Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58735 (KAR)
ERAYYA v. THE STTE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203097/2025 · 2025-10-13
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58735 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58735 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! ""#"$! ! %! &'#&#&
( !#) ! ! ! "
#
"
$%
$
""
%
&
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
#
%
%
"
%
"
"
$
"
! %
$
"
%
&
! - 3 -
#
%
'
&
"
! %
#
$
$ "
$%
&
$#
$
- 4 -
#
$
!%
! $! ! #
!! $
! &
! "
!$
$! (
")$
*
+ ,
- 5 -
"
'
'
)%
'
)%
! "
")$%
' ''
(
")$
*
+
"'
!-
' ,
'
$ & '
' ,
'
(
" %)$
$%#%
.),
'
'
'
'. ' ,
' ' /
'' '
'
- 6 -
0"
" + 0",
123 45626278 23 92:5; <= 615 456262785>3 ) :2?583553 :533553 79 @A>27B3 ?7CC5>?2A: 4>5C2353 <5:78D28D 67 >53478;586 7 E17 A>5 28;B?65; 615>528 28 65>C3 79 876292?A62783 A8; ?7835FB586 AD>55C5863 5865>5; 2867 <56E558 615 456262785>3 A8; 615 >53478;586 7 ) AB617>26=6A445A>361A661565>C37961735AD>55C5863 1A@28D5G42>5;>53478;5867 )B82?24A:26=1A328@265; A44:2?A627839>7C2865>5365;D585>A:4B<:2?674A>62?24A6528 615 4B<:2? AB?6278 97> A::76C586 79 ?7CC5>?2A: 4>5C2353 ;56A2:3 79 E12?1 A>5 D2@58 28 615 3A2; 4B<:2?A6278 A6 885GB>5) % 5A>85;?7B835:97>615456262785>33B<C26361A6 6154>7?533794B<:2?AB?627823?786>A>=676154>7@232783 795?6278&79615A>8A6AHAB82?24A:26253?6#$ 5 9B>615>3B<C26361A6615>53478;586)B82?24A:B617>26= ?A8 4>7?55; 67 AB?6278 615 4>745>6253 78:= 78 7<6A2828D
- 7 -
4>5@27B3 3A8?6278 9>7C 615 7@5>8C586 A8; 61A6 28 615 2836A86 ?A35 87 3B?1 3A8?6278 7<6A285; 15>597>5 615 E17:5 4>7?533 79 AB?627828D 23 2::5DA: 5 9B>615> 3B<C263 61A6 615 >53478;586 7 E17 1A3 28@265; <2;3 9>7C 615 2865>5365;45>378397>A::61597B>?A65D7>25379?7CC5>?2A: 317431A3876356A8=:2C2697>A45>37867A44:=E12?1E2:: ?>5A65A87CA:=A8;?789B3278:5A;28D6712D1<2;;28DA8; B8?5>6A286=58?5355H397>A::7E28D61545626278 %!
615 :5A>85; ?7B835: A445A>28D 97> >53478;586 7 3B<C263 61A6 615 456262785>3 1A@5 <558 7??B4=28D286154>5C235397>7@5>6E7;5?A;53A8;6152> 65>C 1A@28D 5G42>5; 615= 1A@5 <558 4A=28D C5AD5> AC7B86 79 >5863 5 9B>615> 3B<C263 61A6 615 456262785>30 D>25@A8?52361A6615=E7B:;<57B365;9>7C6154>5C2353 A8; ;234:A?5; E12?1 23 B897B8;5; 5 3B<C263 61A6 615 876292?A6278 A4A>6 9>7C 4>7@2;28D 7447>6B826= 67 615 456262785>3674A>62?24A65286157458<2;;28DA:374>7@2;53 >2D16 79 92>36 >59B3A: 15>597>5 15 3B<C263 61A6 615
- 8 -
456262785>3 1A@5 746278 67 52615> 67 4A>62?24A65 28 615 AB?6278 7> 67 5G5>?235 615 >2D16 79 92>36 >59B3A: 3 3B?1 6152>2865>53623E2::<56AH58?A>57953B<C26361A65@58 6154>74735;>A6579;547326A8;615>586A:317E828615 876292?A6278 23 >5A378A<:5 A8; 876 5G7><26A86 3 >5DA>;3 615>5FB2>5C586 79 3A8?6278A3 ?78658;5;<=615 :5A>85;
