- 1 - !"#"$ %# && '' (&) * !"#$ % &' ( # ) *#$+ , $ -.#.. #...+!...$$ #/""$ -.... /.+!$ Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ ' /.+!$ *#$+ , $ -.#.. & "0 )/ ( " *$- + -.#. & ..#- ".. /..../#..+.# ..+..$ /.+!$ ( % & "1 #$ ##..$( / / #+$&#(/ / / ' .-.#.$ ' '/ -.. / ' 2' - 3 - # & 2'( 3456378897:;<:;<=9>?4@4@>9@<A;=3B4C<9C=4?:97@C9> B45C<9:?4@87@=;9<;=;<=7D9C58?4@?;C7:>;<84<7: 37::9C6;C6E5>6F9C=7C>7A7@>>7=9>.-.#.$ 87<<9> GH 9C;4@ ;I;: '5>69 7C> '/ 7C> 4=4@ BB;>9C= :7;F< @;G5C7: ;C67<565@ &?4@ <34@= J@;G5C7:,( ;C C4-..=3;<78897:;<?;:9> $ @; 7<7I7@7E 7=3 :97@C9> B45C<9: <5GF;==9> 78897: A7< GH B:7;F7C= ?4@ 9C37CB9F9C= 4? B4F89C<7=;4C = A7< <5GF;==9> 4C #!.!.# A39C B:7;F7C= A7< @;>;C6 8;::;4C 4C 9C67:5@54<5@ 47> A3;:9 B@4<<;C6 59<=:;C9 ;@B:9>@;I9@4?7@G97@;C6C4.+!$ >@4I9;=;C@7<3 7C> C96:;69C= F7CC9@ 7C> >7<39> 767;C<= F4=4@BHB:9 B75<;C6 7BB;>9C=C7BB;>9C=B:7;F7C=<5<=7;C9><9I9@9;CE5@;9<=4:9?= :967C>4=39@87@=<4?G4>H 9<8;=9=7D;C6=@97=F9C=39>;> C4= @9B4I9@ ?5::H 7C> <5<=7;C9> 89@F7C9C= 83H<;B7: >;<7G;:;=H 7C>:4<<4?97@C;C6B787B;=H39@9?4@9B:7;F89=;=;4CA7<?;:9> 5C>9@9B=;4C#--4?4=4@93;B:9<B= - 4 - " 9<8;=9<9@I;B94?C4=;B9@9<84C>9C=<C4#=4$>;> C4=78897@39HA9@98:7B9>C<5@9@?;:9>4GE9B=;4C< 4884<;C6B:7;F89=;=;4C7::96;C6=37= >@;I9@4?;C<5@9>I93;B:9 A7< C4= 34:>;C6 :;B9CB9 7C> =39@9 A7< I;4:7=;4C 4? =9@F< 7C> B4C>;=;4C< 4? 84:;BH I9C B:7;F 89=;=;4C A7< 7:<4 4884<9> 4C 6@45C>4?G9;C69KB9<<;I97C>7::96;C6B4C=@;G5=4@HC96:;69CB9 4C87@=4?@;>9@4?F4=4@BHB:9 7<9> 4C 8:97>;C6< =@;G5C7: ?@7F9> ;<<59< 7C> @9B4@>9> 9I;>9CB9 :7;F7C= 9K7F;C9> 3;F<9:? 7C> @7::7C7645>7 7< <# 7C> 7C> K< # =4 "# A9@9 F7@D9>C<5@9@9K7F;C9>;=<4??;B;7:7<#7C>64=F7@D9> ;C<5@7CB984:;BH7<K# - C B4C<;>9@7=;4C =@;G5C7: 39:> 7BB;>9C= 4BB5@@9> >59=4@7<37C>C96:;69C=>@;I;C64?7@GH;=<>@;I9@B:7;F7C= <5<=7;C9> 89@F7C9C= 83H<;B7: >;<7G;:;=H 7C> :4<< 4? 97@C;C6 B787B;=H7C>9C=;=:9>?4@B4F89C<7=;4C?@4F;C<5@9@7<?4::4A< + ,-./01,2/-342 0523 # K89C>;=5@9 4? F9>;B7: 7C> =@97=F9C= <!$. .. K89C>;=5@94??44>7C>C45@;<3F9C= < ... $ K89C>;=5@9 4? =@7C<84@=7=;4C 7C> 7==9C>;C6B37@69< <.... " 4<<4?97@C;C6>5@;C6=39=@97=F9C= < ... - 5 - 4<<4??5=5@997@C;C64C7BB45C=4? 89@F7C9C=>;<7G;:;=H <.+ . - /5=5@9F9>;B7:9K89C<9< < .... + 7;C7C><5??9@;C6 < .... 