Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58775 (KAR)

SHREE SHANTAGANGADHAR AND ANR v. BHEEMAPPA AND ORS

RSA/200132/2018 · 2025-09-16

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $#%&#& "" '(%) * !" # # $ % & ' () * # Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # +,- & +,- ) +,- $ % &* & )' & -- & & & . !)- % --!' )-& )-!- )- & -- !)- % --!' & & && & & --(-, & / & 0 & 1 - 3 - &%# 234 566758 34 9387: ;< =27 5667885>=4:797>:5>= ?45>:6@5<3>A=?47=543:7=27B:AC7>=5>::7D@77 :5=7: )-!- 65447: 3> ?)- ;< =27 ::3=3?>58 34=@3D= B:A7 3E5<56B@5 %9?@ 42?@= /93@4= 5667885=7 ?B@=0' 5>: B:AC7>= 5>: :7D@77 :5=7: -- 65447: 3> ?!)- %?8: ?--!' ?97>3?@3F38B:A7545F5>55A7G5:3%9?@42?@=/=27=@358 ?B@=0' 5>: =? :34C344 =27 4B3= ?9 =27 6853>=399@746?>:7>= ? 27 5667885>=4 G7@7 =27 :797>:5>= ?4 5>: @746?>:7>= ? G54 6853>=399 5>: @746?>:7>= ?4 5>: ) G7@7 :797>:5>= ?4) 5>: ! 3> ?!)- %?8: ?--!' ) 27 6853>=399 254 9387: =27 4B3= 9?@ =27 @78379 ?9 :7D85@5=3?> =25= 6853>=399 34 =27 ?G>7@ ?9 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=<;75@3>AB@F7< ?),C754B@3>A5D@742?8:3>A =25= A39=#:77: 3> 95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? 34 ?;=53>7: ;< 9@5B: 5>: C34@76@747>=5=3?>* =? :7D85@7 =25= =27 4587 :77: - 4 - 7H7DB=7: ;< :797>:5>= ? 3> 95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? 34 3887A58 >B88 I F?3: 5>: =? 25>: ?F7@ =27 6?447443?> ?9 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< =? =27 6853>=399* 58=7@>5=3F78< 39 ?B@= D?C74=?=27D?>D8B43?>=25=6853>=399254>?@3A2==?A7=;5DJ =276?447443?>?9=274B3=4D27:B876@?67@=<=27>=?D5>D78 =27 4587 :77: 7H7DB=7: ;< :797>:5>= ? 3> 95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? 5>: =? :3@7D= =27 ?F7@>C7>= =? =5J7 =27 6@?67@=<54;78?>A3>A=??F7@>C7>=5>::3@7D==27@7F7>B7 5B=2?@3=374 =? @7C?F7 =27 >5C74 ?9 =27 :797>:5>=4 9@?C 4 3>D8B:7 >5C7 ?9 6853>=399 ?@ ?F7@>C7>= 54 =27 D547 C5<;7*9?@?B@=D?4=45>:4BD2?=27@@783794 ! 27D547?96853>=399;79?@7=@358?B@=3>>B=42788 34=25=B@F7< ?),=?=588<C754B@3>A)5D@74AB>=54 34 =27 5>D74=@58 6@?67@=< ?9 6853>=399 797>:5>= ? 34 @743:7>= ?9 3>:5A3 B@3>A (() :797>:5>= ? D5C7 =? ?825@ F3885A7 5>: =?8: =25= 27 3>=7>:7: =? D?>4=@BD= 3>=27453:F3885A75>:@7KB74=7:78:7@4?9 =27 F3885A7 =?:?>5=7 6@?67@=< 9?@ D?>4=@BD=3?>?9453: 5>: 59=7@ :34DB443?> ?9 =27 45C7 G3=2 78:7@4 3= 34 :7D3:7: =25= D?B8: ;7 D?>4=@BD=7: 3> =27 85>:4 ;78?>A3>A =? - 5 - 6853>=399 ;7D5B47 3= 34 D?>F7>37>= 685D7 9?@ D?>4=@BD=3?> ?9 5=2 5>: 78:7@4 @7KB74=7: =27 6853>=399 =? A39= =27 6@?67@=< 9?@D?>4=@BD=3?>?95=2 276853>=3995A@77:=?A3F75D@74 ?985>:9?@D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 B=:797>:5>= ?25:>? 4BD2 3>=7>=3?> =? D?>4=@BD= 7F7> =27> 27 :79@5B:7: 6853>=3995>:F3885A7@45>:?;=53>7:A39=;<685<3>A:@5C5> !(() :797>:5>= D787;@5=7: 9B>D=3?