- 1 - !!" !!#!$ % $&"$"$ '$( ! "" # ! " ! # $ % & % % # $ % % %' ( % Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ) ' '( " "% % % # % % $ *" ! !*" # +,-,-./+0 12-32 -4 56578059- -:50 5:9-0- . .;+05,-<+-6=0.:83+04.3-+,-+4/-./,:0+;0+4+/,+: 7> -,4 5/59-/9 -0+3,.0 -4 7+?.0+ ,2-4 .80, 7+-/9 5990-+<+: 7> ,2+ .0:+0 :5,+: ;544+: -/ .)' ./ ,2+ ?-6+ .? ::-,-./56 +/-.0 -<-6 "8:9+5/:"%56578059-!?.042.0,@,2+%-04,;;+665,+ .80,A#7>12-3212-6+566.1-/9,2+45-:5;;+56?-6+:7>,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .BB-44-./+0 -,> .0;.05,-./ 56578059- ,2+ %-04, ;;+665,+ .80, 254 4+, 54-:+ ,2+ .0:+0 :5,+: '' ;544+: ./ 5;;6-35,-./ -/ . ?-6+: 8/:+0 - 3 - 0:+0 CD 86+ 5/: .? .:+ .? -<-6 0.3+:80+ !?.0 42.0, @*# -/ .')C ./ ,2+ ?-6+ .? ::-,-./56-<-6"8:9+E"%56578059- 2+354+.?,2+;+,-,-./+0-4,25,-,-456+44++-/ 0+4;+3,.?65/:7+50-/9>.B+5480-/9530+4 98/,54 .? 5;8/80 <-6659+ 56578059- -4,0-3, 5/: 568=5 25<-/9.7,5-/+:-/,+0B4.?6+54+.?,2+>+50D?.0,2+ ;+0-.: .? C >+504 +F,+/:576+ ?.0 ?80,2+0 ;+0-.: .? C >+504 25, ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 .3-+,> 254 +4,576-42+: B-6= ;0.:83,-./8/-,41-,2-/,2+45-:65/: C 25, ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ 25: ;0.;.4+: ,. ;8, 8; 3./4,083,-./ .? <+/:-/9 G./+ 50.8/: ,2+ ;0.;+0,>.?,2+;+,-,-./+0+,-,-./+025:.7H+3,+:?.0,2+ 45B+ 7> -448-/9 5 6+,,+0 :5,+: D 2+ 51 -/-4,+0 25: -/,+0<+/+: 5/: 25: ;0+<+/,+: 4832 3./4,083,-./ 7+-/9 ,5=+/ 8; 7> ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ .1+<+0 ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ 595-/ -/ 8984, C ;0.3++:+: ,. ;8, 8; 3./4,083,-./ 50.8/: - 4 - ,2+ 3.B;.8/: 1566 .? ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 3./4,05-/-/9 ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0,.?-6+,2+57.<+48-,4++=-/90+6-+?.?;+0B5/+/, -/H8/3,-./ ' 2+0-56.80,7>.0:+0:5,+:''25: 566.1+: ,2+ 5;;6-35,-./ -/ . ?-6+: 8/:+0 0:+0 CD 86+5/:905/,-/9,2+-/,+0-B.0:+0544.892,?.0 7> ,2+ ;65-/,-?? 0+4,05-/-/9 ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ ?0.B ;8,,-/9 8; 3./4,083,-./ ,-66 ,2+ :-4;.456 .? ,2+ 48-, +-/95990-+<+:,2+.0;.05,-./25:;0+?+00+:,2+5;;+56 -/ .)' 7> 4+,,-/9 54-:+ ,2+ .0:+0 :5,+: ' 5/: :-4B-44+: ,2+ 5;;6-35,-./ +-/9 5990-+<+:7>,2+45B+,2+;0+4+/,;+,-,-./-4?-6+: +50/+: 3.8/4+6 5;;+50-/9 ?.0 ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 ,5=-/9 ,2-4 .80, ,20.892 ,2+ 0+3.0:4 487B-,4 ,25, ,2+ 3./4,083,-./ 7+-/9 ;8, 8; 7> ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ .8,4-:+,2+3.B;.8/:1566.?,2+;+,-,-./+01.86:.74,083, ,2+ -/90+44 5/: +90+44 -/,+0<+/+)-/,+0?