- 1 - !" #$ #% $& $ % $' ( % $ ( % )# $ * " +% $ $ , !&( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # - !' !& ( #% $( $ % $. $ % )# !&( * (#" '( " # # &!! (%/ # $ $ - 3 - $ " 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 '( " => <05 =<=: 501;652;</&& 05:5183><5::5>5::59<=32?<05;<->=: 20=:<"032@558>1659@A<05;631B38<2@518C3CC:15D59@A <05E79CB58<3893F3:993<59&432259@A<05 996581=:1D1679C5389 363@7:3C1 >=:20=:< ?631B2:1@7836-"18=(%/ 3;<2 C1D18C :125 <= <05 >1618C => <05 344536 @:15>6A2<3<593:5<03<=8&3<3@=7<(4B F058<0595;532593:383<0F32<:3D5618C1872@53:18C :5C12<:3<1=8 = !(%!&& =8 785!=0=6 1C0 #3A 18>:=8< => =0=6 C:1;76<7:36 1:B 3< <03< <1B5 9:1D5: => <052319@729:=D51<F1<001C02455918:32038985C61C58< B3885: 389 932059 <= 36 :7;G @53:18C :5C12<:3<1=8 =!% !( =8 1<2 @3;G2195 2 3 :5276< => <05 3>=:52319 3;;1958< <05 95;53259 272<31859 C:15D=72 18E7:1523899159=8<0524=< - 4 - ( 05;631B38<2>1659345<1<1=87895:5;<1=8.. => <05 ;< 255G18C ;=B45823<1=8 >=: <05 953<0 => <05 95;5325936=8CF1<018<5:52< 8 25:D1;5 => 27BB=82 <05 :524=8958< =2 389 34453:59<0:=7C0 <051: ;=782562 389 >1659 F:1<<58 2<3<5B58< 958A18C <05 3D5:B58<2 B395 18 <05 ;631B 45<1<1=8 8<05@3212=><054653918C2=><0543:<152<05 631B2:1@7836>:3B59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <055D1958;505;631B38<218=:95:<=4:=D5<05;325 ;631B38<=5H3B185905:256>32#!389C=<5H01@1<59 9=;7B58<2 83B56A H <= H& 8 <05 =<05: 0389 :524=8958<2 03D5 8=< 3997;59 38A =:36 5D1958;5 =F5D5: C=< B3:G59 <05 1827:38;5 4=61;A =8 ;=8258< 32 H 05 631B2 :1@7836 @A <05 1B47C859 E79CB58< 0569<03<<053;;1958<<==G463;5=83;;=78<=> :320 38985C61C58< 9:1D18C => <05 =>>58918C D501;65 @A 1<2 9:1D5: 32 3 :5276< => F01;0 <05 95;53259 272<31859 18E7:152 389 27;;7B@59 <= <05 18E7:152 05 :1@7836 - 5 - >7:<05: 0569 <03< <05 ;631B38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 ;=B45823<1=8=>2'%!36=8CF1<018<5:52<3<<05 :3<5 => .I 43 389 91:5;<59 <05 :524=8958< = <= 954=21< <05 ;=B45823<1=8 3B=78< 36=8C F1<0 18<5:52< 518C3CC:15D59<012344536032@558>1659 . 05653:859;=78256>=:<05;631B38<2032:31259 <05>=66=F18C;=8<58<1=82$ 3" 1:2<6A <05 ;631B38<2 ;631B <03< <05 95;53259 F32 3C59 3@=7< & A53:2 3< <05 <1B5 => <05 3;;1958< <05 95;53259F32F=:G18C329:1D5:18=7:2389:3D562 >:=B <05 A53: <= & =8 B=8<06A 43AB58< => 2%! 4672 2%! @03<<3 45: 93A >=: & 93A2 5H;67918C 0=6193A2" 12 C5<<18C<=<36 2363:A =>2%! 45: B=8<0 = <03< 5>>5;< 05 032 4:=97;59 2363:A ;5:<1>1;3<5 122759 @A <05 5B46=A5: 3< H' 18 241<5 => <03<<05:1@783603232252259<058=<1=83618;=B5=><05 95;53259322%!45:B=8<012=86=F5:2195 @" 5;=896A 32 45: <05 63F 6319 9=F8 @A <05 =8-@65 74:5B5 =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => - 6 - 18;325<0595;53259F32256>!5B46=A59=:=8 3 >1H59 2363:A 38 3991<1=8 => I => <05 52<3@612059 18;=B5 <=F3:92 ?>7<7:5 4:=245;<2- 20=769 @5 <05 F3::38< F05:5 <0595;53259 F32 @56=F <05 3C5 => A53:2 05 23B520366@5;=82195:59 ;" 01:96A3245:<05E79CB58<=><05=8-@6574:5B5 =7:<18<05;325=> ! 53;0 => <05 ;631B38<2 3:5 58<1<659 >=: ;=B45823<1=8 => 2%! 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22 => 6=D5 389 3>>5;<1=8 389 ;=82=:<17B- 9" =7:<06A ;=82195:18C <05 3C5 389 3D=;3<1=8 => <05 95;53259 <05 =D5:366 ;=B45823<1=8 3F3:959 @A <05 :1@783612=8<056=F5:219558;5054:3A2>=:366=F18C <05344536 ' 8<05=<05:0389<05653:859;=78256>=:<05 827:38;5 =B438A 032 :31259 <05 >=66=F18C ;=78<5:! ;=8<58<1=82$ - 7 - 3"1:2<6A<05;631B38<203D5;631B59<03<<0595;53259 F3253:818C2%!45:B=8<0052363:A;5:<1>1;3<5 93<59/1227593><5:<05953<0=><0595;53259 5H;54< <03< <05A 03D5 8=< 4:=97;59 @38G 2<3<5B58<2 =: 38A =<05: 9=;7B58<2 <= 20=F <03< <05 95;53259 F32 C5<<18C 2%! 