Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58738 (KAR)
SHRI NAGAREDDY UMESH REDDY v. THE COMMISSIONER (APPEAL)
WP/202522/2025 · 2025-09-16
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58738 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58738 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%#&&"##
'(
!"
##
#
$
"%
## #
#
$
"%
&
'
## #
#
$
"%
Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(
# ## #
#
$
$
( ) #*'
"
+ #
, # #
!
#
+
#
-.
/
0102324567894:;<70=5:>:=1=179:05242>>:20:?19 >:0479
01 10145 8;@291 67894:; <70 =5: 0:4>79?:9=4 524 2>>:20:?=5078A5B1?:7679<:0:9619A
5:62>=179:?+01=:=1=17914<1;:?4::319A<7;;7C19A 0:;1:<4/ 2 *8245 457C 284: 7=16: 19
;7
?2=:?/&( B1?: 99:D80: 1448:? EF 0:4>79?:9= 7&
- 3 -
E *8245 0?:0 19 ;7
$
"!
?2=:?/,& >244:? EF 0:4>79?:9= 7 B1?:99:D80:
6 :@1=E263=5:2>>:2;<1;:?B1?:99:D80:=7 =5: <1;: 7< 0:4>79?:9= 7 <70 <0:45 67941?:02=179 79 @:01=4 19 ;1A5= 7< ?:6141794 >244:?191?:9=162;@2==:04 ? *8245 1@>8A9:? 0?:09>>:2; E:2019A 7
$
(( ?2=:?/& >244:? EF 0:4>79?:9= 7 B1?:99:D80:
: *8245 A209145:: 70?:0 1448:? EF 0:4>79?:9= 7(197&?2=:?/&&B1?: 99:D80:# & 7894:; <70 =5: 0:4>:6=1B: >20=1:4 80A:? 4:B:02; 679=:9=1794:20?=5:20A8@:9=429?>:084:?=5:+01=>2>:04 C1=5620: ( 7894:; <70 =5: 0:4>:6=1B: >20=1:4 G719=;F 48E@1= =52==5:1448:19B7;B:?19=5:>0:4:9=+01=:=1=179144H820:;F 67B:0:?EF=5:?:6141797<=5:01961>2;:9652=:9A2;80819 +7(& 2;79A C1=5 6799:6=:? @2==:04 ?14>74:? 7< 79 =5: &0? ?2F 7< '8;F ( 7894:; =5:0:<70:
- 4 -
48E@1=4=52==5:62>=179:?+01=:=1=179@2FE:?14>74:?7<19 =:0@4 7< =5: 70?:0 ?2=:? &( >244:? 19 +7(&2;79AC1=56799:6=:?@2==:04 5: 702; 48E@144179 @2?: EF 67894:; <70 =5: 0:4>:6=1B: >20=1:414>;26:?790:670? 5:62>=179:?+01=:=1=17914?14>74:?7<19=:0@47<=5: 70?:0 ?2=:? &( >244:? 19 +7(& 2;79AC1=56799:6=:?@2==:04
5: +01= 7< :0=170201 14 70?:0:? 5: 457C 6284: 97=16:?2=:?/&(1448:?EF=5:=510?0:4>79?:9=19 ;7 B1?: 99:D80: =5: 0?:01901A192;
?2=:?/,& >244:? EF 0:4>79?:9= 7 19 ;7
$
"!
B1?: 99:D80:=5:0?:09>>:2;?2=:?/&>244:?EF 0:4>79?:9= 7 E:2019A 7
$
( ( B1?: 99:D80:
29? =5: A209145:: 70?:0 ?2=:?/&&1448:?EF0:4>79?:9=7(197& B1?:99:D80:#20:H8245:?
- 5 -
, :48;=29=;F =5: +01= :=1=179 14 5: @2==:0140:;:A2=:?=7=5:7<<16:04=7E:?:41A92=:?19=:0@47< =5: 7E4:0B2=179 @2?: 19 >202A02>5 7 7< =5: 70?:0 ?2=:? &( 19 =5: 624: 7<
19 +7(& 29? 7=5:0 6799:6=:? @2==:04=5:>:=1=179:014>:0@1==:?=7<1;:5140:>;F=7=5:457C 6284:97=16:C5165452;;E:67941?:0:?EF=5:421?7<<16:0419 26670?296: C1=5 =5: ;2C C1=519 2 >:017? 7< , ?2F4 <07@ =5: 0:6:1>=7<6:0=1<1:?67>F7<=51470?:0
)* '&"##( &
" 14=7/;7/,&