- 1 - !"!# $%"%% % & &'() &(( * ! " ## # $" ! ## " # $" #% ## # $" & ' ( Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) # # $ # ) # #$! " % !$# $" & ' # )* )"( # )# " ) ) + "$" # ### ))) # !"+' (!'"(!" !'('"() !'(',('-(!'"('./()' ) ( "$ % % )# ) # ) % 0# - 3 - ' 0# ( 12341516765858298- :8-56; <2, /;=8--829 >851 516 ?29-695 2< :6/,96; ?239-6: <2, 516 7/,586- 85 8- 5/@69 37 <2,<89/:;8-72-/: " 16 765858296,- A6894 /??3-6; 2- 52 /,6 -66@89452B3/-1516?,8=89/:7,2?66;894-89858/56;/4/89-5 516=89,8=62+ "$"2</8?13,3,/: 2:8?65/5829 ,648-56,6; <2, 516 2<<69?6- 7398-1/A:6 39;6, 6?5829- !"+' (!'"(!" !'('"(2<1/,/58C/C/C/ /9185/"$"!/9;/:-239;6,-6?5829-!'(',('-(!'"('. /(2<?16;3:6;/-56-/9;?16;3:6;,8A6-' ,6.695829 2< 5,2?8586-( ?5 ++ 769;894 A6<2,6 516 ;;85829/: 8-5,8?5/9;6--829-3;46/8?13, ! 5 8- 516 ?295695829 2< 516 :6/,96; ?239-6: <2, 516 765858296,- 51/5 765858296,- /,6 /,,/C6; /- /??3-6; 2- 52 89 516 /A2.6 ?,8=89/: ?/-6 16 <8,-5 89<2,=/5829 ?/=6 52 A6 :2;46; 29 $ "$" ,64/,;894 5162<<69?651/5 8- -/8; 52 1/.62??3,,6; 29 D$ "$" - 4 - 6<3,516,-3A=85-51/5765858296,216,6891/;<8:6;/ ?2=7:/895/4/89-513-A/9;2<51689<2,=/9529$D$ "$" /::64894 51/5 29 $$ "$" 516 13-A/9; 2< 89<2,=/95 /:294>8512516,->/C:/8;18=/9;;6=/9;6;=296C/9; /--/3:56;18=>8511/9;- 65858296,2"1/;8956,.696; /9; 7/?8<86; 516 B3/,,6: 9 516 =6/958=6 /<56, 5/@894 5,6/5=695 <8,-5 89<2,=/5829 ?/=6 52 A6 <8:6; 16 89.6-584/58298-39;6,5/@6989516-/8;?/-6-/?23956, A:/-5 516 7,6-695 ?2=7:/895 8- <8:6; /9; 516,6<2,6 /??2,;89452:6/,96;?239-6:<2,516765858296,-858-/<85 ?/-6<2,B3/-18942<516?,8=89/:7,2?66;894- 85 8- 516 ?295695829 2< 516 :6/,96; 841 23,5 2.6,9=695 :6/;6, <2, ,6-729;695 2 /9; 516 :6/,96; ?239-6: <2, ,6-729;695 2" 51/5 516 <8,-5 89<2,=/5829 ?/=6 52 A6 ,648-56,6; 29 $ "$" >851 ,64/,; 52 89?8;695 51/51/; 2??3,,6; 29 D$ "$" 9 4289451,2341516<8,-589<2,=/5829 85/776/,- 51/5 -6,823- /::64/5829- /,6 =/;6 235 52 ?29-585356 516 2<<69?6 9 516 =6/958=6 -5/C >/- 2A5/896; <2, <3,516, - 5 - 89.6-584/5829 9;6, -3?1 ?8,?3=-5/9?6- 5,351 2, 2516,>8-6 89 516 =/556, 1/- 925 C65 A669 396/,516; 69?6858-/<85?/-6<2,;8-=8--/:2<516-/=6 6/,;,8/-/./,/E /51:6/,96;?239-6:<2, 516 765858296,- ,827/:@,8-19/ /;/. :6/,96; 841 23,52.6,9=695 :6/;6,<2,,6-729;69525/56/9; ,83,3A/-/./ /C/@ :6/,96; ?239-6: <2, ,6-729;695 2" 6,3-6;516=/56,8/:/./8:/A:629,6?2,; D 9.86>2<516?295695829-3,46;AC516:6/,96; ?239-6:<2,A2515167/,586-5167289551/5>23:;/,8-6<2, =C?29-8;6,/58298- F !"