3-+ / $ 6$67 + ;<<7=;<?;9>A;=3L57C=5FB:7;F7C=;<;C78897:= A7< ?;@<=:H <5GF;==9> B:7;F7C= A7< 76@;B5:=5@;<= <5<=7;C9> 7F85=7=;4C4?:9?=:967G4I9DC99345633937><=7=9>=37= 39 A7< 769> H97@< 7C> 97@C;C6 < .... 89@ 7CC5F ?@4F 76@;B5:=5@9 7C> <+.. 89@ >7H ?@4F 7<4C A4@D =@;G5C7: 7<<9<<9> ;= 7= <#$ . 89@ F4C=3 = B4C<;>9@9> + M 7< ?5CB=;4C7: >;<7G;:;=H 788:;9> F5:=;8:;9@ 4? #+ 7C> 7<<9<<9> B4F89C<7=;4C 4? <.+ . =4A7@>< :4<< 4? ?5=5@9 ;CB4F9 4A9I9@ A3;:9 7A7@>;C6 <7F9 ;= ?7;:9> =4 7>39@9=4@7=;4:7;>>4ACGH4C,G:958@9F945@=;CB7<94? @984@=9>;C !;C<4?7@7<7>>;=;4C 4? ?5=5@9 8@4<89B=< =4 F4C=3:H ;CB4F9 ;C B7<9 4? 89@<4C7: ;CE5@H B:7;F< 7:<4 = A7< <5GF;==9> 7A7@> 4? < .... =4A7@><?5=5@9F9>;B7:9K89C<9<7C>4C:H< ....=4A7@>< 87;C7C><5??9@;C6A9@9;C7>9L57=9A3;B3B7::?4@9C37CB9F9C= @;G5C7: 7:<4 ?7;:9> =4 7A7@> B4F89C<7=;4C =4A7@>< :4<< 4? - 6 - 7F9C;=;9< = A7< <5GF;==9> 9I9C B4F89C<7=;4C 7A7@>9> =4A7@><:4<<4?;CB4F9>5@;C6:7;>5889@;4>A7<4C:4A9@<;>9 ;D9A;<9 7A7@> 4? <.... =4A7@>< =@7C<84@=7=;4C 7C> 7==9C>7C= B37@69< 7C> < ... =4A7@>< ?44> 7C> C45@;<3F9C=A7<7:<44C:4A9@<;>97C><4563=9C37CB9F9C= ! C 4=39@ 37C> F= @99=; 7=;: 9:D5C>; :97@C9> B45C<9:?4@;C<5@9@4884<9>78897:=A7<<5GF;==9>=@;G5C7: 37> =7D9C C4=9 4? ?7B=< 7C> B;@B5F<=7CB9< 7C> 7A7@>9> 7>9L57=9 B4F89C<7=;4C 7C> <7F9 >49< C4= B7:: ?4@ 9C37CB9F9C= 97@>:97@C9>B45C<9: 9@5<9>;F856C9>E5>6F9C= 7C>7A7@> #. /@4F7G4I97C><;CB94C:HB:7;F7C=A7<;C78897: ?4@ 9C37CB9F9C= 4? B4F89C<7=;4C 84;C= =37= A45:> 7@;<9 ?4@ B4C<;>9@7=;4C;< ## C I;9A 4? 7G4I94BB5@@9CB94? 7BB;>9C= B:7;F7C= <5<=7;C;C6 89@F7C9C= 83H<;B7: >;<7G;:;=H 7C> :4<< 4? 97@C;C6 - 7 - B787B;=H7C>G9;C69C=;=:9>?4@B4F89C<7=;4C?@4F;C<5@9@;<C4= ;C >;<85=9 :7;F7C= 37< ?;@<=:H <4563= ?4@ 7>>;=;4C 4? ?5=5@9 8@4<89B=< C I;9A 4? @7=;4 :7;> >4AC ;C " B7<9 &<58@7( 9I9C ;C 89@<4C7: ;CE5@H B:7;F< ?5=5@9 8@4<89B=< 7@9 @9L5;@9> =4 G9 7>>9> =4 F4C=3:H ;CB4F9 7D;C6 C4=9 4? ?7B= =37=B:7;F7C=A7<H97@<4?7697C><9:?9F8:4H9>".M37< =4 G9 7>>9> 35< @9B4F85=7=;4C 4? B4F89C<7=;4C =4A7@>< :4<<4??5=5@9;CB4F9A45:>G9 &<#$ .N".M()+ M)#)#+O<!$!# . # C<4?7@ 7< 87;C 7C> <5??9@;C6 =@97=F9C= @9B4@>< A45:> ;C>;B7=9 7F85=7=;4C 4? :9?= :96 7G4I9 DC99 4C,G:9 58@9F9 45@= ;C B7<9 4? # $ % & ' ' ( )* @984@=9> ;C + ,- . 7A7@>9> <# .... =4A7@>< 87;C 7C> <5??9@;C6 ;C B7<9 4? 