> ?9 9?B>:5=3?> ?9 5>: 9?@ 453: 9B>D=3?> 5<5:7F5 5254G5C3E3 ?9 5>542@77 5>4=25>5 5=2 3E5<56B@5 5>: 7785AB>: 5254G5C3E3 25F7 5==7>:7: 5>: =27< 6@743:7: ?F7@ =27 85<3>A?99?B>:5=3?> 4=?>7 =27> ?9 453: 685D75=38 %5>5AB83' 5>: ?=27@ 78:7@4 25F7 65@=3D365=7: 3> =27 453: 9B>D=3?> 525438:5@ 583J5@ 4434=5>= ?CC3443?>7@ 3E5<56B@5 583G7@7584?5==7>:7:=27453:9B>D=3?>> =27 453: 9B>D=3?> 6853>=399 5>: 234 <?B>A7@ ;@?=27@ G7@7 9783D3=5=7:9?@:?>5=3>A85>:9?@=27D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 5>: 62?=?4 G7@7 584? =5J7> 27 3>F3=5=3?> D5@:4 G7@7 6@3>=7: 5>:3=G54:34=@3;B=7:=?=27F3885A7@45>:5:E5D7>=F3885A7@4 2B4:797>:5>= ?C5:76853>=399=?;7837F7=25=27G?B8: D?>4=@BD= 3> 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 9=7@G5@:4 54 - 6 - 6853>=3995>:234<?B>A7@;@?=27@6@?C347:78:7@4=27<58?>A G3=2 :797>:5>= ? D5C7 =? B;#7A34=@5@ ?993D7 545F5> 5A7G5:35>:=27<=?8:=25=54=234345A@3DB8=B@586@?67@=< 3=D5>>?=;7A39=7:=?=27 ;B=3=D?B8:;7A39=7:=?5>< 3>:3F3:B5867@4?>7>D76853>=3995>::797>:5>= ?5A@77: =? 7H7DB=7 A39= 3> =27 >5C7 ?9 :797>:5>= ? ?>8< 3> 234 3>:3F3:B58 D565D3=<* 5= =25= =3C7 5A53> B;#7A34=@5@ =?8: :797>:5>= ?254>?5A@3DB8=B@586@?67@=<5>:27>D7A39= :77:D5>>?=;77H7DB=7:3>23495F?B@ 27>:797>:5>= ? 7>KB3@7:G3=2 525438:5@ 583J5@5>:27=?8:=?9387567=3=3?> 9?@ A@5>= ?9 5A@3DB8=B@58 6@?67@=< 5>: 27 G?B8: @797@ 3= =? 4434=5>=?CC3443?>7@5>:4434=5>=?CC3443?>7@G388A3F7 67@C3443?> 5>: 59=7@ ?;=53>3>A 4BD2 67@C3443?> :797>:5>= ? D?B8: A7= =27 A39=#:77: DD?@:3>A8< :797>:5>= ? 25: A3F7> 56683D5=3?> 5>: 54 67@ =27 @7D?CC7>:5=3?>4 ?9 525438:5@ ?> !((! =27 875@>7: 4434=5>= ?CC3443?>7@ 67@C3==7: :797>:5>= ? =? ?;=53> A39=#:77: ;< 3C6?43>A =G? D?>:3=3?>4 B>:7@ 7D=3?> - ?9 5@>5=5J5 5>: 7F7>B7 D= =25= 27 42?B8: DB8=3F5=7 =27 85>: G3=23> ?>7<75@9@?C=27453::5=75>:3927G388>?=DB8=3F5=7G3=23> - 7 - , <75@4 85>:4 G388 ;7 9?@973=7: =? =27 ?F7@>C7>= 9=7@ ?;=53>3>A 4BD2 67@C3443?> 5A53> :797>:5>= ? C7= 6853>=399 5>: =27> 6853>=399 I 234 <?B>A7@ ;@?=27@ 25F7 7H7DB=7: @7A34=7@7: A39=#:77: ?> --)((! 3> 95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? 9?@ D?>4=@BD=3?> ?9 > =27 A39=#:77: =27@734@7D3=58=25=54:797>:5>= ?@7KB74=7:=?A39==27 6@?67@=<9?@D?>4=@BD=3?>?95=23=G54A3F7>=?:797>:5>= ?F?8B>=5@38<54A39= 2?BA2=234G54A39=#:77:=27;?>: G@3=7@254G@3==7>;<B45A754?B=5>:?B=4587% ' 797>:5>= ? 254 >? 5=2 5= ?825@ 5>: 27 25: >? 3>=7>=3?>=?D?>4=@BD=5=25= ?825@*?>8<=?:79@5B:6B;83D 27D5C7=? ?825@5>:C5:7F3885A7@4=?;7837F7=25=27G388 D?>4=@BD= 5>:C5:76853>=399=?65@=5G5<2345D@74?9 85>: 797>:5>= ? D?>=3>B7: 234 9@5B: 5>: 4?8: 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< =? :797>:5>= ? 5>: =27@7;< F3?85=7: =27 D?>:3=3?>4 3C6?47: ;< =27 @7F7>B7 5B=2?@3=374 5= =27 =3C7 ?9 A@5>=3>A 67@C3443?> 797>:5>= ? ?BA2= =? 25F7 D?>F7@=7: 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 9?