- 1 - ! ""#"$ %!#&#'##" #!#''! ()* ##& ()* ! " " # " $ " % & $ '& $ ( & ) *$%(+$%(+* $ )" ' * ! , # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $%*!# " " ) ($+ ) ($ " $ )" - & $ '& " ! # " $ & ) & *$%(+$%(+* $ )!" #' - ! " " $ +* )# $ ( " ) " ($+ - 3 - ) *$ " ) . . / " !&" 012345012678094:;2<8=<45:>30: <*$ >: ;>?03 =@ 450 9:7219A0 A<8B19@161>9:4450"73680941931C12331403 B1::03>9 <($+=@45033>4><91?09><2>D>? "7360193 1?1=7216>!;<2:5<24E45042>=791?F#<9450 62<793 <; G719478 <; A<8B09:14><9 1C12303 =@ 450 42>=791?C50201: 2<= <-$>:;>?03=@450 A?1>8194:00H>9609519A08094<;450A<8B09:14><9 * 50 A?1>8194 C1: 3<>96 162>A7?4721? C<2H 193 A<<?>0 C<2H 193 C1: 1603 @012: 1: <9 450 3140 <; 450 1AA>3094 0 ;>?03 A?1>8 B04>4><9 A?1>8>96 A<8B09:14><9 <; :($ 50 42>=791? 1;402 A<9:>302>96 450 094>20 0D>309A0 <9 20A<23 1C12303 1 :78 <; :($ 1?<96 C>45>94020:4144502140<;+IB0219978;2<84503140<; - 4 - B04>4><9 4>?? 201?>J14><9 662>0D03 =@ 450 :1>3 <2302 50 B20;02203450B20:0941BB01? ( 012903A<79:0?;<29:7219A0A<8B19@:7=8>4: 4514 450 A?1>8194 C1: >9B14>094 ;2<8 -*+ 4< **+ 0 :7=8>4: 4514 450 A<8B09:14><9 18<794 1C12303 =@ 450 42>=791? >: 0K<2=>4194 193 450 3>:1=>?>4@ 1::0::03 =@ 450 9<942014>96 <A4<2 0 3>:B7403 K 193K193:4140345144503>:1=>?>4@>:4<=041H0914 $*23 <; 450 (I C5>A5 A<80: 4< I >9:4013 <; *I 5020;<20 50 20G70:4: ;<2 2037A4><9 <; 450 A<8B09:14><9 18<7941C12303=@45042>=791? 50A?1>8194;>?03 2<= <-$;<2 09519A080940A<94093034514450>9A<80<;450A?1>8194 C1: 41H09 14 :%$ B02 8<945 0 :7:41>903 87?4>B?0 ;21A4720: >0 8193>=?0 ?0;4 5@78027: 193 ?0;4 A?1D>A?0 ;21A4720 <; ?0;4 ;2<941? =<90 ?0;4 <2=>4 ?0;4 :B509<>3 ?0;4 19402><2A219>1?;<::1193?0;481K>??12@=<3@193>9?0;4 ;2<941? A<9D0K>4@ 193 >9 ?0;4 ;2<941? 408B<21? 206><91? 1935>:;1A0C1:1?:<3>:;>672037445042>=791?51:02203>9 - 5 - 41H>964503>:1=>?>4@14*I5018<794621940379302450 5013B1>9193:7;;02>96193803>A1?0KB09:0:>:8016020 C1: >9B14>094 ;<2 31@: 193 50 C1: 13D>:03 4< 41H0 =03 20:4;<2452008<945: <A<8B09:14><9C1:621940379302 450 5013 <; ?<:: <; 0129>96: 193 C1: 20G70:403 ;<2 09519A08094<;450A<8B09:14><9 + 0123 450 12678094: ;2<8 =<45 :>30: 193 1?:< B027:034500D>309A0<;)193)*1934503>:1=>?>4@ A024>;>A140:>::703=@4508 % )* >::703 K 0 0K18>903 450 20?0D194 20A<23:1931?:<;>91??@<B>9034514450B14>09451362>0D<7: 4217814>A =21>9 >9L72@ ;1A>1? >9L72@ 193 0@0 >9L72@ 50 79302C094 0802609A@ 30A<8B20::>D0 A219><4<8@ 193 A<9:>302>96 450 :1>3 >9L72>0: 50 1::0::03 450 3>:1=>?>4@ 14 *I19350;724502<=:02D03451445020>:?<::<;D>:><9>9 0@0C5>A5>:3704<<B4>A142<B5@1AA<794:;<23>:1=>?>4@<; I4<<B4>A902D0C5>A5>:>220D02:>=?0193;724502:41403 4514 50 :7:41>903 ;21A4720 <; 81K>??1 193 8193>=?0 1: 1 20:7?445020 >: 30;<28>4@<; ;1A0 >91=>?>4@ 4< 81:4>A1405123 - 6 - ;<<3 ;2<8 :>30 791=?0 4< =>40 ;<<3 370 4< ?<:: <; ;2<94 ?<C02 40045, 9<91?>698094 <; 7BB02 193 ?<C02 L1C A17:>96 L<>94B1>904A>:>8B1>2>964509<281?;79A4><9<;8>33?0 193 ?<C02 A<8B<9094 <; ;1A0 1AA<794: 193 1::0::03 450 3>:1=>?>4@ ;<2 450 1;<20:1>3 >9L72>0: 14 I )* ;724502 <=:02D034514450A?1>8194A199<4?