- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &'( ) !" # $ % $$ & '' $ $( !" ) $ $ $ $ $ )$ *$ $*$ $ !""" # $ $ % $ *)+ )"))")$ $ & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * * ,%& * $* $ $$ * $ $ $$)))" ","')")) *$ $ $ $ $$ * * $ $ $ * $ $ $ $ $- $ % $- & ./01 23. /0456.728 9: ;./07.1 <9578.; :90 =923 23. >/02?.8 ) 3?8/>>./;?8:?;.1/4/?78223.@5146.72/71/A/01 9:23.0?=57/;?7)))"1/2.1","')"))>/88.1=B 23. 9502 9: 11?2?97/; .7?90 ?C?; 514. /71 ?@/B/>50/ 3. :/<28 9: 23. </8. /0. 23/2 97 ",")" /2 /09571 '" >6 7./0 /;;/;;? 0988 97 .6=3/C? /;?D92? 09/1 23. 1.<./8.1 10?C.0 9: 23. 9918 529 A/8 <96?74 - 3 - 29A/018?@/B/>50/:096.6=3/C?/:2.01.;?C.0?7423.=/D.0B ./2/=;.8223/22?6.;900B=./0?740.4?820/2?97$9) ') </6. :096 9>>98?2. 8?1. 97 3?43 8>..1 ?7 / 0/83 /71 7.4;?4.72 6/77.0 23. 10?C.0 9: 23. ;900B ;982 <97209; /71 1/83.1/4/?78223.8/?19918529 5.2923./<<?1.7223. 99185291/6/4.1 ' 3?8 ?8 / </8. :?;.1 :90 C.3?<;. 1/6/4. <;/?6?74 <96>.78/2?979:8)"""""A?23?72.0.82/223.0/2.9:E >/ 3. 0?=57/; <978?1.0?74 .72?0. 6/2.0?/; 97 0.<901 40/72.197;B""""A?23?72.0.82/223.0/2.9:!E>.0/7756 :0961/2.9:>.2?2?972?;;0./;?F/2?97 440?.C.1=B23.8/?1901.023?8/>>./;?8>0.:.00.1 ?7A3?<3?2?8<972.71.123/297",")"A3?;.10?C.09:23. 49918 /529 =./0?74 $9)' ! A/8 <96?74 :096 ?@/B/>50/ 29 .6=/C? /2 23/2 2?6. 23. ;900B =./0?74 0.4?820/2?97$9)')</6.:0969>>98?2.1?0.<2?97/71 1/83.1 23. 49918 /529 8 / 0.85;2 23. C.3?<;. A/8 292/;;B 1/6/4.1>>.;;/72?823.9A7.09:23.49918/529.3/8 792 <;/?6.1 /7B <96>.78/2?97 :096 * A?23 >9;?<B $9) )")," ' """"" A3?<3 A/8 C/;?1 :096 "!"')" - 4 - 29" "')"G H?823..>902A3?<3<;./0;B839A8 23/223.1/6/4.</58.12923.C.3?<;./71 H)?823.0.>/?0 <982 /88.886.72 ?885.1 =B 7/71 /?1B/ 7850/7<. 50C.B90 3. 292/; /69572 97 23. 0.>/?0 ?8 6.72?97.1 /8 8) 'G ?7<;51?74 ;/=950 <3/04.8 H ?8 23. >392940/>38 H' ?8 23. .82?6/2?97 4?C.7 =B 23. >/02B ?7 A3?<3 23. .82?6/2?97 ?8 6.72?97.1 /8 8)))," 52 23. 0?=57/;40/7297;B8""""A?23952/7B=/8?8/71 50C.B90 :..8/71;9889:?7<96.150?740.>/?0>.0?91A/879240/72.1 3.0.:90.0.I5.82.1:90.73/7<.6.729:23.<96>.78/2?97 ! H'?823..82?6/2?974?C.7=B23.850C.B909:23. 7850/7<. 96>/7B :90 /7 /69572 9: 8)))," 16?22.1;B 23. >9;?<B A/8 ?7 .H?82.7<. /8 97 23. 1/2. 9: /<<?1.72 /71 H" ?8 23. /22.82.1 <9>B 9: <.02?:?</2. 9: 0.4?820/2?973./<<?1.723/89<<500.197",")"6.0.;B =.</58.23.;/<D9:/52390 H'A/8792.H/6?7.13.8/?1 /69572 A/8 792 40/72.1 =B 23. 0?=57/; /8 23. /69572 ?8 /88.88.197;B=B23.850C.B909:23.7850/7<.96>/7B/71 79692?C.</7=./220?=52.12923.<;/?6/72.7<.23.8/?1 /69572 /88.88.1 571.0 H) ?. 8) 'G ?8 29 =. 40/72.1>/02:09623?8 H'?823..82?6/2?979:23.0.>/?0 - 5 - 197. =B 23. 850C.B90 9: 23. 7850/7<. 96>/7B /71 /8 >.0 H)23.8/;C/4.C/;5.9:23.49918/529?88 """ , 8 82/2.1 /=9C. 23. 8/;C/4. C/;5. 9: 23. 49918 /529 ?8 8 """ /71 ?2 ?8 29 =. /<<.>2.1 =52 ?2 A/8 792 <978?1.0.1=B23.0?=57/;/83.3/8792.H/6?7.123./52390 9: 23. 19<56.72 16?22.1;B 23. /529 6.2 A?23 /7 /<<?1.72 /71354.1/6/4.</58.12923./5298>.00.>902*0972 =56>.0 :0972 839A 0?432 8?1. 3./1;?432 /71 ?71?</290 A?718<0..7 4;/88 A?23 :0/6. 0?432 8?1. :0972 1990 A?23 4;/88 0?432 8?1. :0972 A3..; 65145/01 82..0?74 8B82.6 =91B 29> 0?4328?1.:0972A3..;2B0.1?8</710?4328?1.0./0C?.A6?0090 9: 23. 529 492 1/6/4.1 A3?<3 <;./0;B 839A8 23/2 23. 0./897/=;..82?6/2?97A/84?C.7:9023.0.>/?09:23.C.3?<;./2 23.0/2.9:8)))," 3.0.:90.23?89502:?718?20./897/=;.29.73/7<. 23. /69572 :096 8"""" 29 * +,- %) 'G J """&A?23?72.0.82/223.0/2.9:!E>/ G 723.0.85;223.:9;;9A?74901.0?8>/88.1 ?& 3./>>./;?8 - 6 - ??& .8>971.72 $9) ?8 1?0.<2.1 29 1.>98?2 8),"'GA?23?72.0.82/223.0/2.9:!E>/ ???& 7 85<3 1.>98?2 23. />>.;;/72 ?8 >.06?22.1 29 A?2310/A 23. .72?0. /69572 /;974 A?23 ?72.0.82 /<<05.197?2 *.- &%!! ( $ ?82$9 ;$9