- 1 - ! " # " $!%&"" $!%&"#&'!!# (") ! " #$ % # &' # &' % &'(' Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ! " # )$ * $ )( # ' + & , + &&* & # -. -. . # ! " -. $ /0123 420502026/0157502026/54183918::5/;5<015 64<54 <805< )( 78335< => 015 84/808?8 0805 <@2/2304802A542=B/8:5/;8:B4B"15452/8C05445C5445<06 - 3 - 83 D015 E$ 2/ 77:298026/ 6' F1545=> 015 382<877:298026/F838::6F5<2/7840 15 =425C C8903 6C 015 9835 845 0180 015 7502026/54 F83 87762/05< 83 08CC B435 2/ 015 2304290 637208: B:=84;8 12:5 315 F83 F64?2/; 83 BG2:284> B435 2<F2C53.B/264 58:01 332308/0 5@8:5 80 015 2304290 637208: B:=84;8 315 877:25< C64 96@@B05< :58A5 F201 5CC590 C46@ HH) 06 ''HH' 15 7502026/54 3B=@203 0180 015 382< :58A5 F83 38/9026/5< => 0152304290B4;56/8/<B7542/05/<5/02304290637208: B:=84;8 15 CB40154 3B=@203 0180 315 5G05/<5< 015 @5<298::58A5C46@)HH'06*HH' 76/ 5G724> 6C 015 :58A575426< 015 7502026/54 877:25<355?2/;754@23326/06I62/015<B0>6F5A54015 96@7505/08B016420><2</60754@201540645I62/537205 4575805<45JB5303315F83/608::6F5<06457640015<B0> / 015 60154 18/< 8 <57840@5/08: 5/JB24> F83 2/202805< 8;82/30 154 6/ 015 ;46B/< 6C B/8B01642K5< 8=35/95 9184;5 @5@6 F83 233B5< 8/< 8/ /JB24> CC2954 F83 - 4 - 87762/05< C054 96/<B902/; 015 5/JB24> 015 /JB24> CC29543B=@2005<845764030802/;01800159184;538;82/30 0157502026/54&877:298/0F545/60746A5< ) A5/ 015458C054 315 F83 /60 754@2005< 06 45764006<B0>=>01596@7505/08B016420>B=35JB5/0:> 31580082/5<3B7548//B8026/15458C0540158B016420>=> 5G549232/; 76F543 B/<54 B:5 6C 84/808?8 2A2: 54A295B:53"$045805<01575426<C46@)HH' 06 HHH 83 B/8B01642K5< 8=35/95 52/; 8;;425A5< => 015 38@5 015 7502026/54 C2:5< 8/ 87758: =5C645 015 8775::805 8B016420> 15 8775::805 8B016420> A2<5 64<54 <805< ' 96/C24@5< 015 64<54 78335< 6/ 18::5/;2/;01538@50157502026/54C2:5<8/ 877:298026/ =5C645 015 84/808?8 0805 <@2/2304802A5 42=B/8: 2/ 77:298026/ 6' 15 42=B/8: A2<5 64<54<805<)(78335<015C6::6F2/;64<54 ! " " # $ - 5 - 52/; 8;;425A5< => 015 8=6A5 64<54 015 7502026/54 183C2:5<0123 420502026/ ' 4281531802::584/5<96B/35:8775842/;C64 0157502026/541833B=@2005<015C6::6F2/;96/05/026/3 8$ 15 45376/<5/0 8B016420> 2/202805< 8 <57840@5/08:5/JB24>8;82/300157502026/546/015;46B/< 0180 315 F83 B/8B01642K5<:> 8=35/0 C46@ )HH' 06 HHH 15 /JB24> CC2954 8C054 96/<B902/; 8 <5082:5< 5/JB24> 3B=@2005< 8 457640 30802/; 0180 015 9184;538;82/300157502026/54F545/60746A5<835<6/ 0123 457640 