Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58666 (KAR)
KHYAMANNA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.RP/200062/2021 · 2025-07-14
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58666 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58666 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#"
$%# &
%&
'
()'*+,! ' ++ -
!"#
$
!"#
$
%&'
("
)
""%#"#
' #"&
) )
%""% #"* "("##"&
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#'& %"(
+'
,
)
,
)
-./0 /1 213.42./.5. -006 7-./5-0 89:54-7 ;9/ <2- =-<1<195-/ .50 7-./5-0 1>2 9:/< 93-/5?-5< 7-.0-/;9/<2-/-4=950-5<!<.<- # 2- /-314195 =-<1<195-/ 14 <2- .88:4-0 @29 2.4 4:;;-/-0 .5 9/0-/ 9; 895318<195 ;9/ <2- 9;;-58-4 =:5142.A7- :50-/ -8<1954 #'& %"( 9; .50 +' 9; 501.5 9<9/ -2187-48<.504-5<-58-0.4:50-/
! "# $%&' ( ! )*"+,'
'
- -
. . / . 0 ( )%%% 1
0
- 3 -
- . . . ) . ! "#
'
- -
. . 0
0 ( )%%%% 1
0
- . . . . ! $%&'
'
0 ( %% 1 0
-
. . . ) 0
! )*"+,'
'
0
2 0
3 % 2- 3.7101<6 9; <2- 9/0-/ 9; 895318<195 .50 4-5<-58- @.4 82.77-5>-0 A-;9/- <2- ;1/4< .==-77.<- 9:/< 15 /1?15.7==-.79' #"& ( -./5-0 ):0>- 15 <2- ;1/4< .==-77.<- 9:/< .;<-/ 4-8:/15> <2- /-89/04 2-./0 <2- ./>:?-5<4 9; <2- =./<1-4 15 0-<.17 .50 A6 ):0>?-5< 0.<-0 ""%#"# 014?144-0 <2-
- 4 -
.==-.79;<2-/-314195=-<1<195-/.50895;1/?-0<2-9/0-/9; 895318<195.504-5<-58-
-15>;:/<2-/.>>/1-3-0A6<2-4.?-<2-.88:4-0 14A-;9/-<2149:/<15<214/-314195=-<1<195 * /1213.42./.5. -0067-./5-089:54-7;9/<2- /-314195 =-<1<195-/ /-1<-/.<15> <2- >/9:504 :/>-0 15 <2- =-<1<195895<-50-0<2.<A9<2<2-9:/<42.3-59<=/9=-/76 .==/-81.<-0 <2- ?.<-/1.7 -310-58- 95 /-89/0 .50 @/95>76 895318<-0<2-.88:4-0;9/<2-.;9/-4.109;;-58-4.5049:>2< ;9/.779@15><2-/-314195=-<1<195 ' 7<-/5.<13-76 /1 213.42./.5. -006 @9:70 895<-50<2.<15<2--3-5<<2149:/<:=297015><2-9/0-/9; 895318<195 A6 -52.5815> <2- ;15- .?9:5< 9/0-/ 9; 1?=/1495?-5<?.6A-4-<.410-.5049:>2<;9/.779@15><2- /-314195=-<1<195 + -/ 895</. 7-./5-0 1>2 9:/< 93-/5?-5< 7-.0-/ 4:==9/<4 <2- 1?=:>5-0 ):0>?-5<4 .50 895<-504 <2.< <2-/- 14 59 8.4- ?.0- 9:< A6 <2- .88:4-0 -1<2-/ ;9/
- 5 -
4-<<15> .410- <2- 895318<195 9/0-/ 9/ /-0:815> <2- 4-5<-58- .5049:>2<;9/014?144.79;<2-/-314195=-<1<19515<9<9 & .315>2-./0<2-./>:?-5<4;/9?A9<2410-4<214 9:/<=-/:4-0<2-?.<-/1.795/-89/0?-<18:79:476
"
5 4:82 =-/:4.7 9; <2- ?.<-/1.7 95 /-89/0 1< 14 8/64<.787-./<2.<.89?=7.15<8.?-<9A-790>-015/-4=-8< 9; . /9.0 </.;;18 .8810-5< 988://-0 95 %"#"* .< .A9:< *""=?@2-/-15.79//6A-./15>9!#+!!(*(0.42-0 .>.154<.?9<9/8687-A-./15>/->14</.<1959!%#!)!+"% 5-./
@.?6 9?=7-B .50 A-8.:4- 9; <2- 1?=.8< 9; <2- .8810-5< /10-/ 9; <2- ?9<9/8687- A6 5.?- ).>.55.<2 C ).>.==. .50 =177195 /10-/ .2.0-3.==. 2.3- 4:4<.15-0 >/1-39:4 15D:/1-4 95 <2- 31<.7 =./<4 9; <2-1/ A906 .4 @-77 .4 4:88:?A-0 <9 <2- 15D:/1-4 95 <2- 4=9< 1<4-7; 5 /-8-1=< 9; ?-44.>- 9; /9.0 </.;;18 .8810-5< @1;- 9; <2- 0-8-.4-0 ).>.55.<2 C ).>.==. 8.?- <9 <2- 4=9< .50 .
