Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58702 (KAR)

SMT SUDHARANI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/201486/2025 · 2025-11-11

Sachin Shankar Magadum

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#$ %#& ## # ' '()* ' )) *+ # ,- ' '()* ' )) * + ! "# $ % ! ! & Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' ( ) ! ! * !! ( $ % ! '+ ! '& ' ' %& ' %& " ( ( , ' ! - # -' * ' ' ! -#-' ''',% & *,' ,' ,- * + ! %'' ' & ( "# ( . ( "# ( - 3 - . ' ( "# ( ! . ! ! ! $ % ! ! & ' ' ( ) ! ! ! ( ! ( $ % ! '+ ! '& ' ' %& ' %& " ' / ' * 0 - 4 - ! - -' ' '' ,% & * , ' ' ! ! ' ' 1 ' 2 ! ' 0- " % 0- & 3454 6478789:5 ;<4 =8>4? @A 734 ;BBC54? 64<59:5 544D8:E FC;538:E 9= 734 6<9B44?8:E5 64:?8:E 8: 9* ;<858:E9C79=9, =9<734 9==4:B456C:853;@>4C:?4<4B789:5,, *<4;?G8734B789:,9= :?8;:4:;>9?4* %=9< 539<71 2& ';B75>4;?8:E79734B;54;<4;5=9>>9G5 3454B9:?<4569:?4:7?4=;B79B9H6>;8:;:7G3985 734G8=49=;BBC54?98:5787C74?;6<8I;74B9H6>;8:78: 9, 544D8:EB9E:8J;:B4;E;8:577346<454:7 6478789:4<5=9<7349==4:B456C:853;@>4C:?4<4B789:5, - 5 - , * <4;? G873 4B789: , 9= 734 69: <4B9<?8:E 734 5G9<: 57;74H4:7 9= 734 B9H6>;8:;:7 ;:? 734 ?46958789:5 9= 73<44 G87:45545 734 >4;<:4? ;E857<;74@A7348H6CE:4?9<?4<?8<4B74?<4E857<;789:9= ; B<8H8:;> B;54 ;E;8:57 734 6478789:4<5 =9< 734 ;=9<45;8? 9==4:B45;:?;BB9<?8:E>A855C4?6<9B455 EE<84I4?@A7345;8?9<?4<7;D8:EB9E:8J;:B4 734 6478789:4<5 3;I4 ;66<9;B34? 7385 9C<7 544D8:E FC;538:E9=7348H6CE:4?9<?4<346<8:B86;>B9:74:789: C<E4?@A7346478789:4<58573;77349<?4<9=B9E:8J;:B485 8:B>4;<B9:7<;I4:789:9=734?8<4B789:5855C4?@A73859C<7 8: <8H8:;> 478789: 9 G38B3 G;5 34;<? ;>9:E G873 <8H8:;> 478789: 9 ) 7 85 564B8=8B;>>A B9:74:?4? 73;7 @A 9<?4< ?;74? 7385 9C<7 3;? FC;534? 734 6<9B44?8:E5 =9< 734 9==4:B45 6C:853;@>4C:?4<4B789:5, *;:?, <4;? G873 4B789: , 9= G38>4 4K6<455>A <454<I8:E >8@4<7A 79 734 54B9:? <4569:?4:7 9:>A 79 =8>4 ; 6<8I;74 B9H6>;8:7796<954BC7434<3C5@;:?%;BBC54?9&=9<734 - 6 - 9==4:B4C:?4<4B789:, :568749=5CB3;564B8=8B ;:? >8H874? >8@4<7A E<;:74? @A 7385 9C<7 734 >4;<:4? ;E857<;74 3;5 4:74<7;8:4? 734 6<454:7 B9H6>;8:7 ;:? 7;D4:B9E:8J;:B44I4:8:<4564B79=734I4<A9==4:B4573;7 3;? ;><4;?A @44: FC;534? 34 6478789:4<5 734<4=9<4 B3;>>4:E4 734 8H6CE:4? 9<?4< ;5 @48:E G39>>A G8739C7 LC<85?8B789: ;:? B9:7<;<A 79 734 4K6<455 ?8<4B789:5 9= 7385 9C<7 4;<? 734 >4;<:4? B9C:54> ;664;<8:E =9< 734 6478789:4<5 734 >4;<:4? 8E3 9C<7 9I4<:H4:7 >4;?4< <46<454:78:E <4569:?4:7 9M7;74 ;:? 