Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58740 (KAR)

THE ASST. EXECUTIVE ENGINEER v. THE SECRETARY AND ANR

WP/205534/2019 · 2025-06-26

M I Arun

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#$ %&# & '( ! " # $ %&&&" '#$$ () ( ' * $"+ ! , $ % $ $ , , $, '( Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! , $ - # &'&" &&&"* - $$ ! , # $ $ # $ # $# ./ , # ( #( 0#- # ( 0#- # ! 11234546 78 9:4 ;2642 <=>>46 3? <<@3A=93;? ;&'&" 6=946 &&&"* 78 9:4 3>923A9 -B614 =?6 24>363?1 CC3A42 =7;B2 ;B29 =@=7B2=13 5364 ??4DB24 9; 9:4 E239 <49393;? 24><;?64?9 ;" 9:4243? :=><24C422469:3>E239<49393;? 4><;?64?9 ;:4243?;?9:412;B?69:=9:3> >4253A4>:=>744?E2;?1CB@@8942F3?=9462=3>46=63><B94 =?6 4C424?A4 ;%)'&& E=> 2413>94246 74C;24 =7;B2 ;B29B@7=21=E:3A:<=>>469:4C;@@;E3?1( - 3 - !!" #$$% ! $ ## & &!!'!(# # ! & # # % # # # #$ %) # & * + %## * % "% #)# #&*$# # , # #$ $ #*# # -* #$ %) ! , # # # % ! "% $$ # "% #)# #&*$# #! + & "% ./" !!" #&*$# #!0 11234546 78 9:4 >=F4 9:4 <49393;?42 :4243? <24C42246,23949393;? ;&'&&*E:3A:A=F49;74 63>F3>>46=?69:4;2642<=>>463?4C424?A4 ;%)'&& =99=3?46C3?=@398 ) ? ><394 ;C 9:4 ;2642 <=>>46 3? 4C424?A4 ;%)'&&=99=3?3?1C3?=@3989:4<49393;?42:4243?636?;9 - 4 - :;?;2 9:4 >=36 =E=26 4?A4 9:4 <49393;?42 9:4243? 24><;?64?9 ; :4243?! <24C42246 <<@3A=93;? ;&'&" B?642 4A93;? ! ;C 9:4 ?6B>923=@ 3><B94> A9 "*) 9;24A;542 9:4=F;B?9>6B4 C2;F9:4 4F<@;842 :4 >=F4 :=> 744? =@@;E46 78 E=8 ;C 9:4 3F<B1?46;264211234546789:4>=F49:4<24>4?9E239 <49393;?3>C3@46 4=2?46A;B?>4@C;29:4<49393;?4263><B94>9:4 24@=93;?>:3< ;C 4F<@;842 =?6 4F<@;844 749E44? 9:4 <49393;?42 =?6 24><;?64?9 ; =?6 A;?94?6> 9:=9 <49393;?423>?;9@3=7@49;<=8=?8=F;B?9>9;24><;?64?9 ;;E4542:4=6F39>9:=99:4<49393;?42:=>>BCC4246 =? ;2642 =9 9:4 :=?6> ;C =7;B2 ;B29 3? 4C424?A4 ;%)'&& E:3A: :=> =99=3?46 C3?=@398 E:4243? 9:4 24@=93;?>:3< 749E44? 9:4 <=2934> :=> 744? =?>E4246 =?6 9:4 ;2642 => =C;24F4?93;?46 :=> 744? <=>>46 6324A93?1 9:4<49393;?42:4243?9;243?>9=949:4E;2GF=?;?=6=3@8 E=147=>3>=>46;?9:4>=36;26429:43F<B1?46;2642 :=>744?<=>>46 - 5 - % :4 <49393;?42 3> B?=7@4 9; >9=94 :;E 9:4 3F<B1?46 ;2642 6;4> ?;9 A;?C32F 9; 9:4 ;2642 <=>>46 3? 4C424?A4 ;%)'&&>9:43F<B1?46;26423><=>>46 ;?@8 9; <=8 =F;B?9> 9; 24><;?64?9 ; => =AA2B46 3? =AA;26=?A4 E39: 9:4 ;2642 <=>>46 3? 4C424?A4 ;%)'&&6;?;9>44=?8422;23?9:4;2642 $;2 9:4 =C;24F4?93;?46 24=>;?> 9:4 E239 <49393;?3>:42478 )* '&( # 3>9 ;("@ ;(