Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58682 (KAR)
THULASIRAM v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200307/2025 · 2025-11-18
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58682 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58682 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$%
&$'$$ $((
)* )++ ,
!" #$% & #
' ' %
' ' $'
' ' ' ' !(
' ' '
'
' !( & # ) %
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* #% #
% "" (! !" ! ! !* $' #% "#%
"#% "#(% !( $ "! !((#%#%
#
% ! $ $
#% !*
$
+ '
'$ #
+ '
%
,-./001/2-.3-21456/778.149 .11:-;<<=/;>93 5/-28;41=17>-9;*#%93>,193>,17,148214/.>1. /;47,148214=-51.#
=1?1;>-9;93>=97->-1.%7>"" -;017-/2/.1#%9 !*/=-.-;<98>93=-@1 9 !* =1<-.>1=14 56 /;4,- ,9A:
92-71 >/>-9;
-B/6/08= 39= >,1 9331;71. 08;-.,/521 8;41= 17>-9;. #%"#%"#%"#(%!(=1/4A->,17>-9;"! - 3 -
93 ,/=/>-6/ 6/6/ /;,->/ !( /;4 17>-9; (#%#?% 93 >,17,148214/.>1./;47,148214=-51.#
=1?1;>-9;93 >=97->-1.% @1;4@1;> 7> ! #39= .,9=> C>,1 #
% @1;4@1;> 7> !% 01;4-;< 5139=1 >,1 44->-9;/2 -.>=-7> /;4 1..-9;. D 017-/2 84<1 -B/6/08=
,1 <-.> 93 >,1 0=9.178>-9; 7/.1 -. >,/> 9;
! ! !*A,-21>,14171/.14 /?-;4=/A/.0=97114-;< 9; ,-. @9>9=5-:1 >,1 4=-?1= 93 /; ;;9?/ 7/= /221<1426 4=9?1 >,1 ?1,-721 -; / =/., /;4 ;1<2-<1;> @/;;1= /;4 4/.,14 /</-;.> >,1 ,-;4 09=>-9; 93 >,1 @9>9=5-:1 . / =1.82>>,14171/.14312249A;/;4A/.4=/<<1439=.9@1 4-.>/;71 > -. .>/>14 >,/> >,=11 -;4-?-48/2. A->;1..14 >,1 -;7-41;>21/4-;<>9=1<-.>=/>-9;93=-@19 !*
( ; ! !*>,1-;39=@/;>294<14/.179;4 -;39=@/>-9; 5139=1 >,1 /;4,- ,9A:
92-71 >/>-9;
-B/6/08=/</-;.>>,10=1.1;>/00122/;>/778.149 /;4 9>,1=. /221<-;< 79@@-..-9; 93 >,1 9331;71 08;-.,/521
- 4 -
8;41=17>-9;!(93>,1,/=/>-6/6/6//;,->/!( /.149;>,-.=-@19 !*7/@1>951=1<-.>1=14 ,1 ;?1.>-</>-;< 33-71= =126-;< 9; >,1 38=>,1= .>/>1@1;>.93161A->;1..1.7->14/. $. >9!/;49; >,1 /221<14 79;31..-9;/2 .>/>1@1;> 93 >,1 /00122/;> /00=1,1;414>,179/778.14/;4,/.3-214/7,/=<1.,11>
* 1/=;14 1;-9= 98;.12 /001/=-;< 39= >,1 /00122/;>.85@->.>,/>>,199=4-;/>11;7,,/./2=1/46 <=/;>14 5/-2 >9 /778.14 9. >9 /</-;.> A,9@ .-@-2/= /221</>-9;./=1@/41/;4A,9A1=1/4@->>1426>,14=-?1= /;4 -;@/>1. 93 >,1 9331;4-;< 7/= ?-41 9=41=. 4/>14 !( ! -; =-@-;/2 001/2 9 !!!*! /;4 ! ! !-; =-@-;/2
