- 1 - !"# $# %% && '%( ) ! " # #$ " %& "" ! %'$' " ( " " &) " * $$) & * # ! " Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " * + * # ,-../01201 34516/07 -05 -8-95 5-7/5 $$) :-;;/5 <= /02>9 2?2. *451/ -05 >7>9 @@25/07 .-26; 92<40-.#-7-5129220 0>&7,2;-::/-.2;A2./5 92 //9-0-1>45- -.2:-72. ./-90/5 @>40;/. ;4<6277/5 -::/-. 8-; <= @.-26-07; A>9 /0,-0@/6/07 >A @>6:/0;-72>0 0 41-::- 8-; 8-.B201<= ;25/ >A -51292#=5/9-<-5 6-20 9>-5 0/-9 ,4<-6 /79>. 40B -7 C)-68,/0592?/9>A.>99=</-92019/12;79-72>00>## #$59>?/2720-9-;,-050/1.21/076-00/9-055-;,/5 -1-20;7 41-::- ,>41, 41-::- 8-; -56277/5 7> >?/906/07>;:27-.,/52/554920179/-76/07>0) ../1201.>;;>A5/:/05/0@=,2;82A/-055-41,7/9A2./5@.-26 :/7272>0405/9/@72>0DD>A >7>9/,2@./; @7-1-20;7>80/9 -0520;49/9>A>AA/05201.>99= - 3 - ) 0 @>07/;7 8,/9/20 9/;:>05/07; 5/02/5 /0729/ @.-26 :/7272>0 -?/96/07; -; 8/.. -; -../1/5 ?2>.-72>0 >A :>.2@= @>05272>0; 792<40-. A9-6/5 2;;4/; -05 9/@>95/5 /?25/0@/ .-26-070>/E-620/5,/9;/.A-;-051>76-9B/5E;# 7>#$0;49/9/E-620/527;>AA2@2-.-;-051>76-9B/5 20;49-0@/:>.2@=-;E 0 @>0;25/9-72>0 92<40-. ,/.5 -@@25/07 ,-5 >@@499/554/7>9-;,-050/1.21/07592?201>A.>99=<=27;592?/9 ./-5201 7>5/-7, >A 41-::- -05 @.-26-07; 8/9/ ,/.5 /0727./5 A>9 @>6:/0;-72>0 >A ;$'# 20@/ 20;49-0@/ 8-; -56277/527,/.520;49/9.2-<./7>:-=;-6/ ' >7;-72;A2/5827,;-6/@.-26-07;-9/20-::/-.7 8-; ;4<6277/5 7,>41, -@@25/07 >@@499/5 20 =/-9 -05 @.-26-07; ,-5 ;7-7/5 7,-7 5/@/-;/5#41-::- 8-; /-90201 ;'#:/96>07,A9>6,>7/.<4;20/;;92<40-.-;;/;;/5 6>07,.= 20@>6/ 0>72>0-..= -7 ;# ;-6/ 8-; 0>7 34;72A2/578-;;4<6277/5-;:/95/@2;2>0>A>0F<./4:9/6/ >497 20 92<40-.5250>7-55G7>-8-95405/9 !! - 4 - @>0?/072>0-.,/-5;78-;-.;>;4<6277/57,-792<40-.5250>7 9/A/9 7> 6/52@-. <2..; 5/;:27/ 41-::- ;4@@46<201 7> 5/-7, 8,2./2079/-76/07 0;-2519>405;;>41,7/0,-0@/6/07 D 92 ,-9-0-<-;-::- -72. ./-90/5 @>40;/. A>9 9/;:>05/07 0>#20;49/9 >0 >7,/9 ,-05 >::>;/5 -::/-. 7 8-;;4<6277/57,>41,7,/9/8-;;>6/;@>:/A>9/0,-0@/6/07 ;-6/ 8-; >AA;/7 <= A-@7 7,-7 827,>47 34;72A2@-72>0 792<40-. -8-95/5 ;'# 7>8-95; .>?/ -05 -AA/@72>0 -05 ;# 7>8-95; 79-0;:>97-72>0 -05 @>0?/=-0@/ /7@ 0 ;-2519>405;>41,752;62;;-.>A-::/-. & /-95./-90/5@>40;/./94;/526:410/534516/07 -05-8-95 $ "9>6 -<>?/ -05 ;20@/ 20;49/9 ,-; 0>7 @,-../01/5 -8-958,2./@.-26-07;-9/20-::/-.>0.=:>2077,-78>4.5-92;/ A>9@>0;25/9-72>02; H,/7,/9 @.-26-07; -9/ /0727./5 A>9 /0,-0@/6/07>A@>6:/0;-72>0-;;>41,7A>9IJ C -6/2;-0;8/9/5:-97.=20-AA296-72?/A>9A>..>8201 9/-;>0; - 5 - 7 2; 0>7 20 52;:47/ 7,-7 -@@25/07 >@@499/5 >0 ./-52017>5/-7,>A41-::-.-26-07;,-?/;7-7/5 7,-7 ,/ 8-; /-90201 ;'# :/9 6>07, A9>6 ,>7/. <4;20/;; <47 ;-6/ 8-; 0>7 ;4<;7-072-7/5 827, -0= 6-7/92-. 