- 1 - !"# $ % & && '() *+ && '() * + ! "#$ % ! &' !"((($ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' %) *($%(%% ! '' *$ ' ! ' ! %*%%(& ' "+ $$%( * + ! &' !"((($ ,* , ,& , - ,"#( % ! , , , "#($ - 3 - '' *$ ' ' $$%( ' ' . ."+ ! %*%%(& $$%( . . /+ ! ' ! , , 0 % , 0 1234561237891:5;<=><56;?41; % 61;12@@12A;231=?A14272?:;55612B234@2;;14?: <$$%( 42514 %*%%(& >C 561 19>13 <5<3 DD?41:5; A2?9; 3?>8:2A <+ 2:4 44A ?;53?D5 2:4 1;;?<:;8471=<3;6<35E5613?>8:2AF $ :G8314DA2?92:52714$C123;;5841:5915B?56 2:2DD?41:5<:(%(#2:4=?A142DA2?9@15?5?<:DA2?9?:7 D<9@1:;25?<: <= ;((((((" 61 3?>8:2A D<:;?413?:7 1:5?311H?41:D1<:31D<34732:5142:29<8:5<=;&$***" - 4 - B?56 ?:5131;5 25 561 3251 <= &I @13 2::89 =3<9 561 4251 <= @15?5?<:5?AA312A?;25?<: * 773?1H14>C561;2?4<34135612@@1AA2:5DA2?92:5 62; @31=13314 56?; 2@@12A 2:4 92?:AC D<:51:514 5625 :< 29<8:5 ?; 732:514 8:413 561 6124 A<;; <= =85831 123:?:7 D2@2D?5CA<;;<=?:D<91483?:7A2?48@@13?<42:42A;<A<;;<= 1J@1D525?<:<=A?=12:49233?271@3<;@1D5;2:4568;31K81;514 =<31:62:D191:5<=561D<9@1:;25?<: * # :;832:D1 D<9@2:C 2A;< @31=13314 56?; 2@@12A 272?:;5 561 ;2?4 2B234 <= 561 3?>8:2A ?: B6?D6 ?5 ?; 92?:AC D<:51:414 5625 <: (%(# 561 DA2?92:5 B2; @3<D114?:7 <:29<5<3DCDA1 55625 5?91252:L13>123?:7317?;5325?<: <"$#&#D291?:232;62:4:17A?71:592::13B?566?76 ;@114 2:4 42;614561 DA2?92:50; >?DCDA1 ; 2 31;8A5 61 =1AA 4<B:2:4;8;52?:14?:G83?1;1;@<:41:5 <%?:56?;2@@12A?; 561<B:13<=561H16?DA12:4613192?:141J@23516143?H13 <=561<==1:4?:7H16?DA162;:<H2A?443?H?:7A?D1:D1'835613?5 - 5 - ?;D<:51:414562556<8765612@@1AA2:5DA2?92:5B6<B2;2714 $ C123; 2:4 B6< ;8;52?:14 <:AC (I 4?;2>?A?5C 561 3?>8:2A 732:514 2: 1J<3>?52:5 29<8:5 <= ;&$***" B?56<85 2:C >2;?;;5614?;2>?A?5C?;(I61:D15612@@1AA2:5DA2?92:5?; 1:5?5A14=<3<:AC;((((("2;@13 ! "# $%& '$(( !31@<3514?:")*+, 5<B234; 914?D2A1J@1:;1;'8356135613?>8:2A732:5142:1JD1;;?H1 D<9@1:;25?<: B?56 ?:5131;5 25 561 3251 <= &I @13 2::89 ?:;5124<=I2:4568;31K81;514=<33148D5?<:<=56129<8:5 A2?92:52@@1AA2:5 B2;2@@12314>1=<3156?;<835 <:(%%(%#2:4561<835<>;13H14561;291 * 61 D<8:;1A =<3 561 2@@1AA2:5 31A?14 8@<: 561 D?525?<: 31@<3514 ?: -! .! / 0 1..! .! ). ( ! 31@<3514 ?: %% +23?:B6?D6?5B2;61A456259?:?989B271;?; 5<>152L1:?:D2;1<=?:G83C<341256<=5619?:<361D6235 @31@2314 >C 561 23:252L2 5251 172A 13H?D1; 856<3?5C ?; 41@1:4?:7 8@<: 561 9?:?989 B271; @1352?:?:7 5< 561 @235?D8A23C123:56?;D2;1561?:G831462;:<5@3<48D142:C - 6 - @3<<= <= ?:D<91 1 915 B?56 2: 2DD?41:5 <: (%(# 56131=<316?;:<5?<:2A?:D<91?;5<>152L1:2;;((("@13 9<:56 2; @13 561 78?41A?:1; <= 561 23:252L2 5251 172A 13H?D1; 856<3?5C ; @13 561 D?525?