7F85=7=;4C 39@9?4@9 7A7@> 4? < .... A45:> C4= G9 E5<=;?;9> :7;F7C= ;< 39:> 9C=;=:9> ?4@ <# .... =4A7@>< 87;C7C><5??9@;C6 #$ 4C,G:9 58@9F9 45@= ;C / 01 ,/2 01 3 , @984@=9> ;C ++ + ! ;C B7<9 4? 7F85=7=;4C7A7@>9><# ....=4A7@><:4<<4?7F9C;=;9< - 8 - :7;F7C= A45:> G9 9C=;=:9> ?4@ <# .... =4A7@>< :4<< 4? 7F9C;=;9< ;CB9 =@;G5C7: >;> C4= 7A7@> 7CH B4F89C<7=;4C 5C>9@<7;>397><7F9;<7A7@>9>GH=3;<45@= #" @;G5C7: 7<<9<<9> F4C=3:H ;CB4F9 7= <#$ . 89@F4C=3CB7<94?7F85=7=;4C4?:4A9@:;FGC4@F7::H<;K F4C=3<,89@;4>37<=4G9=7D9C7<:7H4??39@9?4@9B:7;F7C= A45:>G99C=;=:9>=4<+ ..=4A7@><:4<<4?;CB4F9>5@;C6 :7;>58 89@;4> /4@ ;C87=;9C= 89@;4> 4? # >7H< =@;G5C7: 37< 7A7@>9>=4=7:<5F4?<" ...=4A7@><?44>C45@;<3F9C= =@7C<84@=7=;4C7C>7==9C>7C=B37@69<A3;B378897@<=4G9E5<= 7C>8@489@7C>>49<C4=B7::?4@;C=9@?9@9CB9;D9A;<97A7@> 4? <!$. .. =4A7@>< F9>;B7: 9K89C<9< ;< 767;C<= F9>;B7: G;::< 8@4>5B9> A3;B3 A45:> G9 ;C B4F8:9=9 @9;FG5@<9F9C= 39@9?4@9<7F9>49<C4=B7::?4@;C=9@?9@9CB9 # @;G5C7: 37< 7A7@>9> 4C:H < .... =4A7@>< ?5=5@9 F9>;B7: 9K89C<9< C B45@<9 4? B@4<<9K7F;C7=;4C <5669<=;4C 7G45= 7@=;?;B;7: :;FG 7C> 84<<;G;:;=H 4? 7==9C>;C6 =4 <4F9 A4@D A;=3 7@=;?;B;7: :;FG ;< 8@4E9B=9> 7D;C6 C4=9 4? <7F9 =@;G5C7: 37> 7<<9<<9> ?5CB=;4C7: >;<7G;:;=H 7= + M 4A9I9@ =@;G5C7: 37< C4= 7A7@>9> B4F89C<7=;4C =7D;C6 C4=9 - 9 - 4?@9L5;@9F9C=4?7@=;?;B;7::;FG;=<89@;4>;B7:F7;C=9C7CB97C> @98:7B9F9C= 39@9?4@9 7A7@> 4? < .... 4C =3;< B45C= A45:> G9 ;C7>9L57=9 7F9 ;< 9C37CB9> =4 <#..... 35<B:7;F7C=;<39:>9C=;=:9>?4@@97<<9<<9>B4F89C<7=;4C4? <"#$# . #- 4;C= ?4@ B4C<;>9@7=;4C ;< 7C<A9@9> 87@=:H ;C 7??;@F7=;I94C<9L59C=:H?4::4A;C6 ; 8897:;<7::4A9>;C87@=E5>6F9C=7C>7A7@> >7=9>.-.#.$87<<9>GH9C;4@;I;:'5>69 7C>'/7C>4=4@BB;>9C=:7;F<@;G5C7: ;C67<565@ ;C C4-.. ;< F4>;?;9> :7;F7C=;<39:>9C=;=:9>?4@=4=7:B4F89C<7=;4C 4? <"#$# . 7< 767;C<= <$.++ . 7A7@>9>GH@;G5C7:A;=3;C=9@9<=7=@7=94?-M 89@7CC5F?@4F>7=94?89=;=;4C=;::>984<;= ;; 9<84C>9C=;C<5@9@ =4 >984<;= <7F9 G9?4@9 =@;G5C7:A;=3;C789@;4>4?<;KA99D< ;;; C >984<;= >;@9B=;4C ;<<59> GH =@;G5C7: 7G45= >984<;= 7C> @9:97<9 A45:> 788:H =4 9C37CB9> B4F89C<7=;4C7:<4 - 10 - ;I F45C=;C?;K9>>984<;=;<4@>9@9>=4G9D98= ;C 4<=7: >984<;=< 97@C;C6 3;639<= @7=9 4? ;C=9@9<=;C;=;7::H?4@789@;4>4??;I9H97@< .7 (&& ) # ;<=4#:4$