Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58757 (KAR)

ROOPALABAI AND ORS v. RAMESH AND ANR

MFA/200303/2022 · 2025-10-13

H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#! "# #$ !! %$& ' ! " # Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % %&'()* + " % , # % $ %&'()* - &*** "# + " -. # - - ! "# - - % (** ))(*! - -- % , % % -*(('**/ - 0 -% $ - -- % - 3 - 1 % 1 % % # "1 % # 234 566758 34 9: ;27 <853=5>;4 ?387@ A>@7B 7<;3C> !"#C?;27C;CB 723<874<; ((973>D5DDB37E7@9: ;27FA@D=7>;5>@5G5B@@5;7@(**65447@9:;27 @@8 7>3CB 3E38 %A@D7 /, 3F5:56AB5 3> C))(*! 477H3>D 7>25><7=7>; C? <C=67>45;3C> 5>@ ;C?54;7>3>D8359383;:C>;273>4AB5><7<C=65>:3>4;75@C? ?54;7>3>DC>;27B746C>@7>;C -5<;4 D3E3>D B347 ;C ;27 ?383>D C? ;27 566758 9B37?8:4;5;7@5B7;25;C>*'*!5;59CA;'6= G27> @7<7547@ 545>; G54 ;B5E783>D 3> ;27 35DD3C 3<H425G 975B3>D 7DC/(/*!) 5>@ G27> ;27 453@ E723<87 B75<27@ >75B 5>>AB 5BD5 BC44 5; ;25; ;3=7 ;27 @B3E7B C? A;CB3<H425G @BCE7 ;27 45=7 5 E7B: 23D24677@B5425>@>7D83D7>;=5>>7BB74A8;3>D3>;AB;87 - 4 - C? ;27 45=7 4 5 B74A8; C? G23<2 @7<7547@ 545>; 4A4;53>7@?5;583>FAB3745>@@37@C>;2746C; 27@7<7547@G5425875>@2758;2:5;;27;3=7 C?5<<3@7>;5>@G5475B>3>D4'***/67B=C>;2?BC= 234 5DB3<A8;AB58 GCBH 27 67;3;3C>7B4 973>D ;27 G3?7 5>@ <238@B7> C? @7<7547@ G7B7 4C878: @767>@3>D C> 234 75B>3>D4 A7 ;C A>;3=78: @75;2 C? @7<7547@ ;27 67;3;3C>7B4 8C4; ;273B 75B>3>D =7=97B 7><7 ;27 <853=5>;4 ?387@ ;27 <853= 67;3;3C> A>@7B 7<;3C> )) C? C;CB 723<874 <; 97?CB7 ;27 853=4 B39A>58 477H3>D <C=67>45;3C>?CB;273>FAB3744A4;53>7@3>;27BC5@;B5??3< 5<<3@7>; AB4A5>; ;C ;27 4A==C>4 B746C>@7>; C4 5>@56675B7@5>@?387@;273B4765B5;7GB3;;7>4;5;7=7>;4 @7>:3>D;275E7B=7>;4=5@73>;27<853=67;3;3C> ' >;2795434C?;276875@3>D4C?;2765B;374;27 853=4B39A>58?B5=7@;27344A745>@;27B75?;7BB7<CB@7@ ;277E3@7><727<853=5>;43>CB@7B;C6BCE7;27<547 - 5 - <853=5>; C DC; 7I5=3>7@ 27B478? 