- 1 - ! " # # !!$ % & ' ! "##$%& ! ' ' &()& ' "&%&%&( *& %&$ ' &$%%% " ' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' + # + ,-./ 0,-.1,/ 23415,0 -66,-.718 93. :;, -66,00-1: -1/0,-.1,/23415,093..,5631/,1:"3.63.-:731 ,718-88.7,<,/=>:;,?4/8@,1:-1/-A-./71 3*& %&$ => :;, //0 B .0 ,173. 7<70 4/8, B 7/-. 93. 5;3.: :;, .7=41-0C /-:,/ &%&%&(:;,6,:7:731,.75=,93.,:;7534.:71-66,-0 ) ;, 9-2:4-0 @-:.7D 39 :;, 2-5, 75 :;-: 31 &%E%&$ -: -=34: )%% 6@ :;, 6,:7:731,. A-5 .7/718 ;75 @3:3.2>20, =,-.718 3"&# "*)) A7:; 31, /9.3F -5 :;, 6700731 .7/,. 1 :;, 34:5G7.:5 39 -1?30 <700-8,:;,/.7<,.39:;, =45=,-.7183") '" ($) 2-@, 9.3@ 366357:, 57/, 71 - .-5; -1/ 1,8078,1: @-11,. -1/ 23007/,/ A7:; :;, @3:3.2>20, 315,H4,1:0> - 3 - :;, 6,:7:731,. 545:-71,/ 8.7,<345 71?4.7,5 7, 9.-2:4., 39 :7=7- -1/ 97=40- 39 :;, .78;: 0,8 -1/ :;, 6700731 .7/,." /9.3F /7,/ -: :;, 563: ;, 6,:7:731,. A-5 5;79:,/ :3 -;,,.-=-/ 3567:-0 -1/ :;,.,-9:,. ;, A-5 .,9,..,/ :3 6,D 3567:-0 7/-. 4.718 :.,-:@,1: ;, 41/,.A,1: 54.8,.7,5 A7:; ' -1/ ;-/ :3 :-G, 93003A 46 :.,-:@,1: 93. 57D @31:;5 31:,1/718 :;-: ;, A-5 -8,/ -=34: # >,-.5 A3.G718 -5 - /.7<,. 71 - 30,.3 ,,6 =,0318718 :3 31,.-G-5; -1/A-5 ,-.1718 5&#%%% " 6,. @31:;;, 970,/ :;, 20-7@ 6,:7:731 =,93., :;, .7=41-0 : A-5 231:,1/,/ :;-: :;, 6,:7:731,. ;-5 5499,.,/ 6,.@-1,1: /75-=707:> -1 -22341: 39 71?4.7,5 545:-71,/ => ;7@ : A-5 -053 5:-:,/:;-::;,-;,,.-=-/ 4.-03072,.,875:,.,/- 2-5,71.7@,3& %&$-8-715::;,/.7<,.39:;, =45-1/40:7@-:,0>;-<,970,/2;-.8,"5;,,:-8-715::;,=45 /.7<,. $ ;, .,5631/,1:" 3.63.-:731 -66,-.,/ :;.348;7:523415,0-1/970,/A.7::,15:-:,@,1:231:,1/718 :;-::;,.,A-513542;1,8078,12,31:;,6-.:39:;,/.7<,. - 4 - 39 :;, =45 =4: :;, -227/,1: 3224..,/ /4, :3 :;, 1,8078,12, 31 :;, 6-.: 39 :;, 6,:7:731,. : 75 231:,1/,/ :;-::;,23@6,15-:73120-7@,/=>:;,6,:7:731,.575;78;0> ,D3.=7:-1:-1/7@-871-.>:-053/,17,/:;,-8,7123@, -1/ 32246-:731 39 :;, 6,:7:731,. 7: 231:,1/,/ :;-::;,.7=41-0;-/13?4.75/72:73171:;,@-::,. # 1 :;, =-575 39 :;, -=3<, 231:,1:7315 :;, .7=41-09.-@,/-66.36.7-:,7554,5-1/:;,6,:7:731,.A-5 ,D-@71,/ -5 & -1/ :A3 A7:1,55,5 -5 5 -1/ ) D5&:3&$A,.,@-.G,/71;75,<7/,12, * 9:,.;,-.718:;,-.84@,1:5=>=3:;57/,5:;, .7=41-0 2-@, :3 :;, 2312045731 :;-: :;, 6,:7:731,. ;-/ -053 231:.7=4:,/ 1,8078,12, :3 :;, ,D:,1: 39 #%I -1/ /,:,.