Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58813 (KAR)
THE PRIMARY CO-OPERATIVE AGRICULTURE v. SHAMSHUDDIN S/O DASTGIRSAB KAKHANAKI
CRL.A/200087/2022 · 2025-07-14
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58813 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58813 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!%
$&&
'
'(&)*+')) ,
!"# $ % &
! ' !#( $ %&
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
) ( %*& )
) '
"!##"#! +#"#! )
))) ! ) ) , '
) )
,
-
!$ %- &
! ./01 02 /3/42 4./05.1 67859.4 :70 ;<. /==.44/5;
/5>
# .9=751.5;
/6689.1 ;<783< 9.0?.1 @2;< ;<. 57;26.7:;<./==./40.A/25.1/B9.5;
7A=4/25/5; 29 ;<. /==.44/5;
/5> @<7 </9 6</44.53.1;<.701.07:/6C82;;/47:;<./6689.1:707::.56. 851.0.6;275! 7:.37;2/B4.59;08A.5;9 6;%:709<70;
D 6;E&257 +#"#!1/;.1"!##"#!BF;<. - 3 -
112;275/4 2?24 813. /51 ) 2G/F/=80/ %:70 9<70; D02/4/329;0/;.E&
* )/6;9 25 B02.: @<26< /0. 8;A79; 5.6.99/0F :70 129=79/47:;<.=0.9.5;/==./4/0./9851.0
*! =02?/;. 67A=4/25; 6/A. ;7 B. :24.1 851.0 .6;275 #"" 7: 0 /44.3253 ;<. 67AA299275 7: ;<. 7::.56./3/259;;<./6689.1851.0.6;275! 7: 6; BF 675;.51253 ;</; ;<. /6689.1 29 ;<. A.AB.0 7: ;<. 67A=4/25/5; </?253 A.AB.09<2= B./0253 7+ /51 <. 7B;/25.1 =.0975/4 47/5 25 / 98A 7: 9!"""""
:70 <29 17A.9;26/514.3/45.6.992;F
*# 7A=4/25/5; H /5> 30/5;.1 ;<. 9/21 =.0975/4 47/5 75 #+"!#"! 6689.1 :/24.1 ;7 0.=/F ;<. 47/5 259;/44A.5;9 /9 /30..1 /51 ;<.0.:70. ;<. 67A=4/25/5;
1.A/51.1 ;<. /6689.1 ;7 0.=/F / 98A 7: 9+*""" 6689.1 </9 2998.1 / <.C8. B./0253 7"""( 1/;.1 !+!##"#"25:/?7807:;<.67A=4/25/5;:70/5/A785;7:
9+*"""
75 <29 /66785; A/25;/25.1 25 I29 /5>
- 4 -
2G/F/=80/ <. 9/21 <.C8. 75 =0.9.5;/;275 6/A. ;7 129<7570.1@2;</57:.51709.A.5;;</;D/66785;6479.1E
* 7A=4/25/5; /==07/6<.1 ;<. /6689.1 ;7 0.=/F ;<. /A785; B8; /6689.1 </9 57; 9<7@5 /5F 0.9=759. <.0.:70. / 4.3/4 57;26. @/9 2998.1 75 #+!##"#" ;<0783<0.329;.0.1=79;/511.A/51.1=/FA.5;701.0BF /<.C8.25/98A9+*"""
<.9/2157;26.299.0?.1 75;<./6689.175"*"!#"#!B8;/6689.1:/24.1;7=/F ;<. /A785; 67?.0.1 851.0 ;<. <.C8. 570 0.=42.1 ;<. 4.3/4 57;26. /51 ;<.0.:70. 9783<; :70 /6;275 /3/259; ;<. /6689.1
./05.1 02/4 /329;0/;. /:;.0 67A=4.;253 ;<. 5.6.99/0F :70A/42;2.9 98AA75.1 ;<. /6689.1 /51 0.6701.1;<.=4./ 6689.1=4./1.157;3824;F;<.0.:70. ;02/4@/9<.41
5701.0;7=07?.;<.6/9.7:;<.67A=4/25/5; 67A=4/25/5;37;.I/A25.12;9::26.0BF5/A.0281<..0 </?/5/9,!BF:24253/5/::21/?2;52;9B.</4:9.?.5
- 5 -
1768A.5;9 @.0. =4/6.1 75 0.6701 ?2J 129<75780.1 <.C8. /5> .51709.A.5; 67=F 7: ;<. 4.3/4 57;26. =79;/4 0.6.2=; /51 =79;/4 /6>57@4.13A.5; /8;<702J/;275 4.;;.0;70.=0.9.5;;<.67A=4/25/5;
/5>/51.I;0/6;7: ;<.47/518./9=.0I9!;7(
( 5 <29 60799
.I/A25/;275 <. /1A2;9 ;</; <. 29 @70>253/9;<./5/3.0/B78;75.F./0:07A;<.1/;.7:
60799
.I/A25/;275 B.253 ! !!#"#! . </9 :80;<.0 /59@.0.1;</;/B78;;<0..F./09./042.09!"""""