1>->-9; 9 !!! ;?->-;< />>1;>-9; >9 59>, >,1 3-=.> /;4 >,1 .85.1E81;> /221<-;< @8=41= ,1 .85@->. >,/> >,1 /00122/;> ,/. 511; -@02-7/>14 .92126 9; >,1 5/.-. 93 ,1/=./6 .>/>1@1;>. 41.0->151-;</4@->>14-;>,1,9.0->/29;>,14/>193>,1 /221<14/77-41;> 179;>1;4.>,/>/0026-;<>,10=-;7-021 930/=->6>,1/00122/;>A,9A/.;9>0=1.1;>/>>,1.09>/. - 5 -
01=>,10=9.178>-9;7/.1-./2.91;>->214>95/-20/=>-782/=26 /.,1-.-;B84-7-/278.>946.-;71 ! !* >-.38=>,1= .85@->>14 >,/> >,1 /00122/;> -. A-22-;< >9 /5-41 56 /;6 .>=-;<1;> 79;4->-9;. A-22 ;9> -;482<1 -; .-@-2/= /7>-?->-1. /;4A-22;9>>/@01=A->,>,10=9.178>-9;7/.1
21/=;14 -<, 98=> 9?1=;@1;> 21/41=.>=9;<269009.1.>,101>->-9;79;>1;4-;<>,/>>,1 /00122/;>/778.149 ,/.7=-@-;/2/;>17141;>./;4-./ 0=-@1 .8.017> -; >,1 /221<14 @8=41= 93 /?-;4=/ > -. .85@->>14>,/>>,-.-.;9>/3->7/.139=<=/;>935/-2/>>,-. .>/<1 /;4 >,1 /00122/;> 98<,> >9 3/71 >=-/2 /. /; 8;41=>=-/20=-.9;1= >-.38=>,1=.85@->>14>,/>/.@/;6/. 3-?17=-@-;/27/.1./=101;4-;</</-;.>>,1/00122/;>
.01=>,10=9.178>-9;->.123>,1/00122/;>A/. ;9> >=/?122-;< -; >,1 9331;4-;< ;;9?/ >,/> 7/8.14 >,1 /77-41;> ,1 99=4-;/>1 1;7, A,-21 =131==-;< >9 >,1 7,/=<1.,11>@/>1=-/2.,/./2=1/4695.1=?14>,/>>,1>1.> -41;>-3-7/>-9; 0/=/41 79;487>14 56 >,1 ;?1.>-</>-;<
- 6 -
33-71= .8331=.
3=9@ 38;4/@1;>/2 32/A. ,1 =179=4. /2.9 -;4-7/>1 >,/> >,1 79/778.14 A1=1 /00=1,1;414 9; >,1 5/.-. 93 >,1 /00122/;>F. /221<14 79;31..-9;/2 .>/>1@1;> ,98<, >,1 21/=;14 -<, 98=> 9?1=;@1;>
21/41= 1@0,/.-G1. >,/> >,1 /00122/;> ,/. /;>17141;>. >,-. 79;>1;>-9; -. @1> 56 >,1 21/=;14 1;-9= 98;.12 56 09-;>-;< 98> >,/> >,1 4171/.14 >99 ,/4 /;>17141;>. /;4 @82>-0217/.1.=1<-.>1=14/</-;.>,-@
H 9A>,/>>,17,/=<1.,11>-.3-214/;4-;?-1A 93 >,1 3/7> >,/> >,1 79/778.14 A,9 /=1 /221<14 >9 ,/?1 511; 4-=17>26 -;?92?14 -; 7/8.-;< >,1 41/>, 93 >,1 4171/.14560=9B17>-;<->/./;/77-41;>,/?1/2=1/46511; 1;2/=<14 9; 5/-2 >,1 /00122/;> 7/;;9> 51 >=1/>14 4-331=1;>26@1=1269;>,15/.-.93/221</>-9;.93/;-@9.->6 A,-7, /=1 >,1@.12?1. =13217>14 9;26 -; >,1 .179;4 79@02/-;>294<1456>,1-;39=@/;>
,1 0=9.178>-9; 7/.1 =1.>. 1;>-=126 9; 7-=78@.>/;>-/2 1?-41;71 ,1 /221</>-9; 93 /;-@9.->6