54 / 5>@ DC; 7I2393;7@@C<A=7>;4>5=78:I;CI)>97258?C? B746C>@7>;C;277D585>5D7B347I5=3>7@54 5>@DC;=5BH7@;2B77@C<A=7>;454I4;C ) 27853=4B39A>589:;273=6AD>7@FA@D=7>; 278@;25; ;27 5<<3@7>; ;CCH685<7C> 5<<CA>;C? B542 5>@ >7D83D7>; @B3E3>D C? ;27 @B3E7B C? ;27 C??7>@3>D E723<87 54 5 B74A8; C? G23<2 @7<7547@ 4A4;53>7@ 3>FAB374 5>@ 4A<<A=97@ ;C ;27 3>FAB374 27 B39A>58 A6C> <C>43@7B3>D ;27 CB58 5>@ @C<A=7>;5B: 7E3@7><7 685<7@ 97?CB7 3; 278@ ;25; ;27 <853=5>;4 5B7 7>;3;87@ ;C <C=67>45;3C>C?4'**/58C>DG3;23>;7B74;5;;27 B5;7 C? )J 65 5>@ @3B7<;7@ B746C>@7>; C ;C @76C43; ;27 <C=67>45;3C> 9: 7IC>7B5;3>D ;27 B746C>@7>; C / >4AB5><7 C=65>: 73>D @3445;34?37@ G3;2 ;27 KA5>;A= C? <C=67>45;3C>5>@KA74;3C>3>D ;27 ?54;7>3>D C?8359383;: C>;27B746C>@7>;C;234566758254977>?387@ - 6 - ! 27875B>7@<CA>478?CB;27<853=5>;4B5347@;27 ?C88CG3>D<C>;7>;3C>4 5# 27 875B>7@ <CA>478 ?CB ;27 <853=5>;4 <C>;7>@7@;25;5;;27;3=7C?5<<3@7>;@7<7547@G545D7@ ' :75B4 5>@ 27 G54 75B>3>D 4'***/ 67B =C>;2 9: @C3>D 5DB3<A8;AB58 GCBH A; ;27 >C;3C>58 3><C=7 C? ;27 @7<7547@5447447@9:B39A>585;4*'*/67B=C>;2 G23<234C>;278CG7B43@7 9# 7<C>@8: 27 254 <C>;7>@7@ ;25; ;27 B39A>58 254>C;5@@7@'J;C;273><C=7C?;27@7<7547@;CG5B@4 ?A;AB76BC467<;43>E37GC?;27FA@D=7>;C?;2767ICAB; 3> B76CB;7@ 3> -AB;27B 27 4A9=3;4 ;25;5467B;27FA@D=7>;3> !" !"##$! %$!# & '( )* !% $! + !, -. 75<2 C? ;27 <853=5>;4 5B7 7>;3;87@ ?CB <C=67>45;3C> C? 4****/ A>@7B ;27 275@ C? L46CA458 <C>4CB;3A=0 5>@ L8C44 C? 8CE7 5>@5??7<;3C> - 7 - <# > B7467<; C? 8359383;: ;27 875B>7@ <CA>478 <C>;7>@7@;25;;27B39A>582547IC>7B5;7@;273>4AB5><7 <C=65>: C> ;27 DBCA>@ ;25; ;27 C??7>@3>D E723<87 G54 6837@97:C>@;2767B=3;;7@5B75 ;34234<C>;7>;3C>;25; 7E7> ;2CAD2 3>4AB7@ 254 E3C85;7@ ;27 6C83<: <C>@3;3C> 3> B7467<;C?<853=5>;434<C><7B>7@;273>4AB5><7<C=65>: 254 ;C 65: ;27 <C=67>45;3C> 5=CA>; G3;2 8397B;: ;C B7<CE7B ;27 5=CA>; ?BC= ;27 CG>7B C? ;27 C??7>@3>D E723<87 @# > 4A66CB; C? ;27 <C>;7>;3C>4 ;27 875B>7@ <CA>478254B7837@C>;27FA@D=7>;C?C>098767ICAB; 3>;27<547C?!/0 '!'