- 1 - !"# $#% # # & ' !" # !$%" & !$%## % !$%## % Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ##( ##) ' # *! $"#"## *! +, *! "#"##- ' . *! % ' /. /. ,0+0+12,3 456+7+28 01 9, 0:, 1;2,3 1< 562= 9,63+28 >1& # 7,6?@3+28 # 8@206? 1< ,?6+ :186A@3 B+5568, 6+4:@3 65@C 62= +?03+40 +? 9,<13, 0:+? 1@30 ?,,C+28<1551;+283,5+,<? !"#$"# % % ""& % ' ( ) * #$" "#+ - 3 - , - . /" 0+ % 1 2 3% & "4 # :600:,6<13,?6+=562=7,6?@3+28#8@206?+2 >1& # ?+0@60,= 60 ,?6+ :186A@3 B+5568, 9,5128,= 01:+?<60:,3:626AA662=6<0,3:+?=,7+?,0:,267,1< 0:, A,0+0+12,3 :6? 9,,2 7@060,= +2 0:, 3,B,2@, 3,413=? :60 0:, 3,?A12=,20 ! 6@0:13+0+,? ;+0:1@0 62> 210+4, 13 ,2D@+3> A314,,=,=01+??@,210+<+460+12+2 137!#@2=,3 ?@9!3@5, & 1< @5, E 3,6= ;+0: ,40+12 &$ 1< 0:, 632606C6 62= ,<137? 40 E( =,4563+28 0:, 562= +2 >1& 010655> 7,6?@3+28 643, 1< ,?6+ :186A@3 B+5568, 67128?0 10:,3 562=? 6? F@23,413=,= :69+060+12G 267,= 6? F :62C636 +28,?:;636 6863G :60 +2 <@30:,3624, 0:,3,1< 6 A3,5+7+263> 210+<+460+12 =60,= "#"##:6?9,,2+??@,=9>0:,3,?A12=,20! 060,+2 A@3A130,= ,H,34+?, 1< +0? A1;,3 @2=,3 ,40+12 1< 0:, - 4 - 632606C6 62= ,B,2@, 40 E(% +2 ;:+4: 0:, 562= 9,5128+28010:,A,0+0+12,3+?<1@2=60 51)$ & ,632,=41@2?,5<130:,A,0+0+12,3?@97+0?0:60 0:,,20+3,,H,34+?,1<=,4563+280:,562=6?62F@23,413=,= :69+060+12G62=+??@+286210+<+460+126?A,322,H@3,! +? 12,;+0:1@062>I@3+?=+40+12,3,<,3?010:,13=,3A6??,= 9>0:,1!13=+260,,24:1<0:+?1@30=60,=#$"##"# A6??,= +2 +2 0:, 46?, 1< 62= ?@97+0? 0:60 @2=,3 ?+7+563 4+34@7?0624,? 0:, 1! 13=+260,,24:1<0:+?1@30:6=D@6?:,=0:,210+<+460+12 62=:6==+3,40,=0:,3,?A12=,20!6@0:13+0+,?01=,5,0,0:, 267,1<0:,1B,327,20+23,?A,401<0:,562=9,5128+28 01 0:, A,0+0+12,3 0:,3,+2 ;+0: 6 <@30:,3 =+3,40+12 01 0:, ,A@0> 177+??+12,3 0:60 +< 0:, 562=? 1< 0:, A,0+0+12,3? ;6?3,D@+3,=<130:,A@95+4A@3A1?, :,;1@5=9,605+9,30> 01 +2+0+60, ?@4: 64D@+?+0+12 A314,,=+28? +2 0,37? 1< 6AA5+4695,56;:@? :,?@97+0?0:600:,A,0+0+12,3+20:+? - 5 - 46?, ;:1 +? ?+7+5635> ?+0@60,= 76> 65?1 9, ,H0,2=,= ?+7+5633,5+,< % ,632,= +8: 1@30 1B,327,20 5,6=,3 6AA,63+28 <13 0:, 3,?A12=,20? J 6@0:13+0+,? =1,? 210 =+?A@0, 6 ?+7+563 13=,3 :6B+28 9,,2 A6??,= 9> 0:, 1! 13=+260,,24:1<0:+?1@30 ,63=,3@?,=0:,3,413=? ( :, A,0+0+12,3 456+7+28 01 9, 0:, 1;2,3 1< 0:, 562= 7,6?@3+28 # 8@206? +2 >1& # 1< 0:, ,?6+ :186A@3B+5568,1<6?C+195+ 6?C+65@C:6?A31=@4,= 3,B,2@, 3,413=? +2 0:, 260@3, 1< ,H03640? 10+4, =60,= $"#"## +2 137 1#! +??@,= 9> 0:, 3,?A12=,20!,A@0>177+??