Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58699 (KAR)
CHANBASSAPPA S/O NINGAPPA SOMANNANOOR v. SHIVAMMA AND ORS
RSA/200325/2019 · 2025-08-19
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58699 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58699 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!!"
# $%&$& !''
(%) *
! ! "
#
#
# $ !%#%! &
#'
(
#)
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
*
#! )
+
+
+#
)
,
,
!%% , ,
-#%!- % #%!. ,
$/
,
%-%-#%!. +) #%!#
, $/
"
"
,, ,
,
,
"
- 3 -
0
%!$ 123 45678&4 35*9:; &<<5&8 23 =285; (> ?15 &<<588&:? <8&2:?2== <4&>2:6 ?9 35? &32;5 ?15 7;6@5:? &:; ;5*455;&?5;%%-#%!-<&335;2:9% #%!.(>?15 5:294 2A28 7;65 &;624 =94 3194? B?15 ,243? <<588&?5 974?C D15457:;54 ?15 7;6@5:? &:; ;5*455 ;&?5; %-%-#%!. <&335; 2:
9+) #%!# (> ?15 2A28 7;65 &:;
, 974? &;624 =94 3194? B?15 42&8 974?C 1&3 (55:45A5435; # 15 &<<588&:? <8&2:?2== =285; 9+) #%!# &6&2:3? ?15 453<9:;5:?3 ;5=5:;&:?3 355E2:6 45825= 9= <54<5?7&82:F7:*?29:
) 15*&359=?15<8&2:?2==23?1&?1523?159D:54 &:; <93353394 9= 372? <49<54?> (5&42:6 >9!' @5&3742:6+&*453)67:?&332?7&?5;&?5EE&882A288&659= &;624?&87E&&:;;23?42*? - 4 -
+ 15 <8&2:?2== 1&3 *9:?5:;5; ?1&? ?15 372? 3*15;785 <49<54?> D&3 (589:62:6 ?9 9A54:@5:? 9= &4:&?&E& &:;<8&2:?2== 1&3 (55: *78?2A&?2:6 2? =94 8&3? )% >5&43 5 =285; &<<82*&?29: (5=945 ?15 &:; 42(7:&8 9:
%'%)!--- 4294 ?9 %'%)!--- 15 D&3 *78?2A&?2:6 ?15 3&2;8&:;=94!'>5&43159==2*2&839=&1328;&4A232?5;?15 372? 8&:; &:; =97:; ?15 7:&7?1942G5; *78?2A&?29: 9= <8&2:?2== 1545&=?54 123 7:&7?1942G5; *78?2A&?29: 9= ?15 372? 8&:; D&3 45678&42G5; &:; 64&:? *54?2=2*&?5 1&3 (55: 23375;2:123=&A9749:#%%##%%+15<8&2:?2==*9:?5:;5;
?1&? 15 23 2: 8&D=78 <93353329: 9= 372? 3*15;785 <49<54?> &:; ?15 ;5=5:;&:?3 D2?197? 1&A2:6 &:> 4261? ?2?85 94 2:?5453?9A54?15372?8&:;?15>&45453?4&2:2:6?15<8&2:?2== =49@ *&44>2:6 ?15 &642*78?74&8 9<54&?29:32:?15372?8&:; 5:*515=285;372?=942:F7:*?29:
15;5=5:;&:?9+=285;D42??5:3?&?5@5:?&:;
*9:?5:;5; ?1&? ?15 <8&2:?2== 23 :9? ?15 9D:54 &:;
<93353394 9= ?15 372? 8&:; 15 *78?2A&?29: 9= ?15 <8&2:?2== 9A54?15372?8&:;=94)%>5&431&3(55:;23<7?5;(>?15
- 5 -
;5=5:;&:?3 &:; ?15 64&:? 9= 372? 8&:; 2: =&A974 9= ?15 <8&2:?2==1&3&839(55:;23<7?5;15;5=5:;&:?3*9:?5:;5;
?1&? ?15 <8&2:?2== D&3 =&8358> 45<4535:?2:6 12@358= &3 (589:62:6 ?9 *15;785; &3?5 =285; &<<82*&?29: &:; (> <8&>2:6 =4&7; 15 69? 64&:? 9= 8&:; 15 ;5=5:;&:?3 *9:?5:;5;?1&??153323?&:?9@@23329:54=97:;?1&??15 <8&2:?2== 9(?&2:5; ?15 8&:; (> =4&7; &:; *&:*5885; ?15 64&:? 15 ;5=5:;&:?3 *9:?5:;5; ?1&? ?15> &45 2: <93353329:&:;5:F9>@5:?9=?15372?<49<54?>
. : ?15 (&323 9= ?15 3&2; <85&;2:63 ?15 42&8 974?1&3=4&@5;?15=9889D2:6233753
- 6 -
: 94;54 ?9 <49A5 ?15 3&2; 233753 ?15 <8&2:?2== 1&3 (55: 5H&@2:5; 12@358= &3 "! &:; 69? @&4E5;
H3! ?9 !) &:; 9:5 D2?:533 1&3 (55: 5H&@2:5; &3
"# 15 ;5=5:;&:? 9+ 1&3 (55: 5H&@2:5; &3 "! &:;69?@&4E5;H3!?9'
' 15 42&8 974?
