- 1 - ! "# $ ## #%% & &'%() & (( * ! ! "## $ % # # ## !& "# $# #% ## '&$%#### # ( # ) * ( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - +! ! ! ! ! * ! ! ! ,## '-# ## ( )( $# $#)(% ./ 011/220345 6/738 099:5/; +5' 03; 73 /557+3505/+! !+34./<72/+<4./2/0=3/; ;;747+302 754=794 03; /557+35 (:;8/ 04 0206:=087 $<+= 5.+=4 >=702 +:=4?% 0=/ 7@1:83738 4./ A:;8@/34 +< 9+3B7947+3;04/;!!!03;+=;/=+<5/34/39/;04/; !!! 9+3B794738 4./@ <+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3 '- +< 4./ 3;703 #/302 +;/ C! $<+= 5.+=4 >#?% 03; 5/34/39738 4+ :3;/=8+ =78+=+:5 7@1=75+3@/34<+=01/=7+;+</78.4D/0=503;4+10D<73/+< 5!!! /09. 03; 73 ;/<0:24 +< 10D@/34 +< <73/ 4+ :3;/=8+=78+=+:57@1=75+3@/34<+=01/=7+;+<57E@+34.5 - 3 - 4 75 4./ 9+34/347+3 +< 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 4.04 099:5/; +5 4+ F74. 9+@@+3 +6A/94 <+=@/; 03 :320F<:2 055/@62D 03; +3 -!' 04 !! 73 4./ @7;378.4 3/0= 0@6=7;8/ 9.++2 +3 .0.060; =+0; 0206:=087 6D 0550:24738 # G 4./ ;=7B/= +< 4./ 2+==D 6/0=738=/8754=047+3+#' H''&-03;40I/30F0D'&! 6085 +< 9/@/34 ./=/6D 9+@@744/; ;09+74D 3747022D <7=54 73<+=@047+3 90@/ 4+ 6/ =/8754/=/; 0807354 :3I3+F3 1/=5+35 :=7384./73B/5478047+34./5/011/2203456/738 099:5/; +5' 03; F/=/ 011=/./3;/; 03; 4./D F/=/ 4=7/;<+=4./+<</39/1:375.062/:3;/=/947+3'-+<# F.72/ 4./ 51274:1 9.0=8/ 5.//4 90@/ 4+ 6/ <72/; 0807354 099:5/; +5 C 03; 05 4./D F/=/ 0659+3;738 ./5/011/220345.0B/011/0=/;6/<+=/4./=702+:=403; 12/0;/;3+48:724D03;9207@/;4+6/4=7/; ' ./ 1=+5/9:47+3 4+ 1=+B/ 4./ 8:724 +< 4./ 099:5/;/E0@73/;#4+# 8+4@0=I/;E5#4+ #&03;7;/347<7/;735:11+=4+<7459+34/347+3./ 099:5/;;/37/;0224./739=7@7304+=D@04/=70250B072062/+3 - 4 - =/9+=;6:4.0B/3+42/;03D/B7;/39/735:11+=4+<4./7= ;/</39/ & ./ =702 +:=4 0<4/= 40I738 734+ 9+357;/=047+3 0224./5/@04/=7025+3=/9+=;90@/4+4./9+392:57+34.04 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 75 5:99/55<:2 73 1=+B738 4./ 8:724 +< 4./ 099:5/; 6/D+3; 022 =/05+3062/ ;+:645 03; 099+=;7382D 1055/;4./7@1:83/;A:;8@/34+<9+3B7947+303;+=;/=+< 5/34/39/ /738 088=7/B/; 6D 4./ 50@/ 4./ 011/220345 099:5/;+5'03;0=/6/<+=/4.75+:=4 /0=; 2/0=3/; 9+:35/2 =7 0.034/5. /507 011/0=738 <+= 4./ 011/220345 099:5/; +5' 03; 03; =7+102I=75.300;0B2/0=3/;78.