29 =/21 /9 =.0975/4 47/5 /51 /; ;</; G856;80. <.C8. 25 C8.9;275@/9;/>.5BF;<./5>
./1A2;9;</;;<.0.@/9/980.;F;/>.5/;;<. ;2A.7:30/5;253;<.47/5/5197/49707A29970F7;.. </9 /59@.0.1 ;</; ;@7 F./09 ;<. /6689.1 </9 0.=/21 ;<. 47/5/A785;/51<.12157;0.=/F98B9.C8.5;4F.</9 /59@.0.1 ;</; 75 !+!!#"#! ;<. <.C8. @/9 =0.9.5;.1 ;7;<./5>/9<.9;7==.10.=/F253;<.47/5/A785;. </9 :80;<.0 /59@.0.1 ;</; @2;<25 / =.0271 7: 92I A75;<9
- 6 -
:07A ;<. 1/;. 7: ;/>253 ;<. 47/5 /6689.1 </9 0.=/21 / 98A7:9#""""
/51;<.9/A.29/==07=02/;.1;7@/019 ;<.25;.0.9;/51=02562=/4/A785;
+ . :80;<.0 /1A2;9 ;</; 75 #+"!#"!
/6689.1 </9 0.=/21 / 98A 7: 9#""""
/51 0.6.2=;9 </?. B..5 32?.5./1A2;9;<.:7800.6.2=;9@<.0.25;<./6689.1 </90.=/21;<./A785;@<26<@.0.A/0>.1/9I9!;7 *
!" .:80;<.0/1A2;9;</;1.9=2;.B.2531.186;275 ;7;<./A785;=/2125I9!;7*;<.0./0.18.9;7;<. 67A=4/25/5;H/5>
!! ./05.1 02/4
813. /:;.0 67A=4.;275 7: .?21.56.0.6701.1/6689.19;/;.A.5;/929675;.A=4/;.1 851.0.6;275!7:08B9.C8.5;;<.0.;7/6689.1 37; .I/A25.1 <2A9.4: /9 ,! BF :24253 /5 /::21/?2;
@<.0.25 <. </9 9=.62:26/44F 9;/;.1 ;</; <.</9 9235.1 75 ;<.B4/5>1768A.5;/;;<.;2A.7:7B;/252539!""""" /9=.0975/447/5
- 7 -
!# . :80;<.0 1.=79.1 ;</; :780 <.C8.9 </?. B..5;/>.5BF;<./5>75#+"!#"!+@<26<@.0.B/5>
! . </9 9=.62:26/44F 1.=79.1 ;</; /:;.0 =/F253 ;@7 259;/44A.5;9 75 /66785; 7:
!+ /51.A26 <. @/985/B4.;7=/F;<.259;/44A.5;9/51;<.9/A.</9B..5 25;2A/;.1;7;<./5>/5/3.0
!* . :80;<.0 1.=79.1 ;</; ;<. /5> /5/3.0 0.=0.9.5;.1;</;<.@78411296899@2;<;<./5>/51 ;<.50.?.0;;29/497<291.=792;275;</;.?.5/:;.0:24253 ;<.=0.9.5;67A=4/25;;<./5>/5/3.09/0.?292;.1<29 <789./51</0/99253<2A
! . </9 9=.62:26/44F 1.=79.1 ;</; ;<.0. @/9 57 B/1 25;.5;275 /51 <. 121 57; </?. A75.F 75 /66785; 7:
!+/51.A26/51;<.0.:70.<.6784157;0.=/F;<. A75.F25;2A..</9:80;<.01.=79.1;</;<.29/=770 /302684;8029; /51 ;<.0. /0. 9.?.5 A.AB.09 25 <29 :/A24F @<7/0.1.=.51.5;75<2A/51<.290./1F;7=/F/98A 7:9!"""
;76479.;<.A/;;.0
- 8 -
! 5<2960799
.I/A25/;275<.</9/1A2;;.1;</; /9 /3/259; 9!"""""