&=?54 15&42:6 &467@5:?3 &:;
&<<45*2&?2:6 ?15 5A2;5:*5 9: 45*94; 1&3 &:3D545; 23375 93!?9 ) 2: ?15 &==24@&?2A5 &:;;5*455; ?15372?9= ?15 <8&2:?2== &:;453?4&2:5; ?15 ;5=5:;&:?3 =49@ 2:?54=542:6 2: ?15<5&*5=78<93353329:&:;5:F9>@5:?9=?15<8&2:?2==9A54 ?15372?3*15;785<49<54?>
- 15 ;5=5:;&:? 93# ?9 . 1&A5 *1&885:65; ?15 3&2;F7;6@5:?9=?1542&8974?2:9% #%!.15 ,243?<<588&?5974?&=?5415&42:6?15&467@5:?39:(9?1 32;53 1&3 <&335; ?15 2@<76:5; F7;6@5:? 45A5432:6 ?15 F7;6@5:?<&335;(>?1542&8974?&:;;23@2335;?15372? 9= ?15 <8&2:?2== 153&2; F7;6@5:?9= ?15 ,243?<<588&?5 974?1&3(55:*1&885:65;2:?123&<<5&8
- 7 -
!% 123 974? 1&3 &;@2??5; ?15 &<<5&8 (> =94@78&?2:6?15=9889D2:637(3?&:?2&8I753?29:9=8&D
! " #$
%
!! 5&4:5; *97:358 =94 ?15 &<<588&:? D978;
*9:?5:; ?1&? ?15 <8&2:?2== D&3 7:&7?1942G5; *78?2A&?94 9= ?15372?<49<54?>15=285;&<<82*&?29:=9464&:?9=372?8&:;
15 &1328;&4 158; 5:I724> &:; 23375; &67A&82 4&@&:& &?4& H! (> <&332:6 &: 94;54 H# 15 <8&2:?2== 1&3 <&2; <45@27@ 45*52<? D12*1 23 &? H) 3 ?15 ;5=5:;&:?3 D545 2:?54=542:6 2: 123 <93353329: 15 45I753?5; ?15 &1328;&4 ?9 62A5 <982*5 <49?5*?29: 15 &1328;&42:?74:1&3D42??5:&85??54?9?962A5<982*5 <49?5*?29: 5 37(@2?3 ?1&? &3 9: ?15 ;&?5 9= 372? ?15 <8&2:?2== 1&3 (55: 2: <93353329: 9= ?15 372? <49<54?> &3 9D:54 1545=945 15 23 5:?2?85; =94 <54<5?7&8 2:F7:*?29: &6&2:3??15;5=5:;&:?3
- 8 -
!# 5&4:5;*97:358=74?15437(@2?3?1&??1594;54 <&335;(>?15&1328;&4H *&:*582:6?1564&:?9=372? 8&:; ?9?15 <8&2:?2== 23 ;742:6?15<5:;5:*> 9= ?15 372? &? ?15 2:3?&:*5 9= ?15 ;5=5:;&:?3 &:; ?15 3&@5 1&3 (55: *1&885:65;&:;:9D2?23<5:;2:6*9:32;54&?29:(5=945?123 974?2:"9#%#.) #%##5=74?15437(@2?3?1&?(> A24?759=?153&2;94;54&?H?15<93353329:9=?15372? <49<54?>1&3:9?(55:?&E5:=49@?15<8&2:?2==&:;?153&2;