@71,/ :;, 23@6,15-:731 41/,. /799,.,1: ;,-/5 -5 =,03A - 5 - ( )*+, -.)/,*01/ & -71-1/5499,.718 5)#%%% " 3553994:4.,7123@,/4, 6,.@-1,1:/75-=707:> 5$$%% " ) 355397123@,/4.7180-7/46 6,.73/ 5)%%% " $ ,/72-0D6,15,5 5$%%% " # ::,1/-1:2;-.8,5 5)%%% " * 752D6,15,5 5#%%% " ( 31<,>-12,,D6,15,5 5%%% " 35539-@,17:7,5 5%%%% " E '4:4.,,/72-0D6,15,5 5&%%%% " 0*( ,234 5)06/07185079/):(1:)/6)0;) .)0101/)71,)/010()+0<0;) ,*1+6-.)/,*01/1) ,4 ( ,718 -88.7,<,/ => :;, 7@6481,/ ?4/8@,1: :;,6,:7:731,.75=,93.,:;7534.:71-66,-0 ;,0,-.1,/23415,0-66,-.71893.:;,-66,00-1: A340/54=@7::;-::;,.7=41-0,..,/71;30/718:;-::;,., 75231:.7=4:3.>1,8078,12,:3:;,,D:,1:39#%I31:;,6-.: 39 :;, 6,:7:731,. , A340/ 54=@7: :;-: :;, 2;-.8,"5;,,: A-5 970,/ -8-715: =45 /.7<,. 310> -1/ :;,.,93., :;, .7=41-0 A-5 13: ?45:797,/ 71 9-5:,1718 :;, 231:.7=4:3.> 1,8078,12, , 6371:5 34: :;-: :;, =45 =,718 - ;,-<> 6-55,18,. <,;720, :;, /,8.,, 39 2-., :;-: 5;340/ ;-<, - 6 - =,,1:-G,1=>:;,/.7<,.39:;,=45A-531:;,;78;,.57/, -1/:;,.,93.,9-5:,171807-=707:>:3:;,,D:,1:39#%I31 :;, 6,:7:731,. 75 41?45:797-=0, 75 5,231/ 6.318 39 :;, -.84@,1: 75 :;-: :;, H4-1:4@ 39 23@6,15-:731 -A-./,/ =>:;,.7=41-07531:;,03A,.57/,;,6,:7:731,.=,718 -8,/ -=34: )% >,-.5 A-5 A3.G718 -5 - /.7<,. -1/ :;, ,@603>,.39:;,6,:7:731,.A-5,D-@71,/-5-1/-5 542;:;,7123@,39:;,6,:7:731,.-: 5&#%%% ";-/=,,1 6.3<,/ => ;7@ ,567:, 542; 6.339 :;, .7=41-0 ;,0/ 7123@,-: 5%%% "A;72;7513:545:-71-=0,710-A E ,-0536371:534::;-::;,/75-=707:>5:-:,/=> )A-5:3:;,,D:,1:39$(I:3:;,07@=-1/%I:3:;, A;30, =3/> ,567:, :;-: :;, .7=41-0 ;-5 -55,55,/ :;, 9412:731-0 /75-=707:> -: &#I A;72; 75 31 :;, 03A,. 57/, ;45 ;, 5,,G5 71/408,12, => :;75 34.: 71 .,-55,55@,1: 39:;,23@6,15-:731-@341: &% 0,-.1,/ 23415,0 93. .,5631/,1: 54=@7:5:;-::;,231:.7=4:3.>1,8078,12,23157/,.,/=>:;, .7=41-0 -: #%I 75 6.36,. -1/ 23..,2: -1/ :;,., -., 13 - 7 - .,-5315:371:,.9,.,A7:;:;,5-@,,-05354=@7:5:;-: :;, 23@6,15-:731 -A-./,/ => :;, .7=41-0 75 ?45: -1/ 6.36,.-1/-5542;;,/,9,1/5:;,7@6481,/?4/8@,1: && ;,97.5:-56,2::3=,23157/,.,/=>:;7534.: 75A;,:;,.:;,.,75-1>231:.7=4:3.>1,8078,12,31:;,6-.: 39 :;, 6,:7:731,. 