- 7 -
51>A11; >,1 /00122/;> /;4 >,1 4171/.14 A-22 ,/?1 >9 51 0=9?14 48=-;< >=-/2 $,1; >,1 99=4-;/>1 1;7, ,/. /2=1/46 ,124 >,/> >,1 >1.> -41;>-3-7/>-9; 0/=/41 -. 38;4/@1;>/22632/A14>,1=1@/-;-;</221</>-9;/</-;.>>,1 /00122/;> =1.>. 9;26 9; >,1 -;39=@/;>F. .8.0-7-9; /=-.-;< 98> 93 0=1?-98. .783321 51>A11; >,1 /00122/;> /;4 >,1 4171/.14 ,1.1 /=1 @/>>1=. 39= >=-/2 ; >,1 2-<,> 93 >,1 @/>1=-/2.02/7149;=179=4>,-.98=>-.93>,179;.-41=14 ?-1A>,/>>,1/00122/;>-.1;>->214>9511;2/=<149;5/-2 3 .>=-;<1;> 79;4->-9;. /=1 -@09.14 ;9 0=1B84-71 A-22 51 7/8.14 >9 >,1 0=9.178>-9; ,-. 98=> /2.9 3-;4. -> /00=90=-/>1>9-@09.1/44->-9;/2./31<8/=4.>91;.8=1>,/> >,1 /00122/;> 491. ;9> -;482<1 -; .-@-2/= 9331;71. 48=-;< >,101;41;7693>=-/2
" 9=>,139=1<9-;<=1/.9;.>,139229A-;<9=41=-. 0/..14
,1=-@-;/2001/2-./229A14
- 8 -
,1-@08<;149=41=4/>14(! !" !0/..1456>,1 44->-9;/2 -.>=-7> /;4 1..-9;. 84<1 /;4 017-/2 84<1 -B/6/08= -; =2 -.7 9 ! -;.93/= /. -> =1B17>.>,15/-2/002-7/>-9;93>,1/00122/;>/778.149 -.,1=156.1>/.-41 ,1 /00122/;>/778.14 9 -. 4-=17>14 >9 51 1;2/=<14 9; 5/-2 -; =-@1 9 !* 93 /;4,- ,9A:
92-71 >/>-9; -B/6/08= =1<-.>1=14 39= >,1 9331;71. 08;-.,/5218;41=17>-9;.#%"#%"#%"#(% !(=1/4A->,17>-9;"!93>,1,/=/>-6/6/6//;,->/ !(/;48;41=17>-9;(#%#?%93>,17,148214/.>1. /;4 7,148214 =-51. #
=1?1;>-9; 93 >=97->-1.% @1;4@1;> 7> ! 01;4-;< 5139=1 >,1 44->-9;/2 -.>=-7> /;4 1..-9;. 84<1 /;4 017-/2 84<1 -B/6/08= -; 017-/2 /.1 #% 9 !* .85B17> >9 >,1 39229A-;<79;4->-9;. /% ,1/00122/;>.,/221I178>1/01=.9;/259;439= /.8@93 . !!!!!A->,>A9.8=1>-1.39=>,1 2-:1.8@>9>,1./>-.3/7>-9;93>,1B8=-.4-7>-9;/2 98=>
- 9 -
5% ,1/00122/;>.,/22/001/=5139=1>,1=-/298=> 9; /22 ,1/=-;< 4/>1. 8;21.. .017-3-7/226 1I1@0>1439=?/2-4=1/.9;. 7% ,1 /00122/;> .,/22 ;9> 4-=17>26 9= -;4-=17>26 >,=1/>1; -;3281;71 9= >/@01= A->, >,1 0=9.178>-9;A->;1..1.
4% ; ?-1A 93 >,1 .85@-..-9; 56 >,1 21/=;14 -<, 98=> 9?1=;@1;> 21/41= =1</=4-;< >,1 /00122/;>F. /;>17141;>. -> -. 38=>,1= 4-=17>14 >,/>>,1/00122/;>.,/22;9>79@@->/;6.-@-2/= 9331;71. 01;4-;< >=-/2 /;4 .,/22 ;9> -;>-@-4/>1 >,1 79@02/-;/;> $ 9= /;6 9>,1= @/>1=-/2 0=9.178>-9;A->;1..1. -* )$$+ '
-.>9 29