! ! " " 1 & B76CB;7@ 3> 5>@ $ & /2 / & B76CB;7@ 3> 347><7C>;2747DBCA>@4274CAD2; ?CB588CG3>D;27566758 ( > ;27 C;27B 25>@ B3 A@5B425> 875B>7@ <CA>478 56675B3>D ?CB ;27 >4AB5><7 C=65>: <C>;7>@ - 8 - ;25;7E7>;2CAD2;27<853=C?;27<853=5>;4;25;@7<7547@ G54 75B>3>D 4'***/ 67B =C>;2 ;27: 25E7 >C; 6BC@A<7@5>:@C<A=7>;;C74;598342;2745=727B7?CB7 ;27 B39A>58 254 B3D2;8: 5447447@ ;27 >C;3C>58 3><C=7 5; 4*'*/67B=C>;2 7<C>@8: ;27 875B>7@ <CA>478 ?CB ;27 >4AB5><7 C=65>: <C>;7>@7@ ;25; <C>43@7B3>D ;27 5D7 5>@ 5EC<5;3C>C?;27@7<7547@CE7B588<C=67>45;3C>5G5B@7@ 9:;27B39A>5834FA4;5>@B754C>5987 * 54;8: 27 254 <C>;7>@7@ ;25; 5@=3;;7@8: ;27 3>4AB7@254E3C85;7@;276C83<:<C>@3;3C>454;27@B3E7BC? ;27 C??7>@3>D E723<87 @BCE7 ;27 45=7 97:C>@ ;27 67B=3;;7@ 5B75 5>@ ;27B7?CB7 43><7 ;27 6C83<: <C>@3;3C>4 5B7 E3C85;7@ ;27 B39A>58 254 B3D2;8: 7IC>7B5;7@ ;27 3>4AB5><7 <C=65>: ?BC= 65:3>D ;27 <C=67>45;3C> 5=CA>;7><7274CAD2;?CB@34=34458C?;27566758 - 9 - 75B@ ;27 875B>7@ <CA>478 ?CB ;27 65B;374 67BA47@ ;27 FA@D=7>; 5>@ 5G5B@ 3><8A@3>D ;27 566758 6567B4 ;34>C;3>@346A;7;25;@7<7547@ 545>;@37@3> 5BC5@;B5??3<5<<3@7>;C<<ABB7@C>*'*!@A7;C;27 3>FAB374 4A4;53>7@ 3> ;27 5<<3@7>;<5A47@9:;27 @B3E7BC? ;27C??7>@3>DE723<873735DD3C3<H425G975B3>DC(/ /*!) E7> ;2CAD2 ;27 <853=5>;4 <853= ;25; @7<7547@ G54 75B>3>D 4'***/ 6= ;27: 25E7 >C; 6BC@A<7@ 5>: @C<A=7>; ;C 74;598342 ;27 45=7 27B7?CB7 ;27 >C;3C>58 3><C=7 ;C 97 5447447@ 54 67B ;27 DA3@783>74 344A7@ 9: ;27 5B>5;5H5 ;5;7 7D58 7BE3<74 A;2CB3;: -CB ;27 5<<3@7>; C<<ABB7@ 3> ;27 :75B *! ;27 >C;3C>58 3><C=7 C? @7<7547@ 254 ;C 97 <C>43@7B7@ 5; 4*'*/ 6= 27B7?CB7 ;27 B39A>58 254 B3D2;8: 5447447@ ;27 >C;3C>583><C=7C?@7<7547@5;4*'*/6= > E37G C? ;27 FA@D=7>; C? 67I CAB; 3> ;27 <547C?"4A6B5#'JC?;273><C=7C?;27 - 10 - @7<7547@254;C975@@7@;CG5B@4?A;AB76BC467<;4;5H3>D >C;7C?;275D7C?;27@7<7547@54':75B427B39A>58 ;5H3>D >C;7 C? >A=97B C? @767>@7>;4 C? @7<7547@ 254 B3D2;8: @7@A<;7@ ;2 C? ;27 3><C=7 C? ;27 @7<7547@ ;CG5B@423467B4C>587I67>47427566BC6B35;7=A8;36837B 56683<598734L0 > E37G C? ;27 85G 853@ @CG> 9: ;27 A6B7=7 CAB; 3> ;27 <547 C? 5 !" ! "##$! %$!