Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58652 (KAR)
SMT SARASWATHI DEVI B PATIL v. THE COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/200349/2025 · 2025-11-04
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58652 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58652 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%$&!$!$
'!(
!!""#
$
%
&
$
' ' %
!#(
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
'
'
# '
"" " #" !
'
!#""
&
$
'
)*
'
)"#%
)
"" )
)
%
)
! ( "("#"( (+ "("#(+ (
"("# ,"
" ( "("#"+ ( "("#
)
" " # " ! )
'
'
'
%
)
) )
)
)
- 3 -
- '
$ - '%
./0/012.3 04 5.613. /704 183/ 4..902: 61;;1<02: 3.;0.6=4*
!" #$
$
%
&
'
##(#### ) & *&+ ),*& -&& *&
&
.
/&-
, 0
"
7. >?4. 16 /7. @./0/012.3 04 /7?/ 7. 04 /7.
1<2.3?2A@144.441316@31@.3/B5.?302:14" "
" "" ?2A" #?;;40/8?/.A
- 4 -
?/ 3?5 17?;;? ?0>783 7?/ /7. @./0/012.3 7?4 >124/38>/.A ? >1CC.3>0?; 471@ ?2A 1A1<2 12 /7. 4?0A @31@.3/B 02 /7. B.?3 + 4 48>7 @./0/012.3 7?4 5..2 .2D1B02:/7.@31@.3/B.4@12A.2/14"/1#<71?3./7.
1<2.34 16 /7. ?AD10202: @;1/4 7?E. 5..2 @8//02: 8@ >124/38>/012 02 E01;?/012 16 /7. 580;A02: 5B. ;?<4 ?2A /7.
4?2>/012 @;?2 02 /7. 4?2>/012.A @;?2 7. @./0/012.3 7?A :0E.2 3.@3.4.2/?/012 /1 /7. 3.4@12A.2/ 1 ?8/7130/B /1 /?9.?>/01202?>>13A?2>.<0/7/7.@31E04012416'?32?/?9? 820>0@?;0/0.4 >/ +# 02>. 21 ?>/012 04 /?9.2 /7. @./0/012.3045.613./704>183/
.?32.A>1824.;613/7.3.4@12A.2/14"/1# 485C0/4 /7?/ /7. E01;?/012 ?;;.:.A 5B /7. @./0/012.3 7?4 ?;3.?AB 5..2 >1C@182A.A 5B /7. 3.4@12A.2/ 1 ?8/7130/B5B>1;;.>/02:/7. >1C@182A02:6.. 4 48>7 7. 485C0/4 /7?/ /7. @./0/012 0/4.;6 7?4 5..2 3.2A.3 02638>/8184
- 5 -
# .?3A.384.A/7.3.>13A4 ! 7.?;;.:?/0124C?A.5B/7.@./0/012.3?3./7?/ /7. 3.4@12A.2/ 14" /1 # <71 ?3. 02 /7. @31>.44 16 @8//02: 8@ >124/38>/012 12 /7. @;1/ ?AD?>.2/ /1 /7.
@31@.3/B 16 /7. @./0/012.3 7?E. 21/ >1C@;0.A <0/7 /7.
580;A02: 5B. ;?<4 ?2A /7. 4?2>/012 @;?2 <70>7 3.F803.4 /7.C /1 ;.?E. @31@.3 ?2A 48660>0.2/ 4./ 5?>94 A8302: /7. >124/38>/012
7. 3.@3.4.2/?/012 >?;;02: 8@12 /7.
3.4@12A.2/ 1CC044012.3/1;11902/1/7.C?//.3?2A@?44 ?@@31@30?/.13A.37?4B0.;A.A213.48;/
718:7 ;.?32.A >1824.; 613 /7. @./0/012.3 485C0/4/7?//7.E01;?/0127?45..2>1C@182A.A6..4/7. @./0/01204A04@14.A16<0/7/7.61;;1<02:*
.4@12A.2/ 1 1CC044012.3 47?;; >1240A.3 /7.
3.@3.4.2/?/0124 16 /7. @./0/012.3 ?4 6182A ?/ 22.G83. 4.30.4?2A47?;;>1CC820>?/.13A.3?>/012/?9.206?2B
- 6 -
/7.3.12 <0/7 4@.>060> A./?0;4 /1 /7. @./0/012.3 <0/702 ?2 18/.3;0C0/16(A?B4631C/7.A?/.163.>.0@/16>.3/060.A >1@B16/70413A.3
!)* '$!$( &
04/1;1!! '