- 1 - ! " # $%& $'() &$(( * ! "# $ % & ' # # # # ' (& Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ' )& # (!& & "# $ #' &* ' ' % # ' +( ' #$ %( ' $,% # # # & - ' '' # +-&)&!&$%)&($)%)&($+%) ($% ) ($)% ) ($+% &&$% &!$% )&$&% )$% ' ) ' ' # ! + . / ' # # # ' ' ' # # ' , 0 $# 0 % 12 3245456728 9257: 412 ;<<=>2? 57 85@2 6 6A;B;7;:;8#6B5<24;456782:5>4282?A68412 6AA27<2> 3=75>1;9B2 =7?28 2<4567> +- &)& !&$% )&($)% )&($+% ) ($% ) ($)% ) ($+% &&$% &!$% - 3 - )&$&%;7?)&$%6A 1;8;45C;C;C;;7154; )DA68 >1684E FG5>>22H57:46I=;>1412<85@57;B386<22?57:> 57545;42?;:;57>4128327?57:67412A5B26A412B2;872? ??54567;B5J5B=?:2$87%;7?'5K;C;3=8;67 4129;>5>6A?582<4567> 5>>=2?9C41285;B6=8457# 6& - 2;8? 85 ;5C;? =BB; B2;872? <6=7>2B A68 412 3245456728 85 ;@;?;8 1;1;9=??57 B2;872? 5:1 6=846J287@274#B2;?28A6882>367?2746&/4;42;7? 85 5C;I;4 ';82? >4;? B2;872? <6=7>2B A68 82>367?274 6#28=>2?412@;4285;B>6782<68? ) 7 J52L 6A 412 85J;B <674274567> =8:2? 9C 412 B2;872?<6=7>2B>A6896414123;8452>4123657441;4L6=B? ;85>2A68@C<67>5?28;45675> !"#$% - 4 - C;7>L2846412;96J2365745>57412 A68412A6BB6L57: + 2>367?274 6 A5B2? 412 385J;42 <6@3B;574 57 #6& - ;:;57>44123245456728;BB2:57:41;412 5> ; 5J5B 7:57228 9C386A2>>567 ;7? 12 L;> 57 B6J2 L541 41282>367?27412C1;?5745@;4282B;4567>153A86@ &- 45BB ;C/ + ,1272J28 412 ;<<=>2? L;> 57 722? 6A @672C >12 @;7;:2? 46 :24 54 A86@ 412<6@3B;57;74 ;7? =>2?4668?28A66?67B572;4412<6>46A412<6@3B;57;74 1=> 12 1;? >3274 @682 41;7 >( B;H1> 67 412 ;<<=>2? 67BC L541 ;7 574274567 46 @;88C 128 7>3542 6A 41;4 412 ;<<=>2? :64 27:;:2? L541 >6@2672 2B>2 ;7? <6@@5442? <12;457: 12 2M48;<42? @672C 67BC L541 ;7 57427456746?2A8;=?412<6@3B;57;74,127415>A;<4L;> 986=:14 46 412 7645<2 6A 412 3;8274> ;7? 9864128 6A 412 ;<<=>2?412C>4;842??2@;7?57:> B;H1>A86@412 - 5 - <6@3B;57;74 12C L282 ;B>6 4182;42757: 15@ 6A <58<=B;457: 412 J5?26 3284;5757: 46 412 <6@3B;57;74 ;7? ;B>6<85@57;BBC5745@5?;457:46<;=>215>?2;41=857:412 @6741 6A =72/ + ;<<=>2? 1;? >274 128 127<1@27 L16<;@2464126AA5<26A412;<<=>2?;9=>2?15@57A5B41C B;7:=;:2 ;>>;=B42? 15@ ;7? ;B>6 <85@57;BBC 5745@5?;42? ;7?L;872?15@7644682A28464127;@26A412;<<=>2? ;7C @682 A;B>2 <85@57;B <;>2 <;@2 46 92 82:5>4282? ;:;57>4412<6@3B;57;74A68<57:15@46694;579;5B 4 5> >4;42? 41;4 67 & <6@3B;57;74 L274 46 C928 85@2 #6B5<2 4;4567 5K;C;3=8; A68 412 3=836>26AB6?:57:412<6@3B;574;:;57>4412328>67>L16 1;J2 >274 69><272 J5?26> 46 15> &' =4 76 <6@3B;574 L;> 82:5>4282? 4 5> >4;42? 41;4 412 ;<<=>2? 1;> <67>3582? L541 412 #6B5<2 L16 82A=>2? 46 4;H2 ;7C ;<4567 J27 L127 412 <6@3B;57;74 @24 412 =32857427?274 6A #6B5<2 5K;C;3=8; 5>485<4 ;7? >=9@5442? ; <6@3=4285N2? <6@3B;574 76 <6@3B;574 L;> 82:5>4282? 1282A682 412 57A68@;74 82I=2>42? 