+:=4+B/=3@/34 #2/0;/=<+=4./=/51+3;/34404/#/=:5/;4./@04/=7025 +3=/9+=;7392:;7384./=702+:=4=/9+=;5 C 3 B7/F +< 4./ =7B02 9+34/347+35 :=8/; 6D 2/0=3/;9+:35/2<+=4./10=47/54./1+7344.04F+:2;0=75/ <+=@D9+357;/=047+375 - 5 - D035F/=4+4./06+B/1+73475734./> ? <+=4./<+22+F738 ./ 9+34/347+3 +< 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 75 4.04 4./ 1=/5/34011/22034502+38F74.9+099:5/;.0B/9+@@744/; ;09+74D 6D F0D20D738 4./ 2+==D 6/0=738 =/8754=047+3 +#' H''&- 03; 40I738 0F0D '&! 6085 +< 9/@/34 53049.738 905. +< 5&!!! 03; 0 @+672/ 1.+3/ <=+@ #3+=;/=4+1=+B/4.759+34/347+34./1=+5/9:47+3 /E0@73/;#F.+754./+F3/=+<4./2+==D745/2<4.05 025+/E0@73/;4./@0.0J0=F743/55/54+4./51+4@0.0J0= 03;5/7J:=/1039.030@0B7;/E5#'4+#+3/+<4./5/ F743/55/5.0B/5:11+=4/;4./905/+<4./1=+5/9:47+3 #C754./+F3/=+<4./203;F./=/4./2+==D73 K:/547+3F05<+:3;10=I/;03;#754./F+=I/=734./ - 6 - 507;203;# 03;#-0=/4./@0.0J0=F743/55/54+ E#'+3/+<4./5/F743/55/5.0B/5:11+=4/;4./905/ +<4./1=+5/9:47+3 - #!754./@0.0J0=F743/554+E#:3;/= F.79.9+=17+B/.792/F.79.F05507;4+.0B/6//3:5/; 6D 4./ 099:5/; 73 9+@@7557+3 +< 4./ +<</39/ F05 5/7J/; 03;'&!9/@/346085+<9/@/345F.79.F05507;4+.0B/ 6//340I/30F0D6D4./099:5/;F/=/025+5/7J/;:3;/= E#& .75 F743/55 025+ 3+4 5:11+=4/; 4./ 905/ +< 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 ! # 75 4./ +32D /D/F743/55 F.+ F05 4./ ;=7B/= +< 4./ 2+==D 73 K:/547+3 F.+ 51+I/ 06+:4 9+@@7557+3 +< 4./ +<</39/ 03; <72738 +< 4./ <7=54 73<+=@047+3605/;+3F.79.<7=5473<+=@047+390@/4+6/ =/8754/=/; B/3 4.+:8. 4.75 F743/55 .05 5:11+=4/; 4./ 905/+<4./1=+5/9:47+3F74.=/80=;4+9+@@7557+3+<4./ +<</39/./.053/B/=7;/347<7/;099:5/;+5'03;F.+ 0=/4./011/220345./=/73 - 7 - # 4+ # 0=/ 4./ 1+279/ +<<797025 ./D .0B/ 5404/; =/80=;738 =/8754=047+3 +< =7@/ +C! !& +< 0206:=087 :=02 #+279/ 4047+3 <+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/ :3;/= /947+3 '-- +< # F./=/73 4./5/ 011/2203450=/025+099:5/; # 754./F743/55F.+755:11+5/;4+51/0I 06+:44./1:=9.05/+<9/@/346085<=+@099:5/;+<+= 4./ 1:=1+5/ +< 9+354=:947+3 +< .75 .+:5/ B/3 4.75 F743/55.053+45:11+=4/;4./905/+<4./1=+5/9:47+3 ' =+@ 4./ @04/=7025 +3 =/9+=; 74 011/0=5 4.04 099+=;738 4+ 4./ 905/ +< 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 =7@/ +C! !& +< 0206:=087 :=02 #+279/ 4047+3 90@/ 4+ 6/ =/8754/=/; 0807354 099:5/; +5 4+ C 4./=/73 03; ;:=73873B/5478047+3734./1=/5/34905/4./5/011/220345 F/=/011=/./3;/;03;+<</39/59+@@744/;6D4./@734./ 1=/5/34905/ 90@/ 4+ 278.4 E9/14 4./ +<<79702 F743/55/5 # 4+ # 3+3/ +< 4./ +4./= F743/55/5 .0B/ 5:11+=4/;4./905/+<4./1=+5/9:47+3 - 8 - & ;@744/;2D4./734./1=/5/34905/90@/4+ 6/=/8754/=/;0807354:3I3+F31/=5+35475+32D# F.+ .05 5//3 4./ 1/=5+35 F.