Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58614 (KAR)
GANAPATHI AND ORS v. SANTOSH AND ANR
MFA/202156/2024 · 2025-09-22
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58614 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58614 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$ % %
""
&%' ()
"" *
(
)
! "
# $
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
&$'$ (
! )
#
" #
" ! %
*$'$
""
&$
(
)
"
+
# ! "
"
, ! "
" $,
"
"
)
" )# -
)
- 3 -
#
") %
*(
)
# $
! "
%
&$'$ (
! - 4 -
)
#
" #
" ! %
*$'$
""
&$ (
)
"
+
# ! "
"
, ! "
" ) # - $-
) #
" ) %
. "
)#
/)
- 5 -
$
" 0$ 12 31456 78 94:1;:<=2 255>1<? 5<@:<95;5<= 03 90;A5<2:=10< :2 :B:C656 1< =@5 DE6?;5<= :<6 :B:C6 6:=56 - A:2256 1< 0$, 78 5<10C 1F14 )E6?5 :<6 661=10<:4 :2:F:>:48:<
" 0' 12 31456 78 94:1;:<=2 255>1<?5<@:<95;5<=0390;A5<2:=10<:2:B:C6561<=@5 DE6?;5<= :<6 :B:C6 6:=56 - A:2256 1< 0$- 78 5<10C 1F14 )E6?5 :<6 661=10<:4 :2:F:>:48:<
":9=2 45:61<? =0 3145 94:1; A5=1=10<2 :C5 :2 E<65C+
@:=0<$:=:70E=A;6595:256* @:C;:<<: B:2 C161<? G ;0=0C 98945 75:C1<? 0 &$ &'$ :<6 9@146 *:HE;:< :<6 @:<<FF: B5C5 A14410<C165C2#@5<=@58C5:9@56<5:C@E;:<2ECF144:?5 :==@:==1;5:CE=1B13=I :C75:C1<?0&'
& '$9:;53C0;0AA021=52165:<6@5B:26C1F1<?=@59:C
- 6 -
1<C:2@:<6<5?41?5<=;:<<5C:<6402=90<=C04:<66:2@56 =0=@5;0=0C989452:C52E4=03:99165<=:HE;:<:<6 @:<:FF: 6156 :<6 @:C;:<<: 2E2=:1<56 25F5C5 1<DEC152 :<6@5@:2:42061560<=@52A0=5?:4C5AC525<=:=1F5203 6595:256 @:F5 31456 94:1; A5=1=10<2 @5 C17E<:4 @:2 :2252256 90;A5<2:=10< :<6 A:2256 :B:C6 4:1;:<=2 @:F5 31456 =@525 :AA5:42 255>1<? 5<@:<95;5<= 03 90;A5<2:=10<
5:C<56 90E<254 30C :AA544:<=2 1<
" 0$B0E4690<=5<6=@:=:HE;:<B@061561< =@5:99165<=B:2:?5685:C2:20<=@56:=503:99165<= 2 A5C DE6?;5<= 03 0<.745 A5H 0EC= 1< =@5 9:25 03 ! " #$%& & '#=@5 ;0<=@481<90;503=@59@146@:2=075=:>5<:=2$& :<6 ;E4=1A415C =0 75 :AA4156 := 7:256 0< =@5 3:=@5C.2 :?5 :<6 :?5 03 =@5 3:=@5C B:2 85:C2 @5 3EC=@5C 90<=5<656 =@:= 94:1;:<=2 751<? 3:=@5C =B0 212=5C2 :<6 ?C:<6;0=@5C:C55<=1=456=090<20C=1E;:<6=@5C17E<:4
