- 1 - ! " #$ " #$ "" %&' () "" * *%&' ( ) !"!#$ $ " $ $ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ % " $ $&' ( " " $ $&' $ ) $* " $&' + $ , ,$ *** ( $ !)) " $ $ $ !#-#. + $ *"/ ."."#$ - 3 - * * * 0--$ * "-""." , ,*$ *, .)."." "-""." , ,* $ * 1 * * $ *, & *( * ) $ $ $ !#-#. $ 2$ + $ 3 $ $ !"!#$$ $ !#.. " " $ - 4 - $ !#-#. $ $ !#...- . $ * " $ $&' !#-#. # " $ $ $&' !#-#. ) " $( $ $&' !#-#. , $ ,$ $ $ $ !)) + $ *)/ $ * * * * 0--$ * - 5 - , .)."." "-""." , ,* $ *, & * * $ $, ( ( 3, 3, * $ (3, * * 4"."- #"." 5 6789 :; <=8 >??877>@< A @5BC>@D8 D4E?>@; >@9 * 4"...#)"." 5 6789 :; <=8>??877>@<5AD7>E>@<5D>77@F@GB85<4@<=8HB9FE8@< >@9>I>C99><89.)."." @4"-""."$?>5589 :; <=8 997 8@4C %7 ,B9F8>@9 ,* ><9>C 64C 5=4C<$ J<=8 C:B@>71 4@7; 4@ <=8 GB>@<BE 46 D4E?8@5><4@ " =8 9><8 46 >DD98@<$ @%47%8E8@< 46 %8=D78 >@998><=46 :9B7>K>L44K;>@>@9<=87>:7<; <4?>;D4E?8@5><4@>C8@4<@95?B<8=84@7;95?B<8 @<=858>??8>75:;<=8>??877>@<!@5BC>@D8D4E?>@;>5 - 6 - <=8 D4E?8@5><4@ >I>C989 :; <=8 C:B@>7 5 %8C; 8M4C:<>@<>@9C8GBC85C89BD<4@@<=84<=8C=>@9$<=8 >??877>@<5 A D7>E>@<5 588L5 8@=>@D8E8@< 46 D4E?8@5><4@>5<=85>E85@>98GB><8 8>C9 E< C88< ><7 87LB@9$ 78>C@89 D4B@587>??8>C@F64C<=8>??877>@<A @5BC>@D84E?>@; @ * 4"."- #"." >@9C >@85=>L$ 78>C@89 D4B@587 >??8>C@F 64C <=8 >??877>@<5D7>E>@<5 @ * 4"...#)"." CE<C88<><787LB@9<>L@F<=54BC< <=C4BF= <=8 HB9FE8@< >@9 >I>C9 %8=8E8@<7; 5B:E<<89 <=><<=8D7>E?8<<4@I>56789:;<=86><=8C$:C4<=8C>@9 55<8C 46 98D8>589 BC@F <=8 ?8@98@D; 46 <=8 ?8<<4@$ 6><=8C 8M?C89 >@9 @ =5 ?7>D8$ <=8 4<=8C 78F>7 C8?C858@<><%85466><=8CI8C8:C4BF=<4@C8D4C9=8<I4 5:7@F5 H4@89 <=8 6><=8C @ 67@F <=8 ?8<<4@ B< 46 <=8E$?8<<4@8C4"I>5E>H4C>@9@4<98?8@98@<4@<=8 :C4<=8C4I8%8C$<=855<8CI>5>E@4C>@95<><89<4:8 98?8@98@<4@<=8:C4<=8CI=8@<=86><=8CI>5>7%8=8 - 7 - C:B@>7 4BF=< <4 =>%8 >I>C989 <=8 D4E?8@5><4@ @4< B@98C<=874554698?8@98@D;:B<B@98C<=874554685<><8 >5 7>9 94I@ :; <=8 HB9FE8@< 46 <=5 D4BC< @ @98C<=858 DCDBE5<>@D85$ <=8 >I>C9 C8GBC89 <4 :8 E49689 >@9 C89BD89 @ <=858 FC4B@95$ 5=8 54BF=< <4 >774I <=8 >??8>7>@9C89BD8<=8D4E?8@5><4@ # 86B<@F<=85B:E554@54678>C@89D4B@58764C <=8 >??877>@< A @5BC>@D8 D4E?