?7B835: 97> 615 456262785>3 28 65>C3 79 5?6278 & 79 615 ?6 15 3B<C263 87 3B?1 3A8?6278 23 >5FB2>5; 328?5 615 4>74735;AB?62782378>586A: :5A35<A323A8;876789>55 D>A86A3?7865C4:A65;B8;5>5?6278&%+,79615?63 >5DA>; 67 615 612>; ?786586278 79 615 :5A>85; ?7B835: 97> 456262785>3 E261 >5DA>; 67 615 A87CA:= 61A6 ?7B:; <5 ?>5A65;286155@58679A44:2?A62783<528DCA;5<=45>3783 28A::61597B>?A65D7>253153B<C263873B?1A87CA:=E2:: <5?>5A65;28A3CB?1A3345?292?A6278796154>745>6253E261 8BC<5>3C5A3B>5C586A8;615:7?A627823D2@5828;56A2: 58?5355H397>;23C233A:7945626278 % 5A>;5>B35;615>5?7>;3
- 9 -
% 15>5 23 87 ;234B65 79 615 9A?6 61A6 615 456262785>31A@5<5587??B4=28D615?7CC5>?2A:4>5C2353 <5:78D28D67>53478;5867 97>7@5>6E7;5?A;531A@28D <558 28;B?65; A3 658A863 28 65>C3 79 615 AD>55C5863 15=?:A2C671A@5<5584A=28D>5863>5DB:A>:=28?5615 876292?A6278 A6 885GB>5) 23 233B5; <= 615 >53478;586 7 ?A::28D97>61528658;5;C5C<5>379D585>A:4B<:2?67 4A>62?24A65 28 615 AB?6278 79 615 3A2; 4>5C2353 78 :5A35 :2?5835 <A323 A3 >2D16:= 472865; 7B6 <= :5A>85;
?7B835: 97> >53478;586 7 615 456262785>3 A:37 1A@5 >2D16674A>62?24A65286153A2;<2;;28D4>7?5331A6A4A>6 28 65>C3 79 ?78;26278 7! 79 615 3A2; 876292?A6278 456262785>3E17A>5A:>5A;=7??B4=28D6154>5C23531A@5 746278675G5>?2356152>>2D167992>36>59B3A:<=7995>28D615 3AC5 28 E>2628D B?1 5G5>?235 79 >2D16 79 92>36 >59B3A:
E7B:; <5 ?7832;5>5; 29 615 456262785>3 7995> I 7@5>A8;
A<7@5 615 928A: <2; AC7B86 28?5 615 456262785>3 1A@5 746278 79 4A>62?24A628D 28 615 4B<:2? AB?6278 A3 E5:: A3 67 5G5>?235 615 >2D16 79 >59B3A: A3 4>7@2;5; 28 ?78;26278 7! 615 A44>51583278 79 615 456262785>3 876 1A@28D 7447>6B826=674A>62?24A6523C234:A?5;
- 10 -
%$ 3 >5DA>;3 615 ?786586278 79 615 :5A>85; ?7B835:97>615456262785>3E261>595>58?5675?6278&79 615?6>5FB2>28D4>5@27B33A8?6278796157@5>8C58623 ?78?5>85;262385?533A>=6787653B?14>5@27B33A8?6278 79 615 7@5>8C586 23 ?7865C4:A65; 78:= B8;5> B<) 5?6278795?6278&79615?6E12?1>5A;3A3B8;5>
!
"
# $
%& 28?5 615 AB?6278 4>74735; 23 <A35; 78 :5A35 :2?5835 78 4A=C586 79 ?7832;5>A6278 79 >586 :2?5835 955A8;;547326873B?14>5@27B33A8?627823>5FB2>5;15 3A2;?78658627823615>597>5C234:A?5;
- 11 -
% 15 612>; ?786586278 79 :5A>85; ?7B835: 97> 615 456262785>3 >5DA>;28D 615 A87CA:= 61A6 CA= ?AB35 28 615 :2D16 79 >53478;586 7 876 >536>2?628D 615 8BC<5> 79 A44:2?A863 6123 7B>6 ;7 876 928; A8= 97>?5 28 615 3A2; 3B<C23327828A3CB?1A3873B?1>536>2?6278?A8<54:A?5; 97>A8=45>3789>7C<2;;28D6154>5C2353
%# 861A6@25E79615CA665>45626278:A?H3C5>263 >535>@28D:2<5>6=67615456262785>3675G5>?2356152>>2D1679 92>36 >59B3A: 7> 4A>62?24A65 28 615 AB?6278 615 45626278 23
#*+ (&#& ) '"
"" 2367:7