Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58725 (KAR)
SHOBA v. MALLAMMA
CRL.RP/200012/2023 · 2025-07-15
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58725 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58725 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#!$
#$
%
&%'()*
+%(( ,
!"#! $
% &
'! !"#
$ %&
(
)*+ '#( & & )+"""
)"""# ( (
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(##""# ( #'++"# (
((
,
%,
&
# -./0 /1.2.31 3-./4-0 56748-3 96/ :;- <-:1:164-/
" 64-.<<-./896/:;-/-8<640-4: ) ;- /-=18164 <-:1:164-/ 18 :;- .5578-0 >;6 8799-/-0 .4 6/0-/ 69 564=15:164 14 6#'++"# >;15; >.856491/?-014/1?14.3 <<-.36)"""#96/:;-699-45- <7418;.@3-740-/-5:164#) 69-26:1.@3-48:/7?-4:8 5:
%96/8;6/:A 5:B&.406/0-/-0:6<.C914-698+ 67: 69 >;15; 8+ 18 6/0-/-0 :6 @- <.10 .8 56?<-48.:164.408:6>./080-9/.C142-D<-48-869 :;-:.:-
- 3 -
' ;-9.5:8>;15;./-7:?68:4-5-88./C96/018<68.3 69:;-</-8-4:/-=18164<-:1:164./-.8740-/
'# </1=.:- 56?<3.14: 5.?- :6 @- 913-0 740-/ -5:164 " 69 / .33-2142 :;- 56??188164 69 699-45- <7418;.@3- 740-/ -5:164 #) 69 5: @C :;- /-8<640-4: @C564:-40142:;.:14/-8<-5:69:;-;.4036.4/-5-1=-0@C :;-.5578-014.87?698:;-.5578-01887-0. 5;-E7- @-./142 6) * 64 #*"#' 0/.>4 64 .4F1G.C.<7/.;-8.105;-E7-64</-8-4:.:1645.?-:6 @- 018;6467/-0 >1:; .4 -406/8-?-4: A.55674: 5368-0B ;-/-.9:-/3-2.346:15->.85.78-0:6:;-/-=18164<-:1:164-/ @C :;- /-8<640-4: >;15; >.8 8-4: @C /-218:-/-0 <68: .5F46>3-02-07-64#"*"#';-8.?-18073C8-/=-064 :;- .5578-0 64 #)*"#' @7: :;-/- >.8 46 /-<3C 46/ 56?<31.45- 69 :;- 5.331428 69 :;- 3-2.3 46:15- .40 :;78 8672;:96/.5:164
-./4-0 :/1.3 .218:/.:- .9:-/ 56?<3-:142 4-5-88./C96/?.31:1-887??64-0:;-.5578-0.40/-56/0-0
- 4 -
:;-<3-. 5578-0<3-.0-046:2713:C.40:;-/-96/-:/1.3>.8 ;-30 ! 4 6/0-/ :6 </6=- :;- 5.8- 69 :;- 56?<3.14.4: 8;-26:-D.?14-0;-/8-39.8 #.40<3.5-064/-56/091=- 0657?-4:84.?-3C018;6467/-05;-E7-@.4F-406/8-?-4: 56<C 69 :;- 3-2.3 46:15- <68:.3 /-5-1<: .40 .5F46>3-02-?-4: + 5578-0 8:.:-?-4: .8 18 564:-?<3.:-0 740-/ -5:164 )#) / >.8 /-56/0-0 .40 :;-/-.9:-/ .5578-0 8:-<<-0 14:6 >1:4-88 @6D .40 26: -D.?14-0 ;-/8-39 .40 <3.5-0 64 /-56/0 81D 0657?-4:8 >;15; >-/- -D;1@1:-0 .40 ?./F-0.8D#:6D!56?</18142695-/:191-056<C69 :;- 5;./2-8;--: 14 6'))"# 5-/:191-0 56<C 69 :;- ( 6!"#' 5-/:191-0 56<C 69 :;- 56?<3.14: 14 /1?- 6!"#' 5-/:191-0 56<C 69 :;- :.:-?-4: 69 1/1G. 148.10 5/1?- 47?@-/ 5-/:191-0 56<C 69 :;- 8<6: ?.;.H./ .40 5-/:191-056<C69:;-/672;8F-:5;
;-/-.9:-/ 3-./4-0 :/1.3 .218:/.:- ;-./0 :;- ./27?-4:8 9/6? @6:; 810-8 .40 .9:-/ 564810-/142 :;-
- 5 -
?.:-/1.3-=10-45-<3.5-064/-56/0@C@6:;:;-<./:1-814. 57?73.:1=-?.44-/564=15:-0:;-.5578-0.408-4:-45-0.8 /-9-//-087</.
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
- 6 -
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
- 7 -
#! ;-/-96/- :;- 564:-4:164 7/2-0 64 @-;.3969 :;- /-=18164 <-:1:164-/ 14 /-8<-5: 69 :;- 64- .40 :;- 8.?- :/.48.5:164 :;- 56?<3.14.4: ;.8 913-0 :>6 0199-/-4: 56?<3.14:85.446:@-5674:-4.45-0143.> #+
;-4:;-0-9-45--=10-45-18<3.5-064/-56/018 46: 8799151-4: :6 /-@7: :;- </-87?<:164 :;- 3-./4-0 :/1.3 702- 564=15:142 :;- .5578-0 96/ :;- 699-45- 740-/ -5:164 #) 69 5: .40 :;- 3-./4-0 702- 14 :;- 91/8: .<<-33.:- 67/:.991/?142:;-564=15:16418G78:.40</6<-/ # .=142 8.10 :;78 . 87? 69 8 1?<68-0 :6>./08 :;- 0-9/.C142 -D<-48-8 69 :;- :.:- 5.446: @- 5674:-4.45-0143.>.8:;-31818</1=C:6:;-<./:1-8.4046 :.:-?.5;14-/C1814=63=-0 556/01423C:;-8.?-4--08:6 @-8-:.810- #* -45-:;-96336>1426/0-/
%1& -=18164-:1:16418.336>-014<./:I
- 8 -
%11&
;13-?.14:.14142:;-564=15:16469:;- .5578-0 96/ :;- 699-45- 740-/ -5:164 #) 69 -26:1.@3- 48:/7?-4:8 5: :;- 914- .?674: 18 /-075-0:68+:68+
%111& ;- -4:1/- 87? 69 8+ 18 6/0-/-0 :6 @- <.10 .8 56?<-48.:164 :6 :;- 56?<3.14.4:I
%1=& 4 :;- -=-4: 69 9.137/- :6 <.C :;- 56?<-48.:164 :;- .5578-0 8;.33 740-/26 1?</1864?-4:.86/0-/-0@C:;-:/1.3.218:/.:-I
%=& 1?- 18 -D:-40-0 :6 <.C :;- 914- .?674::133" ""I
%=1& 7?6981?<68-0@C:;-:/1.3 .218:/.:- 56491/?-0 @C :;- 91/8: .<<-33.:- 67/: :6>./080-9/.C142-D<-48-869:;-:.:-18;-/-@C 8-:.810-I
%=11& 9915- 18 01/-5:-0 :6 /-:7/4 :;- :/1.3 67/:/-56/08>1:;56<C69:;186/0-/96/:;>1:;96/ 1887-69?60191-0564=15:164>.//.4:
-) %$( ! 18:6#36+)