>;4C0>6541:=0;<20450 1AA>3094 C>45 7BB02 128 370 4< ;21A4720 <; 578027: 1AA<794:;<23>:1=>?>4@<;I4<1283704<A<947:><9<; =21>9 >9 1AA>3094 >: >8B1>2>96 450 2<74>90 B5@:>A1? ;79A4><9: 1AA<794:;<23>:1=>?>4@<;*I1931::0::034503>:1=>?>4@14 I193457:4<41?3>:1=>?>4@14+I4<450C5<?0=<3@193 A?012?@:414034514450?<::<;D>:><9>90@0>:>220D02:>=?0 ) 1::0::03 450 3>:1=>?>4@ 79302 K( 193 50:41403451481?79>403;21A4720<;:51;4?0;4578027:C>45 >8B?194 193 81?79>403 ;21A4720 ?0;4 A?1D>A?0 193 51: B02819094B5@:>A1?>8B1>28094>920?14><94<7BB02?>8=450 457:4503>:1=>?>4@>:(I0C1:5<:B>41?>J03;<21B02><3<; 31@: 012903 A<79:0? ;<2 450 A?1>8194 20?>03 7B<9 1 30A>:><9<;45>:<724B1::03>9 <-$%31403 >9C5>A54503>:1=>?>4@<;450A?1>8194C1:41H09 - 7 - 14(I<9450<945062<79345144503>:1=>?>4@41H09=@450 42>=791? >: <9 450 ?<C02 :>30 5020;<20 A<9:>302>96 450 0D>309A0<;450<A4<2:1934503>:1=>?>4@1::0::03=@4508 45>: <724;>93: >4201:<91=?0 4< 41H0 450 3>:1=>?>4@ 14 (I >9:4013 <; *I 50 B04>4><902 C1: 1603 @012: 193 50 C1: 3<>96 162>A7?4720 193 A<<?>0 C<2H 193 0129>96 :$B028<94574450A?1>8194;1>?034<B2<D05>: >9A<80 =@ ;>?>96 19@ 3<A78094: 5020;<20 1: B02 450 67>30?>90: <; 450 129141H1 4140 061? 02D>A0: 745<2>4@ 1:50804C>454501AA>3094<9*+5>:>9A<80>:4< =041H0914:%$B028<945>9:4013<;:%$ - : B02 450 A>414><9 20B<2403 >9 =04C009>9A1:0<; :0?; 08B?<@03 B02:<9 C5< >: 1603 =0?<C ( @012: (I >9A<804<=041H094<C123:?<::<;;74720>9A<80 :%$M(IN:$ :$(IN:-%$ 5020 >: 9< 3>:B740 206123>96 450 803>A1? 0KB09:0: 6219403 =@ 450 42>=791? 50 42>=791? 1?2013@ - 8 - A<9:>302034503>:A51260A123803>A1?=>??:193B20:A2>B4><9: 79302 K% 193 K- 193 1AA<23>96?@ 19 18<794 <; :%$ C1: 6219403 79302 450 5013 <; 803>A1? 0KB09:0:193>49003:9<>9402;0209A050A<8B09:14><9<; :*$6219403793024505013<;B1>9193:7;;02>96>: 4< =0 09519A03 4< :%$ 193 :$ >: 4< =0 6219403793024505013<;?<::<;1809>4>0::*$>: 4< =0 6219403 79302 450 5013 <; 4219:B<2414><9 0K421 9<72>:58094 193 144093194 A51260: 193 ;74720 803>A1? 0KB09:0: 1?2013@ 6219403 >0 :*$ 9003: 9< >9402;0209A0504<41?A<8B09:14><9C<7?3=01:79302. #+ ,-./012,3/-453 12,3/-453 67-34,.894:5/ ;74 <::<;;74720>9A<80 :-%$ 03>A1?0KB09:0: :%$ * 1>9193:7;;02>96: :%$ ( 219:B<2414><9 0K421 9<72>:58094 193 144093194 A51260: :*$ <::<;1809>4>0: :$ + 74720803>A1?0KB09:0: :*$ 4-+ / 012903 A<79:0? ;<2 450 9:7219A0 A<8B19@ :7=8>4: 4514 I <; 450 A<8B09:14><9 >: 30B<:>40314 450 4>80<;;>?>96<;4501BB01? - 9 - 09A0450;<??<C>96<2302. " !># <*$ ;>?03 =@ 450 9:7219A0A<8B19@>:3>:8>::03, !>># 2<= <-$;>?03=@450 A?1>8194>:1??<C03>9B124, !>>># 50 A?1>8194 >: 094>4?03 4< 4<41? A<8B09:14><9 <; :+$ 1?<96 C>45 +I >94020:4<945009519A03A<8B09:14><9, !>D# 50 9:7219A0 A<8B19@ >: 3>20A403 4< 30B<:>4450=1?19A018<7941?<96C>45>94020:414 4502140<;+IB0219978C>45>9<908<945;2<8 4503140<;45>:<2302, !D# 50 :41474<2@ 30B<:>4 8130 =@ 450 9:7219A0 A<8B19@ =0;<20 45>: <724 :51?? =0 4219:8>44034<45042>=791?;<245C>45, - 10 - !D># 930B<:>4<;450A<8B09:14><918<794 =@ 450 9:7219A0 A<8B19@ 450 A?1>8194 >: 14 ?>=024@ 4< C>45321C 450 094>20 18<794 1?<96 C>45 1AA2703>94020:4 #. ('##"* &" >:4 <.? <.( ."