- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! " # # $%&'( ' $%&% ( ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !* + $ *(! (, &* (! + # + - # ./0123./0456.72890:6;:238<1.8 3<8 /==./> <8 9<>.1 ;? 23. 7850/7@. @:6=/7? /4/<782 23. 5146.72 /71 /A/01 1/2.1 *(! (, <7 :&* (! ;? 23. .7<:0 <B<> 514. /71 /71 11> 3/3/=509:083:02C23.20<;57/>D * 3. @>/<6/72 A/8 /4.1 % ?./08 /71 A/8 1:<74 =0<B/2. E:; /71 A/8 ./07<74 8&((($ =.0 6:723 5. 2: 23.<7E50<.88599.0.1<7/0:/120/99<@/@@<1.72;?23.@>/<6/72 :7 (* (F 23. @>/<6/72 9<>.1 / @>/<6 =.2<2<:7 <7 :&* (! 8..G<74 @:6=.78/2<:7 :9 8 %(((($ 3. 20<;57/>/92.0@:78<1.0<7423..72<0.6/2.0</>:70.@:013/8 - 3 - /A/01.1 / 856 :9 8, ((($ />:74 A<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. :9 FH =.0 /7756 90:6 23. 1/2. :9 =.2<2<:7 2<>> 0./><I/2<:7440<.B.1;?23.8/<15146.72/71/A/0123. 7850/7@.@:6=/7?3/8=0.9.00.123<8/==./>:723.40:571 :9J5/7256:9@:6=.78/2<:7 ' ./07.1 @:578.> 9:0 23. 7850/7@. @:6=/7? 6/<7>? 23/2 1<8/;<><2? /88.88.1 ;? 23. :@2:0 <8 .K@.88<B. .3/87:220./2.123.@>/<6/72./88.88.123.1<8/;<><2?/2 ''H 2: 23. A3:>. ;:1? 3. 20<;57/> 0.>?<74 5=:7 23. 8/<1 .B<1.7@. 3/8@:78<1.0.123. 1<8/;<><2? /2 '(H 3.20<;57/> :54322:3/B.2/G.7*01:9''H+ <87:2/7.K=.02<7 :=323/>6:>:4?.95023.082/2.123/2/8=.023.3<82:0?:9 23. @/8.$83..2 3. 8582/<7.1 <7E50? 15. 2: 9/>> 3.0. <8 7: 0.9.0.7@. 23/2 3. 8582/<7.1 <7E50<.8 <7 23. 0:/1 20/99<@ /@@<1.72 5023.0 23.0. <8 7: 0.@:01.1 7 23. 7.K2 1/? 23. @:6=>/<72 A/8 4<B.7 ;52 <2 A/8 7:2 /==0.@</2.1 =0:=.0>?;?23.20<;57/> % 3. 20<;57/> 3/8 :;8.0B.1 <7 =/0/40/=3 :( 23/2 23. 8544.82<:7 A/8 6/1. ;? 23. 7850/7@. @:6=/7? - 4 - 23/2 23. /@@<1.72 A/8 :@@500.1 15. 2: 0/83 /71 7.4><4.72 0<1.0 :9 6:2:0@?@>. A3<@3 @>./0>? 83:A8 23/2 3. /16<22.1 23. /@@<1.72 /71 @:78<1.0<74 23. @.02<9<.1 @:=? :9 23. @3/04.$83..2 8=:2 6/3/I/0 A:571 @.02<9<@/2. <2 A/8 3.>1 23/2 23. /@@<1.72 :@@500.1 :7>? 15. 2: 23. 0/83 /71 7.4><4.7210<B<74:923.0<1.0:923.6:2:0@?@>.8=.0K' L A:571 @.02<9<@/2. 