89?=7.15< 8.?- <9 A- 790>-0 .50 =9718- .;<-/ <29/9:>2 153-4<1>.<195 ;17-082./>-!42--<
- 6 -
5 /-8-1=< 9; <2- 82./>-!42--< 7-./5-0 </1.7 .>14</.<-<99E89>51F.58-.504-8:/-0<2-=/-4-58-9;<2- .88:4-0 .50 .;<-/ 0:- </1.7 895318<-0 <2- .88:4-0 59<15> <2.< <2- .88:4-0 @.4 <2- 0/13-/ 9; <2- 9;;-5015> 79//6 .50 2-01059<2.3-.56-B=7.5.<195<99;;-/;9/<2-0-.<29;<@9 =-/4954@29./-<2-/10-/.50=177195/10-/9;<2-?9<9/8687- A-./15>9!%#!)!+"%95.889:5<9;/.42.505->71>-5< 0/1315>9;<2-79//6A-./15>9!#+!!(*(95%"#"* .<*""=?5-./
@.?69?=7-B # -./5-0 ):0>- 15 <2- ;1/4< .==-77.<- 9:/< /-! .==/-81.<-0<2-.;9/-4.10-310-58-.50895;1/?-0<2-9/0-/ 9;895318<195 % 5 <2- 71>2< 9; <2- /-314195.7 >/9:504 <214 9:/< /-!.==/-81.<-0 <2- ?.<-/1.7 -310-58- 95 /-89/0 5 =-/:4.7 9; 4:82 ?.<-/1.7 -310-58- 95 /-89/0 1< 14 59<-0 <2.< .=./< ;/9? 89?=7.15< <2- =/94-8:<195 /-71-0 95 <2- -310-58- 9;
!.5D:5.<2 .50 * 2.>.??. @29 2.3- 59< 9576 @1<5-44-0 <2- .8810-5< .50 .749 15;9/?-0 <2- @1;- 9; <2- 0-8-.4-0 .A9:< <2- 15810-5< .50 <2-6 0-=94-0 A-;9/- <2-
- 7 -
9:/<@1<2>/.=2180-<.174.4<9@2.<</.54=1/-095<2-0.<- 9;15810-5<.50@21824<990<2-4-./8215>8/944!-B.?15.<195 95A-2.7;9;<2-.88:4-0 ( :/<2-/ <2-/- 14 59 014=:<- <2.< <2- .88:4-0 14 0/13-/ 9; <2- 79//6 @2182 8.?- ;/9? .F4:7<.5=:/ /9.0 <9@./04<2-;17<-/A-0.508977:0-0.>.154<<2-?9<9/8687-
/9@515> .77 <2-4- .4=-8<4 9; <2- ?.<<-/ <2-/- @.459-B=7.5.<195@2.<49-3-/9;;-/-0A6<2-.88:4-059/ <2-/- @.4 .56 @/1<<-5 4:A?1441954 ;17-0 95 A-2.7; 9; <2- .88:4-0 * 50-/4:8281/8:?4<.58-49/0-/9;/-89/015><2- 895318<195A6<2-</1.7):0>-895;1/?-0A6<2-;1/4<.==-77.<- 9:/< 5--04 59 15<-/;-/-58- A6 <214 9:/< <2.< <99 15 <2- /-314195.7D:/14018<195 ' .315> 4.10 <2:4 1< 14 =7-.0-0 95 A-2.7; 9; <2- /-314195 =-<1<195-/ <2.< /-314195 =-<1<195-/ 2.4 794< 214 @1;- /-8-5<76.502-144:;;-/15>;/9?=./<1.7A71505-4495.889:5< 9; >7.:89?. .50 <2-/- 14 59A906 <9 799E .;<-/ <2- ;.?176
- 8 -
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
4#""" ! ## 889/015>76;9779@15>9/0-/
- 9 -
1 2-/-314195=-<1<19514.779@-015=./<G
11 217- ?.15<.1515> 895318<195 9; <2- /-314195 =-<1<195-/ ;9/ <2- 9;;-58- :50-/ -8<1954 #'& %"(!
9; /-.0 @1<2 -8<195 +' 9; 8<<2-4-5<-58-9;1?=/1495?-5<9/0-/-0A6<2- </1.7 .>14</.<- 895;1/?-0 A6 <2- ;1/4< .==-77.<- 9:/< 9; <@9 6-./4 ;9/ <2- 9;;-58- :50-/ -8<195 %"(!9;14/-0:8-0<941B?95<24A61?=9415> -52.58-0;15-.?9:5<9;
4#""" !G
111 -5<-58- 9; 1?=/1495?-5< 9/0-/-0 ;9/ 9;;-58- :50-/ -8<195 #'& 9; 14 2-/-A6 4-< .410-.41<?-/>-4@1<2<2-9;;-58-:50-/-8<195 %"(!9;G
13
-4<9;<2-4-5<-58-4<.504:5.7<-/-0G
3 1?- 14 >/.5<-0 <9 =.6 <2- -52.58-0 ;15-.?9:5<<177#""+#"#G
31 9.749<1?-14>/.5<-0;9/<2-/-314195 =-<1<195-/ <9 4://-50-/ A-;9/- <2- </1.7 9:/< 14 -B<-50-0<177#""+#"#G
311 .17:/- <9 =.6 -52.58-0 ;15- .?9:5< @9:70 .:<9?.<18.776 /-4:7< 15 /-4<9/.<195 9; <2-
- 10 -
4-5<-58-9/0-/-0A6<2-</1.7.>14</.<-895;1/?-0 A6<2-;1/4<.==-77.<-9:/<G
3111 ;;18- 14 01/-8<-0 <9 /-<:/5 <2- </1.7 9:/< /-89/04 .795> @1<2 . 89=6 9; <214 9/0-/ ;9/ 144:.58-9;?901;1-0895318<195@.//.5<
., '& + #
14<979'#