+ 9+@@744/; 4./ +<</39/ 6:4 3+ /54 ;/347<79047+3 #0=0;/ F05 9+3;:94/; 6D 4./ 3B/547804738<<79/=4+9+33/944./099:5/;4+4./022/8/; +<</39/224./@04/=702F743/55/5/E9/144./73<+=@034 # .0B/ 4:=3/; .+5472/ 03; .0B/ 3+4 5:11+=4/; 4./ 905/+<4./1=+5/9:47+3 3;/= 5:9. 97=9:@54039/5 ;+ 3+4 <73; 03D @04/=7024+9+33/944./011/220345 099:5/;+5'03;4+ 4./+<</39/73K:/547+3<+=4./1:=1+5/+<9+3B7947384./@ 5+2/2D+34./60575+<4.//B7;/39/+<#F.+75507; 4+.0B/011=/./3;/;4./011/22034573=7@/+C! !& +< 0206:=087 :=02 #+279/ 4047+3 ./=/ 75 3+4.738 +3 =/9+=;4+9+33/944./099:5/;4+4./+<</39/73K:/547+3 3;/= 5:9. 97=9:@54039/5 011/220345 099:5/; +5' 03; 0=/ /34742/; <+= 09K:74402 6D /E4/3;738 4./ 6/3/<74 +< ;+:64 - 9 - C .0B/8+3/4.=+:8.4./7@1:83/;A:;8@/34+< 9+3B7947+303;+=;/=+<5/34/39/1055/;6D4./=702+:=4 4 .05 1=+9//;/; 4+ 9+3B794 4./ 099:5/; +3 4./ 8=+:3; 4.04/B/34.+:8.@0.0J0=F743/55/5.0B/3+45:11+=4/; 4./ 905/ +< 4./ 1=+5/9:47+3 4./ /B7;/39/ +< 4./ 3B/547804738<<79/=73517=/;4./9+3<7;/39/734./@73;+< 4./ +:=4 03; # F.+ =/9+B/=/; 4./ 739=7@7304+=D 0=4792/5 .05 ;/1+5/; 6/<+=/ 4./ +:=4 03; 4./ 50@/ 75 5:<<797/34 4+ 9+33/94 4./ 099:5/; 4+ 4./ +<</39/ 73 K:/547+3 :9. 03 +1737+3 <+=@/; 6D 4./ =702 +:=4 9033+4 6/ 099/14/; 05 4./ 099:5/; 9033+4 6/ 9+3B794/; <+=4./+<</39/1:375.062/:3;/=/947+3'-+<#5+2/2D +3 4./ 60575 +< 4./ /B7;/39/ +< # F.+ F05 4./ 3B/547804738 <<79/= F./3 4./ @0.0J0= :3;/= F.79. 4./ 739=7@7304+=D@04/=7025507;4+.0B/6//3=/9+B/=/;044./ 7354039/+<4./099:5/;753+41=+B/;73099+=;039/F74. 20F./=/75065+2:4/2D3+=/05+3054+F.D3+3/+<4./ F743/55/5.0B/5:11+=4/;4./905/+<4./1=+5/9:47+3 - 10 - 3;/=5:9.97=9:@54039/50@+<4./+1737+3 4.04 4./ 7@1:83/; A:;8@/34 +< 9+3B7947+3 03; +=;/= +< 5/34/39/1055/;6D4./=702+:=47527062/4+6/5/4057;/ 99+=;7382D1=+9//;4+10554./<+22+F738 $7% ./=7@730211/0275 $77% ./ (:;8@/34 +< 9+3B7947+3 !!! 03; +=;/= +< /34/39/ ;04/; !!! 1055/; 73/557+3505/+! !+34./<72/+< 2/0=3/; ;;747+302 754=794 03; /557+35 (:;8/ 0206:=087 75 ./=/6D 5/4 057;/ +35/K:/342D 4./ 011/220345 099:5/; +5' 03; 0=/ 09K:744/; <+= 4./ +<</39/ 1:375.062/:3;/=/947+3'-+<# $777% 072 6+3; +< 4./ 011/220345 099:5/; +5' 03; 03; 4.04 +< 4./7= 5:=/47/5 5.022 5403; 9039/22/; $7B% 73/ 0@+:34 7< 03D ;/1+574/; 6D 4./ 011/220345 099:5/;+5'03;75+=;/=/;4+ 6/ =/<:3;/; 4+ 4./@ 0<4/= 011/02 1/=7+; 75 +B/= - 11 - /8754=D 4+ 5/3; 609I 4./ =702 +:=4 =/9+=;5 02+38 F74.9+1D+<4.75A:;8@/34<+=73<+=@047+303;<+=3//;<:2 0947+3 +) &##( $ 754+2+! #