6,.45-0 39 :;, 63072, 6-6,.5 A340/ /752035, :;-: :;, ' 6.3/42,/ -: D& 717:7-00> 71/72:,/ :;, =45 /.7<,. 93. 1,8078,1: /.7<718 -1/ -9:,. 71<,5:78-:731 63072, 970,/ 2;-.8,"5;,,: -8-715: :;, =45 /.7<,.310>;,563:@-;-F-.-:D)-1/:;,5G,:2;-: D$-.,39<7:-07@63.:-12,D$5;3A5:;-::;,563:39 :;,-227/,1: 75 -: :;,2,1:., 39 :;,.3-/ ;, .7=41-0 71 6-.-8.-6;3E397:5?4/8@,1:3=5,.<,5:;-::;,-227/,1: 3224..,/ 31 :;, @7/071, 39 :;, .3-/ -1/ :;,.,93., :;, 6,:7:731,.5;340/,D60-71-5:3A;>;,2340/13:/.7<,31 :;, 0,9: 57/, 39 :;, .3-/ :3 -<37/ :;, -227/,1: 1 :;-: 8.341/ 7: 23@,5 :3 :;, 2312045731 :;-: :;,., 75 231:.7=4:3.>1,8078,12,:3:;,,D:,1:39#%I31=,;-0939 :;,6,:7:731,. - 8 - & 2-.,9406,.45-039:;,:,5:7@31>39:;,& -1/-5A,00-5;752.355",D-@71-:731=>:;,.,5631/,1:/3 13: ,0727: -1>:;718 -=34: :;, 231:.7=4:3.> 1,8078,12, 31 :;,6-.:39:;,6,:7:731,.;,.,93.,:;,3.-0:,5:7@31>39 :;, & 75 13: 39 -1> .,0,<-12, ;,., 75 13 ,<7/,12, A;72; ;-5 =,,1 0,-/ 31 =,;-09 39 :;, .,5631/,1: 1/,. :;,5, 27.24@5:-12,5 :;, 310> H4,5:731 75 A;,:;,. :;, D$2340/;-<,.,07,/=>:;,.7=41-0:3;30/:;-::;,., 75231:.7=4:3.>1,8078,12,J &) ;, 0,-.1,/ 23415,0 93. :;, -66,00-1: 60-2,5 .,07-12, 31 :;, ?4/8@,1: 39 6,D 34.: 71 :;, 2-5, 39 71 :;75?4/8@,1::;,6,D34.:2-@,:3:;,2312045731:;-: :;, 231:.7=4:3.> 1,8078,12, -5 -55,55,/ => :;, .7=41-0 =-5,/ 31 :;, 563: @-;-F-. A-5 23..,2: -1/ ;,0/ :;-: :;,.,A-513231:.7=4:3.>1,8078,12,1:;,2-5,31;-1/ :;, 563: @-;-F-. -: D$ 5;3A5 :;-: :;, -227/,1: 1 %#7<,-A ** - 9 - 3224..,/ -: :;, 2,1:., 39 :;, .3-/ ;, 3:3. ,;720, 156,2:3.C5.,63.:-:D*A340/5;3A:;-::;,.78;:57/, =4@6,. 39 :;, =45 ;-/ /,6.,55,/ 7157/, ;75 71/72-:,5 :;-::;,@3:3.2>20,;-/23007/,/:3:;,.78;:57/,=4@6,. 39:;,=45 =<73450>79:;,-227/,1:3224..,/-::;,2,1:., 39:;,.3-/=45A-531:;,0,9:0-1,39:;,.3-/-1/7:A-5 7124@=,1: 4631 :;, 6,:7:731,. :3 ,D60-71 -5 :3 A;> ;, 2340/ 13: .7/, ;75 @3:3.2>20, 31 0,9: 0-1, 39 :;, .3-/ ;,.,93., :;, -=3<, ?4/8@,1: .,07,/ => :;, 0,-.1,/ 23415,093.:;,-66,00-1:7513:39-1>;,06:3;7@ &$ : @45: =, 3=5,.<,/ :;-: :;, <,;720, 39 :;, .,5631/,1: 75 - ;,-<> 6-55,18,. <,;720, A;,.,-5 :;, @3:3.2>20, =,718 - :A3 A;,,0,. :;, /,8.,, 39 2-.,:;-: 5;340/=,,D,.275,/=>:;,=45/.7<,.A-5@3.,,,6718 71 <7,A :;75 -56,2: 7: A340/ =, 6.36,. :3 ;30/ :;-: :;, 231:.7=4:3.