@ >?>#5A@3DB8=B@58 6B@6?47;B=:79@5B:7:=276853>=3995>:4?8:3==?:797>:5>= ? 3887A588< 2B4 453: 4587 :77: 34 >B88 I F?3: 5>: - 8 - :797>:5>= ?G388>?=A7=5><@3A2=?F7@=276@?67@=< 27 6853>=399254A3F7>6@?67@=<?>8<9?@D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 9 ?F7@>C7>= ?@ 5>< ?=27@ 3>4=3=B=3?> D5C7 9?@G5@: =? D?>4=@BD= 5=2 3> 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 6853>=399 254 >? ?;E7D=3?>9?@3=95=234>?=D?>4=@BD=7:6853>=3992547F7@< @3A2==?A7=;5DJ2346@?67@=< , 797>:5>= ? 254 9387: =27 G@3==7> 4=5=7C7>= G27@73> 27 5:C3==7: =25= 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< G54 =27 5>D74=@58 6@?67@=< ?9 6853>=399 5>: 234 ;@?=27@ D=B588< :797>:5>= ? 34 25F3>A 5= 3>:5A3 3> 3E5<56B@5:34=@3D=43>D79@?C8?>A=3C77254566@?5D27: 6853>=3993>=27<75@((!5>:54J7:85>:7:6@?67@=<9?@=27 6B@6?47?9D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 853>=399G54@75:<=?4788- 5D@74 AB>=5437 65@= ?9 B@F7< ?), 9?@5 4BC ?9 4,---# G23D2 G54 3=4 C5@J7= F58B7 5>: 27 :7>37: =27 ?=27@5F7@C7>=43>=276853>=75:C3==7:=25=;?=26853>=399 5>: :797>:5>= 25: A?>7 =? B;#7A34=@5@ 993D7 545F5> 5A7G5:35>:B;#7A34=@5@=?8:=25=:797>:5>= ?34>?= 25F3>A 5>< 5A@3DB8=B@58 6@?67@=< 5>: 27>D7 3= D?B8: >?= ;7 =@5>497@@7: ;< G5< ?9 4587 7 9B@=27@ 6875:7: =25= 27>D7 - 9 - 6853>=399 5A@77: =? A3F7 =27 6@?67@=< =? :797>:5>= ? ;< G5< ?9 A39= 54 67@ 5:F347 ?9 B;#7A34=@5@ 9=7@ 453: =@5>45D=3?>:797>:5>= ?D?>:BD=7:3>5BAB@5=3?>9B>D=3?> ?>!(()5>:588=27F3885A7@4F?8B>=5@38<65@=3D365=7:3> =27453:9B>D=3?>5>:3=G545A@5>:4BDD744B=27:7>37: =27 ?=27@ 5F7@C7>=4 3> =27 6853>= >9?@=B>5=78< 5D@7 , AB>=54 3> 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< G54 5DKB3@7: ;< =27 ?F7@>C7>= 9?@ 9?@C5=3?> ?9 23A2G5< @?5: 5>: :797>:5>= 25:5:@75C=?;B38:52BA7 9?@=276B@6?47?96B;83D 5= 85@A7 3> 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< ?G7F7@ 453: :@75C D5>>?=;79B893887:;7D5B47?95DKB343=3?>?9C5E?@6?@=3?>?9 =274B3=6@?67@=<;<=27?F7@>C7>= 27@759=7@:797>:5>= ? G7>= ;5DJ =? 3>:5A3 G3=2 7C6=< 25>:4 ?G7F7@ 27 5:C3==7: =25= 525438:5@ 254 A3F7> 67@C3443?> =? 6B@D2547 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 5>: 6853>=399 5>: 234 ;@?=27@ 25F7 7H7DB=7: 4587 :77: 9?@ 4,---# ?> --)((! 797>:5>= ? G54 =7C6?@5@38< @743:3>A 5= 3>:5A3 7 :7>37: =25= 27 G54 3>=7>:7: =? D?>4=@BD= 3> =27 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 5>: 27 254 D275=7: =27 F3885A7@4 5>: - 10 - D?887D=7: C?>7< 6@?67@=< 7=D 7>D7 6@5<7:9?@ :34C34458 ?9=274B3=G3=2D?4=4 797>:5>= ? 9387: 234 G@3==7> 4=5=7C7>= G27@73> 27 D?>=7>:7: =25= 27 6B@D2547: ), AB>=54 ?B= ?9 4B3=4D27:B876@?67@=<3>=27<75@--!9@?C:797>:5>= ? B>:7@ @7A34=7@7: 4587 :77: 7 D?>=7>:7: =25= :797>:5>= ? 254?997@7: =? 4788 ), AB>=54 ?985>: 54 27 G?B8:>?= D?>4=@BD= 3>=27453:6@?67@=<;7D5B47?F7@>C7>=254 5DKB3@7: "-L ?9 =27 85>: 9?