>@;$ C >@85= >L I<=>77%8=8E8@D85B:E<<89<=><<54@C8D4C9<=><<=8 D7>E ?8<<4@ I>5 6789 :; <=8 6><=8C >@9 5:7@F5 46 98D8>589<=4BF=?8<<4@8C4"I>55=4I@>5E>H4C>@9 7>:4BC4I8%8C$?8<<4@8C4 8$D7>E>@<4 I>5 E@4C >@9 98?8@98@< 4@ <=8 :C4<=8C 64C <=8 C8>54@ <=8 6><=8CI>55B668C@F6C4E?>C>7;55>@9B@>:78<4I>7L 5 ?8C <=8 HB9FE8@< 46 4@1:78 ?8M 4BC< @ <=8 D>58 46 1 - 8 - $I=8C8@<5=879<=>< <=8 6><=8C >@9 4<=8C 98?8@98@< 5:7@F5 >C8 >754 <4 :8 D4@598C89>598?8@98@<54@<=898><=46:>D=874C@<=8 6>E7;I=8C8@6><=8CI>55=4I@<4:8B@>:78<48>C@>@9 4<=8C98?8@98@<54@<=86><=8C>C8>75498?8@9@F4@<=8 @D4E8 46 98D8>589 @ <=8 D>58 4@ =>@9$ >5 <=8 6><=8C I>5 5B668C@F 6C4E ?>C>7;55$ B@>:78 <4 I4CL >@9 =8 I>5 8@<C87; 98?8@98@< 4@ <=8 @D4E8 46 98D8>589 54 >754 ?8<<4@8C 4 $ 6 @4<$ ?8<<4@8C 4" =8 C:B@>7 <>L@F @<4 D4@598C><4@ 46 <=8 5>9 6>D< I=78 >I>C9@F D4E?8@5><4@$ 989BD<89 #.N 64C <=8 C8>54@ <=8 6><=8C 9899BC@F<=8?8@98@D;46<=8?8<<4@4I8%8C$5@D8 <=8 ?8<<4@8C 4 :8@F E@4C >@9 98?8@98@< 4@ 98D8>589 :C4<=8C$ 989BD<89 #.N <4I>C95 ?8C54@>7 8M?8@585 46 98D8>589 >@9 #.N >5 @D4E8 <4 <=8 6>E7; 8$ <=8 7455 46 98?8@98@D; 4I8%8C$ <=8 C:B@>7 =>5 @4< <>L8@ <=8 @D4E8 46 98D8>589$ I=4 I>5 "" ;8>C5 >< <=8<E84698><=>@9I>58>C@@F5"$...!5>7>C;?8C 2 2009 ACJ 1298 - 9 - E4@<= I4CL@F >5 > =86 @ > =4<87 4I8%8C$ <=8 C:B@>7=>5<>L8@<=8@D4E8><5"$...!?E$I=D= 58%8@>F>@5<<=8@D4E86M89B@98C<=8=>C<?C8?>C89 :; <=8 >C@><>L> <><8 8F>7 8C%D85 B<=4C<; 64C <=8 ;8>C".".><5 $#.!=8@D4E8><78>5<><<=8C><8 46 5 $#.! 4BF=< <4 =>%8 :88@ D4@598C89 :; <=8 C:B@>7 =8 C:B@>7 6BC<=8C 8CC89 @ @4< <>L@F <=8 6B<BC8?C45?8D<5<4<=88M5<@F@D4E8@%8I467>I7>9 94I@:;<=84@1:78 ?8M4BC<@<=8D>5846 !" # $ #%&' #() *+ #, "*"!)- % ' # , )!." #- !.)'