> 1,8078,12, 31 :;, 6-.: 39 :;, 6,:7:731,. A-5 %I-1/:;-:31:;,6-.:39:;,=45/.7<,.A-5%I - 10 - &# 3@718 :3 :;, H4-1:4@ 39 23@6,15-:731 7: @45: =, 3=5,.<,/ :;-: :;348; ;-/ 5:-:,/ :;-: ;, A-5 6->718 5&#%%% " :3 :;, 6,:7:731,. -0318 A7:; :A3 3:;,. /.7<,.5 ,@603>,/ => ;7@ ;, 9-70,/ :3 6.3/42, :;, .,875:,. A;72; ;,;-/ @-71:-71,/71 :;-:.,8-./ : @-> =, 13:,/ :;-: :;, 2,.:7972-:, 7554,/ => ;7@ -: D& -66,-.5 :3 ;-<, =,,1 2.,-:,/ 310> 93. :;, 64.635, 39 6.3/42718 :;, 5-@, =,93., :;, .7=41-0 ;, 54663.:718 @-:,.7-0 :3 5;3A :;-: :;, 6,:7:731,. A-5 ,@603>,/ 231:7143450> 93. 5499727,1: 6,.73/ A7:; 5-0-.> 39 5&#%%% " 6,. @31:; -., 13: 93.:;23@718 3A,<,. 23157/,.718 :;, -8, 39 :;, 6,:7:731,. -1/ :;-: ;, A-5 /.7<,.:;,.7=41-0-55,55,/;757123@,-: 5%%% "6,. @31:; 13:731-00> ;75 -55,55@,1: => :;, .7=41-0 1,,/ 13:=,71:,.9,.,/A7:;A;,1:;,:,5:7@31>39:;,75 41.,07-=0, &* ;,.7=41-0-55,55,/:;,,<7/,12,39)-1/ 2-@,:3:;,2312045731:;-::;,.,759412:731-0/75-=707:>39 &#I ;, 6,:7:731,. ;-/ 545:-71,/ 9.-2:4., 39 :7=7- -1/ - 11 - 97=40-39:;,.78;:0,8-1/:;,.,A,.,7@60-1:57157:4A;,1 D".-> A-5 :-G,1 -: :;, 715:-12, 39 ) ;, /75-=707:> 2,.:7972-:, 39)-: D&&# 5:-:,5 :;-::;,.,5:.72:7315 39:;,@3<,@,1:-::;,;76?371:757:)%I:;,.,75035539 @4520, 5:.,18:; A;72; -22341:5 93. %I 3:-00> :;,5, -56,2:5 A700 231:.7=4:, :3 #I , 5:-:,5 :;-: :;,., 75 /,93.@7:> 71 :;, 9412:731-0 6357:731 -1/ :;,.,93., ;, 40:7@-:,0>23@,5:3:;,2312045731:;-::;,.,756,.@-1,1: 6-.:7-0 /75-=707:> 39 $(I 39 :;, .78;: 03A,. 07@= A;72; 23..,5631/5:3%I39:;,A;30,=3/> &( =<73450> :;, 9412:731-0 /75-=707:> 75 - @-::,. A;72; ;-5 :3 =, /,27/,/ => :;, .7=41-0 ) 2-1 310> /,635,-=34::;,6;>572-0/75-=707:>=4:13::;,9412:731-0 /75-=707:>;,6,:7:731,.=,718-/.7<,.31-30,.3,,6-5 5:-:,/=>;7@5,09-5A,00-5=>);-553@,/7997240:>31 -22341:39:;,9.-2:4.,39:7=7--1/97=40-39:;,.78;:0,8 1 /.7<718 -<,;720, :;,45, 39 :;,.78;: 0,8 75 39 67<3:-0 7@63.:-12,1:;-:<7,A39:;,@-::,.:;,-55,55@,1:39 9412:731-0/75-=707:>=>:;,.7=41-0-:&#I-66,-.5:3=, - 12 - 31 03A,. 57/, ;75 34.: 3671,5 :;-: :;, 9412:731-0 /75-=707:> 39 :;, 6,:7:731,.31 -22341:9412:731-0/75-=707:> 39$(I:3:;,.78;:03A,.07@=A340/=,%I,12,:;, 03553994:4.,7123@,752-0240-:,/-5 5%%% "D&D&( D%IK,=>24 =>-/36:718-@40:7607,.39L&(C A;72;7541/7564:,/ & ;, .7=41-0 ;-5 -A-./,/ @,-8,. 