- 1 - ! " " #$ " #$ "" %& ' ! " # $ % ! & #$ && '& ( ' ) # & Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # '((' * % ! # # ' + # # $ ' !$ # , ' # - # . . / / $ ! ./ $ 012344536127834456639:192;<39=5=>?4398=36619@ 19 A;52:1>9 :05 B;C@?59: C3:5C , 19 >' 43225C 78 CC6 591>< 1D16 ;C@5 39C ?46>8552 >?45923:1>9 >??1221>95< 3: 1C3< !E><20><:F:05>??1221>95<G$>9:05@<>;9C>E6137161:8 - 3 - 53<C ?: <55:1 3:16 56H;9C1 653<95C =>;925634453<19@E><:0534456639:I192;<39=5=>?4398 39C?:32D3<3B 3:0653<95C=>;925634453<19@E>< :05 =3D53:><'<524>9C59: > 39C <1 #55<393@>;C3 36143:16653<95C=>;925634453<19@E><<524>9C59:> ?: <55:1 3:16 56H;9C1 D505?59:68 2;7?1:2 :03: :012 344536 12 E165C >9 :J> @<>;9C2 1<2:68 >9 :05 @<>;9C :03: :05<5 12 9> B;<36 <563:1>92014 75:J559 :05 <524>9C59:>39C<524>9C59:>155?46>85539C 5?46>85< 39C :05 <524>9C59: > J32 9>: 4>2252219@ 398D361C39C5EE5=:1D5C<1D19@61=59=5:>C<1D5:05D501=65 2 2;=0 :05 =631? 45:1:1>9 E165C ;9C5< ?46>8552 >?45923:1>9 =: !E>< 20><: F:05 =:G$ 12 9>: ?319:319376539C613765:>75<5B5=:5C ( > 2;72:39:13:5 :05 =>9:59:1>9 :05 653<95C =>;9256032<5E5<<5C:>:05>61=5<5=><C215 32J566 32=03<@52055:J05<5191:123665@5C:03::05<524>9C59: > 36>9@ J1:0 >:05<2 J5<5 4<>=55C19@ 19 :05 3< - 4 - 756>9@19@ :> <524>9C59: > 05 34456639:'192;<39=5 =>?4398032<3125CE>66>J19@2;72:39:136A;52:1>92>E63J J01=0<53C232;9C5<. 1 05:05< :05 >??1221>95< E>< :05 ?46>8552 >?45923:1>9 12 B;2:1E15C 19 23CC619@ 6137161:8 3@3192: :05 34456639: :0>;@0 :05 C5=5325C J32 9>: 0>6C19@ D361C 39C 5EE5=:1D5 C<1D19@ 61=59=5 3: :05 :1?5 >E 3==1C59:K 11 05:05< :05 >??1221>95< E>< :05 ?46>8552 >?45923:1>9 B;2:1E15C 19 0>6C1@ :03: :05<5 5L12:2 :05 5?46>8?59: <563:1>92014 75:J559 :05 C5=5325C 39C <524>9C59:>K 111 05:05< :05 >??1221>95< E>< :05 ?46>8552 >?45923:1>9 B;2:1E15C 19 =>921C5<19@ :05 ?>9:068 J3@5 >E :05 C5=5325C 3: 2' 19 :05 37259=5 >E ?>9:068 19=>?5 4<>>E 39C @<39:19@ =>?45923:1>9>E 2,,'KK - 5 - ==><C19@68 2>;@0: :> 366>J :05 344536 392J5<19@ :05 2;72:39:136 A;52:1>92 >E 63J 19 E3D>;< >E :05 34456639:'192;<39=5=>?4398 5E;:19@ :05 2;7?1221>9 >E 653<95C =>;9256 34453<19@E><:0534456639:<132D3<3B 3:0J1:0366 D505?59=52;7?1::5C:03::053==1C59:032:3H59463=5>9 15 3E:5< :05 3?59C?59: :> :05 =: >E3<322363<8><19=>?512=>9=5<95C:05=3461?1:032 7559<563L5C3E:5<3?59C?59:0>;@0:05=>9:59:1>9>E <1D19@ 159=5 032 7559 :3H59 78 :05 653<95C =>;9256 34453<19@ E>< :05 34456639:'192;<39=5 =>?4398 :05 ><1@1936 <1D19@ 1=59=5 032 7559 4<>C;=5C 36>9@ J1:0 ?5?>75E><5:05>??1221>95<>9J01=0J32 :3H59 >9<5=><C 39C :05 23?5 12 3D3163765 19 :05 <5=><C 9 :03: D15J >E :05 ?3::5< :05 =>9:59:1>9 <5@3<C19@ 9> D361C39C5EE5=:1D561=59=5C>529>:0>6C398J3:5< , >E3< 32 B;<36 <563:1>92014 12 =>9=5<95C :05 <524>9C59: > :05 >J95< >E :05 D501=65 34453<5C 39C - 6 - E165C 012 2:3:5?59: >E >7B5=:1>92 9>: C59819@ :05 5?46>8?59:39C:0519B;<5C320125?46>85515C<1D5< 9 :0525 =1<=;?2:39=52 1: 12 9>: >459 E>< :05 192;<39=5 =>?4398 :> =>9:59C :03: :05<5 12 9> 5D1C59=5 >E B;<36 <563:1>92014 05 3C?1221>92 78 J38 >E 2:3:5?59: >E >7B5=:1>9278:055?46>85<12?