- 1 - !"! #$" % $ &' &()* & )) + ! ! "#$ !!# % & ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #$ & () (' ( * ( + ( ,! ( ( - & ' ( ( . . / &. / ' 0123 24 15067 833191:4 ;012:03 <8=:60; >82 ?70 @0?4?48:026 24 191312 7171A=334: ;012:03 4B7 8=2? 8C02:90:? ;01302 >82 ?70 ?1?0 1:3 24 74C1:1:3 1??1:1670??4;012:03<8=:60;>82?70206@8:30:? 8 70@2060:?@0?4?48:46>4;03=:30260<?48:*8>?70830 8>2494:1;28<03=20D4?7?70>8;;8D4:B@21E02. !" # $% &' ((( - 3 - ) * +" ,+-. +/0 1 !" - 1 !" " " % 2 2 2 ( $ " " 3" 0(4 !"# $% &' ((( ) * +" ,+-. +/0 1 !"- 51 !"6 (1<?68>?70<1604:A240>D74<7120=?986?:0<06612E>82 346@861;8>?70@2060:?@0?4?48:12016=:302. <89@;14:? <190 ?8 A0 ;83B03 AE 4331@@1 =5124 D4?7 451E1@=21 8;4<0 ?1?48: 8: !! D74<7 D16 20B46?0203 4: 2490 8,! >82 ?70 8>>0:<06 @=:4671A;0 =:3020<?48:6!!,1:3!8>?70:341:0:1;830 46? 8> ?70 <89@;14:? 1C0290:?6 D8=;3 20C01; ?71? <89@;14:1:? 1:3 8?7026 713 >82903 1 8: 8C02:90:? 2B1:4F1?48: 4: ?70 :190 1:3 6?E;0 G- &08@;0 2B1:4F1?48:>8216?0 1:3:C428:90:?0B0:021?48:' # 89@;14:1:?A04:B?700<20?12E8>?706143 8@0:03 1: 1<<8=:? 4: H46 1:I 161C067D121 42<;0 21:<7 451E1@=21 8D: ? 46 746 6@0<4>4< <160 ?71? ?70 6143 20<04C06 38:1?48:6 >289 ?70 38:826 1:3 >289 6=<7 198=:? ?70E120=:302?1I4:B30C0;8@90:?1<?4C4?4064:?702=21;12016 - 4 - 70: ?70 91??02 6?883 ?7=6 8:0 21:4; 2134@ 784?0 &@0?4?48:02 8 70204:' 1@@281<703 ?70 <89@;14:1:? 4: 0<09A02 ! 8C02 98A4;0 ?0;0@78:0 1:3 4:?283=<03 8:0 94?7 =9121 191 D78 46 4:3=;B03 4: B0??4:B 38:1?48:6 ?8 82B1:4F1?48:6;4I0?71?8>?70<89@;14:1:? $ ? 46 >=2?702 1;;0B03 4: ?70 <89@;14:? ?71? @0?4?48:026 4:>82903?70<89@;14:1:??71?120@2060:?1?4C08>G=4201371<7 <8?0<7:341C? ?3-D8=;3A078;34:B1900?4:B4::341?8 D82I 8=? ?70 38:1?48:6 >289 >8204B: <8=:?2406 1:3 >82 82B1:4F4:B6=<7900?4:B6 :0036?8900??700H@0:606 * 6@02?70166=21:<0B4C0:AE?70@0?4?48:02616=98> 6!!!!!! D16 @143 AE ?70 <89@;14:1:? ?8 G 82;3 :?02:1?48:1;89@1:E-1??704:6?1:<08>@0?4?48:0261:394?7 =9121191?728=B7 , 8D0C02 1>?02 20<04@? 8> 6143 6=9 8> 6!!!!!! ?7020D16:8206@8:60>289?70@0?4?48:026?8?70<89@;14:1:? 1:3 =;?491?0;E 1>?02 D14?4:B >82 6=>>4<40:? ?490 <89@;14:1:? <190 ?8 I:8D ?71? ?70 716 A00: <701?03 AE ?70 @0?4?48:026 1:3 8?7026 ? 46 6?1?03 ?71? 8:;E 1 6=9 8> 6#!!! 716A00:20@143?8?70<89@;14:1:? - 5 - ! 1603 8: ?70 <89@;14:? @8;4<0 20B46?0203 1 <160 1:3 4:C06?4B1?03?7091??02 :?70901:?490@0?4?48:02671C01@@281<703?7468=2? 600I4:B J=1674:B 8> ?70 @28<0034:B6 8: ?70 B28=:3 ?71? 6!!!!!! 46 20@143 8: !,! 1:3 ?7020>820 <8:?4:=1?48:8>?70<2494:1;@28<0034:B646?8?1;;E=:D1221:?03 1:3D8=;3206=;?4:1A=608>@28<0668>;1D 02<8:?21241913127171A=334:;012:03 4B78=2? 8C02:90:? ;01302 1:3 24 74C1:1:3 1??1:1670??4 ;012:03 <8=:60; >82 ?70 206@8:30:? 8 8@@860 ?70 @0?4?48: @21E02AE<8:?0:34:B?71?20@1E90:?8>?70198=:?D8=;3:8? 20:302?70<2494:1;<89@;14:?4:>2=<?=8=64:C40D8> 60??;03@24:<4@;068>;1D0:=:<41?03AE?70 8:-A;0@0H8=2? 4: ?70 <160 8> 20@82?03 4: 1:368=B7?>8234694661;8>?70@0?4?48: 1C4:B 70123 ?70 12B=90:?6 8> A8?7 64306 ?746 8=2? @02=603?7091?0241;8:20<82390?4<=;8=6;E : 6=<7 @02=61; 8> ?70 91?0241; 8: 20<823 4? 46 <2E6?1; <;012?71?198=:?D16?21:6>02203>289 ?8?70@0?4?48:026 - 6 - 1:3?8?70G82;3:?02:1?48:1;89@1:E-8:?70166=21:<08> ?70@0?4?48:02670204: # 838=A?198=:?466=A60J=0:?;E20@143=?4?46:8D 60??;03 @24:<4@;0 8> ;1D ?71? 9020 20@1E90:? 8> ?70 198=:? 1>?02 <701?4:B D8=;3 :8? 0>>1<0 ?70 <2494:1;4?E 4:C8;C034:?704:<430:? 0?71?164?91E4?46>82?70@12?406?8D82I8=??7042 206@0<?4C0 20903E A0>820 ?70 241; 8=2? AE >4;4:B :0<06612E 1@@;4<1?48:4>?702046?2=060??;090:?A0?D00:?70<89@;14:1:? 1:3@0?4?48:02670204: $ 0602C4:B 6=<7 ;4A02?E ?746 8=2? 46 8> ?70 <8:6430203 8@4:48:?71??70@0?4?48:20;40><1::8?A0B21:?03 * 0:<0?70>8;;8D4:B. 0?4?48:46 ,* &% ) " I<9 46? 8.; 8., .