+0+ -/ -,4 ;0.:83,-./53,-<-,>I,25,,2+;+,-,-./+0-4564.-/,+/:-/9,. - 5 - .;+/5/:+4,576-425/ 3+0+5B506.8054-,47>;0.:83, 12-32 1.86: 7+ 5:<+04+6> 5??+3,+: 2+ ?80,2+0 487B-,4 ,25,,2+0-56.80,25:,5=+//.,+.?,2+4+54;+3,4.?,2+ B5,,+0 12-6+ 566.1-/9 ,2+ 5;;6-35,-./ 12-32 254 7++/ /+95,+: 7> ,2+ %-04, ;;+665,+ .80, 1-,2.8, ,2+0+ 7+-/9 5/> <56-: 0+54./ 15005/,-/9 -/,+0?+0+/3+ 5, ,2+ 25/:4 .? ,2-4.80, / 0+4;./4+ 6+50/+: 3.8/4+6 0-.80-42 25425B;80 5;;+50-/9 ?.0 ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ 487B-,4,25,,2+<+0>354+?-6+:7>,2+;+,-,-./+0-,4+6?-4 /.,B5-/,5-/576+-/54B83254,2+0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ -4 /., ;8,,-/9 8; 5/> 3./4,083,-./ ./ 5/> ;.0,-./ .? ;0.;+0,> 7+6./9-/9 ,. ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 -/54B832 54 ,2+ +/,-0++F,+/,.?530+498/,54.?65/:-4+/36.4+:7> 5 3.B;.8/: 1566 2+ ;+,-,-./+0 254 /. ,. J8+4,-./ ,2+ 3./4,083,-./ 53,-<-,-+4 7+-/9 8/:+0,5=+/ 7> ,2+0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ - 6 - & +?80,2+0487B-,4,25,,2+45-:<+/:-/9G./+-4 7+-/9 -B;6+B+/,+: -/ ,+0B4 .? ,2+ :-0+3,-./ .? ,2+ .<+0/B+/, ,. ;0.<-:+ 5/: ;0.,+3, ,2+ -/,+0+4, .? ,2+ 4,0++, <+/:.04 + ?80,2+0 487B-,4 ,25, 7+?.0+ ,5=-/9 8; ,2+1.0=.?3./4,083,-./.?<+/:-/9G./+:8+;876-35,-./4 1+0+-448+:3566-/9?.0,2+.7H+3,-./+,-,-./+02+0+-/25: /.,0+4;./:+:,.,2+45B+2+0+?.0+2+487B-,4,25,,2+ 0-56 .80, 25: +00+: -/ /., ,5=-/9 /.,+ .? ,2-4 B5,,+0 12-32 254 7++/ 4+, 0-92, 7> ,2+ %-04, ;;+665,+ .80, 15005/,-/9/.-/,+0?+0+/3++/3+;05>+:?.0:-4B-4456.? 10-,;+,-,-./ +50:+084+:,2+0+3.0:4 D / 5 J8+0> 7> ,2-4 .80, 6+50/+: 3.8/4+6 ?.0 ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ 54 1+66 54 6+50/+: ::-,-./56 .<+0/B+/, :<.35,+ 487B-,,+: ,25, ,2+ 3./4,083,-./ .? <+/:-/9G./+-4,5=+/8;-/?80,2+05/3+,.,2+;0.<-4-./4 .? ,2+ ,0++, +/:.04 !0.,+3,-./ .? -<+6-2..: 5/: +9865,-./ .? ,0++, +/:-/9# 3, ' !?.0 42.0, @,2+ - 7 - 3, 'A# +08456 .? ,2+ 45-: 3, ' 1.86: -/:-35,+ ,25, ,2+ @6.356 58,2.0-,>A 5/: @;65//-/9 58,2.0-,>A 54 :+?-/+: 8/:+0 ,2+ 45-: 3, ' 25<+ 7++/ <+4,+: 1-,2 ,2+ ;.1+0 ,. 0+9865,+ ,2+ 4,0++, <+/:-/9 564. ;0.<-:-/9 432+B+ ?.0 ;0.<-:-/9 ?53-6-,-+4 12-6+ 0+9865,-/9 ,2+ 4,0++, <+/:-/9 2+ 45-: 3, ' ?80,2+0 ;0.<-:+4 ,2+ 0-92,4 5/: .76-95,-./4 ,. 4,0++, <+/:.04 0+6.35,-./ 5/: +<-3,-./ .?4,0++,<+/:.04 ,564.;0.