734 >4;<:4? B9C:54>=9<<4569:?4:79?4(=;B79B9H6>;8:;:7 4=9<4 ;?I4<78:E 79 734 I;>8?87A 9= 734 9<?4< 6;554?@A734>4;<:4?;E857<;747;D8:EB9E:8J;:B4=9<734 9==4:B456C:853;@>4C:?4<4B789:5, , *<4;?G8734B789:,9= 8785;669587479<4=4<79 734 ?8<4B789:5 855C4? @A 7385 9C<7 8: <8H8:;> 478789: 9 G34<4@A 734 4;<>84< 6<9B44?8:E5 G4<4 - 7 - FC;534?;<;E<;635,799=7345;8?9<?4<G38B3;<4 <4>4I;:7 =9< 734 6<454:7 B9:58?4<;789: ;<4 4K7<;B74? 34<48:@4>9G=9<<4;?A<4=4<4:B4 ! "# $ %&% ' & '# ! " #$ % # $ %&% ! # # '# ()# * + # ', - # . /# 0 #$# ! $# '# 1 $ - 8 - # 23 3 # # 3 3 4# 3 3 # / # # 0 5 67(87 ! ! ''9, 0 :;' '# < # "# ! 3 # . '+' # . 1 '+' # # = # # > * :;B;<4=C>64<C5;>9=7344K7<;B74?69<789:9= 734 LC?EH4:7 <4:?4<4? @A 734 99<?8:;74 4:B3 9= 7385 9C<7 8:734 4;<>84<<9C:? 9= >878E;789: 87 85 H;:8=45773;7 734 99<?8:;74 4:B3 3;? B;74E9<8B;>>A FC;534? 734 6<9B44?8:E5 8:59=;< ;5 734A 64<7;8:4? 79 734 9==4:B45 - 9 - 6C:853;@>4C:?4<4B789:5, *;:?, <4;?G8734B789:,9=734 34964<;78I469<789:9= 734 5;8? 9<?4< >4;I45 :9 5B964 =9< ;H@8EC87A 9< H858:74<6<47;789: 34 99<?8:;74 4:B3 G38>4 FC;538:E 7344:78<46<9B44?8:E53;?564B8=8B;>>A<454<I4?>8@4<7A79 734 54B9:? <4569:?4:7G8=4 79 =8>4 ; =<453 6<8I;74 B9H6>;8:7C:?4<4B789:,9=734<9:>A8:<4564B7 9=734;>>4E4?9==4:B4C:?4<4B789:,9=734 73;7 85 734 ;>>4E4? 54B9:? H;<<8;E4 5;8? 79 3;I4 @44: B9:7<;B74?@A;BBC54?9G873;BBC54?9?C<8:E734 5C@58574:B4 9= 734 >;G=C> H;<<8;E4 @47G44: 734 54B9:? <4569:?4:7;:?;BBC54?9 ) : I84G 9= 73454 B>4;< ;:? C:4FC8I9B;> ?8<4B789:5 B9:7;8:4? 8: 734 964<;78I4 69<789: 9= 734 9<?4< ?;74? 7344;<>84<6<9B44?8:E5 5799? FC;534? 8:7348<4:78<47A4KB467=9<734>8H874?>8@4<7A<454<I4?79 6<954BC747343C5@;:?=9<734;>>4E4?9==4:B49=@8E;HA 345;8?9<?4<3;5;77;8:4?=8:;>87A;:?@8:?57346;<7845 4:B4 734 8:5787C789: 9= 734 6<454:7 54B9:? 6<8I;74 - 10 - B9H6>;8:7 @A 734 54B9:? <4569:?4:7 8: 9, 9:B4;E;8:;>>4E8:E734I4<A5;H49==4:B45 C:?4< 4B789:5 , , * <4;? G873 4B789: , 9= 734 85 :97 9:>A 8H64<H8558@>4 8: >;G @C7;>59?4H9:57<;745;H;>;=8?4;:?I4K;789C58:74:779 <4964:H;774<573;73;I4;><4;?A@44:B9:B>C?4?@A7385 9C<7 CB3 ;: ;774H67 79 B8<BCHI4:7 734 =8:;> 9<?4< 9= 73859C<7;H9C:7579;:;@C549=7346<9B4559=>;G;:? 734 B9:78:C;789: 9= 73454 6<9B44?8:E5 G9C>? <45C>7 8: ; H85B;<<8;E49=LC578B4 34 <4B9<?5 =C<734< ?85B>954 73;7 9: ;: 4;<>84< 9BB;589:G34:;58H8>;<6<8I;74B9H6>;8:7G;5=8>4?@A734 54B9:? <4569:?4:7 ;>>4E8:E 8?4:78B;> 9==4:B45 734 LC<85?8B789:;>69>8B4;=74<?C48:I4578E;789:3;?=8>4?;12 <469<7@4=9<4734>4;<:4?;E857<;74 9G4I4<734>4;<:4? ;E857<;74 G8739C7 6;558:E ;:A 9<?4< 9: 734 5;8? 