1 In Civil Appeal No.3595/2024 decided on 08.08.2025. - 7 -
@:2 5CC56 1< <0= :B:C61<? 90<20C=1E; :<6 :B:C61<? 0<48 40220340F5:<6:3359=10<:=2$=@=@5252@5 AC:856=0:440B=@5:AA5:4
$ 5:C<56 90E<254 30C :AA544:<=2 1<
" 0' B0E46 90<=5<6 =@:= =@5 6595:256 B:2 :?56 $ 85:C2 :<6=@5 C17E<:4 @:2C1?@=48 =:>5< 1<90;5 := 2-& :<6 C1?@=48 :AA4156 ;E4=1A415C @5 3EC=@5C 90<=5<656 =@:= =@5 C17E<:4 @:2 <0= :B:C656 3E=EC5AC02A59=E2B@19@12C5JE1C56=075:B:C656:=K 4:1;:<=2:C530EC1<<E;75C:<6=@58:C565A5<6:<=203 =@5 6595:256 :<6 =@5C530C5 656E9=10<2 =0 75 =:>5< := =@:2:?:1<2=C6=:>5<78=@5=C17E<:4@5=C17E<:4 @:2<0=:B:C65690<20C=1E;=0:4494:1;:<=2@53EC=@5C 90<=5<656=@:==@5C17E<:4@:25CC561<:B:C61<?1<=5C52= 3C0; =@5 6:=5 03 DE6?;5<= 1< 70=@ 94:1; A5=1=10<2 :<6 AC:82 =0 :B:C6 1<=5C52= 3C0; =@5 6:=5 03 A5=1=10< #1=@ =@5252@5AC:856=0:440B=@5:AA5:4
5:C<56 90E<254 30C C52A0<65<= 0 B0E46 90<=5<6 =@:= =@5 C17E<:4 90<2165C1<?
=@5 DE6?;5<= 03
- 8 -
0<.745 A5H 0EC= 1< =@5 9:25 03 ( ) & ' @:2 C1?@=48 :B:C656 90;A5<2:=10<30C40220365A5<65<981<=@59:250365:=@ 03 :HE;:< B@0 B:2 :?56 85:C2 5 3EC=@5C 90<=5<656=@:=94:1;:<=2751<?212=5C2:<6?C:<6;0=@5C :C5<0=5<=1=45690<20C=1E; 53EC=@5C90<=5<656=@:=1< =@59:250365:=@03@:C;:<<:=@5C17E<:4@:25CC561< =:>1<?=@51<90;5:=2-&:<61=12B1=@0E=:<87:212 :<6:2A5C9@:C=AC5A:C5678=@545?:45CF1952E=@0C1=8 30C25==45;5<=03612AE=521<0>*:6:4:=@=@5<0=10<:4 1<90;5 12 31H56 30C =@5 85:C $ 12 2'& @5 90;A5<2:=10<:B:C65678=@5C17E<:4E<65C0=@5C@5:62 :C5DE2=:<6AC0A5C
, :F1<? @5:C6 45:C<56 90E<2542 =@12 0EC= @:2 A5CE256 1;AE?<56 DE6?;5<=2 :<6 0=@5C ;:=5C1:42 A4:956 0<C590C6
(
&%
( '
' @5 6595:256&:HE;:< B:2 :?56 85:C2 :2 0<=@56:=503:99165<=4:1;:<=0123:=@5C94:1;:<=
2 Reported in (2014) 1 SCC
- 9 -
02:<6:C5212=5C2:<694:1;:<=012?C:<6;0=@5C 03=@56595:256:HE;:< -
<=@59:25() &*$&+"=@5 0<.745 A5H0EC=@:2=:>5<<0=10<:41<90;503=@56595:256:= 2&@52:169:259:;5=07565916561<=@585:C :<6=@594:1;A5=1=10<A5C=:1<2=0=@585:C-- < =@59:250<@:<6=@5:99165<=@:2=:>5<A4:951<=@585:C $@5C512?:A0385:C21<75=B55<=@5:99165<=1< =@59:2503() &*$&+:<6=@5AC525<=9:25