23@6,15-:731 41/,. :;, ;,-/ 39 6-71 -1/ 5499,.718 3157/,.718 :;, 1-:4., 39 :;, 71?4.7,5 :;, 6,:7:731,. 75 ,1:7:0,/93.-54@39,24 41/,.:;75;,-/ &E ;,.7=41-0;-5-A-./,/-54@39 5)%%% " 41/,. :;, ;,-/ 39 0355 39 7123@, /4.718 0-7/ 46 6,.73/ ;, 5-@, 75 23157/,.,/ => :;75 34.: 93. * @31:;5 -1/ :;,.,93.,-54@39,234 %%%D* 75-A-./,/ % ;, .7=41-0 13:718 :;-: :;, 6,:7:731,. A-5 716-:7,1: 93. 310> # /->5 ;-5 -A-./,/ - 54@ 39 5)%%% " 41/,. :;, ;,-/ 39 -::,1/-1: 2;-.8,5 - 13 - 231<,17,12, ,:2 :;, 5-@, 1,,/5 :3 =, ,1;-12,/ :3 ,4 & ;,.7=41-0;-5-A-./,/-54@39 5%%%% " 41/,.:;,;,-/39035539-@,17:7,571079,-1/23157/,.718 :;,9-2::;-::;,6,:7:731,.;-5:35499,.:;,71?4.>93.:;, .,5: 39 ;75 079, A;70, ;, A3.G5 -5 - /.7<,. 7: A340/ =, 6.36,.:3-A-./-54@39,24 41/,.:;75;,-/ ;,D&&*:;,.,63.:39:;,D".->5;3A:;-: :;,., -., 7@60-1:5 71 57:4 ;,.,93., :;, 6,:7:731,. 75 ,1:7:0,/ 93. 94:4., @,/72-0 ,D6,15,5 39 ,4 A;72; A340/ 13: 2-..> 71 -1> 71:,.,5: 715:,-/ 39 5&%%%% "-A-./,/=>:;,.7=41-0 ) ;, 23@6,15-:731 -A-./,/ => :;, .7=41-0 41/,. :;, ;,-/ 39 @,/72-0 ,D6,15,5 /3 13: .,H47., -1> 71:,.9,.,12, $ ;45 :;, 6,:7:731,. 75 ,1:7:0,/ 93. - :3:-0 23@6,15-:73141/,.:;,93003A718;,-/5 - 14 - ( )*+, -.)/,*01/ & -71-1/5499,.718 5$%%%% " 3553994:4.,7123@,/4, 6,.@-1,1:/75-=707:> 5)*$%% " ) 355397123@,/4.7180-7/46 6,.73/ 5$%%% " $ ,/72-0D6,15,5 5$%%% " # ::,1/-1:2;-.8,5752 D6,15,5231<,>-12, ,D6,15,5 5&%%%% " * 35539-@,17:7,5 5$%%%% " ( '4:4.,,/72-0D6,15,5 5%%%% " 0*( ,=24 ),,< ,24 ),,*-5/0*?*7+)+890;) 7185/*( ,4 /;*/6)-)/0 ,=4 # 1:;,.,540::;,-66,-0/,5,.<,5:3=,-003A,/ 71"6-.:,12,:;,93003A718 7 ;,-66,-075-003A,/716-.: 77 ;, -66,00-1: 6,:7:731,. 75 ,1:7:0,/ 93. - 54@ 39 5)%% " 71 -//7:731 :3 :;, 23@6,15-:731 -A-./,/ => :;, .7=41-0 -0318 A7:; 71:,.,5: -: *I 6- 9.3@ :;, /-:, 39 6,:7:731 :700 7:5 /,6357: ,D204/718 - 15 - 71:,.,5:3<,. 5%%%% "-A-./,/:3A-./5 94:4.,,/72-0D6,15,5 777 ;, .,5631/,1:"3.63.-:731 75 /7.,2:,/ :3 /,6357::;,23@6,15-:731-@341:A7:;71- 6,.73/ 39 57D A,,G5 9.3@ :;, /-:, 39 :;75 3./,. 7< ,5: 39 :;, 3./,. 39 :;, .7=41-0 5:-1/5 41-0:,.,/ < ;, ,875:.> :3 5,1/ =-2G :;, :.7-0 234.: .,23./5:3:;,2312,.1,/34.: / " $ # & # & #)