12 <469<79<;558E:8:E<4;59:5=9<875;BB467;:B49<<4L4B789: 6<9B44?4? 79 7;D4 B9E:8J;:B4 9= 734 9==4:B45 6C:853;@>4 C:?4< 4B789:5 , , * <4;? G873 - 11 - 4B789: , 9= 734 34 99<?8:;74 4:B3 9= 7385 9C<77;D8:E:9749=7345;8?8<<4EC>;<87A;:?734>;BD9= H;74<8;> 79 5C57;8: 73954 ;>>4E;789:5 3;? FC;534? 734 4:78<4 6<9B44?8:E5 4KB>C?8:E 9:>A 734 9==4:B4 C:?4< 4B789: , =9< G38B3 >8@4<7A G;5 <454<I4? ;5 8:?8B;74?4;<>84< , 4568745CB3B;74E9<8B;>?8<4B789:5734>4;<:4? ;E857<;74 G38>4 4:74<7;8:8:E 734 5C@54FC4:7 B9H6>;8:7 3;5 9:B4 ;E;8: 7;D4: B9E:8J;:B4 9= 734 I4<A 5;H4 9==4:B45 734<4@A ;B78:E 8: ?8<4B7 B9:7<;I4:789: 9= 734 @8:?8:E =8:?8:E5 <4B9<?4? @A 734 99<?8:;74 4:B3 385 B>4;<>A <4=>4B75 :9:(;66>8B;789: 9= H8:? ;:? ; =;8>C<4 79 ;66<4B8;74 734 8H69<7 9= 734 4;<>84< LC?8B8;> 6<9:9C:B4H4:79:54FC4:7>A7349<?4<8H6CE:4?5C==4<5 =<9H54<89C5LC<85?8B789:;>8:=8<H8784585B9:7<;<A79734>;G >;8??9G:@A73859C<7;:?734<4=9<4B;::97@45C57;8:4? 8:7344A459=>;G - 12 - 7 85 79 @4 4H63;58J4? 73;7 734 >4;<:4? ;E857<;74G38>4 ?4;>8:EG873;B9H6>;8:7 9= 734 6<454:7 :;7C<485<4FC8<4?795B<C6C>9C5>A;?34<479734H;:?;74 9= 4B789: , 9= 734 < G38B3 E9I4<:5 734 B9E:8J;:B4 9= 9==4:B45 <4>;78:E 79 H;<<8;E4 :B4 734 5G9<: 57;74H4:7 9= 734 B9H6>;8:;:7 85 <4B9<?4? 734 >4;<:4? ;E857<;74 85 ?C7A(@9C:? 79 4K;H8:4 G34734< 734<4 4K8575 6<8H; =;B84 H;74<8;> 79 6<9B44? 9:>A ;E;8:57 ;BBC54? 9 =9< 734 ;>>4E4? 9==4:B4 C:?4< 4B789: , 34 ;E857<;74 H;A 4K74:? 734 6<9B455 79 9734< ;BBC54? 64<59:5 :;H4>A 734 <4>;78I45 9< ;559B8;745 9= ;BBC54?99:>A8=734<485B9E4:7;:?564B8=8BH;74<8;> 9:<4B9<?8:?8B;78:E73;7734A3;?;B78I4>A6;<78B86;74?8: 9< ;@4774? 734 ;>>4E4? 54B9:? H;<<8;E4 H4B3;:8B;> 855C;:B4 9= 6<9B455 ;E;8:57 ;>> 734 ;BBC54? G8739C7 5;785=A8:E 73454 >4E;> 6<4B9:?8789:5 G9C>? ;H9C:7 79 ; H85B;<<8;E49=LC578B4;:?G9C>?@4C:5C57;8:;@>48:>;G '9< 734 =9<4E98:E <4;59:5 ;:? 8: I84G 9= 734 B;74E9<8B;> =8:?8:E5 <4B9<?4? @A 7385 9C<7 34<48:;@9I4 734=9>>9G8:E - 13 - 34<8H8:;>478789:5;<4;>>9G4? 34 8H6CE:4? 9<?4< ?;74? 6;554? @A 734 >4;<:4? ??8789:;> 8I8> -C?E4 ;:? -' ;>;@C<;E8 8: 9, 7;D8:E B9E:8J;:B4 9= 734 9==4:B45 6C:853;@>4 C:?4<4B789:5, *<4;?G873 4B789:,9= 8534<4@AFC;534? 785H;?4B>4;<73;7734>4;<:4?;E857<;74 53;>> @4 ;7 >8@4<7A 79 4K;H8:4 734 B9H6>;8:7 9:>A 79 734 >8H874? 4K74:7 9= B9:58?4<8:E G34734<;6<8H; =;B84 B;54 85H;?4 9C7 C:?4< 4B789: , ;E;8:57 ;BBC54? 9 ;:? 8= G;<<;:74?;E;8:579734<557<8B7>A8:;BB9<?;:B4 G873>;G .* ' ##) & 8579>9 **Deleted Vide Court Order dated 25.11.2025