- 1 - !"" ##$%#&'" " ("!$)$*$$# $!$**! +'#, $!$**! +'#, " # ! " #$$ $ %&!''" & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( )&#)*" # %&!''" $ $+ !,& #"! &'#' ')'*) ' +) ')'*) ' &'#' + " & ! ! #$$ - )&!!& $ $+ - 3 - # # )&#)*" # - )&!''" )*.' , # "! ''*' &'#' + /& *''#) *' 0 1 2 2 3 ')# 45 6789:;<= ><//5? <; <@<7? ?<65? ''*' 8; A&'#'9B645 A6A7CC8?5;6 =<8D/789:;<= A+8E<B<>:7<FA7/4A7606456789:;<=1 - 4 - ;5 D6 <D:;<9<8 D56 @864 <CC8?5;6 A; "'&<;?/:CC:D95?6A6458;E:785/574:/9<;?<;? /A;/ 85 C=<8D<;6 A/ 6A ! F8=5? C=<8D >56868A; /55G8;H CAD>5;/<68A; AF /''''#) 95FA75 645 6789:;<= 45 6789:;<= <F657 CA;/8?578;H 645 5;6875 5I8?5;C5 A; 75CA7? <@<7?5? < /:D AF /"*''#) <=A;H @864 8;6575/6 <6 645 7<65AF.J>57<;;:DF7AD645?<65AF>56868A;68==645?<65 AF 75<=8K<68A; HH785I5? 9B 645 /<8? :?HD5;6 <;? <@<7? 645 ;/:7<;C5 CAD><;B F8=5? A' #'! <;? /:9D8665?64<6A;"'&<D:;<9<8@</>7AC55?8;HA; DA6A7CBC=5 95<78;H 75H8/67<68A; A )&#)*" </ >8==8A; 78?574578?57AF645DA6A7CBC=5?78I5;645/<8?DA6A7CBC=5 8;<7</4<;?;5H=8H5;6D<;;57</<75/:=6645>8==8A;78?57 F5== ?A@; <;? /:/6<8;5? H785IA:/ 8;E:785/ <;? /:9/5L:5;6=B ?85? A; ''& @48=5 :;?57HA8;H 675<6D5;6 6 8/ CA;65;?5? 64<6 645 CAD>=<8;6 8/ H8I5; @864 < ?5=<B AF ! ?<B/ <;? 645 75</A;/ FA7 ?5=<B 8/ ;A6 5M>=<8;5? 45 CAD>=<8;6 @</ F8=5? </ <; <F65764A:H46 <;? @864 D<=<F8?5 8;65;68A;6AC=<8D645CAD>5;/<68A;45C=<8D<;6/5M<D8;5? </<;5B5@86;5//9:645@</;A6/4A@;</5B5@86;5// - 5 - 8; 645 C4<7H5)/4556 45 >A=8C5 4<I5 ;A6 75CA7?5? 645 /6<65D5;6AF<;?45@</;5I57/4A@;645/>A6AF645 <CC8?5;66A645>A=8C545CAD>=<8;68/F8=5?A;' '' <6.!4A:7/<;?645/>A6AF645<CC8?5;68/!G8=AD5657/ <@<BF7AD645>A=8C5/6<68A;9:6645/>A6D<4<K<7@</?A;5 A;645/<D5?<B956@55;.6A"'4A:7/@48C48/;A6 >A//89=5 CA;/8?578;H 645 ?8/6<;C5 F7AD 645 >A=8C5 /6<68A; 6A 645/>A6AF645<CC8?5;645A@;57AF645DA6A7CBC=58/;A;5 A645764<;97A6457AF645C=<8D<;6A<;?645?5C5</5?8/ 645@8F5AF645C=<8D<;6A45CAD>=<8;<;68/645/A;AF 645 ?5C5</5? 8?57 AF 645 DA6A7CBC=5 8/ 645 97A6457)8;)=<@ AF645C=<8D<;6A/<;?!<;?645B4<I5F<=/5=B8D>=8C<65? 645DA6A7CBC=54575FA75645<@<7?><//5?9B645 8/ =8<9=56A95/56</8?5 ! ;A6457 <>>5<= 8; A'"'*#' 8/ F8=5? 9B645C=<8D<;6//55G8;H5;4<;C5D5;6AF645CAD>5;/<68A; 45B CA;65;?5? 64<6 ?5C5</5? <D:;<9<8 @</ 5<7;8;H < /:DAF/*'''#)>57DA;649B?A8;HCAA=85@A7G9:6645 6789:;<=4</6<G5;6458;CAD5AF645?5C5</5?<D:;<9<8</ "''#)<;?645<DA:;6/H7<;65?:;?57645A645745<?/<75 - 6 - <=/A D5<H57 :76457 86 8/ /:9D8665? 64<6 #!7? 8/ 6A 95 ?5?:C65?6A@<7?/>57/A;<=5M>5;/5/<;?&'J8/6A95<??5? 6A@<7?/ F:6:75 >7A/>5C6/ <;? J 8;6575/6 A; 645 CAD>5;/<68A;<DA:;68/6A95<@<7?5?<;?64:/75L:5/65? FA75;4<;C5D5;6AF645CAD>5;/<68A; & 5<7;5? CA:;/5= FA7 645 ;/:7<;C5 CAD><;B CA;65;?5? 64<6 645 <CC8?5;6 4</ ACC:775? A; "'& 45 6AAG 675<6D5;6 F7AD "'& 6A ''& <;? /:CC:D95? 6A 645 8;E:75/ A; ''& 5/>A;?5;6 A 75D<8;5? 