3. 8582/<7.1 /;0/8<:78 :B.0 0<432 .?.;0:A 0<4329/@. /71 @3<7/;0/8<:7 :B.00<432 G7..;52 >/@.0/2.1 A:571 :B.0 0<432 .?.;0:A /71 5==.0 ><= 90/@250. :990:72/>;:7.<7B:>B<74>.92:0;<2/71I?4:6/2<@/0@3:723. >.928<1.A3<@3/0.40<.B:58<77/250. F >/<6/72 />8: .K/6<7.1 + 3:543 3. 3/8 7:2 20./2.1 23. @>/<6/72 3. /88.88.1 23. 1<8/;<><2? 571.0 K!/71@>./0>?:;8.0B.123/223.0.<8;><717.88<7$.?. 8 =.0 8@/7 3.8582/<7.1 90/@250.:9 5==.0 A/>> :9 2 6/K<>>/0? 8<758 . A/8 /16<22.1 :7 ((* (F /71 1<8@3/04.1 :7 %(* (F /71 A/8 .K/6<7.1 <7 /0/?/7/ .20/>/?/ :7 (* (F . 8582/<7.1 =:82 20/56/2<@ @:7258<:7:9$<720/:0;<2/>8.46.72:9:=2<@7.0B.A<236<>1 @:6=0.88<:7 /2 <72.0/@/77/><@5>/0 @:508. ;? 86/>> - 5 - 3.6/2:6/ /2.0 3. A/8 /16<22.1 <7 23. =:>>: 3:8=<2/> .74/>505 :7 ( (* (F /71 2::G 20./26.72 9:0 ;0/<7 <7E50?20./2.1@:78.0B/2<B.>?/711<8@3/04.1:7%(* (F A3<>. 3. A/8 <7 82/;>. @:71<2<:7 2 A/8 @>./0>? 6.72<:7.1 23/2 >.92 8<1. :=2<@ 7.0B. /20:=3? <8 0.8=:78<;>. 9:0 2:2/> ;><717.88 /71 23. 1<8/;<><2? <8 /88.88.1 /2 (H 2: 6<K.1 @0/7</> 7.0B. 1/6/4. /71 <2 A/8 />8: 82/2.1 23/2 3. 8582/<7.190/@250.:9>.928<1.90:72/>;:7./71>/2.0/>A/>>:9 >.92 6/K<>>/0? 8<758 9:0 A3<@3 (H 1<8/;<><2? A/8 /88.88.1 35823.2:2/>;:1?1<8/;<><2?A/8/88.88.1/8''HA3<@3<8 =.06/7.72<77/250.3.20<;57/>@:78<1.0<7423.7/250.:9 <7E50<.823.=.0<:1:93:8=<2/><I/2<:7/71/>8:@:78<1.0<7423. .B<1.7@.:923.:@2:03/80<432>?@:78<1.0.123.1<8/;<><2?/2 '(H 2: 23. A3:>. ;:1? 3<8 :502 9<718 7: 0./8:7 2: <72.09.0.A<2323.8/<19<71<74 ! 723.0.85>223.9:>>:A<74 < 3. /==./> 9<>.1 ;? 23. 7850/7@. @:6=/7?<81.B:<1:96.0<28/71<8) - 6 - << 3. /6:572 1.=:8<2.1 ;? 23. 7850/7@. @:6=/7? 83/>> ;. 20/786<22.1 2: 23. 20<;57/> 9:023A<23) <<< 3. 7850/7@. @:6=/7? <8 1<0.@2.1 2: 1.=:8<2 23. @:6=.78/2<:7 /6:572 /A/01.1 ;? 23. 20<;57/> />:74 A<23 <72.0.82 A<23<7 / =.0<:1 :9 :7. 6:72390:623.1/2.:923<8:01.0) <B 7 85@3 1.=:8<2 23. @>/<6/7280.8=:71.728 /0. =.06<22.1 2: A<2310/A7 23..72<0./6:572/>:74A<23/@@05.1<72.0.82) )* %$ ' # <82 :> :'F