<: 31@<3514 ?: * 0$ ( 4! 0 ! % % ( ! 56?; <835 =?:4; ?5 312;<:2>A1 5< 52L1 561 98A5?@A?132;E#F 61 2@@1AA2:5 ;8;52?:14 =<AA<B?:7 ?:G83?1; 2; @13 J*/!<8:4135?=?D251 85<=B6?D6=?=56?:G83C?;;?9@A1 2:4 <5613 ?:G83?1; 231 73?1H<8; ?: :25831 @@1AA2:5 62; 1J29?:145614<D5<32;!%2:461?;;814J" ?;2>?A?5C 135?=?D251;@13J61B2;249?5514<:(%(#2:4 8:413B1:5 ;83713C <: 561 ;291 42C 2:4 4?;D623714 <: (&%(# 1 B2; ?:@25?1:5 =<3 %$ 42C; 61 4<D5<3 <>;13H14 5625 2; @13 +"32C <= 561 A1=5 =1983 ;6<B; 8:?514 =32D5831=19832:42;;1;;145614?;2>?A?5C<=561A1=5A<B13A?9> 2;%#I5<$(I613?>8:2A62;52L1:$34<=561;2912; (I2:456?;<835=?:4;:<312;<:5<?:513=131B?56561;2?4 <34136131=<31561A<;;<==85831123:?:7D2@2D?5CD<91;5<, ;(((J%J#J(IM;(((" - 7 - & 61 3?>8:2A 732:514 914?D2A 1J@1:;1; <= ;$$***"2:456?;<835=?:4;:<312;<:;5<?:513=131B?56 561;2?4<3413 ( 61 2@@1AA2:5 B2; 6<;@?52A?N14 =<3 %$ 42C; <:;?413?:7561:25831<=?:G83?1;@13?<4<=6<;@?52A?N25?<:2:4 6?;27156?;<835=?:4;?5312;<:2>A15<732:5;*#((("=<3 @2?: 2:4 ;8==13?:7 ;((((" =<3 A<;; <= 291:?5?1; 2:4 ;((((" =<3 532:;@<3525?<: 1J532 :<83?;691:5 2:4 <5613 2551:42:5D62371; @@1AA2:5 B2; 2714 $ C123; 25 561 5?91 <= 561 2DD?41:5 1 ;8;52?:14 =?H1 ?:G83?1; <85 <= B6?D6 =<83 231 73?1H<8;?::258316131=<3156?;<835=?:4;?5312;<:2>A15< 732:52:2B234;%((((("5<B234;A<;;<==85831@3<;@1D5; <=9233?271 % : 2AA 561 5<52A D<9@1:;25?<: D<91; 5< ;%***"B?56?:5131;5255613251<=I@132::89=3<9 561@15?5?<:5?AA312A?N25?<: $ 61 2B234 @2;;14 >C 561 3?>8:2A ?; 9<4?=?14 2; 8:413, - 8 - ,-./ 012342/ <;;<==85831123:?:7D2@2D?5C (((" %2?:2:4;8==13?:7 *#(((" $<;;<=291:?5?1; ((((" 14?D2A1J@1:;1; $$***" #32:;@<3525?<: 1J532 :<83?;691:5 2:42551:42:5D62371; ((((" <;; <= =85831 @3<;@1D5; <= 9233?271 %(((((" 3-5 # # * DD<34?:7AC 561 2@@1AA2:5DA2?92:5 ?; 1:5?5A14 =<3 2 3148D14 D<9@1:;25?<: <= /# # * 2; 272?:;5 ;&$***" :56131;8A5561=<AA<B?:7<3413?;@2;;14, ? <562@@12A;231 5(% ?? 61 DA2?92:52@@1AA2:5 ?; 1:5?5A14 =<3 2 3148D14 D<9@1:;25?<:<=;%***"B?56?:5131;525561 3251<=I@132::89=3<95614251<=@15?5?<:5?AA 312A?N25?<: ??? 1;@<:41:5 " :;832:D1 D<9@2:C 62; 2A3124C 41@<;?514#(I<=561D<9@1:;25?<:2B23414>C561 3?>8:2A56131=<31:;832:D1<9@2:C?;4?31D514 5< 41@<;?5 561 >2A2:D1 29<8:5 2A<:7 B?56 ?:5131;5 2DD3814 <: ?5 B?56?: 9<:56 =3<9 561 4251 <= 4?;<3413 - 9 - ?H ; 561 2@@1AA2:5 9?765 62H1 2552?:14 561 271 <= 92G<3?5C 61 ?; @139?5514 5< B?56432B 561 1:5?31 29<8:52A<:7B?56?:5131;52DD3814<:?5 H 9<8:5 2A3124C 41@<;?514 ?; 5< >1 532:;=13314 5< 561 /.* '& ) % ?;5 <,A <,$ ,