% 54 >754 .N 85D>7><4@ @ <=8 %8C; 5>E8 HB9FE8@<<4:8>9989<4<=8D4E?8@5><4@>I>C989B@98C <=8 D4@%8@<4@>7 =8>95 64C 8>D= D4E?78<89 <=C88 ;8>C5 6C4E ". *BC<=8C$ =8 =>5 5B:E<<89 <=>< <=8 D4E?8@5><4@ >I>C989 :; <=8 C:B@>7 B@98C <=8 D4@%8@<4@>7 =8>9 5 4@ <=8 74I8C 598 <= <=5$ =8 54BF=<<4>774I<=8>??8>7>@98@=>@D8<=8D4E?8@5><4@ :;95E55@F<=8>??8>7:;<=8@5BC>@D8D4E?>@; 3 - 10 - ) >%@F =8>C9 <=8 78>C@89 D4B@587 64C <=8 ?>C<85$ ?8CB589 <=8 8@<C8 >??8>7 ?>?8C5$ <=8 4@7; GB85<4@<=><I4B79>C5864CD4@598C><4@5( O=8<=8C <=8 D4E?8@5><4@ >I>C989 :; <=8 C:B@>7 :86< I<=@ <=8 8M?C8554@ HB5< D4E?8@5><4@$ 6 <=8 >@5I8C 5 4<=8CI58$ I=8<=8C @<8C68C8@D8 >< <=8 =>@9546<=54BC<5C8GBC89PQ BC>@5I8C<4<=8>:4%8?4@<64CD4@598C><4@ 5J?>C<7;@>66CE><%87;164C<=864774I@F( - <54@C8D4C9<=><<=86><=8C4698D8>589I>5 5B668C@F6C4E?>C>7;55>@9B@>:78<4I>7L>@998?8@98@< 4@<=8@D4E84698D8>589=8<I45:7@F5I=4H4@89 <=86><=8C@67@F<=8?8<<4@$<=4BF=?8<<4@8C4"8$ D7>E>@< 4" I>5 5=4I@ <4 :8 E>H4C >@9 8>C@@F$ =4I8%8C$ ?8<<4@8C 4 D7>E>@< 4 I>5 E@4C >@9 98?8@98@<4@<=8:C4<=8C5@D86><=8CI>5B@>:78<48>C@ - 11 - 5 CF=<7; D4@<8@989 :; <=8 78>C@89 D4B@587 64C <=8 >??877>@<5D7>E>@<5@<=8>??8>76789:;<=8EC87;@F4@ <=8HB9FE8@<464@1:78 ?8M4BC<@<=8D>5846 $ <=8 C:B@>7 ?C4?8C7; D4@598C89 <=8 D>58 <4 >I>C9 D4E?8@5><4@ B@98C <=8 =8>9 J7455 46 98?8@98@D;1 5 5BD=$ <=8 D4@<8@<4@ 46 78>C@89 D4B@587 >??8>C@F 64C <=8 >??877>@<@5BC>@D8 D4E?>@; <4 >I>C9 D4E?8@5><4@B@98C<=874554685<><89485@4<>C58=8 C:B@>7 =>5 8CC89 @ @4< D4@598C@F <=8 @D4E8 <=4BF= @4<<45"#$...!?8CE4@<=>5D7>E89:;<=8D7>E>@<5 @%8I46>:58@D846>@;@D4E8?>C<DB7>C5<=8C:B@>7 4BF=<<4=>%8D4@598C89<=8@D4E86M89B@98C<=8D=>C< ?C8?>C89:;<=8 ><5 $#.!?E=8C:B@>7 6BC<=8C8CC89@@4<D4@598C@F<=86B<BC8?C45?8D<5<4<=8 8M5<@F @D4E8 <>L@F @<4 D4@598C><4@ <=8 >F8 46 98D8>589 54 >754 85D>7><4@ >< .N 64C 8>D= D4E?78<89 <=C88 ;8>C5 6C4E ". 4@ <=8 D4E?8@5><4@ >I>C989 B@98C<=8D4@%8@<4@>7=8>95@%8I467>I7>994I@:; <=8 4@1:78 ?8M 4BC< @ <=8 D>58 46 - 12 - =>< >?