Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58785 (KAR)
MUKTHAR BEGUM W/O MD. ASAD AND ANR v. MOHD. MAQBOOL S/O MOHD. MOOSA, AND ANR
MFA/202412/2022 · 2025-10-16
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58785 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58785 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
##
$%& '
!""#
$
% $$ &
$ '
(
"""! !)! *$
")! $
$
"###!+ % $ &
,
-
$
'
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!&'
$ $$ , #!## !#
,
$ $ . $
$$
,
/ ,$
" &$ / ,$ '
012345012678094:;<450=012903>;79:0=<;2?;45450 @124A0:
5A:1@@01=A:<A=03161A9:4450B73680941931C123 ;< 450 2A?791= @1::03 A9 ;!# ?D 450 193 33A4A;91=09A;2AEA=,736014A31231403#!##
50<1>4:;<450>1:01204514;9###3 5193 $1:51 @2;>003A96 ;9 1 90C 8;4;2>D>=C0 <2;8 131:5AE@044;1=1?7216AA91E02D:=;C819902193CA45370 >174A;9 4 4514 4A80 1 =;22D ?012A96 206A:4214A;9 ;"
- 3 -
"! 51: @12F03 5A: E05A>=0 CA45;74 <;==;CA96 421<<A> 27=0: ?D @744A96 @12FA96 =A654: ;2 19D :A691= ;9 450 8A33=0 ;< 450 2;13 193 450 :1A3 3 5193 $1:51 A9 :@A40 ;< 370 3A=A609>0 >180 A9 >;941>4 CA45 450 1?;E0 :1A3 =;22D 193 804 CA45191>>A30941933A03;9450:@;4
A: @12094: <A=03 1 >=1A8 @04A4A;9 >=1A8A96 >;8@09:14A;9 ;<
:+######"
50 2A?791= 1<402 >;9:A302A96 094A20 81402A1= ;9 20>;23 6219403 A9 4;41=
:##"A9C5A>51::0::03450>;942A?74;2D906=A609>0 ;9 450 30>01:03 14 #G 193 2081A9A96 ;9 450 ;C902 ;< 450 =;22D1931C12303 :+##"4;45030>01:03CA45A94020:4 14 450 2140 ;< G @02 19978 <2;8 450 3140 ;< @04A4A;9 4A== 30@;:A4
662A0E03?D450:1A3;230245A:1@@01=A:@20<02203 A9C5A>5A4A:>;940930345144502A?791=C1:02203A941FA96 450A9>;80;<45030>01:031: :###"@028;9451:450 30>01:03C1:3;A96C0=3A96C;2F193C1:0129A96 :####" @028;945193450906=A609>0;<#GC5A>5C1:<AH03;9450 30>01:03 ?D 450 2A?791= A: 022;90;7: : @02 H$ I :@;4 @19>519181450;<<093A96E05A>=0C1:@12F03A94508A33=0;<
- 4 -
450 2;13 CA45;74 @12FA96 =A654: ;2 :A691=: 5020<;20 450 >;942A?74;2D906=A609>0;<#G<AH03;945030>01:0320J7A203 4; ?0 :04 1:A30 193 457: 20J70:403 <;2 8;3A<A>14A;9 ;< 450 ;2302
+ 012903>;79:0=;<45020:@;93094::7?8A44034514 4502A302;<4508;4;2>D>=051:9;2AEA96A>09:0 ! 50 819902 ;< 450 1>>A3094 A4:0=< :5;C: 4514 450 30>01:03 C1: 2A3A96 450 8;4;2 >D>=0 193 31:503 450 @12F03 =;22D ?012A96 206A:4214A;9 ;""! 4 C1: @12F03 CA45;74 @744A96 @12FA96 =A654: 193 CA45;74 <;==;CA96 421<<A> 27=0:50>51260:5004A:<A=03161A9:445032AE02:;<?;45450 E05A>=0: 9 45A: 206123 7=0 &'&AE' ;< 450 ;13
067=14A;9: ) &<;2 :5;24 K450 7=0: )L' 206123A96 >;942A?74;2D906=A609>02013:1:<;==;C:
! ! ! " #
$
- 5 -
! ! ! %
%
%
! %
%
! %
! !