<-:+4?.0,2+:-4;8,+0+:0+4456 B+325/-4B -/368:-/9 5/> ;+04./ 5990-+<+: 7> ,2+ 45-: ;0.3+4435/564.5;;0.532,2+?.08B;0.<-:+:,2+0+8/:+0 2+0+?.0+ -, 35//., 7+ 45-: ,25, ,2+ 53,-./ 7+-/9 -B;6+B+/,+: 7> ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ -4 ./+ 1-,2.8,58,2.0-,> /5/>+<+/,,2+<+/:-/9G./+-47+-/9 :+3650+: 5/: +50B50=+: 7> ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ 5:B-,,+:6> ./ ,2+ ;0.;+0,> 7+6./9-/9 ,. ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./5/:-/?80,2+05/3+,.,2+.7H+3,.?3,' 0+?+00+:,.57.<+ 2.892 ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 254 365-B+: ,25, 4832 -B;6+B+/,5,-./.?432+B+5/:3./4,083,-./.?,2+<+/:-/9 - 8 - G./+ 254 .74,083,+: ,2+ 0-92, .? ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 12-32 -4 487H+3,B5,,+0,.48-,,2-4.80,0+?05-/?0.BB5=-/95/> .74+0<5,-./ ,2+0+./ 4-/3+ ,2+ B5,,+0 -4 487H8:-3+ /54B832 54 ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 -4 05-4-/9 ,2+ -448+ .? 4832 3./4,083,-./ 3584-/9 -/,+0?+0+/3+ -/ ,2+ /5,80+ .? .74,083,-/9 ?0++ -/90+44 5/: +90+44 .? ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 -/,. ,2+?53,.0>12-32-43800+/,6>;0.:83-/9,2+B-6=5/:564. ,2+-/,+/:+:8459+.?-,4.1/;0.;+0,>?53-/9,2+0.5:,. ;8, 8; 3./4,083,-./ ,2-4 .80, -4 .? ,2+ 3./4-:+0+: <-+1 ,25, ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 -4 5, 6-7+0,> ,. +F;0+44)0+:0+44 -,4 90-+<5/3+8/:+0,2+;0.<-4-./4.?,2+3,'7>B5=-/9 50+;0+4+/,5,-./7+?.0+,2+5;;+665,+58,2.0-,>54;0.<-:+: ,2+0+8/:+0 12-32 42566 3./4-:+0 ,2+ 45B+ -/ 533.0:5/3+ 1-,2651 40+950:,.,2+B+0-,4.0.,2+01-4+,2+.0:+0 ;544+:7>,2+%-04,;;+665,+.80,,2-4.80,:./.,?-/: 5/>90.8/:5,,2-4H8/3,80+,.-/,+0?+0++4+0<-/96-7+0,> ,.,2+;+,-,-./+0,.?-6+48320+;0+4+/,5,-./1-,2-/:5>4 ?0.B,2+:5,+.?0+3+-;,.?53+0,-?-+:3.;>.?,2-4.0:+0,. - 9 - ,2+ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ 1-,2 ?80,2+0 :-0+3,-./ ,. 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ ,. 3./4-:+0 ,2+ 45B+ 1-,2-/ C :5>4,2+0+5?,+05/:,.3.BB8/-35,+,2+.0:+0,5=-/9-/,. 3./4-:+05,-./ ,2+ 0+J8-0+B+/, .? 651 5/: 564. ,2+ -/3./<+/-+/3+ 7+-/9 +F;0+44+: 7> ,2+ ;+,-,-./+0 ;544 0+54./+:5;;0.;0-5,+.0:+0-/,2+B5,,+0 -66 4832 .0:+0 -4 ;544+: 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ 42566 /., ,5=+ 5/> ;0+3-;-,5,-<+ 4,+;4 -/ ,2+ ;0.3+44 .? -,4 3./4,083,-./ ?0.B ,.:5> ./150:4 ,-66 3./4-:+05,-./.?,2+0+;0+4+/,5,-./54:-0+3,+:57.<+ C , -4 B5:+ 36+50 ,25, 5?,+0 ;544-/9.? .0:+0 ./ 4832 0+;0+4+/,5,-./ 0+4;./:+/, .0;.05,-./ 1-66 ;0.3++: -/533.0:5/3+1-,2651 ")* '$"$( &! C