@5 0<.745 EAC5;5 0EC= 1< =@5 9:25 03 2EAC:!@:2@546:2E<65C&
! """#$ %$ & '
- 10 -
( (
(
)*+,
,
-
. (
)** ,
* / ! """#$
0
1
)
. +*
! 2""""#$ ! +""""
'
3 ( 456")27 )* ('' *8"79
! :""""#$ 1
& ' ! )"""# /
- 11 -
& '
1
,
& '
! )"""#$ &
! 8"""" 1
1
! )"""#$
! 82""""#$;
<=@52:169:25 0<.745A5H0EC=@:2=:>5< ;0<=@48 1<90;5 03 9@146 := 2$& :<6 :AA4156 ;E4=1A415C$90<2165C1<?=@5;0=@5C.2:?50385:C2 < =@5 9:25 0< @:<6 =@5 ;0=@5C 12 <0= 94:1;:<= 4:1;:<= 0123:=@5C:<6@512:?5685:C2:<690<2165C1<?=@5 2:;5;E4=1A415C:AA419:74512C61<90;5@:2=075 656E9=56 =0B:C62 A5C20<:4 5HA5<252 03 =@5 6595:256 & 9@146 < F15B 03 =@5 :70F5 4022 03 65A5<65<98 =0 75 =:>5<:2E<65C+
2$&HHHL2&
- 12 -
@5=C17E<:4@:20<48:B:C6563E<5C:45HA5<252 1< 2E; 03 2& 4:1;:<=2 :C5 5<=1=456 =0 3E<5C:4 5HA5<2521<2E;032$&:<640220352=:=51<2E;
03 2$& @5 C17E<:4 @:2 :B:C656 : 2E; 03 2$& =0B:C62 40F5 :<6 :3359=10< 4:1;:<= 0 751<? 3:=@5C 03 =@5 6595:256 *9@146 12 5<=1=456 =0 3141:4 90<20C=1E;032&4:1;:<=02:<6:C5=B0 ;1<0C 212=5C2 03 =@5 6595:256 *:HE;:< @5 2:16 =B0 212=5C2 @:F5 402= 40F5 :<6 :3359=10< 90;A:<10<2@1A :<6 204:=1E; 03 =@51C 7C0=@5C 6595:256&:HE;:< @5C530C5 94:1;:<= 02 :<6 :C5 :420 5<=1=456 =0 90<20C=1E; 03 2& 5:9@ 4:1;:<= 0 751<?
?C:<6 ;0=@5C 03 =@5 6595:256 &9@146 B@0 @:2 402= 40F5 :<6 :3359=10< 90;A:<10<2@1A:<6204:=1E;6E5=0=@565:=@03@5C?C:<6 9@146 @5C530C5 2@5 12 :420 5<=1=456 =0 90<20C=1E; 2& <F15B03=@5:70F594:1;:<=2:C55<=1=456 =0=0=:490;A5<2:=10<:2E<65C+
- 13 -
+ ,-./ 01,2/-342 42 /
0220365A5<65<98 &
0<20C=1E; &
"E<5C:4HA5<252 $&
0220352=:=5 $& 3-+ *5(
< F15B 03 =@5 :70F5 94:1;:<=2 :C5 5<=1=456 =0=:4 90;A5<2:=10< 03 /*5( :?:1<2= / ( :2 :B:C65678=@5C17E<:4
*(
&%6( '
@5 6595:256 &@:C;:<<: B:2 :?56 $ 85:C2 :2 0< =@5 6:=5 03 :99165<= B@19@ B:2 =00> A4:95 1< =@5 85:C $ 4:1;:<=2 :C5 B135 20< :<6 =B0 ;1<0C 6:E?@=5C2@5=C17E<:4@:2=:>5<1<90;503=@56595:256 :=2-&A5C;0<=@@5C512<07:212=0=@5C17E<:4 =0=:>51<90;5032-&2A5C9@:C=AC5A:C5678=@5 5?:45CF1952E=@0C1=830C25==45;5<=03612AE=521<0>& :6:4:=@ =@5 <0=10<:4 1<90;5 30C =@5 85:C $ 12