45: B=8<0 32 3 2363:A F=:G18C 32 9:1D5: F1<0 :524=8958< = 05:5>=:5 <05 :1@7836 032 :1C0<6A 32252259 <05 83<1=836 18;=B5 => <05 95;53259 32 2%! 45: B=8<0 5 >7:<05: ;=8<58<59 <03< 218;5 ;631B38<2 03D5 >31659 <= 4:=D5 <05 52<3@612059 18;=B5 => <0595;53259<05:1@78360328=<:1C0<6A3F3:959>7<7:5 4:=245;<2 @" 5;=896A =8 344:5;13<1=8 => =:36 389 9=;7B58<3:A 5D1958;5 389 ;=82195:18C <05 3C5 389 3D=;3<1=8 => <05 95;53259 <05 =D5:366 ;=B45823<1=8 3F3:959 @A <05 :1@7836 12 E72< 389 :532=83@65 58;5 2=7C0< >=: 912B12236=><05344536 - 8 - & 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 43:<152 45:7259 <05 E79CB58< 389 3F3:9 18;67918C <05 344536 4345:2 / <128=<1891247<53:383<0915918:=39<:3>>1; 3;;1958< 032 =;;7::59 =8 & 975 <= :320 389 85C61C58< 9:1D18C=> 9:1D5:=><05 @72@53:18C:5C12<:3<1=8 = !(%!&& D58 <0=7C0 ;631B38<2 03D5 ;631B59 <03<<0595;53259F32C5<<18C2363:A=>2%!45: B=8<03239:1D5:052363:A;5:<1>1;3<593<59/ 12 122759 3><5: <05 93<5 => 3;;1958< 389 <05A 03D5 4:=97;59 9:1D18C 61;58;5 F01;0 ;653:6A 20=F2 <03< 95;53259 F32 3 9:1D5: @A 4:=>5221=8 389 362= 4:=97;59 9:1D5: @39C5 3< H!& =82195:18C <05 23B5 1< 12 344:=4:13<5 <= ;=82195: <05 18;=B5 => <05 95;53259 3< 2(%! 45: B=8<0 = <05 3>=:52319 18;=B5 I 032<=@539959=83;;=78<=>>7<7:54:=245;<218D15F=> <05 63F 6319 9=F8 @A <05 =82<1<7<1=8 58;0 => <05 74:5B5 =7:< 18 " # 274:3" 072 <05 B=8<06A 18;=B5 ;=B52 <= 2&%! 18;5 <05:5 3:5 - 9 - >1D5 95458958<2 1< 12 344:=4:13<5 <= 9597;< %<0 => <05 18;=B5 => <05 95;53259 <=F3:92 45:2=836 5H458252 389 :5B31818C 3B=78< 032 <= @5 <3G58 32 012 ;=8<:1@7<1=8 <= <05>3B16A0595;53259F323C593@=7<&A53:23<<05 <1B5 => <05 3;;1958< 389 B76<14615: 34461;3@65 <= 012 3C5 C:=74 12 ?'- 072 <05 ;631B38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=B45823<1=8 => 2'&.%! 2&JJ'J%" =83;;=78<=>?6=22=>95458958;A- 8 3991<1=8 <05 ;631B38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=B45823<1=8=>2%!=83;;=78<=>?6=22=>52<3<5- 389 ;=B45823<1=8 => 2%! =8 3;;=78< => ?>785:36 5H458252- 8 D15F => <05 63F 6319 9=F8 @A <05 74:5B5 =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => " # 274:3";631B38<=F1>5=><0595;532591258<1<659>=: ;=B45823<1=8 => 2%! 7895: <05 0539 => 6=22 => 24=7236;=82=:<17B;631B38<=2389(;0169:58=><05 95;53259 3:5 58<1<659 >=: ;=B45823<1=8 => 2%! 53;0 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22 => 43:58<36 ;=82=:<17B- 389 - 10 - ;631B38<=238943:58<2=><0595;532593:558<1<659 >=: ;=B45823<1=8 => 2%! 53;0 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22=>>16136;=82=:<17B- 072<05;631B38<23:558<1<659<=<05>=66=F18C ;=B45823<1=8$ !"#$%!&!' ( '% ( !$ #'" &!$%! )"* =22=>95458958;A '&. 785:365H458252 =22=>52<3<5 =22=>24=7236 ;=82=:<17B =22=>3:58<36 ;=82=:<17B & =22=>16136;=82=:<17B & $#+ ,-, . ( 8<05:5276<<05>=66=F18C=:95:12432259$ 1" 0534453612#++/ '%!#($ 11" 05 E79CB58< => <05 631B2 :1@7836 12 B=91>159 - 11 - 111" 05 ;631B38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 <=<36 ;=B45823<1=8 => ",-, . 32 3C3182< 2'%!3F3:959@A<05:1@7836 1D" 05 827:38;5 =B438A 12 91:5;<59 <= 954=21< <05;=B45823<1=83B=78<36=8CF1<018<5:52<3< .I 43 >:=B <05 93<5 => >1618C => <05 ;631B 45<1<1=8 <166 <05 93<5 => :5361K3<1=8 F1<018 3 45:1=9=>21HF55G2>:=B<0593<5=>:5;514<=> ;=4A=><012E79CB58< D" 05 344=:<1=8B58< 954=21< 389 :565325 => 3B=78<20366@5B39518<5:B2=><053F3:9=> <05:1@7836 0'. )10* 0'. )2342* 12<=$6=$ $