0-<;/0@/92<40-.-;;/;;/5270>72>0-..=>72>0-.20@>6/A>9 =/-9 </201 ;&'# :/9 6>07, -05 ;-6/ ,-; 7> </ @>0;25/9/592<40-.921,7.=@>0;25/9/5-1/-;:/9:>;7#6>97/6 9/:>97 -7 ' =/-9; -05 -::.2/5 64.72:.2/9 >A >0F<./ 4:9/6/>49720@-;/>A,-;,/.57,-7 /?/0 20 @-;/ >A -;;/;;6/07 >A 6>07,.= 20@>6/ >A 5/@/-;/5 0>72>0-..= @.-26-07; 8>4.5 </ /0727./5 A>9 -55272>0 7>8-95; A4749/ :9>;:/@7; /@/-;/5 8-; -1/5 ' =/-9; -05 ;/.A /6:.>=/5 >99/;:>05201 -55272>0 7>8-95; A4749/ :9>;:/@7; 8>4.5 </ -7 'G 92<40-. 921,7.= 5/54@7/5 )95 7>8-95; :/9;>0-./E:/0;/;>A5/@/-;/5>0;/K4/07.=@>6:47-72>0>A .>;;>A5/:/05/0@=8>4.5</;&'#L'GEE% )957>8-95;:/9;>0-./E:/0;/; M;D&)&# :-97 A9>6 ;-25 @>6:/0;-72>0 @.-26-07;#82A/ -05 5-41,7/9 8>4.5 </ /0727./5 7> @>6:/0;-72>0 7>8-95; .>;; >A ;:>4;-. @>0;>97246 -05 :-9/07-. @>0;>97246 -7 ;# 9/;:/@72?/.= ,/= 8>4.5 -.;> </ /0727./5 7> ;'# - 6 - 7>8-95; A40/9-. /E:/0;/; -05 ;'# 7>8-95; .>;; >A /;7-7/ 0 ;-25 -6>407 -; :/9 5/@2;2>0 >A >0F<./ 4:9/6/ >49720" @-;/;4:9- 7,/=8>4.5<//0727./5 A>9-55272>0>AG,4;@.-26-07;8>4.5<//0727./5A>97>7-. @>6:/0;-72>0>A;#405/9@>0?/072>0-.,/-5; .-26-07; :9>54@/5 6/52@-. <2..; 6-9B/5 -; E$ 92<40-. ,-; 0>7 -;;210/5 -0= 9/-;>0; A>9 5/0=201 @>6:/0;-72>0 7>8-95; 6/52@-. /E:/0;/; ;20@/ 5/-7, >A 41-::- 8-; 549201 79/-76/07 /94;-. >A @/972A2/5 @>:2/; >A E$ 6-5/ -?-2.-<./ <= ./-90/5 @>40;/. A>9 @.-26-07; -05 /E-620/5 <= ./-90/5 @>40;/. A>9 9/;:>05/07#20;49/9 -.;> 8>4.52052@-7/7,-7>;:27-.<2..827,:-25/05>9;/6/078-;A>9 ;#8,2./7>7-.-6>407>A6/52@-.<2..;8-;;D'& 6>407 @>?/9/5 405/9 -5?-0@/ 9/@/2:7 @-00>7 </ @>0;25/9/5 0-<;/0@/>A-0=;/92>4;52;:47/-<>475/-7,>A20349/5549201 79/-76/07 @.-26-07; 8>4.5 </ /0727./5 A>9 -6>407 ;:/07 7>8-95; 6/52@-. /E:/0;/; ,/9/A>9/ ;46 >A ;'D'&# 2; -8-95/57>8-95;6/52@-./E:/0;/; ) ;921,7.=;4<6277/5<=./-90/5@>40;/.A>920;49/9 -8-95 >A ;# 7>8-95; 79-0;:>97-72>0 -05 @>0?/=-0@/ - 7 - -05;'#7>8-95;.>?/-05-AA/@72>0<=92<40-.8>4.5 0>7 </ 34;72A2/5 ,4; @.-26-07; 8>4.5 </ /0727./5 A>9 7>7-. @>6:/0;-72>0 >A ;''# >207 A>9 @>0;25/9-72>0 2; -0;8/9/5:-97.=20-AA296-72?/>0;/K4/07.=A>..>8201 2 ::/-. 2; -..>8/5 20 :-97 34516/07 -05 -8-95 5-7/5$$):-;;/5<=/02>92?2.*451/-05 >7>9 @@25/07.-26;92<40-.#-7-5129220 0>&2;6>52A2/5@.-26-07;-9/,/.5/0727./5 A>97>7-.@>6:/0;-72>0>A;''#-;-1-20;7 ;$'#-8-95/5<=92<40-. 22 7,/9@>05272>0;-<>479-7/>A207/9/;75/:>;27-05 9/./-;/>A@>6:/0;-72>08>4.5-::.=-;:/9-8-95 >A92<40-.7>/0,-0@/5-8-95:9>:>972>0-7/.= 222 0;49/9 2; 529/@7/5 7> 5/:>;27 /0,-0@/5 @>6:/0;-72>0</A>9/92<40-.827,20;2E8//B; /-90/5 @>40;/. A>9 20;49/9 2; :/96277/5 7> A2./ ?-B-.-7 827,20A>498//B; *+ '%% ( # 2;7>.>)&7(B