17>32=5717?=0557=1:5613;161=D.7 =05 172A:3795 9.B437D =. 43D =059.B45723=1.7J 11 05=05: =05 9.B45723=1.7 3C3:858 ;D =05 :1;A736 ;5>1= C1=017 =05 5I4:5221.7 .> <A2= 9.B45723=1.7 1> =05 372C5: 12 .=05:C125 C05=05: =05 23B5 :5@A1:52 :5'85=5:B173=1.7 3= =05 03782.>=05.A:=J " A: 372C5: =. =05 3;.E5 4.17=2 >.: 9.72185:3=1.7172.>3:324.17= .1217G3>>1:B3=1E5H378 4.17= .12G43:=6D173>>1:B3=1E5H>.:=05>.66.C17?, !! ) 05 :1;A736 3>=5: 9.72185:17? =05 57=1:5 B3=5:136 463958 ;5>.:5 1= 378 03E17? ?.17? =0:.A?0 =05 <A8?B57=.>=05.7H;6545I.A:=17"&& ! ' () )* :54.:=58 17 +,- . $ ., 378 17 =05 3;25795 .> 37D 5E185795 658 ;D =05 72A:3795.B437D=.20.C=03==05.C75:.>=05E501965 C1=0 F7.C658?5 =03= =05 8:1E5: 818 7.= 0.68 3 E3618 378 5>>59=1E5 6195795 038 57?3?58 01B =. 8:1E5 =05 E501965 >32=5758 =05 57=1:5 613;161=D .7 =05 72A:3795 .B437D - 9 - C0190 C5 >556 8.52 7.= :5@A1:5 37D 17=5:>5:5795 3= =05 03782.>=012.A:=99.:817?6DC5372C5:584.17= . 17 G3>>1:B3=1E5H 378 3?3172= =05 34456637= + 72A:3795 .B437D . >3: 32 =05 9.B45723=1.7 12 9.795:758 =05 :1;A736 032 >31658 =. 9.72185: =05179.B53= 2!( ' >.:=05D53: )32>1I58;D=055?365:E195A=0.:1=D 05 :1;A736 032 >31658 =. 9.72185: =05 9325 .> =05 34456637=2 >.: 38817? *A=A:5 :.2459=A2 =3F17? 17=. 9.72185:3=1.7 =05 3?5 .> =05 85953258 32 D53:2 32 .7 =05 83=5 .> 853=0 7 =0525 91:9AB2=37952 =05 9.B45723=1.7 3C3:858 ;D =05 :1;A736 :5@A1:52 :59.72185:3=1.7 378 :5'85=5:B173=1.7 99.:817?6D C5 372C5:584.17= .17G43:=6D173>>1:B3=1E5H 3E17? 9.72185:58 =05 7.=1.736 179.B5 32 2!( ';D38817?# K32*A=A:54:.2459=21=9.B52 =. 2"(( ' 3E17? 9.72185:58 =05 23B5 15 2"(( ';D858A9=17?L=.C3:8245:2.736179.B5378 3446D17? 344:.4:13=5 BA6=14615: 32 G"H =05 6.22 .> - 10 - 854578579DC.A689.B52=.2 !# '2!( M # KII"IL 05>39==03==05:53:5>.A:85457857=205795 6.22 .> .72.:=1AB 1796A817? >16136 9.72.:=1AB =. 43:57=2 37821;617?21=C.A689.B52=.2 '2# I # 43:= >:.B =03= 2( ' 5390 12 3C3:858 =.C3:82 6.22 .> 52=3=5 378 >A75:36 5I457252 :52459=1E56D 36.7? C1=0 K 15 K M K 529363=1.7 .7 =05 9.7E57=1.7360538205:5>.:52!" '2) I K123C3:858A785:=050538G K529363=1.7/ ! 0A2.7:5'85=5:B173=1.7378:5'9.72185:3=1.7 =05 9631B37=29:.22 .;<59=.:2 3:5 57=1=658 >.: =.=36 9.B45723=1.732>.66.C2, +,-./01+2.,342 0523 .22.>54578579D 2 !# ' .22.>2=3=5 2 ( ' .22.>*A75:36I457252 2 ( ' .22 .> .72.:=1AB *16136 .72.:=1AB 378 3:57=36 .72.:=1AB2# I# 2 ' - 11 - K 529363=1.7 >.: =0:55 9.B465=58 D53:2 .> .75 =5:B .7 9.7E57=1.736 05382 N2 M ( M ( I KO 2 !" ' . ) # 99.:817?6D =05 9:.22 .;<59=.:23:5 57=1=658 =. 2AB .> 2!# 32 3?3172= =05 () %' 05 570379589.B45723=1.7.7=0585=5:B173=1.7C.:F2.A==. ;5 2#!"' C0190 20366 93::D 17=5:52= 3= K 45: 377AB>:.B=0583=5.>45=1=1.7=166:5361P3=1.7 ( *.: =05 >.:5?.17? :532.72 C5 4:.9558 =. 4322 =05>.66.C17?, 1 05344536>1658;D=0572A:3795.B437D 12 ) 11 05 9:.22 .;<59=1.7 >1658 ;D =05 9631B37=29:.22 .;<59=.:2 12 05:5;D / & - 12 - 111 05<A8?B57=3783C3:883=58 432258 ;D =05 881=1.736 12=:19= 378 5221.72 .A:= 378 881=1.736 183: 21==17? 3= 323E3F36D373 12 05:5;D B.81>158 1E 059.B45723=1.73C3:858;D=05:1;A736 12 :5'85=5:B1758 =. 2!# ' C0190 20366 93::D 17=5:52= 3= =05 :3=5 .> K 45: 377AB >:.B =05 83=5 .> 45=1=1.7 =166 :5361P3=1.7 E 05 3B.A7= 17 854.21= ;D =05 34456637= ' 72A:3795 .B437D ;5 =:372B1==58 =. =05 :1;A736>.:812;A:25B57= E1 05 ;363795 :5'85=5:B1758 9.B45723=1.7 36.7? C1=0 17=5:52= 2=3=58 20366 ;5 854.21=58 ;D =05 34456637= ' 72A:3795 .B437DC1=01721IC55F2>:.B=0583=5.> :59514= .> 9.4D .> =012 .:85: ;5>.:5 =05 9.795:758:1;A736 - 13 - E11 44.:=1.7B57= 32 C566 32 812;A:25B57= 12 3245:=05.:85:432258;D=05:1;A736 E111 ..:85:32=.9.2= !-) &#!!( % !-) &( % 12= .,6 .,#