015 <57840@5/08: 5/JB24> F83 9:635< 15458C054 015 38@5 8B016420> => 5G549232/; 76F543 B/<54B:56C78335<0152@7B;/5<64<548/< 015 38@5 23 96/0484> 06 015 457640 3B=@2005< => 015 /JB24>CC2954/9520F8315:<01800157502026/54F83 /60 B/8B01642K5<:> 8=35/0 C46@ 015 <B0> 8;82/ => 2@7B;/5< 64<54 015 8B016420> 98//60 04580 015 75426< C46@ )HH' 06 HHH 83 B/8B01642K5< 8=35/0 /3B776406C12396/05/026/1545:25<6/015IB<;@5/06C - 6 - 6/E=:5 75G 6B40 2/ 015 9835 6C ! 4576405<2/ %"#$% &''()(8/<8:36IB<;@5/06C01236B402/015 98356C * ! 4576405<2/ %"#$% &''()(8/<8:36IB<;@5/06C01236B402/015 98356C * ! +2/ 6<237635<6C6/*H =$ 596/<:> 15 96/05/<5< 0180 015 7502026/54 877:25< C64 :58A5 6/ @5<298: ;46B/<3 C054 015 :58A5 75426<315183;2A5/84574535/08026/355?2/;754@23326/ 06 457640 C64 <B0> 537205 4575805< 45JB5303 015 45376/<5/08B016420><2</60754@20 154 06 453B@5F64? B5 06 015 C8B:0 6C 015 45376/<5/03 315 98//60 =5 7B/2315<=>045802/;018075426<83B/8B016420K5<8=35/0 9$ 830:> 15 96/05/<5< 0180 32/95 015 7502026/54 F83 5G6/54805< C46@ 8:: 9184;53 015 75426< 6C 8=35/95 316B:< 18A5 =55/ 045805< 83 6/ <B0> 15 8B016420> 96@@2005<8/544642/045802/;01575426<83:58A5F2016B0 8::6F8/95 1545C645 15 748>5< C64 8::6F2/; 015 F420 7502026/ - 7 - /0156015418/<42#248/8;6B<8248<84 :584/5<<<2026/8:6A54/@5/0<A698058775842/;C64015 0805 96/05/<5< 0180 IB30 =598B35 015 7502026/54 F83 5G6/54805<C46@0159184;532/015<57840@5/08:5/JB24> 01575426<6C8=35/956C0157502026/5498//60=5045805< 83 6/ <B0> / 015 <57840@5/08: 5/JB24> 015 7502026/54 F83 5G6/54805< 6/ 015 ;46B/< 0180 315 18< 877:25< C64 :58A5 8:6/; F201 8 @5<298: 95402C29805 8/< 015 877:298026/ F83 75/<2/; C64 96/32<548026/ 180 <653 /60 2@7:> 0180 315 F83 6/ <B0> 15 :58A5 877:25< C64 => 015 7502026/54 F83 =5>6/< 015 754@2005< :2@20 1545C645 015 42=B/8: 42;10:> <245905< 0180 015 75426< 6C 8=35/95 316B:< =5 045805<83:58A5060155G05/08A82:8=:580154945<208/< 015 45@82/2/; 75426< 83 :58A5 F2016B0 8::6F8/95 9964<2/;:>15748>5<C64<23@2338:6C015F4207502026/ * 584< 015 :584/5< 96B/35: C64 015 7840253 8/< 754B35<015F420787543 ( 0 23 /60 2/ <237B05 0180 015 7502026/54 877:25< C64:58A5C46@HH)06')HH'0238:36/602/ - 8 - <237B0501808<57840@5/08:5/JB24>F832/202805<8;82/30 154 C64 B/8B01642K5< 8=35/95 <B42/; 015 75426< C46@ )HH' 06 HHH / 015 <57840@5/08: 5/JB24> 015 /JB24> CC2954 15:< 0180 015 9184;53 8;82/30 015 7502026/54F545/60746A5<830157502026/5418<3B=@2005< 8 :58A5 877:298026/ 3B776405< => 8 @5<298: 95402C29805 F1291F8375/<2/;=5C6450158B016420>5/9501575426< 96B:</60=5045805<83B/8B01642K5<8=35/95 H 6F5A54 20 23 8:36 /60 2/ <237B05 0180 015 7502026/54 F83 8=35/0 C46@ )HH' 06 HHH 1545C645 015 42=B/8: 42;10:> 8::6F5< 015 877:298026/ 2/ 78408/<<245905<060458001575426<C46@)HH'06 HHH 83 :58A5 06 015 5G05/0 6C :58A5 80 154 945<20 8/<01545@82/2/;75426<6C0158=35/95318::=5045805< 83:58A5F2016B08::6F8/95 023CB40154/605<01800157502026/54877:25<C64 :58A5 C46@ )HH' 06 )HH' :016B;1 315 3B=@2005<84574535/08026/355?2/;754@23326/06453B@5 <B0> C46@ 'HH' =B0 45964<3 <572903 0180 6/ - 9 - 'HHH 315 8;82/ 877:25< C64 :58A5 C46@ *HH 06(HH8:6/;F201@5<298:45964<3 15 7502026/54 F83 83?5< 06 457640 C64 <B0> 80 015 2304290 637208: 12048<B4;8 6/ H'HH( C054 F64?2/;C646/5<8>315877:25<C64983B8::58A5C640F6 <8>3 B=35JB5/0:> 315 5G05/<5< 154 :58A5 C46@ )HH( 06 HH( 6/ @5<298: ;46B/<3 15 8775::805 8B016420> 183 ;2A5/ 8 9:584 C2/<2/; 0180 5A5/ 016B;1 315 183 3B=@2005< 4574535/08026/ 06 457640 C64 <B0>6/0156015418/<315183C2:5<877:298026/C64:58A5 5/9:632/;015@5<298:45964<31545C6450158B016420>183 42;10:> 15:< 015 75426< C46@ )HH' 06 HHH 045802/;75426<6C8=35/9583:58A5F2016B08::6F8/95 A5/ 015 IB<;@5/03 45:25< B76/ => 015 7502026/542/01598356C "3B748$8/< +"3B748$845/60877:298=:506015C89036C01574535/0 9835830158B016420>1835G549235<01576F54B/<54B:5 6C015/015382<983520F8315:<01805A5/ 016B;1015<57840@5/08:5/JB24>18<C6B/<0155@7:6>55 - 10 - B/8B01642K5<:> 8=35/0 015 45964< 316F5< 0180 015 5@7:6>5518<877:25<C64:58A5F2018@5<298:95402C29805 15877:298026/C6438/9026/6C:58A5F8375/<2/;F2016B0 8/><592326/08?5/C46@0158B016420>0F8315:<0180015 5@7:6>55 F83 B/8B01642K5<:> 8=35/0 1545C645 015 6/E=:5 75G 6B40 15:< 0180 015 :58A5 75426< 98//60 =5 045805<83B/8B01642K5<8=35/95 / 015 74535/0 9835 16F5A54 015 8B016420> 5G549235<76F54B/<54B:56C01807502026/54 F838=35/0C46@015<B0>F2016B0754@23326/5/95015 IB<;@5/0345:25<B76/=>0157502026/54845/60877:298=:5 06C89036C01239835 ) 6/32<542/; 015 @805428:3 8A82:8=:5 6/ 45964< 015 183 42;10:> 8::6F5< 015 877:298026/ 2/ 7840 8/< <245905< 015 45376/<5/03 06 04580 015 75426< C46@ )HH'06HHH83:58A5060155G05/06C:58A5 80154945<208/<01545@82/2/;75426<6C8=35/9583:58A5 F2016B0 8::6F8/95 1545C645 01545 23 /6 54464 64 2::5;8:202532/01564<5478335<=>015 - 11 - ' 9964<2/;:>015F4207502026/23<23@2335< "*+ (") & "*+ (#&'!!#) & 230 6: 6'*