<. </9 0.=/21 9*("""
. 1.52.1 ;</; /9 75 !+!##"#" <. @/9 18. 25 / 98A 7:
9+("""
. 1.52.1 ;<. 9833.9;275 ;</; 25;.5;275/44F <. 6479.1 ;<. /66785; /:;.0 2998253 B4/5> <.C8. . 1.52.1;</;25701.0;7/?721;<.42/B242;F<.</91.=79.1 :/49.4F
!( <./B7?..?21.56.750.6701</99783<;;7B. 0. /==0.62/;.1BF;<.67859.4:70;<./==.44/5;
! 5 6/0.:84 675921.0/;275 7: ;<. /B7?. .I6.=; I(;<.0.29577;<.01768A.5;;</;</9B..5=4/6.175 0.6701 75 B.</4: 7: ;<. /==.44/5; H /5> )80;<.0 ;<. ,! 29 57; ;<. =.0975 @<7 9/56;275.1 ;<. 47/5 <.0. @/9572A=.12A.5;:70;<./5>;7=07186.;<.5.6.99/0F 1768A.5;9;7.9;/B429<;</;/975;<.1/;.7:=0.9.5;/;275 7:;<.<.C8.;<./66785;99;/;.A.5;7:;<.67A=4/25/5; </1;<.18.7:9+*"""
- 9 -
!+ 1A2;;.14FI9!;7*/0.;<.0.6.2=;97:;<. =/FA.5;9A/1.BF;<./6689.1;7;<.67A=4/25/5;/A. 2957;;/>.557;.7:BF;<.,!@<24.:80529<253;<.I( B.:70.;<.780; 1A2;;.14F,!@/957;@70>25325;<. 67A=4/25/5; H /5> @<.5 I9! ;7 * </9 67A. 25;7 .I29;.56. #" <.0.:70. ;<.0. @/9 57 =792;2?. .?21.56. 75 0.6701 =4/6.1 BF ;<. 67A=4/25/5; ;7 .9;/B429< ;</; ;<.0. .I29;.1 ;<. 4.3/44F 0.67?.0/B4. 18. 25 / 98A 7:
9+*"""
/9 =.0 I( @<.0.BF ;<. <.C8. 25 C8.9;275 6/A. ;7 B. 2998.1 BF ;<. /6689.1 ;7@/019 ;<. 0.=/FA.5;7:;<.47/5
#! 5 ;<. 675;0/0F ;<.0. 29 / 64./0 ;.9;2A75F 7:
;<./6689.1;</;I!<.C8.@/9;/>.525B4/5>/;;<. ;2A. 7: ;<. 4.51253 47/5 2;9.4: . </9 ;/>.5 / 9=.62:26 1.:.56.;</;B.6/89.7:
!+/51.A26<.6784157;
0.=/F;<.47/57@.?.025<2960799
.I/A25/;275<.</9
- 10 -
/1A2;;.1;</;/98A7:9!"""
<.@7841=/F;76479. ;<./66785;
## )70;<.0./9759B.9;>57@5;7;<.67A=4/25/5; H/5>;<.F12157;/30..:70;<.9/A.
# />253 57;. 7: ;<. :/6; ;</; ;<.
/6689.1 </9 /30..1 ;7 0.=/F / 98A 7: 9!"""
;7@/019 ;<. 47/5 /A785;<29/1A299275</9B..5;7;/44F7?.0477>.1BF;<. 4./05.1 ;02/4 /329;0/;. <.0.:70. .?.5 ;<783< ;<. <.C8.29=0.9.5;.1:70/98A7:9+*"""
9256.;<.0. 29 /5 /1A299275 ;</; /6689.1 29 18. 25 / 98A 7:
9!"""
;<.67A=4/25;783<;;7</?.B..5/447@.1;7 ;<..I;.5;7:9!"""
.9=.62/44F@<.5;<.0.29/64./0 /1A299275757/;<
#* <. 4./05.1 02/4 /329;0/;. :/24.1 ;7 675921.0 ;<. 9/A. <.0.:70. ;<. 129A299/4 7: ;<. 67A=4/25; 25 ;7;75..19;7B.9.;/921.BF/447@253;<.67A=4/25;25/ 98A7:9!"""
- 11 -
# 667012534F;<.:7447@253
2& ==./429/447@.125=/0;
22& .9=751.5;
/6689.1 29 675?26;.1 :70 ;<.7::.56.851.0.6;275! 7: 6;/5129 120.6;.1 ;7 =/F / 98A 7: 9!"""
75 70 B.:70. !" #"# :/24253 @<26< <. 9</44 851.03792A=4.2A=02975A.5;:70/=.02717:92I A75;<9
1 '%) ! 29;7!47#