@ 9?@C5=3?> ?9 @?5: 797>:5>= ? F7@3937: =27 @7D?@:4 5>: 6B@D2547: =27 ), AB>=54 9?@ 4)---# 37 =27 23A274= D?>43:7@5=3?> 5C?B>= 853>=399 ;73>A@743:7>=?9 ?825@F3885A7J>7G5;?B=6B@D2547;B=5= =25==3C727254>?=@5347:83==8793>A7@5>:>?=?;E7D=7:9?@ 4BD2 4587 797>:5>= ? 34 5 ;?>593:7 6B@D2547@ 7>D7 4B3= 5A53>4= 23C 34 >?= C53>=53>5;87 7 9B@=27@ D?>=7>:7: =25= 4B3= 34 >?= C53>=53>5;87 3> 85G 54 67@ 7D=3?> ) ?9 5@>5=5J5 5>: 79?@C4 D= ;7D5B47 3F38 ?B@= 254 >? EB@34:3D=3?> =? 2?8: =25= D?>:3=3?>4 3C6?47: ;< =27 @7F7>B7 :765@=C7>= =? :797>:5>= ? 5= =27 =3C7 ?9 A@5>=3>A - 11 - 67@C3443?>=?23CG7@7F3?85=7:7>D76@5<7:9?@:34C34458 ?9=274B3=G3=2D?4=4 " 27 =@358 ?B@= ?> =27 ;5434 ?9 =27 5;?F7 6875:3>A42549@5C7:=279?88?G3>A344B74 !! " # " $ # " # % # & ' ( - 12 - % " " )' " *)+$,,,-. / % " 0-)1 23*#4 276853>=399254;77>7H5C3>7:54 5>:A?= 7H5C3>7: ?>7 G3=>744 54 5>: A?= C5@J7: H =? H( 27:797>:5>= ?45>:G7@77H5C3>7:54 5>: 5>:=27<7H5C3>7:?>7G3=>74454 )5>:A?= C5@J7: H =? H 27 =@358 ?B@= 59=7@ 275@3>A =27 5@ABC7>=4 ?> ;?=2 43:74 5>: 566@7D35=3>A =27 C5=7@358 7F3:7>D7 ?> @7D?@: 254 5>4G7@7: 44B7 ?4 " 5>: 5::3=3?>58 44B7 ? :5=7: -"-- 3> =27 5993@C5=3F7 - 13 - 5>: 44B7 ?4 ! 5>: ( 65@=8< 3> 5993@C5=3F7 5>: 44B7 ?,5>:5::3=3?>5844B7 ?9@5C7:?>-,-(--3>=27 >7A5=3F75>:65@=8<:7D@77:=274B3=AA@37F7:;<=27453: B:AC7>=5>::7D@77=27:797>:5>= ?45>:25F79387: ?)- ?> =27 9387 ?9 =27 ::3=3?>58 34=@3D= B:A73E5<56B@5 27453:566758D5C7=?;7588?G7:5>: =27 4B3= D5C7 =? ;7 :34C3447: 54 >?= C53>=53>5;87 AA@37F7: ;< =27 453: B:AC7>= 5>: :7D@77 ;?=2 6853>=3994 5>: :797>:5>=4 25F7 6@797@@7: 47D?>: 566758 3> ?---,"- 5>: ?--)!(-, ;79?@7 =234 ?B@= ?=2 5667584 G7@7 588?G7: 5>: =27 C5==7@ G54 @7C5>:7:;5DJ =?=27 93@4=5667885=7 ?B@= ;< 47==3>A543:7 =27B:AC7>=5>::7D@7765447:3>=275667585>::3@7D=7: =2793@4=5667885=7?B@==?:346?47?9=27566758?>C7@3=43> 5DD?@:5>D7G3=285G;<9?88?G3>A=27?;47@F5=3?>4C5:73> =27B:AC7>=9=7@@7C5>:=2793@4=5667885=7?B@=275@: =27 875@>7: D?B>4784 ?> ;?=2 43:74 5>: 9?@CB85=7: =27 9?88?G3>A6?3>=49?@D?>43:7@5=3?> - 5 - 14 - # ( #. $ /# " 5 ( # " ) 1 2 3 *#4 "# ( 27 93@4= 5667885=7 ?B@= 59=7@ 275@3>A =27 5@ABC7>=4 254 65447: =27 3C6BA>7: B:AC7>= G27@73> 6?3>= ?45>:)G7@75>4G7@7:3>=27>7A5=3F75>:6?3>= ? 5>4G7@7: 65@=8< 3> =27 5993@C5=3F7 5>: :34C3447: =27 566758 5>: D?>93@C7: =27 B:AC7>= 5>: :7D@77 65447: ;< =27 =@358 ?B@= AA@37F7:;< =27453: B:AC7>= ?9=2793@4= 5667885=7 ?B@= :797>:5>= ?4 5>: 25F7 9387: =27 6@747>=47D?>:566758 - 234 47D?>: 566758 D5C7 =? ;7 5:C3==7: =? D?>43:7@=279?88?G3>A4B;4=5>=358KB74=3?>4?985G - 15 - " % " $(("/ # 67 $" " " % # $ $ ( ( # # " $ ( # " % # # 4 '! 3# 4 75@>7: 7>3?@ ?B>478 9?@ =27 5667885>=4 G?B8: D?>=7>:=25==27A39=:77:+HG545;4?8B=75>:=27@7 G7@7>?D?>:3=3?>4=?74=5;8342 27453:A39=:77:254 ;77> 7H7DB=7: ;< =27 6853>=399 5>: 234 ;@?