>C<$ <=8 C:B@>7 =>5 @4< D4@598C89 <=8 D>58 46 <=8 D7>E>@<5 <4 >I>C9 >@; D4E?8@5><4@ B@98C <=8=8>9J67>7D4@54C<BE1 @<8CE5467>I7>994I@:; <=8 4@1:78 ?8M 4BC< @ / 0 I=8C8@ <=84@1:78 ?8M4BC< ><?>C>FC>?= 4" =879 <=>< <=8 CF=< <4 D4@54C<BE I4B79 @D7B98 <=8 D4E?>@;$ D>C8$ =87?$ D4E64C<$ FB9>@D8 >@9 >668D<4@ 46 <=8 98D8>589$ I=D= 5 7455 <4 =5 6>E7; >@9 6BC<=8C >< ?>C>FC>?=4" $<=85>E8>E4B@<5<4FC8><5=4DL>@9 >F4@;<4<=86>E7;46<=898D8>589 0 >C>FC>?=45"<4" 46<=85>9HB9FE8@< >C8C8?C49BD89:;B564C8>5;C868C8@D8 12 ! " # $% & '(" # ) *(* +,' & - ( ' ' - . / - '' ' 0 ! ' & ! .&1 & & )2 .3 .' . - . 2 & .3) 2 & .3) '2!& & .34 1 . 4 ".- ,"-" - 13 - -&' &' . #) ) &) .! ) 1' ) & ' !! ! ' ') - & ! .&# 5 ) -&' &' 6 & & - ' ' 2 2 & . 1 &&# '!' 1 1 & ! / '7-!- &&- . ((1 ! & ! 2. #) #) ) !!) ' ' ! ( #81 & & 2 " & .1 ' &' . ' ! ) ! & ! 2 & ') ) !!) #) '&) 1' ' 13 2 9& & . 1 ! . ! ' &' ! &' ' & '1 ' ! &' 1 : ' 1# ' ! .&# ! ' ' 4 1 1#! & &'' 1 &!. &' ( &' ! &() !!) . ' & ! .&#3 . @ %8I 46 <=8 5>E8$ 5@D8 <=8 6><=8C 989 9BC@F<=8?8@98@D;46<=8>??8>7$<=85:7@F5I=4H4@89 <=8 6><=8C >C8 8@<<789 64C 67>7 D4@54C<BE >5 <=8; =>%8 745< D4E?>@;$ D>C8$ =87?$ D4E64C<$ FB9>@D8$ >5 I877 >5 >668D<4@46<=898D8>589I=D=5>7455<4=56>E7; @ %8I 46 D=>@F8 @ <=8 @D4E8 >5 ?8C <=8 =>C<$ .N - 14 - 85D>7><4@ <4 :8 >I>C989 B@98C <=8 D4@%8@<4@>7 =8>95$ <=8 D4E?8@5><4@ >I>C989 :; <=8 C:B@>7 C8GBC85 C8! D4@598C><4@>@9C8!98<8CE@><4@( @%8I46<=8@D4E85<><89 >@94@C8! 98<8CE@><4@$ <=8 J455 46 8?8@98@D;1 I4CL5 4B< >5 64774I5( + ,( %+-* . /' 0 - 0 - 0 (- " 5?8C<=8HB9FE8@<46<=84@1:78 ?8M4BC< @ <=8 D>58 46 ' # , )!." B?C>$ <=8 D7>E>@<5 >C8 8@<<789 <4 5.$...! 8>D= B@98C <=8 =8>9 46 J455 46 4@54C<BE1 >@9 <=8C8 5=>77 :8 .N 85D>7><4@ 4@ <=8 D4@%8@<4@>7=8>9564C<=C88D4E?78<89;8>C5464@8<8CE 6C4E".