- 1 - ! " #$# %&!$!&& & ' ( ')*+ ('!!** , !" # !" $ % !! !" % # !" % " & ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !""" ! !" ' ( ) * + ** "# , % % %* " %""! ' (* - % * ) * *"$ . * " $" * ** # () $ % /" * "$ $()(0)$()(1) * ( ) " * * % + - 3 - ( + ) 223145 61 76 ! 89 08:4 6" 6; <=<9<><0 6=824 7<7869 8?<@<A30 58170827 04>8174045 ;60 7B4 6;;49241 A3981B<C=4 39540 4278691 # () $ 04<5 D87B 427869 /" 6; B<0<78@< @<@< <9B87< "$ (;60 E "$F) <95 39540 4278691 $()(0) <95 $()(1) 6; 2B453=45 <1741 <95 2B453=45 08C41 (04G4978696;706287841):495:49727"(;601B607 E ( ) 27F) <04 144H89> 76 I3<1B 7B4 208:89<= A06244589>189878<745<><89177B4: 4<05 08 <:<5<A30 =4<0945 263914= ;60 7B4 A4787869401 08 <:<5<0 B<B<C35589 =4<0945 8>B 6307 6G409:497 =4<540 ;60 041A695497 6 J 7<74 <95 :7<?41BD<08 <:<5<0 =4<0945 263914= ;60 041A69549764031457B4:<7408<=169042605 $ 4<0945 263914= ;60 7B4 A4787869401 269749545 7B<7 A478786940 6<223145 6 81 7B4 B31C<95 6; - 4 - 041A695497 6 <223145 61 <95 $ <04 B81 A<04971 <223145 61 <95 <04 B81 1817401 <95 <223145 6! 81 7B4 169 6; <223145 6 ;<=14 26:A=<897 2<:4 76 C4 ;8=45 <><8917 <223145 61 76 ! 06A89> 89 <== 7B4 ;<:8=@ :4:C401 4 13C:87745 7B<7 7B4 :<008<>4 C47D449 A478786940 6<223145 6 <95041A6954976 D<1 < =6G4:<008<>4DB82BD<1B4=553089>7B4@4<0" B4@ B<G4C4>677497D62B8=5049;06:7B480:<008<>4223145 6 81 D60H89><7 G<08631 263970841<95 B4 3145 76 G8187 958<692489<@4<041A6954976<=69>D87BB407D6 2B8=5049 D404 0418589> 89 <9G4= <B<0<1B70< 17<74 <H89> <5G<97<>4 6; 7B4 <C14924 6; <223145 6 1B4 54G4=6A458978:<2@D87B6948941B<78=%B49<223145 62<:476H96D<C6377B4808==828704=<78691B8AB4;8=45< A4787869;6058G6024DB82BD<113C14I3497=@D87B50<D9;60 7B4 A30A614 6; ;8=89> 7B4 A4787869 C4;604 7B4 ?30815827869<= 6307<78?<@<A30 - 5 - 4<0945263914=<=1613C:8717B<7897B4:4<9 78:4 041A695497 6 ;8=45 < 208:89<= 2<14 <><8917 1<85 8941B <78= <==4>89> 26::811869 6; 6;;4924 A3981B<C=4 39540 427869 $#! 6; 9 7B4 1<85 26:A=<897 1B4 1A428;82<==@<5:87745B408==828704=<78691B8AD87B1<858941B <78= 9 G84D 6; <== 7B414 ;<271 <95 28023:17<9241 A4787869401<223145 61 76 ! D404 967 <==6D89> B40 76 26:4 76 7B4 :<708:698<= B6314 4=8C40<74=@ < ;<=14 26:A=<8972<:476C4;8=45<><8917<==;<:8=@:4:C40169=@ 76 A0411308K4 7B4: 4924 87 81 < ;87 2<14 76 I3<1B 7B4 A49589>208:89<=A06244589>1 ! 4<0945 263914= ;60 7B4 041A6954971 6AA6189> 7B4 A4787869 13C:87 7B<7 1408631 <==4><78691 <04 :<54 C@ 7B489;60:<97897B4;801789;60:<78699G4178><786981967 @4726:A=474589G84D6;7B4605406;17<@>0<9745C@7B81 630797B4:4<978:4A4787869401<0496749787=45;60 >0<97 6; 04=84; 6; I3<1B89> 7B4 A49589> 208:89<= A06244589>1 - 6 - # 9 G84D 6; 7B4 08G<= 26974978691 30>45 C@ 7B4 =4<0945263914=;60C67B7B4A<078417B4A68977B<7D63=5 <0814;60:@26918540<786981 !"