- 1 - ! ! "#$ %!&!'!! !!'' () * ! " #$$ % & ! !' ( #)****$ % & ' (( +( $, (***$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( - & & - ' ./0 122314 /0 5/436 171/809 9.3 :;67<389 61936 **$ 210036 => 9.3 1/4?1> 41/<0 @/=;814 18714A@3 38B. 18714A@3 &5A@ 0.A@9 C9.3 @/=;814D' /8 A5* 83 @1E10.1 A .1@181221 AA:1@/ .181221 <39 ?/9. 18 1BB/6389 A8 ** 186 6/36 .3@35A@3./0519.3@1860/093@5/4361B41/<239/9/A8=35A@3 9.3@/=;814B41/</87BA<238019/A8A50)*****#=;9 9.3 @/=;814 .10 6/0</0036 9.3 B41/< 239/9/A8 A8 9.3 7@A;869.198A9@1F349/BE39?102@A6;B36=35A@3/9 + 77@/3F36 => 9.3 01/6 :;67<389 9.3 B41/<189 .102@353@@369./0122314/8?./B./9/0BA89386369.19.3 A=91/836 9.3 9/BE39 F/63 9/BE39 =31@/87 A +*$+ 61936 ** 9A 9@1F34 5@A< 16/ A5 ;4=1@71 /8 1 - 3 - 21003873@9@1/8=31@/87 A,*186109.3@3?10.31F> @;0. /8 9.3 BA<21@9<389 6;3 9A 0;6638 :3@E 186 :A49 A5 9@1/8 .3 5344 6A?8 186 6/36 A8 9.3 02A9 .3 @/=;814 A=03@F36 9.19 9.3 9/BE39 2@A6;B36 ;863@ G) ?10 8A9 @3BAF3@36=>9.32A4/B31918>09173A5/8H;309186/9?10 8A9 <389/A836 /8 9.3 B103 6/1@> ;9 9.3 23@;014 A5 9.3 B1036/1@>61936**#G+19BA4;<8 A,B431@4> 0.A?0 9.19 9.3 9/BE39 =31@/87 A +*$+ ?10 @3BAF3@36 5@A< ./0 =A6> .3@35A@3 9.3 5/86/87 A5 9.3 @/=;8149.199.363B31036?108A91=A815/6321003873@ /03@@A83A;0 ) 31@836 BA;8034 5A@ 9.3 1223441890 .10 @34/36 ;2A89.363B/0/A8A59.3A8D=4323GA;@9/8 ?.3@3/8/9 ?10 .346 9.19 9.3 /8/9/14 =;@638 /0 A8 9.3 B41/<1890 9A 0.A?9.199.363B3103621003873@?10.1F/87F14/69/BE39 186?.389.3B41/<18906/0B.1@7369.301<39.3=;@638 1 (2023) 19 SCC 116 - 4 - 0./590A81/4?1>6</8/09@19/A89A6/02@AF39.301/651B9 BBA@6/874>181<A;89A50$*****#?107@18936 31@69.31@7;<3890A5=A9.0/630 31@836BA;80345A@9.3@302A863890919369.19 3B9/A8 $ A5 9.3 1/4?1> 41/<0 @/=;814 B9 /0 8A9 BA<24/36 => 9.3 B41/<1890 A?3F3@ BA80/63@/87 9.3 1=AF3 B/919/A8 9./0 A;@9 5/860 /9 @310A81=43 9A 7@189 18 1<A;89A50$*****#9A?1@60BA<238019/A8 , 89.3@30;499.35A44A?/87A@63@/0210036 &/' .3122314/0144A?36 &//' .312234418901@3389/94365A@BA<238019/A8A5 0$*****# &///' .3 @302A86389#389@14 1/4?1> /0 6/@3B936 9A 632A0/9 9.3 15A@301/6 BA<238019/A8 1<A;89 ?/9./8 A83 <A89.5@A<9.36193A59./0:;67<38951/4/87?./B.9.3> .1F39A21>/893@30919I219/44632A0/9 - 5 - &/F' 8 0;B. 632A0/9 9.3 1223441890 1@3 23@</9936 9A?/9.6@1?9.3389/@31<A;8914A87?/9./893@3091BB@;36 A8/93H;144> +,- ('!! ) & /09 A4 A