=27@ 3> 95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? ?> --)((! :?>5=3>A B@F7< ?), C754B@3>A 5D@74 B= ?9 =27 453: =G? 5D@74 ?9 85>: 5> 7H=7>= ?9 - 5D@7 -, AB>=54 254 ;77> 5DKB3@7: ;< =27 ?F7@>C7>= 9?@ 9?@C5=3?> ?9 >5=3?>58 23A2G5< B>:7@ - 16 - >?=393D5=3?>:5=7:"--797>:5>= ?G2?D?B8:>?= D?>4=@BD= 3>F37G?9=275DKB343=3?>?9C5E?@6?@=3?>?9 =27 85>: 254 4?8: =27 @7C53>3>A 7H=7>= ?9 ), AB>=54 3> 95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? B>:7@ 4587 :77: + H( 7KB3F587>= =? H! :5=7: ---! 3> 234 D@?44# 7H5C3>5=3?>2545:C3==7:=25==27@7G7@7>? D?>:3=3?>43> =27A39=:77:5>:584?5:C3==7:=25=-5D@7-,AB>=54254 ;77>5DKB3@7:;<=27?F7@>C7>=74B;C3=4=25=B>:7@ G25= D3@DBC4=5>D74 5 A39= C5< ;7 4B467>:7: ?@ @7F?J7: 34 6@?F3:7: B>:7@ 7D=3?> ?9 @5>497@ ?9 @?67@=< D= 27@734>?D3@DBC4=5>D77>BC7@5=7:3>=27A39=:77: 9?@ 3=4 @7F?D5=3?> 27 =@358 ?B@= 5>: =27 93@4= 5667885=7 ?B@=25F77@@7:3>D?>43:7@3>A=276?3>==25==27A39=:77: 5= H 34 5;4?8B=7 5>: =27@7 5@7 >? D3@DBC4=5>D74 =? 4B467>:?@@7F?J7=27453:A39=:77:79B@=27@5@AB7:=25= =27A39=:77:+H254;77>7H7DB=7:?>--)((!5>: =274B3=254;77>9387:3>=27<75@--!477J3>A:7D85@5=3?> =25=3=34>B885>:F?3:5>:5467@@=3D87,(?9=273C3=5=3?> D==274B3=34;5@@7:;<83C3=5=3?>79B@=27@4B;C3=4=25= 7F7> =2?BA2 =27 :797>:5>=4 25F7 >?= =5J7> =27 :797>D7 ?9 - 17 - 83C3=5=3?> 3> =27 G@3==7> 4=5=7C7>= ;B= 54 67@ 7D=3?> ) ?9 =27 3C3=5=3?> D= =27 83C3=5=3?> =? ;7 D?>43:7@7: 7F7> 39 =27@7 34 >? :797>D7 < 685D3>A @7835>D7 ?> =27 :7D343?> ?9 =27 ?>0;87 67H ?B@= 3> =27 D5474 ?9 !"#""$%%" %&'( )@76?@=7:3>% *++ 5>: '"#(% ,"%#'" -.%/" !'% ") @76?@=7: 3> 0 * ++ 1 27 4B;C3=4 =25= 54 67@ @=3D87 ,( =27 4B3= 34 =? ;7 9387: G3=23> =2@77 <75@4 7 9B@=27@ 685D74 @7835>D7 ?> =27 :7D343?> ?9 =27 ?>0;87 67H ?B@=3>=27D547?9/2 3"45 '"%6'% &'( )@76?@=7:3>0 *++ 5>:4B;C3=4=25=3> D547?99@5B:?@B>:B73>98B7>D7=2765@=374CB4=47=9?@=2 9B8865@=3DB85@45>:A7>7@585887A5=3?>45@73>4B993D37>==?5> 5F7@C7>=?99@5B:7685D3>A@7835>D7?>=27:7D343?>?9=27 ?>0;8767H?B@=3>=27D547?9%"%$%" 7 +'&#'" 4&( % +) @76?@=7: 3> 0 * ++ 8 254 4B;C3==7: =25= =27 9@5B: CB4= ;7 74=5;83427: ;7<?>:@754?>5;87:?B;=7685D3>A@7835>D7?>=27:7D343?> ?9 =234 ?B@= 3> =27 D547 ?9 .%22 49%%) @76?@=7: 3> - 1 254 4B;C3==7: =25= =27 - 18 - A39=D5>;7D5>D7887:?>8<B>:7@D3@DBC4=5>D74C7>=3?>7:3> 7D=3?>?9 @5>497@?9@?67@=<D=?@B>:7@7D=3?>( 5>:(?9=27 ?>=@5D=D=79B@=27@685D3>A@7835>D7?> =27:7D343?>?9=27?>0;8767H?B@=3>=27D547?9"' % %&'( (,%% % &'( ) @76?@=7: 3> 0 * ++ 254 5@AB7: =25= =27 A39= 3C6?43>A D?>:3=3?>@74=@53>3>A5837>5=3?>34F?3:7685D3>A@7835>D7?> =27:7D343?>?9=27?>0;8767H?B=3>=27D547?9 5% 5 '2"5&&.%&'( @76?@=7:3>0 *1++ 254D?>=7>:7:=25==274B;47KB7>=D?>:BD=?9:?>77 D5>>?=;75A@?B>:9?@@74D3443?>?9A39=>=2747A@?B>:4 276@5<7:=?588?G=275667585>::34C344=274B3= 75@>7: D?B>478 9?@ =27 @746?>:7>= ? G?B8: D?