&
) 9 6;A96 452;765 450 7=0 &'&AE' ;< 450 7=0: )45032AE02:51==9;4@12F450E05A>=0A94508A33=02;13 945A:>1:04;;450=;22DC1:@12F03A94508A33=0;<4502;13 CA45;74 @12FA96 =A654: ;2 19D :A691= 193 457: 450 9:7219>0 ;8@19D ;< 450 =;22D 1=;90 A: =A1?=0 4; @1D 450 >;8@09:14A;9 19345;765450>;79:0=<;24509:7219>0;8@19D>;9409303 4514 45020 C1: 9; 4; 450 30>01:03 193 1=:; <1>4 4514 450 >51260 :5004 A: <A=03 161A9:4 ?;45 450 32AE02: A9 EA0C ;< 450
- 6 -
1?;E0 7=0:8094A;903450094A20906=A609>0A:;9450@124;< 45032AE02;<450=;22D
50 30>01:03 C1: 1603 # D012: 4 A: :7?8A4403 4514 450 30>01:03 C1: 0129A96 1 :78 ;< :####" ?74 9; 3;>78094:C020@2;37>034;@2;E0450:1A3A9>;80A9>050 804 450 1>>A3094 ;9 ### 1: @02 450 129141F1 4140 061= 02EA>0: 745;2A4D 5A: A9>;80 A: 4; ?0 41F09 14
:!#"193#GA:4;?0133034;C123:<74720@2;:@0>4: 1:@02450>A414A;920@;2403A9
!"#$% &&'193#G A: 4; ?0 3037>403 4;C123: 5A: @02:;91= 0H@09:0: 1: @02 450 >A414A;9 20@;2403 A9 ( ) # #$ *&+ ! ! '50=;::;<30@09309>DC;7=3 >;80:4;
:!#"M#G"#G..)N :#!###"
# $04A4A;902 ;: 193 120 450 @12094: ;< 450 30>01:031>5;<4508120094A4=01:78;< :####"79302 <A=A1= >;9:;24A78 1: @02 >A414A;9 20@;2403 A9 ,) - . ! " #$ / 0 & & / & ' 50D 120 1=:;
- 7 -
094A4=0<;2 :####"79302450>;9E094A;91=5013:1:@02450 >A414A;920@;2403A9
! " #$ % &&' 09>0 450 4;41= >;8@09:14A;9C;7=3?01:79302 =; 013:;<>;8@09:14A;9 8;794:
;::;<30@09309>D
:#!###"
;9:;24A78& :####".'
:)####"
;9E094A;91=5013:
:####"
;41=
:)###"
9EA0C;<4501?;E0450>=1A8194A:094A4=04;4;41= >;8@09:14A;9;< :)###"1=;96CA45A94020:4144502140 ;< +G @02 19978 <2;8 450 3140 ;< @04A4A;9 4A== 450 3140 ;< 201=AO14A;9 50 2140 ;< A94020:4 6219403 ?D 450 42A?791= A: 8;3A<A03<2;8G4;+G
012903>;79:0=<;24509:7219>0>;8@19D:7?8A4: 4514#G;<450>;8@09:14A;918;7941C12303?D45042A?791= A:30@;:A403?0<;2045042A?791=
>>;23A96=D450<;==;CA96;2302
&A' 501@@01=A:1==;C03A9@124-
- 8 -
&AA' 50 >=1A8194: 120 094A4=0 4; 4;41= >;8@09:14A;9;< :)###"1=;96CA45A94020:414 4502140;<+G@0219978<2;84503140;<@04A4A;94A== 4503140;<201=AO14A;91:161A9:4 :+###"1=;96 CA45A94020:4144502140;<G@0219978-
&AAA' 9 EA0C ;< 450 :7?8A::A;9 ;< 450 =012903 >;79:0= 1@@012A96 <;2 450 9:7219>0 >;8@19D 4514 1=2013D#G;<4501C12318;794A:30@;:A403?0<;20 450 42A?791= 450 9:7219>0 >;8@19D A: 3A20>403 4; 30@;:A4 450 ?1=19>0 ;< >;8@09:14A;9 A9>=73A96 09519>03 >;8@09:14A;9 1=;96 CA45 A94020:4 14 450 2140;<+G@0219978CA45A91@02A;3;<;908;945 <2;84503140;<45A:;2302?0<;2045042A?791=-
&AE' 9 :7>5 30@;:A4 450 >=1A8194: 120 @028A44034;CA45321C450094A20>;8@09:14A;91=;96 CA45A94020:41>>270345020;90J71==D
()* $#&
"
A:4;=;!