#6 " # <853=5>; C 973>D ;27 G3?7 C? ;27 @7<7547@ 34 7>;3;87@ ?CB <C=67>45;3C> C? 4****/ A>@7B ;27 275@ C?18C44C?46CA458<C>4CB;3A=1<853=5>;C4;C973>D ;27<238@B7>C?@7<7547@5B77>;3;87@?CB<C=67>45;3C>C? 4****/ 75<2 A>@7B ;27 275@ C? L8C44 C? 65B7>;58 <C>4CB;3A=0 ' 2A4 C> B7/5447443>D ;27 <C=67>45;3C> ;27 <853=5>;45B77>;3;87@;C;27?C88CG3>D<C=67>45;3C> - 11 - ()*+,-./+0+1*2 1/*2*+.*-1, (0+./+ %,& C44C?@767>@7><: "*'*M'JII 8744;2# )(/ -A>7B587I67>474 '***/ C44C?74;5;7 '***/ C44C?46CA458 <C>4CB;3A= ****/ C44C?5B7>;58 <C>4CB;3A= ****/ .-3 45546 ) > B7467<; C? 8359383;: 34 <C><7B>7@ 5@=3;;7@8: ;27C??7>@3>DE723<87G546837@97:C>@;2767B=3;;7@5B75 4 4A<2 ;27 3>4AB7@ 254 E3C85;7@ ;27 6C83<: <C>@3;3C>4 27B7?CB7 ;27 B39A>58 254 7IC>7B5;7@ ;27 3>4AB5><7 <C=65>:?BC=65:=7>;C?<C=67>45;3C>5>@8359383;:254 977> ?3I7@ C> ;27 CG>7B C? ;27 C??7>@3>D E723<87 27 3=6AD>7@FA@D=7>;5>@5G5B@65447@9:;27B39A>58254 >C;977><25887>D7@9:;27CG>7BC?;27C??7>@3>DE723<87 - 12 - 5>@ C> ;27 C;27B 25>@ 27 254 5<<76;7@ ;27 45=7 27 566758 34 ?387@ 9: ;27 <853=5>;4 27 67I CAB; 3> ;27 <547 C? $ " # 278@ ;25; 3> B7467<; C? 65:=7>; C? <C=67>45;3C>34<C><7B>7@;273>4AB5><7<C=65>:254;C 65:<C=67>45;3C>5=CA>;;C;27<853=5>;4?3B4;B747BE3>D 8397B;:;CB7<CE7B?BC=;27CG>7BC?;27C??7>@3>DE723<87 ! >;27B74A8;G76544;27?C88CG3>D 5#275667583472 9# 27 FA@D=7>; C? ;27 853=4 B39A>58 34 =C@3?37@ <# 27 <853=5>;4 5B7 7>;3;87@ ;C 5 ;C;58 <C=67>45;3C> C? 4(*(/ 54 5D53>4; 4'**/5G5B@7@9:;27B39A>5858C>D G3;23>;7B74;5;;27B5;7C?)J67B5>>A= @# 27746C>@7>;C/ >4AB5><7C=65>:34 @3B7<;7@ ;C @76C43; <C=67>45;3C> 5=CA>; - 13 - 58C>D G3;2 3>;7B74; 5; ;27 B5;7 C? )J 67B 5>>A= ?BC= ;27 @5;7 C? ?383>D C? ;27 <853= 67;3;3C> ;388 ;27 @5;7 C? B7583N5;3C> G3;23> 5 67B3C@C?43IG77H4?BC=;27@5;7C?B7<736;C? 5<C6:C?;234FA@D=7>; 7# 397B;: 34B747BE7@ ;C ;27 3>4AB5><7<C=65>: ;CB7<CE7B;27<C=67>45;3C>5=CA>;?BC=;27 CG>7BC?;27C??7>@3>DE723<87 ?# 27 566CB;3C>=7>; @76C43; 5>@ B787547 C? <C=67>45;3C>5=CA>;42588975467B;27CB@7B C?;27B39A>58 16 %!& # 16 % #$ & # 34;C8C)