#$% @<91D40767B4<C6G4A68978189 ;60 7B4;6==6D89> !! 41A695497 6 ;8=45 ;8017 89;60:<7869 :<H89> 1408631 <==4><78691 <><8917 7B4 A4787869401<223145 61 76!781B4026974978697B<7<1697B45<746;89285497 84 69 " 1B4 B<5 C449 76 7B4 B6314 6; 7B4 A4787869401<223145 61 76 ! DB404 7B4@ B<G4 26::87745 7B4 6;;4924 7 81 967 89 581A374 7B<7 7B4 :<008<>4 C47D449 A478786940 6<223145 6 <95 041A695497681<=6G4:<008<>4DB82BD<17<H49A=<24 - 7 - 897B4@4<0"6A@6;08:46 $"$6;<9G4= 87@ 4D 3:C<8 6=824 7<7869 04>8174045 ;60 7B4 6;;49241A3981B<C=4395404278691$#!<95$#!()(9)6; <95 39540 4278691 $()(D) <95 $()(G) 6; ( ) 27 5812=6141 7B<7 041A695497 6 <1 7B4 89;60:<97 ;8=45 < 26:A=<897 <><8917 8941B <78= B4 <G40:4971:<54897B4;801789;60:<78695812=61417B<71B4 D<1B<G89>8==828704=<78691B8AD87B8941B<78=%B497B81 8==8287 04=<78691B8A 2<:4 76 7B4 H96D=45>4 6; B40 B31C<95 84 A478786940 6<223145 6 B4 17<0745 I3<004=89> D87BB40 / 4<0945 263914= ;60 7B4 A4787869401 <=16 A065324526A@6;7B417<74:4976;041A69549761<8576 B<G4 C449 04260545 C@ 7B4 %6:49 6=824 7<7869 8?<@<A30 2260589> 76 DB82B 1B4 B<1 395407<H49 76 <AA06<2B 7B4 6307 6; =<D ;60 0416=37869 6; B40 581A374 D87B B40 B31C<95 6D4G40 89 7B4 :4<9 78:4 A041497 26:A=<897 2<:4 76 C4 ;8=45 D87B <==4><78691 %B49 041A695497 6 <5:871 7B<7 1B4 D<1 B<G89> - 8 - 8==828704=<78691B8A D87B8941B<78=897B4<C149246;B40 B31C<95897B4263970@<95A4787869406<2231456 C489> 7B4 B31C<95 17<0745 I3<004=89> D87B B40 <;740 26:89> 76 H96D <C637 7B4 1<85 ;<27 56 967 ;895 <9@ ?3178;82<7869;60041A695497676G81877B4B6314DB404 A4787869406176!<2231456176!<040418589><95 :<H89><==4><786917B<77B4@B<G426::877457B46;;4924 " 9540 132B 28023:17<9241 ;895 26918540<C=4 ;6024 89 7B4 13C:811869 :<54 C@ =4<0945 263914= ;60 7B4 A47878694017B<77B4A4787869401<0406A4589<208:89<=2<14 C@:<H89>C<=5<==4><78691 B404;604<:6;7B46A89869 7B<7 89878<7869 6; 208:89<= A06244589>1 <><8917 7B4 A478786940181 89 <C3146;A062411 6;=<D <95 7B4 1<:481 =8<C=476C4I3<1B45 2260589>=@ <91D40 7B4 <C6G4 A6897 89 7B4 <95A06244576A<117B4;6==6D89> B4A478786981 - 9 - 49589> 208:89<= A06244589>1 89878<745 <><8917 7B4 A4787869401<223145 61 76 ! 89 08:4 6" 6; <=<9<><0 6=824 7<7869 8?<@<A30 58170827 04>8174045 ;60 7B4 6;;49241 A3981B<C=4 39540 4278691 # () $ 04<5 D87B 427869 /" 6; "$ <95 39540 4278691 $()(0) <95 $()(1) 6; ( ) 27 81 I3<1B45 !-+ '&&* $ 8176=6