$@%8I467>I7>994I@:;<=84@1:78 ?8M 4BC<@<=8D>5846' # ,)!."B?C>=885D>7><4@ >< .N 64C 4@8 D4E?78<89 ;8>C5 I4CL5 4B< <4 5"$...! DD4C9@F7;$ <=8 >??877>@<5D7>E>@<5 >C8 8@<<78964C>5BE46+ (%+ 0. - 15 - -/'12345+6++7+4189:;@D7B9@F++ 8<83<7+4189:; *BC<=8C$>D4E?8@5><4@46+-(8>D=5 >I>C989 B@98C <=8 =8>9 6++ +131=; 75 697=43< =0>=7+=+ 75 437+>413187; C85?8D<%87;$ >74@F I<= .N85D>7><4@=8C864C8$+**(5#$...M"M ...<4I>C956+++131=;75697=43<=0>=7+=+ 75437+>413187; =B5$4@C8!98<8CE@><4@>@9C8!D4@598C><4@$ <=8 >??877>@<5 >C8 8@<<789 64C <4<>7 D4E?8@5><4@ >5 64774I5( =35+?:>=7+3187 :971 45546 8?8@98@D; 5 ".$0$...! 455465<><8 5 #$...! 45546*B@8C>7M?8@585 5 #$...! 45546*7>74@54C<BE 5.$...M) 5 "$.$...! .N 85D>7><4@ 64C <=C88 D4E?78<89 ;8>C5 4@ D4@%8@<4@>7 =8>95 R5"$.$... M .N M ;8>C5S 5 "$...! + *( - 16 - # =8 <4<>7 D4E?8@5><4@ C8!98<8CE@89 :; <=5 4BC< I4CL5 4B< <4 5" $)$...! >5 >F>@5< 5 $")$...! >I>C989 :; <=8 C:B@>7$ >74@F I<= @<8C85< >< )N ?8C >@@BE 6C4E <=8 9><8 46 67@F 46 <=8 ?8<<4@ <77 C8>7K><4@ DD4C9@F7;$ <=8 ?4@< 64C D4@598C><4@5>@5I8C89?>C<7;@>66CE><%8 ) *4C <=8 64C8F4@F C8>54@5$ <=5 4BC< ?C4D8895 <4?>55<=864774I@F( =8 >??8>7 6789 :; <=8 >??877>@< A @5BC>@D8D4E?>@;@* 4"."- #"." 5-"%*"%%)-3 =8 >??8>7 6789 :; <=8 >??877>@<5 A D7>E>@<5 @ * 4"...#)"." 5 $$ 4)-5"#5+ '!/ =8HB9FE8@<>@9>I>C99><89.)."." ?>5589 :; <=8 99<4@>7 8@4C %7 - 17 - ,B9F8 >@9 ,* >< 9>C @ 4"-""."5=8C8:;E49689/ % =8>??877>@<5D7>E>@<5>C88@<<78964C> <4<>7 D4E?8@5><4@ 46 5" $)$...! >5 >F>@5< 5 $")$...! >74@F I<= @<8C85< ><)N?8C>@@BE6C4E<=89><84667@F46 <=8?8<<4@<77C8>7K><4@/ % @ %8I 46 95?45>7 46 @5BC>@D8 D4E?>@;15 >??8>7@* 4"."- #"." $<=8>E4B@< @ 98?45< :864C8 <=5 4BC< 5=>77 :8 <C>@5E<<89 64C<=I<= <4 <=8 D4@D8C@89 C:B@>764C95:BC58E8@</ % =8 :>7>@D8 C8!98<8CE@89 D4E?8@5><4@ >E4B@< >74@F I<= >DDCB89 @<8C85< 5<><89 5=>77 :8 98?45<89 :864C8 <=8 D4@D8C@89 C:B@>7 :; <=8 >??877>@< A @5BC>@D8D4E?>@;@* 4"."- #"." >@9 C85?4@98@< 4" @ * - 18 - 4"...#)"." I<=@ > ?8C49 46 5M I88L5 6C4E <=8 9><8 46 C8D8?< 46 D4?; 46 <=54C98C/ % ??4C<4@E8@< >@9 95:BC58E8@< 5 >5 ?8C <=84C98C46<=8C:B@>7/ % 44C98C>5<4D45< 5( %" ' $ 5( %' $ 5<4(74(" (,