- 14 -
2'&4:1;:<=2:C55<=1=456=03E=EC5AC02A59=E2:= K :2 A5C ,$! ' -. 0<2165C1<? =@5 :?5 03 =@5 6595:256 ;E4=1A415C :AA419:745 12 2 65A5<6:<=2 :C5 30EC 1< <E;75C656E9=10<=0B:C62A5C20<:45HA5<25212=@ < F15B03=@5:70F540220365A5<65<9812:2E<65C+
2'& M K L 2''& H H H L2-&
$ 4:1;:<=2 751<? B135 :<6 =@C55 9@146C5< :C5 5<=1=456 =0 90<20C=1E; 1< 2E; 03 2& 5:9@ 15 2& :2 :?:1<2= 2& :B:C656 78 =@5 C17E<:4 @5 =C17E<:4 @:2 C1?@=48 :B:C656 3E<5C:4 5HA5<2521<2E;032$&:<640220352=:=51<2E; 03 2$ < F15B 03 =@5 :70F5 94:1;:<=2 :C5 5<=1=456=0=0=:490;A5<2:=10<:2E<65C+
3 Reported in AIR 2017 SUPREME COURT 5157
- 15 -
+ ,-./ 01,2/-342 42 /
0220365A5<65<98 -&
0<20C=1E; &
"E<5C:4HA5<252 $&
0220352=:=5 $& 3-+
6(
<F15B03=@5:70F594:1;:<=2:C55<=1=456=0=0=:4 90;A5<2:=10<03/ 6(:?:1<2=/(:2 :B:C65678=@5C17E<:4
, 4:1;:<=2 1<70=@9:252!:C55<=1=4561<=5C52=3C0; =@56:=503A5=1=10<=1441=2C5:41N:=10<@5=C17E<:4@:25CC561< :B:C61<? 1<=5C52= 3C0; =@5 6:=5 03 DE6?;5<= 4:1;:<=2 :C5 5<=1=456=01<=5C52=:=C:=503KA5C:<<E;3C0;=@56:=503 A5=1=10<=1441=2C5:41N:=10<
'
<F15B03=@5:70F5=@530440B1<? 1! 0=@:AA5:42:C5 /&
11! 4:1;:<=2 1< 0$, :C5 5<=1=456 =0 =0=:4 90;A5<2:=10<032'&:2:?:1<2=2$$&
- 16 -
:2 :B:C65678 =@5 C17E<:4 B1=@ 1<=5C52= := =@5 C:=5 03 KA5C:<<E;3C0;=@56:=503A5=1=10<=144C5:41N:=10< 111! 4:1;:<=2 1< " 0$ 0$,! :C5 <0= 5<=1=456 =0 1<=5C52= 30C =@5 654:8 A5C106 03 $'$ 6:821<3141<?:AA5:4:2A5C0C65C6:=56$ 1F! 4:1;:<=2 1< " 0' 0$-! :C5 5<=1=456=0 =0=:4 90;A5<2:=10< 03 2-& :2 :?:1<2=2&:2:B:C65678=@5C17E<:4B1=@ 1<=5C52= := =@5 C:=5 03 KA5C :<<E; 3C0; =@56:=503 A5=1=10<=144C5:41N:=10< F! 4:1;:<=2 1< 0$- :C5 <0= 5<=1=456 =0 1<=5C52=30C=@5654:8A5C10603$'$6:821<3141<?:AA5:4 :2A5C0C65C6:=56$ F1! @5 0C65C 03 =@5 C17E<:4 C5?:C61<? 2@:C5 03 :B:C6 :;0E<=:<60C65C0365A021=12C5;:1<56E<:4=5C56
.( & % %' $
12=040,