412 85;B - 6 - 6=84 46 82:5>428 412 <;>2 ;7? 57545;42 B2:;B ;<4567 12 85;B6=841;>82A2882?412@;4428A6857J2>45:;4567 367 L15<1412'<;@2469282:5>4282?5785@26 6A ;B;7;:;8 #6B5<2 4;4567 7 412 @2;745@2 412 32454567281;>;3386;<12?415>6=84>22H57:46I=;>1412 <85@57;B386<22?57:> ! 7 328=>;B 6A 412 @;4285;B> 67 82<68? ;7? 67 12;857: 412 B2;872? <6=7>2B> A68 9641 412 3;8452> 54 5> A6=7? 41;4 412 <6@3B;57;74 5> <67427?57: 41;4 ?=857: =72/ + 412;<<=>2? ;7?128 3;8274> 1;J2 >274 >6@2 L16 1;J2 4182;4272? ;7? ;>>;=B42? 412 <6@3B;57;74 ?@5442?BC 76 <6@3B;574 L;> A5B2? 57 41;4 82:;8? 385J;42 <6@3B;574 <;@2 46 92 B6?:2? 67 &( 7 412 >;5? <6@3B;574 54 5> >4;42? 41;4 412 <;=>2 6A ;<4567 A68 A5B57: 412 385J;42 <6@3B;574 ;86>2 67 & L127 412 K=85>?5<4567;B #6B5<2 82A=>2? 46 82:5>428412<85@57;B<6@3B;5746><8;36A3;328;332;8> 46 1;J2 9227 386?=<2? 9C 412 <6@3B;57;74 57 >=33684 6A 15> <674274567 768 <63C 6A >=<1 <6@3B;574 A68L;8?2? - 7 - 254128 46412 K=85>?5<4567;B #6B5<2 4;4567 68 464125:128 AA5<28>82I=2>457:4682:5>428412<;>2( 2J27 412 ?582<4567 5>>=2? 9C 67F9B2 32M 6=84 57 5> 764 A6BB6L2? C;44274567L;>?8;L79C412B2;872?<6=7>2B A68 412 3245456728 46 412 A;<4 41;4 412 <6@3B;57;74 1;? A5B2? 412 A58>4 57A68@;4567 L541 ;7?15 16LH #6B5<2 4;4567 L15<1 L;> 82:5>4282? 57 85@2 6) 67 ( ;:;57>4 ;<<=>2?3245456728 128257 ;7? 128 A;@5BC @2@928> 1282 5> 82A2827<2 46 ;7 57<5?274 41;4 1;? 6<<=882? 67 ) & 4 5> >4;42? 41;4 ;A428 57J2>45:;4567412#6B5<21;J2A5B2?E F823684;7?41285;B 6=841;>764;<<2342?412E F8236846L2J2854:;J2;7 633684=754C46412<6@3B;57;7446A5B215>38642>432454567 ( BB 412>2 A;<4> ;7?<58<=@>4;7<2> 5A<67>5?282? L541412>2I=27<26A?;42>;7?2J274>545><B2;841;4412 <6@3B;57;74L161;?82B;4567>153L541412;<<=>2?;4672 1 &$!%( - 8 - 365746A45@25>9274=36746382>>=85N212846@;88C15@ 6846824=87412;@6=74L15<1125>>;5?461;J2>327467 128 ,127 412 3245456728 ;7? 412 <6@3B;57;74 9641 ;82 @;K68> ;7? 1;? 82B;4567>153 J6B=74;85BC 412 <6@3B;57;74 <;7764<6@32B412;<<=>2?46@;88C15@ - 4 5> 412 :852J;7<2> 6A 412 <6@3B;57;74 41;4 ;96=4 >( B;H1> L;> >3274 9C 15@ 67 412 ;<<=>2? ;7?412>;@2L;>764824=872?4615@A41;45>412<;>2 412 <6@3B;57;74 L5BB 1;J2 46 ;3386;<1 412 5J5B 6=84 >22H57:82<6J28C6A412>;@2 =4412>;@2<;776492; <;=>26A ;<4567 A68 A5B57: <85@57;B <6@3B;574 672;A428 412 641281282A682;@6A412635756741;457545;45676A412 <85@57;B 386<22?57:> 5> 57 <B2;8 ;9=>2 6A 386<2>> 6A B;L 27<2 412 >;@2 5> B5;9B2 46 92 I=;>12? <<68?57:BC ;7>L28412;96J23657457412;AA58@;45J2;7?386<22?46 3;>>412A6BB6L57: $5% 12<85@57;B324545675> - 9 - $55% 12 <85@57;B 386<22?57:> 57545;42? ;:;57>4 412 ;<<=>2?3245456728 57 # 6& - 76L 327?57: 67 412 A5B2 6A 412 B2;872? ??54567;B 27568 5J5B =?:2 ;7? ' 5K;C;3=8; 5> 12829C I=;>12? +) $ ( # 5>46&B6+- #