><5:0392;EE1=159::>4<>D5 :05B;<36<563:1>9201439C1:129>:>459E><:05192;<39=5 =>?4398:>=>9:59C:03::05<5129>B;<36<563:1>92014 9 :0525 =1<=;?2:39=52 366 :05 2;72:39:136 A;52:1>9 >E 63J <3125C 03C 7559 344<>4<13:568 392J5<5C 78 :05 <17;936 2 2;=0 :05<5 12 9>:019@ <5?3192 :> 392J5< 39C 3==><C19@682>;@0::>C12?122:05344536 53<C :05 653<95C =>;9256 34453<19@ E>< :05 43<:15245<;25C:0559:1<5 3445364345<2 36>9@ J1:0 :<136 >;<:<5=><C2 * : 12 9>: 19 C124;:5 :03: :05 3==1C59: 03C >==;<<5C C;<19@ :05 853< 15 2;725A;59: :> 3?59C?59:>E:05=:19:05853<J05<578:05 =3461?1::>J3<C22363<8'19=>?50327559<563L5C0>;@0 - 7 - :0561=59=5J329>:?3<H5C:0523?5J324<>C;=5C36>9@ J1:0 ?5?> 39C :05 23?5 J32 :3H59 >9 <5=><C J01=0 12 <1@0:6832=>9:59C5C78:05653<95C=>;9256E><=631?39:2 3D3163765 19 :05 <5=><C2 39C :05 23?5 12 9>: C124;:5C 78 :05653<95C=>;925634453<19@E><:0534456639:'192;<39=5 =>?4398 32 :05 23?5 J32 9>: C124;:5C 75E><5 :05 <17;936362> ><3C<1D5<19:05853<:0519=>?5>E 2' 4? =399>: 75 :5<?5C 32 5L><71:39: 2 2;=0 7>:0 :05 2;72:39:136 A;52:1>9 >E 63J 19 <5245=: >E C<1D19@ 61=59=5 32 J566 32 19=>?5 032 7559 4<>45<68 =>921C5<5C78:05<17;93622;=09>:019@<5?3195CE>< :012>;<::>=>921C5<E;<:05< >J =>?19@ :> :05 B;<36 <563:1>92014 32 45< 2;72:39:136 A;52:1>9 > <3125C 19 :05 344536 J059 :05 <524>9C59: > :05 >J95< >E :05 D501=65 34453<5C 39C E165C2:3:5?59:>E>7B5=:1>93C?1::19@<563:1>920140>;@0 05 032 9>: 7559 5L3?195C :05 <563:1>92014 032 7559 4<>D5C78:053C?1221>9219:052:3:5?59:>E>7B5=:1>92 E:05192;<39=5=>?439803C398>7B5=:1>9:05192;<39=5 - 8 - =>?4398 >;@0: :> 03D5 2;??>95C :05 5?46>85< 39C 561=1:5C:0523?5E<>?01?784;::19@01?19:05J1:9522 7>L :> 2;72:39:13:5 1:2 =631? >9 B;<36 <563:1>92014 >J5D5< :05 <17;936 3: 43<3@<340 >* ;95A;1D>=3668 >725<D5C:03:<524>9C59:>239C03D59>:C124;:5C <563:1>92014 >E C5=5325C J1:0 :05? 32 >E 5?46>85< 39C 5?46>85522;=0056C:03::053C?1::5CE3=:2955C9>: 754<>D5C 9:0525=1<=;?2:39=52J5E19C9>19E1<?1:152 19:05><C5<43225C78:05<17;93651:05<19:3H19@19=>?5 >E C5=532C 3: 2'4? >< :05 C<1D19@ 61=59=5 >E C5=5325C 32 J566 32 B;<36 <563:1>92014 2 2;=0 9> =325 0327559?3C5>;:39C0;29>2;72:39:136A;52:1>9>E 63J ?3C5 >;: :> 3C?1: :05 344536 9C5< :0525 =1<=;?2:39=5232J52559>19E1<?1:152053445367519@ C5D>1C>E?5<1:212C12?1225C 05 <17;936'>??1221>95< =>9=5<95C 12 C1<5=:5C :> <565325 :05 3?>;9: J1:0 19:5<52: J01=0 12 C54>21:5C 39C 459C19@ 75E><5 :05 <17;936'>??1221>95< - 9 - 19 :5<?2 >E :05 ><C5< 1?4;@95C 19 :012 344536 15 ><C5< C3:5C, 12:>.6>. . () %" & $ () %& $