#$% G C/9->6,52516/A2.6728958-89 <2,516<2::2>894 - 6 - 16 =/56,8/:- 29 ,6?2,; ;8-?:2-6 51/5 29 $D$ "$"765858296,21/;<8:6;/?2=7:/895/4/89-5 51613-A/9;2<51689<2,=/95/9;2516,-/9;858-/::646; 51/5 516C 1/.6 ;6=/9;6; =296C /--/3:56; /9; /A3-6; 18= 89 <8:51C :/943/46 27C 2< 516 >239; ?6,58<8?/56 8- /:-2 7,2;3?6; AC 516 :6/,96; ?239-6: <2, 516 765858296,- /??2,;894 52 >18?1 516 89E3,6; 8- A,23415 52 /8?13, 9-585356 2< 6;8?/: ?869?6- /9; 6/?1894 2-785/: /8?13, >851 / 18-52,C 51/5 516,6 >/- /--/3:5 AC <8.6 76,-29- 29 $$ "$" /5 D!$ 7= 569;6,96-- /5 :6<5 56=72,2=/9;8A3:/, E2895 8- 9256; 9 516 =6/958=6 516 89<2,=/95 1/- <8:6; 516 <8,-5 89<2,=/5829 29 $ "$" /::6489451/529D$ "$"/??3-6;2-52 >12/,6 765858296,-16,6891/.68::64/::C5,6-7/--6;895216,123-6 /9; 89-8-56; 52 -6:: 5168, :/9; /A3-6; 516= 89 <8:51C :/943/46/9;/--/3:56;516=>8511/9;-/9;;,/446;16, -/,66 >851 /9 895695829 52 235,/46 16, =2;6-5C /9; 52 ;6</=6 16, AC ,6<6,,894 52 16, ?/-56 /9; 516,6AC - 7 - ?2==8556; 2<<69?6 5 8- 76,589695 52 9256 51/5 <8,-5 89<2,=/5829 ?/=6 52 A6 <8:6; 29 $ "$" 16 7,6-695 76585829 ?/=6 52 A6 <8:6; AC 516 765858296,- A6<2,6 518- 23,529$!$"$"168956,8=2,;6,2<-5/C2<<3,516, 7,2?66;894->/-7/--6;AC51622,;89/5669?12<518- 23,529$D$"$"1/5=6/9-52-/C51/5>85189G52 ;/C-8956,8=2,;6,2<-5/C>/-4,/956;AC518-23,5 + 5 8- 516 -655:6; 7,272-85829 2< :/> 51/5 8< / 76585829<2,B3/-189439;6,6?5829 "2<, 8-<8:6; 8==6;8/56:C /<56, <8:894 2< 516 <8,-5 89<2,=/5829 516 29:C C/,;-58?@ 52 ?29-8;6, 516 76585829 8- >16516, ?2498H/A:6 2<<69?6 8- =/;6 235 29 7:/89 ,6/;894 2< 516 <8,-5 89<2,=/58292,92594289451,2341516<8,-589<2,=/5829 -6,823- /::64/5829- /,6 =/;6 >18?1 /=2395- 52 ?2==8--829 2< ?2498H/A:6 2<<69?6 %16516, /9C -3?1 2<<69?6 >/- ?2==8556; 2, >16516, 85 8- 29:C / ?23956, A:/-5 /- 516 765858296, 1/; <8:6; / ?2=7:/895 /4/89-5 516 13-A/9;2< 516 89<2,=/95 8-52A6<239; 235AC ?/,,C894 235 516 89.6-584/5829 89 ;65/8: 35 A6<2,6 -3?1 /9 - 8 - 89.6-584/58298-?/,,86;23585?/9925A6?29?:3;6;51/5/ </:-6?2=7:/895?/=652A6<8:6;AC516,6-729;695- $ 9;6, -3?1 ?8,?3=-5/9?6- >169 516 <8,-5 89<2,=/5829 85-6:< =/@6- 235 ?2==8--829 2< / ?2498H/A:6 2<<69?6 /= 2< 516 2789829 51/5 85 8- 925 / <85 ?/-6 <2, B3/-18942<5167,2?66;894- ??2,;894:C /9->6, 516 /A2.6 72895 89 516 /9;7,2?66;527/--516<2::2>894 16?,8=89/:765858298- +) &%%( " #8-52:2"