>=7>:=25==2785>:254;77>A39=7:;<=276853>=3995>:234 ;@?=27@9?@D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 5>:>?==?=273>:3F3:B585>: =27 45C7 D5> ;7 477> 3> =27 @7D3=58 ?9 A39= :77: + H D?>=53>7: 59=7@ :74D@36=3?> ?9 =27 6@?67@=< 7 9B@=27@ 4B;C3=4=25==27A39=254;77>A3F7>=?=27 5>:>?==? =27 3>:3F3:B58 37 :797>:5>= ? 7 9B@=27@ 4B;C3=4 =25= =27 4587 :77: + H! 7H7DB=7: ;< =27 :797>:5>= ? 3> - 19 - 95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? 34 ;< 3>:3F3:B58 5>: >?= ;< =27 3> 234 7F3:7>D7 254 4=5=7: =25= =27 A39= 254 ;77> A3F7> 9?@ D?>4=@BD=3?> ?9 5=2 3> 234 D@?44# 7H5C3>5=3?> 254 5:C3==7: =25= =27 A39= 254 ;77> A3F7> ;< =276853>=39949?@D?>4=@BD=3?>?95=279B@=27@D?>=7>:7: =25=395><D?>:3=3?>3C6837:?@7H6@7448<C5:75==27=3C7 ?9A3F3>AA39=5>:4BD25D?>:3=3?>5@7>?=9B893887:=27>=27 A39=34=?;7@7F?J7:;5DJ=?=27:?>?@5>:?>=27453:6?3>= 27685D74@7835>D7?>=27:7D343?>?988525;5:3A2?B@=3> =27 D547 ?9 " ' +'% "% '2 (:5 % % %&'( @76?@=7: 3> 1 '# 7 685D3>A @7835>D7 ?> =27 453: B:AC7>= 9B@=27@ D?>=7>:7:=25=G27>=2785>:34A3F7>=?D25@3=5;8765@=<9?@ 5 467D393D 6B@6?47 5>: 39 67@9?@C5>D7 ?9 =25= 6B@6?47 34 @7>:7@7: 3C6?443;87 =27> 4BD2 A39= ;7D?C74 >B883=< 5>: 3= 42588;7@7F7@=;5DJ=?=27:?>?@7685D3>A@7835>D7?>=27 :7D343?> ?9 =27 ?>0;87 67H ?B@= 3> =27 D547 ?9 '5 6'%&' 3" '/ % %&'( 2( ' +'% @76?@=7: 3> + 18 ) 254 D?>=7>:7: =25= B>D?>:3=3?>58 A39= :77: 5>: 5> 5A@77C7>= ;7=G77> - 20 - :?>?@ 5>: :?>77 7H7DB=7: ?> 45C7 :5< D?>:3=3?>4 6@74D@3;7:3>5A@77C7>=G?B8:5==5D2=?=27A39=54A39=:77: 5>: 5A@77C7>= 9?@C 65@= ?9 ?>7 =@5>45D=3?> 7 9B@=27@ 4B;C3=4 =25= 7F7> 6@3?@ =? =27 A39= :77: =27@7 G54 5 9B>D=3?> ?9 85<3>A ?9 9?B>:5=3?> 4=?>7 3> =27 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=<5>:6@3>=7:>F3=5=3?>5@:+H)>F78?6+H! 5>: 62?=?+H, 3>:3D5=7 =25= =27 A39= 34 C5:7 9?@ D?>4=@BD=3?> ?9 3> =27 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< F7> =2?BA2 =27@7 34 >? 5A@77C7>= 3> G@3=3>A ;B= 588 D3@DBC4=5>D74 25667>7: 6@3?@ =? =27 A39= :77:+H 3=4789 3>:3D5=7 =25= =27@7 G54 5 ?@58 5A@77C7>= ;7=G77> :?>?@4 5>:=27:?>77=25==27A39=:77:347H7DB=7:9?@D?>4=@BD=3?> ?9 79B@=27@4B;C3=4=25==27:797>:5>= ??BA2= =?25F7D?>4=@BD=7:=27 3>=27@7C53>3>A7H=7>=?985>: 59=7@ 5DKB343=3?> ?9 6?@=3?> ?9 =27 85>: ;< =27 ?F7@>C7>= ;B=3>4=75:?9D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 274?8:@7C53>3>A7H=7>= ?9),AB>=54=?567@4?>G2?34?95:3997@7>=@783A3?>5>:3= 254 5997D=7: =27 97783>A4 ?9 =27 6853>=3994 5>: =27 F3885A7@4 ?>43:7@3>A 588 =2747 5467D=4 =27 =@358 ?B@= 5>: =27 93@4= 5667885=7?B@=25F7@3A2=8<:7D@77:=274B3= - 21 - ) 5F3>A275@:=27875@>7:D?B>4784=234?B@=254 67@B47: =27 3C6BA>7: B:AC7>=4 5>: =27 =@358 ?B@= @7D?@:4 ! 27 5:C3==7: 95D=4 ?9 =27 D547 5@7 =25= 6853>=399 5>: 234 <?B>A7@ ;@?=27@ 23F5665 G7@7 ?G>7@4 ?9 85>: ;75@3>AB@F7< ?),C754B@3>A)5D@74AB>=54?B=?9 G23D2 6853>=399 5>: 234 <?B>A7@ ;@?