94;54 <&335; (> ?15 3323?&:? 9@@23329: H 23 *1&885:65;2:?153&2;D42?<5?2?29:A5:2:3<2?59=?123 ?15 ,243? <<588&?5 974? 5445; 2: 35??2:6 &32;5 ?15 F7;6@5:? 9= ?15 42&8 974? 9: ?15 (&323 9= ?15 94;54 <&335;(>?153323?&:?9@@23329:54H 5=74?154 37(@2?3 ?1&? ?15 5A2;5:*5 9= "# D2?1 456&4; ?9 <93353329:1&3:9?(55:*1&885:65;&3?154523:9*4933/ 5H&@2:&?29:5:*5<4&>5;?9&889D?15&<<5&8
!) 5&4:5; *97:358 =94 453<9:;5:?3/;5=5:;&:?3 D978;*9:?5:;?1&??15<8&2:?2==1&3@&;5&<<82*&?29:=94 64&:?9=8&:;(>@&E2:6=&83537(@23329:?1&?15(589:63
- 9 -
?9 *15;785; &3?5 &:; =4&7;785:?8> 9(?&2:5; H!/ &67A&82 4&@&:& &?4& 15 3&2; &3<5*? *&@5 ?9 8261? &:; 3323?&:? 9@@23329:54 &=?54 5:I724> <&335; 94;54 H *&:*582:6 ?15 64&:? 9= 8&:; 2: =&A974 9= <8&2:?2== 5*9:?5:;3?1&??15;5=5:;&:?3&452:<93353329:9=372? <49<54?> &:; ?15> 1&A5 &839 =285; &<<82*&?29: H' 355E2:6 64&:? 9= 372? <49<54?> 5 =74?154 37(@2?3 ?1&? ?1545 23 *897; 9A54 ?2?85 9= ?15 <49<54?> ?1545=945 15 23 :9?5:?2?85;=9445825=9=2:F7:*?29:"2?1?12315<4&>5;=94 ;23@233&89=&<<5&8
!+ &A2:6 15&4; 85&4:5; *97:358 =94 ?15 <&4?253 ?123 974?
<54735; ?15 2@<76:5; F7;6@5:? &:; ?15 42&8 974?5*94;3
! 15 <8&2:?2== 1&3 =285; & 372? =94 <54<5?7&8 2:F7:*?29: (&35; 9: 123 ?2?85 &3 <54 H!/&67A&82 4&@&:& &?4& 23375; (> &1328;&4 &3 <54 94;54 9= ?15 &1328;&4H# 15<8&2:?2==1&3<&2;<45@27@45*52<? 9= D12*1 23 &? H) 15 372? 1&3 (55: =285; 9:
#%##%!# 3 9: ?15 ;&?5 9= ?15 372? H!/&67A&82
- 10 -
4&@&:&&?4&23375;(>&1328;&41&3:9?(55:*&:*5885;
H+/85??54D42??5:(>?15&1328;&4?92:;2*&?53?1&? ?15<982*5<49?5*?29:23&**94;5;?9?15<8&2:?2==?9<49?5*? 123 <93353329: 9A54 372? <49<54?> "#/&43&<<& 1&3 ;5<935; ?1&? ?15 <8&2:?2== 23 2: <93353329: 9= ?15 372? <49<54?> &:; 15 23 *78?2A&?2:6 ?15 3&@5 1545 23 :9 *4933/5H&@2:&?29:9="#1545=945?153&2;5A2;5:*5 9="#45@&2:5;7:*1&885:65;
!. 742:6 <5:;5:*> 9= ?15 372? ?15 3323?&:? 9@@23329:54 1&3 <&335; &: 94;54 &? H ;&?5;