5M)><765 45 >A=8CB @</ 8; 5M8/65;C5 </ A; 645 ?<65AF645<CC8?5;645CAD>=<8;6@</H8I5;A;' '' 85 <F657 ! ?<B/ 8/ ;A6 645 5B5@86;5// 6A 645 ACC:775;C5AF645<CC8?5;645B4<I5;A6>7A?:C5?D5?8C<= 75CA7?/F7AD64578D<7B5<=64 5;65745>A=8C54<I5;A6 75CA7?5? /6<65D5;6/ AF 645 @86;5//5/ A; 645 ?<65 AF 645 <CC8?5;6 @4A 8/ <; 5B5@86;5// 6A 645 8;C8?5;6 4</ <?D8665? 64<6 45 I8/865? 645 />A6 <F657 F8I5 ?<B/ AF 645 <CC8?5;6<;?64575@</;AI548C=5A;645/>A6/>57M& % 75>A76 645 <CC8?5;6 @</ ;A6 ACC:775? ?:5 6A <;B D5C4<;8C<=?5F5C6/M8/645C<:/5AF?5<64C5768F8C<65 - 7 - 8;@48C4868/D5;68A;5?64<6645?5<648/?:56A45<?8;E:7B I5; 8; M*) 5>A76 86 8/ /6<65? 64<6 645 ?5C5</5? ?85? ?:5 6A 45<? 8;E:7B 45 6789:;<= 75=85? :>A; < C86<68A; 75>A765? 8; 956@55; @45758; 86 8/ 45=? 64<6 645 ?5=<B8;F8=8;H645 8/;A6/:FF8C85;6H7A:;?FA7?8/D8//<=AF 645 C</5 AF 645 C=<8D<;6/ :6 645 ;/:7<;C5 CAD><;B 4</ CA;65;?5?64<664578?57AF645DA6A7CBC=58/64597A6457)8;) =<@AF645C=<8D<;6A/<;?!<;?A@;57AF645DA6A7CBC=5 8/64597A6457AF645C=<8D<;6A<;?<D:;<9<88/645@8F5 AF645C=<8D<;6A45CAD>=<8;6@</H8I5;<F657!?<B/ 9B 8D>=5<?8;H 645 I548C=5 95<78;H 75H8/67<68A; A )&#) *" 6@</F:76457<7H:5?64<6645CAD>=<8;68/H8I5;A; ' '' <6 <9A:6 .! 4A:7/ 45 />A6 D<4<K<7 @</ ?A;5A;645/<D5?<B956@55;.'4A:7/6A"'4A:7/ 64A:H4645>=<C5AF<CC8?5;68/<6<?8/6<;C5AF!G8=AD5657/ F7AD645>A=8C5/6<68A; ; < C86<68A; 75>A765? 8; 956@55; !! !! 86@</45=?</FA==A@/2 - 8 - ! " ! ! # $%&'( &) & - 9 - * & + , . 5 75=85? :>A; < C86<68A; 75>A765? 8; "# $% &' % " ( ) <;? <7H:5? 64<6 645 ?5C5</5? <D:;<9<8/:/6<8;5?45<?8;E:785/9:6/45?8?;A6D56@864 <CC8?5;6A;"'&<;?/45@</;A667<I5=8;H</<>8==8A; 78?57 A; 645 /<8? DA6A7CBC=5 45B 8D>=5<?5? 645 I548C=5 <F657! ?<B/ A;=B 6A H<8;@7A;HF:==B 45 @</ <?D8665? 8; 645 4A/>86<= 68== ''& <;? /:CC:D95? 6A 645 8;E:785/ I5; <F657@<7?/ ;A CAD>=<8;6 @</ H8I5; 9B 645 C=<8D<;6/ 45?5=<B8;F8=8;H645CAD>=<8;68/;A65M>=<8;5?<;B@4575 64575FA75648/ A:76F8;?/64<6868/C=5<7C</5AF8D>=8C<68A; AF 645 I548C=5 <F657 ! ?<B/ AF 645 F8=8;H AF 645 F<=/5 - 10 - CAD>=<8;69B645/A;AF645?5C5</5?9B?:=B8D>=8C<68;H645 I548C=5 AF 645 75=<68I5 @48C4 8/ 8;/:75? @864 645 ;/:7<;C5 CAD><;B 45 78?57 AF 645 DA6A7CBC=5 8/ <=/A < C=A/5 75=<68I5#97A6457)8;)=<@ A ?A:96 86 8/ < 95;5F8C8<= =5H8/=<68A; 9:6 648/ A:76 /4A:=? 95 C<:68A:/ 75H<7?8;H 8;IA=I5D5;6AF645I548C=5/<;?F<G5C=<8D/ ;I85@AF645 <9AI5 ?8/C://8A; 648/ A:76 F8;?/ 64<6 86 8/ C=5<7 C</5 AF 8D>=8C<68A; AF 645 I548C=5 </ /:C4 645 C=<8D<;6/ <75 ;A6 5;686=5FA7<;BCAD>5;/<68A;<;?645 ;/:7<;C5CAD><;B8/ ;A6=8<9=56A><B645CAD>5;/<68A; " CCA7?8;H=B645FA==A@8;H2 # 8 45 <>>5<= F8=5? 9B 645 ;/:7<;C5 CAD><;B85 A' #'!8/<==A@5?, 88 45 <>>5<= F8=5? 9B 645 C=<8D<;6/ 8; A'"'*#'8/?8/D8//5?, - 11 - 888 45 <DA:;6 ?5>A/865? 9B 645 ;/:7<;C5 CAD><;B /4<== 95 75F:;?5? 6A 645 ;/:7<;C5CAD><;B, -. +*$$#, )# 8/6A2=A2 2