=27@ 25F7 A39=7: 5D@74 374B3=4D27:B876@?67@=<3>95F?B@?9:797>:5>= ?B>:7@ 5@7A34=7@7:A39=:77::5=7:--)((!79?@77H7DB=3?>?9 4BD2 A39=#:77: :797>:5>= ? 25: D787;@5=7: 85<3>A ?9 9?B>:5=3?> 4=?>7 9B>D=3?> ?> !(() 5>: 3> =25= 9B>D=3?>:3A>3=5@374375<5:7F55254G5C3E3?95>542@77 5>4=25>5 5=2 3E5<56B@5 5>: 7785AB>: 5254G5C3E3 25F75==7>:7:5>:=27<6@743:7:?F7@=279B>D=3?>?985<3>A ?9 9?B>:5=3?> 4=?>7 =27> ?9 453: 685D7 5=38 %5>5AB83' 5>: ?=27@ 78:7@4 25F7 65@=3D365=7: 3> =27 453: 9B>D=3?> 525438:5@ 583J5@ 4434=5>= ?CC3443?>7@ 3E5<56B@5 583 G7@7 584? 5==7>:7: =27 453: 9B>D=3?> 5>: 3> =25= 9B>D=3?> 6853>=399 5>: 234 <?B>A7@ ;@?=27@ G7@7 9783D3=5=7: 9?@ :?>5=3>A 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 9?@ - 22 - D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 =34584?5>5:C3==7:95D==25=6853>=399 234;@?=27@5>::797>:5>= ?566@?5D27:B;#7A34=@5@9?@ @7A34=@5=3?> ?9 A39= :77: ;B= B;#7A34=@5@ @79B47: =? @7A34=7@ 54 3= 34 23= ;< 7D=3?> - ?9 =27 5@>5=5J5 5>: 79?@C4 D= 7>D7 59=7@G5@:4 :797>:5>= ? ?;=53>7: 67@C3443?>9@?C4434=5>=?CC3443?>7@=27>A?=A39=?94B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< ?> --)((! B>:7@ H = G54 7H7DB=7:3>=27>5C7?9:797>:5>= ?67@4?>588<5>:>?= 3> 95F?B@ ?9 ;7D5B47 B;#7A34=@5@ ?;E7D=7: 9?@ @7A34=@5=3?>?95A@3DB8=B@586@?67@=<3>95F?B@?9 , =34>?=3>:346B=7=25=:797>:5>= ?3>=7>:7: =?D?>4=@BD= 3>=274B3=4D27:B876@?67@=<5>:?>8<9?@ =25=6B@6?4727?;=53>7:A39=:77:9@?C=276853>=3995>:=234 G54=27B>:7@4=5>:3>A?96853>=3995>:F3885A7@4F7>3>=27 G@3==7> 4=5=7C7>= :797>:5>= ? =??J D?>=7>=3?> =25= 27 25:5:@75C=?D?>4=@BD=52BA7 3>=274B3=4D27:B87 6@?67@=< ;B= 3= ;7D5C7 9B=387 ;7D5B47 ?9 5DKB343=3?> ?9 - 5D@7-,AB>=543>=274B3=4D27:B876@?67@=<;<?F7@>C7>= 9?@9?@C5=3?>?9>5=3?>5823A2G5< - 23 - > =27 A39= :77:+H 3= 34 @7D3=7: =25= :797>:5>= ? @7KB74=7: 9?@ D?>4=@BD=3?> ?9 =27 6@?67@=< 34 A3F7> =? 23C 54 A39= F?8B>=5@38< 9?@ ?>43:7@3>A=27453:5467D=43=34D875@=25=:797>:5>= ? 42?G7:2343>=7>=3?>=25=27G?B8:D?>4=@BD=5 3>=27 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 5>: =27@79?@7 =27 6853>=399 5>: 234 <?B>A7@ ;@?=27@ 25F7 A39=7: =27 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< =? :797>:5>= ? " ?8:3>A 5 9?B>:5=3?> 85<3>A 4=?>7 9B>D=3?> ;< 3>F3=3>A@783A3?B4275:4?9:3997@7>=@783A3?B43>4=3=B=3?>45>: @7F7>B7 5B=2?@3=374 5>: 9783D3=5=3>A =27 6853>=399 5>: 234 ;@?=27@ 54 :?>?@4 3=4789 3>:3D5=7 =25= =27@7 G54 5 ?@58 5A@77C7>=;7=G77>:?>?@45>:=27:?>77=25==27A39=:77: 347H7DB=7:9?@D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 797>:5>= ?9@?C=27:5=7?9A39=:77::5=7: --)((!=3885DKB343=3?>?9-5D@7-,AB>=543>=27<75@ -- 25: >?= :?>7 5><=23>A =? D?>F7@= =27 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 9?@ >?>#5A@3DB8=B@58 6B@6?47 ?@ 27 :3: >?= :? 5><=23>A 9?@ D?>4=@BD=3?