#.!##%!# *&:*5882:6 ?15 64&:? @&;5 2: =&A974 9= <8&2:?2== 15 <8&2:?2== 1&3 *1&885:65; ?15 3&2; 94;54 9= 3323?&:? 9@@23329:54 H (5=945 ?15 5<7?> 9@@23329:54 2: 5A2329: 5?2?29: 9)# #%!)/!+ 15 *9<> 9= ?15 45A2329: <5?2?29: 23 &? H 7(35I75:?8> ?15 <8&2:?2== =285; & @5@9 =94 D2?1;4&D&8 9= 3&2; 45A2329: <5?2?29: &35; 9: ?15 3&2; @5@9 ?15 5<7?> 9@@23329:54;23<935;9=?153&2;45A2329:<5?2?29:15 <8&2:?2== 1&3 *1&885:65; ?15 3&2; 94;54 9= 3323?&:? - 11 -
9@@23329:54 H (5=945 ?123 974? 2:
"9#%#.) #%## 15 ;9*7@5:?3 <49;7*5; 2:;2*&?5 ?1&? ?15 94;54 <&335; (> ?15 3323?&:? 9@@23329:54 H 1&3(55:3?&>5;2:?153&2;D42?<5?2?29:39: ?15;&?59=372??1545D&3:9&:>*897;9:?15?2?859=?15 <8&2:?2==39&3?945856&?512@?9=285372?=94;5*8&4&?29:
! 15 *8&2@ 9= ?15 ;5=5:;&:?3 23 ?1&? ?15> &45 *78?2A&?2:6 ?15 372? 8&:; 7:&7?1942G2;58> &:; ?15 &<<82*&?29: ;&?5; %!%)!--- H' 23 <5:;2:6 *9:32;54&?29:(5=945?15&7?1942?25315372?<49<54?>1&3 :9?(55:64&:?5;?9;5=5:;&:?3
!' 15<8&2:?2==1&3&839<49;7*5;H3'&:;!# <19?964&<13 &:; H!)/ *9:?&2:2:6 ;262?&8 2@&653 9= ?15 <19?964&<13 15 3&2; <19?964&<13 319D ?1&? ?15 <8&2:?2== 23 3?&:;2:6 &:; 15 1&3 ;76 (954D588 2: ?15 372? 8&:; "2?197? *9:32;542:6 &88 ?1535 &3<5*?3 ?15 ,243? <<588&?5974?1&35445;2:45/&<<45*2&?2:6?155A2;5:*5 9: 45*94; &:; 35??2:6 ?15 F7;6@5:? <&335; (> ?15 42&8 974?&:;;23@2332:6?15372?9=?15<8&2:?2==15<8&2:?2==
- 12 -
1&3 <49A5; 123 <93353329: 9A54 ?15 372? <49<54?> : *9:32;542:6?153&@5?1542&8974?1&362A5:2?3=2:;2:6 9: 23375 9! : A25D 9= ?15 &(9A5 ?15 37(3?&:?2&8 I753?29:9=8&D23&:3D545;&**94;2:68>
!- : A25D 9= ?15&(9A5?15F7;6@5:? <&335;(> ?15 ,243? <<588&?5 974? 45I72453 ?9 (5 35? &32;5 &:;
F7;6@5:? <&335; (> ?15 42&8 974? 45I72453 ?9 (5 453?945;5:*5?15=9889D2:6
! 15&<<5&823&889D5;
# 15 2@<76:5; F7;6@5:? &:; ;5*455 ;&?5; %%-#%!-<&335;2:9% &'((>?15 5:2942A287;65&;6242335?&32;5
) 15 F7;6@5:?
&:; ;5*455 ;&?5; %-%-#%!. <&335; 2:
9+) #%!# (> ?15 2A28 7;65 J
,&;62423453?945;
+, (&$&) %! ! #+
K9445*?5;A2;51&@(5494;54;&?5;%)%)#%#.