+12,3A31=@4,=6022,H@3,! ;1@5= +2=+460, 0:60 0:, 562= +2 >1& 1< ,?6+ :186A@3 B+5568, :6? 9,,2 =,4563,= 6? 62 @23,413=,= :69+060+12019,267,=6?K :62C636+28,?:;6366863L :, ?6+= 210+4, :6? 9,,2 +??@,= 7,3,5> 12 0:, A31A1?65 +??@,=9>0:,??+?0620177+??+12,31=,06+5?6?0162> - 6 - 210+4,:6B+289,,2+??@,=010:,A,0+0+12,31362>,2D@+3> :6B+289,,2412=@40,=+20:+?3,863= @4:6=,456360+12 ;+0:1@0 +??@+28 0:, 210+4, 13 412=@40+28 62> ,2D@+3> A630+4@5635>;:,20:,A,0+0+12,3456+7?019,0:,1;2,31< 0:, A31A,30> +2 D@,?0+12 +? @2?@?06+2695, 12?,D@,205> 0:, <@30:,3 A3,5+7+263> 210+<+460+12 +??@,= 9> 0:, 3,?A12=,20! 060,@2=,3 ,40+121<0:,632606C662= ,B,2@, 40 E(% 01 ,H45@=, 0:, 562= 9,5128+28 01 0:, A,0+0+12,3 <317 0:, 5+7+0? 1< ,?6+ :186A@3 B+5568, 1< 6?C+ 65@C +2 6+4:@3 +?03+40 62= 01 412<+37 6 2,; 3,B,2@,B+5568,4655,=K :62C636+28,?:;6366863L6?C+ 65@C6+4:@3+?03+404622109,?@?06+2,= ) :,1!13=+260,,24:1<0:+?1@30+2+0?13=,3 =60,=#$"##"#A6??,=+2'1"&") #"##3,<,33,= 01 691B, @2=,3 0:, ?+7+563 4+34@7?0624,? :6= D@6?:,= 0:, 210+4, 62= 0:, 210+<+460+12 ;+0: 6 =+3,40+12 01 0:, 3,?A12=,20 ! ,A@0> 177+??+12,3 01 +2+0+60, 0:, A314,,=+28? @2=,3 0:, 6AA5+4695, 62= 4D@+?+0+12 40 +< - 7 - 0:,,A@0> 177+??+12,3=,4+=,? 01 64D@+3,0:, 562= <13 ?6+=A@3A1?, $ :, <640? 263360,= 691B, 9,+28 ?+7+563 01 0:, 12, +2B15B,= +2 ?6+= 46?, 0:+? 1@30 =1,? 210 <+2= 62> 3,6?1201=+<<,3<3170:,?67,,24, 0:,<1551;+28 + '3+0,0+0+12+? ++ 10+<+460+12 =60,= $"#"## A31=@4,= +2 22,H@3,! +??@,= 9> 3,?A12=,20 1# J ,A@0> 177+??+12,3 6? ;,55 6? A3,5+7+263> 210+<+460+12 =60,= "#"## +??@,= 9> 3,?A12=,20 1 6? A,3 22,H@3,! 63,D@6?:,=010:,,H0,201<# 8@206?1<562=+2 >1& #9,5128+2801 0:,A,0+0+12,3 +++ ,?A12=,201&+?=+3,40,=01412?+=,30:, 3,A3,?,2060+12 19I,40+12 1< 0:, A,0+0+12,3 A31=@4,= 60 22,H@3,?! 62= 62= 6<0,3 - 8 - :15=+28 62 ,2D@+3> 6? 4120,7A560,= @2=,3 56; A6?? 13=,3 0:,3,12 12, ;6> 13 0:, 10:,3 62= 4177@2+460, 0:, ?67, +2 ;3+0+28010:,A,0+0+12,3 +B 13 0:, A@3A1?, 1< 412B,2+,24, A,0+0+12,3 +?605+9,30>01?@97+06<3,?:3,A3,?,2060+12 65128 ;+0: 0:, 3,D@+3,= =14@7,20? ;+0:+2 <+<0,,2=6>?<3170:,=60,1<3,4,+A01<0:, 4,30+<+,=41A>1<0:+?13=,3 B ,?A12=,20 1# ?:655 @2=,306C, 0:, ,H,34+?, 6? =+3,40,= 691B, 62= A6?? 6AA31A3+60, 13=,3? ;+0:+2 & 7120:? <317 0:, =60, 1< A,0+0+12,3 ?@97+00+28 0:, 3,A3,?,2060+126?691B, B+ <0,3 ,2D@+3> +< +0 +? <1@2= 0:60 0:, A,0+0+12,3+?+2=,,=0:,1;2,3+2A1??,??+12 1< 0:, 562= +2 >1& # 7,6?@3+28 # - 9 - 8@206? 6? 456+7,= :+? 267, ?:655 9, 3,?013,=+20:,3,B,2@,3,413=? () &# #' % ' +?01 51&#