> ?9 =27 3> =27 4B3= 4D27:B87 - 24 - 6@?67@=< F7> 59=7@ -- 3> =27 @7C53>3>A 6?@=3?> ?9 ), AB>=254=27:797>:5>= ?254>?=D?>4=@BD=7:=27 234D?>:BD=?9:797>:5>= ?3=478942?G4=25=43>D79@?C 3>D76=3?>27G54>?=3>=7>:7:=?D?>4=@BD=5=23>=274B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< 27 ?>0;87 67H ?B= 3> =27 D547 ?9 '5 6'%&' 3" '/ %4B6@5' 254 278: =25= 5> B>D?>:3=3?>58 A39= :77: 5>: 5> 5A@77C7>= ;7=G77> :?>?@ 5>: :?>77 7H7DB=7: ?> 45C7 :5< 5>: 5 D?>:3=3?>4 6@74D@3;7:3>5A@77C7>=G?B8:5==5D2=?=27A39=54A39=:77: 5>: 5A@77C7>= 9?@C4 65@= ?9 =27 =@5>45D=3?> F7> =2?BA2 =27@734>?G@3==7>5A@77C7>=;B=D3@DBC4=5>D74=??J685D7 6@3?@=?A39=:77:372?8:3>A59?B>:5=3?>4=?>79B>D=3?>9?@ D?>4=@BD=3?> ?9 G388 74=5;8342 =25= =27@7 G54 5 ?@58 5A@77C7>=;7=G77>:?>?@45>::?>77=25==27A39=349?@=27 6B@6?47?9D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 27@79?@7=27A39=7H7DB=7: ;< =27 :?>?@4 3> 95F?B@ ?9 =27 :797>:5>= ? G54 D?>:3=3?>58 > F37G ?9 =27 5;?F7 =27 :7D343?> ?9 =27 D?# ?@:3>5=77>D2?9=234?B@=3>=27D547?9.%22 %4B6@5'@7A5@:3>A@7F?D5=3?>?9A39=D?>43:7@3>A7D=3?> ?9 D=:?74>?=5668<=?=27D547?>25>: - 25 - ( 75@>7: 7>3?@ ?B>478 254 D?>=7>:7: =25= 54 67@ @=3D87 ,( ?9 =27 3C3=5=3?> D= =27 67@3?: ?9 83C3=5=3?> ;7A3>4 =? @B> 9@?C =27 :5=7 ?9 3>4=@BC7>= 3=4789 4 67@ @=3D87 ,( ?9 =27 3C3=5=3?> D= =? D5>D78 ?@ 47= 543:7 5> 3>4=@BC7>==2767@3?:?983C3=5=3?>=?93874B3=34=2@77<75@4 5>: 83C3=5=3?> ;7A3>4 =? @B> G27> =27 95D=4 7>=3=83>A =27 6853>=399 =? 25F7 =27 3>4=@BC7>= ?@ :7D@77 D5>D7887: ?@ 47= 543:7 ?@ =27 D?>=@5D= @74D3>:7: 93@4=;7D?C7 J>?G>=? 23C 27D5B47?95D=3?>9?@=276853>=3995DD@B7:?>8<?>=27:5< G27> =27 :797>:5>= ? 4?8: 4B3= 4D27:B87 6@?67@=< C754B@3>A),AB>=54=?:797>:5>= ??>---! 27 4B3=D5C7=?;79387:3>=27<75@--!3=478937G3=23>=2@77 <75@4 9@?C =27 :5=7 ?9 =27 453: 4587 :77: 7H7DB=7: ;< :797>:5>= ? 3>95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? 27@79?@7 =27 4B3=9387:;<=276853>=39934G3=23>=2767@3?:?983C3=5=3?> - F7> 59=7@ 5DKB343=3?> ?9 - 5D@7 -, AB>=54 ?9 85>: ;< =27 ?F7@>C7>= 9?@ 23A2G5< =27 6853>=3994 G7@7 G53=3>A 9?@ :797>:5>= ? =? D?>4=@BD= 3> =27 @7C53>3>A85>:C754B@3>A),AB>=54 276853>=3994D5C7=? J>?G =27 9@5B: ?9 =27 :797>:5>= ? =25= =27 A39= :77: 34 - 26 - >?=?;=53>7:9?@D?>4=@BD=3?>?9 G27>:797>:5>= ? 4?8:),AB>=543>95F?B@?9:797>:5>= ?F7>3>H!# 4587:77::5=7:---!7H7DB=7:;<:797>:5>= ?3> 95F?B@ ?9 :797>:5>= ? 3= 34 4=5=7: =25= :797>:5>= ? 254 6B@D2547: =27 6@?67@=< ?>43:7@3>A =27 A39=#:77: + H=27453:@7D3=583>=27453:4587:77:5=H!34584? 95847 27 93@4= 5667885=7 ?B@= 254 @7837: B6?> =27 :7D343?> ?9 =27 ?>0;87 67H ?B= 3> =27 D547 ?9 && 4( ' !% " ' % &'( ) @76?@=7: 3> 8+ 8G27@73>3=34278:=25=M ( ( # " $ ( # " #$ "& N >F37G?9=275;?F7=274B;4=5>=358KB74=3?>4?9 85G 9@5C7: 3> =27 6@747>= 566758 5@7 5>4G7@7: 3> =27 >7A5=3F7 ) >=27@74B8==279?88?G3>A - 27 - 2756675834" 2" ( +( '&#&) % 34= ?8 ?!"