- 1 - !" #$#% &'$!' () !" # $ % & % % ' %% % % ( %% !!! % % % ) % "!!! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * % !" + % !" %% % % ! % & % ! , + & % ! %% ,* & !+ ! " %& % & , & ! - 3 - # $ % & %% % *-. % -+. - %% - ". % % +' % & , % ' & % !+ *+ & % + / % % !+ % % % % % &% % ( - 4 - $% ( ' 01 2345 61545478 49 :4;1< 2450 = 63=>13 57 <431?5 501 =@507345419 ?78?1381< 57 07;< 501 1;1?5478 :73 501 6795 7: =>73=8<16@5>=>737:4A=>=6@3=45>73673=5478 01 6795 7: =>73 =8< 16@5> =>73 45> 73673=5478 4A=>6@3= 49 B=?=85 %18?1 501 6319185 2345 6154547849:4;1<2450501:7;;7248C63=>139 ! " #$%&'()*+,,-.* " * %/ 01 +2 ! ! # 3 # )* ! " %/ 4 " ! 5 6" ! ! !! ! " - 5 - " 7 $ /!8 9 * 012345615454780=9D118:4;1<78*! !+ 0131=:513 ?135=48 73673=5739 7: 4A=>=6@3= 45> 73673=5478 0=B1 D118 <49E@=;4:41< 0131=:513 501 9=4< <49E@=;4:4?=5478 0=9 D118 ?0=;;18C1< D> 501 <49E@=;4:41< 73673=5739>B435@17:485134F73<137:50497@35501> ?78548@1 57 :@8?5478 =9 73673=573 &018 5049 49 501 945@=54785015=512=9@8<13=<4;1FF=20150135707;< 5011;1?547873875 8501F1=8204;1501312=9=;97= ?78:@9478 2015013 57 =;;72 :7@3 1FD139 7: 1C49;=54B1 7@8?4; 57 B751 48 501 1;1?54789 73 875 049 7@35 78 +! !0=96=991<501:7;;7248C73<13 * 01615454781348&7!*"!+0=997@C05 :73 = 2345 48 501 8=5@31 7: F=8<=F@9 <431?548C 501 319678<185 7 57 ?7894<13 = ;15513 D1=348C 7 %!+ <=51< + !+ :732=3<1< D>501319678<185 7+=8<57 31;1=91501?=;18<=37: 1B1859:731;1?548C501=>73=8<16@5>=>73:73501 - 6 - 8<513F=8<:7350195=8<48C?7FF45511F1FD139 7: 5014A=>=6@345>73673=5478 > 2=> 7: =8 485134F 63=>13 501 6154547813 0=9 97@C05 :73 = <431?5478 57 501 319678<185 7 875 57 =;513501B75139;495:735018<513F1;1?547897:=>73 =8<16@5>=>73574A=>=6@345>73673=5478=9613 049 ;15513 D1=348C 7 %!+ <=51< + !+ 01 ;1=381< 18473 7@891; :73 501 6154547813 ?78518<9 50=5 501 319678<185 7+ 0=< =<<31991< = ;15513 <=51< + !+ 57 501 319678<185 7 =8< 18?;791<501312450=;4957:B75139:735018<513F7: =>73 =8< 16@5> =>73 %721B13 45 49 ?;=4F1< 50=5 =:513:48=;4G=54787:5019=4<;4957:B75139=8=551F6549 F=<1 57 48?;@<1 501 8=F1 7: :7@3 F1FD139 7: 501 ;1C49;=54B1?7@8?4;78501631F49150=5501>=313194<48C 245048 501 ;4F459 7: 501 73673=5478 %1 50131:731 ?78518<1< 50=5 9@?0 =?5 7: =551F6548C 57 48?;@<1 501 8=F17:501F1FD1397:501;1C49;=54B1?7@8?4;:=;;9:7@; 7:5011C4953=54787:;1?573=;@;19 "! 13 ?7853= ;1=381< ?7@891; :73 501 319678<185 7+ 9@DF459 50=5 @8<13 1?5478 * 7: 501 =38=5=H= @84?46=; 73673=5478 ?5 ", 501 1;1?573=; 37;; ?=8 D131B491<54;;501;=95<=51:73:4;48C50187F48=5478%1 ?78518<9 50=5 501 :7@3 F1FD139 7: ;1C49;=54B1 ?7@8?4; 0=<F=<1=6637634=51 31E@1959D1:731+ !+=8< 501438=F192131=6637B1<57D148?;@<1<48501;4957: B75139 78 + !+ %1 ?78518<9 50=5 D> F495=H1 501438=F19213187548?;@<1<48501B75139;495204?0 - 7 - 637F651<50167;454?=;6=35>57204?0501>D1;78C1<57 =<<3199 = ?7FF@84?=5478 <=51< !! ! 57 48?;@<1 501438=F1948501;4957:B75139:7;;7248C204?095169 2131 5=H18 57 48?;@<1 501 8=F1 7: 50791 F1FD139 7: 501;1C49;=54B1?7@8?4; 01 =:7319=4< ?7851854789 50372 @6 9@D95=854=; E@195478 7: ;=2 204?0 811<9 57 D1 ?7894<131< %721B13 948?1 501 1;1?54789 57 501 6795 7: =>73 =8< 16@5> =>73 :73 501 8< 513F =8< F1FD139 7: 501 95=8<48C ?7FF45511 49 37@8< 501 ?73813 41 78 ,! !4549=6637634=51576=99=8485134F73<1378 501:7;;7248C513F9. 4 01B75139207918=F19=31:7@8<48501;4956316=31< D>501319678<1857=978!,! !90=;;1I13?491 50143B7519=55011;1?54789?01<@;1<78,! !:73 50167957:=>73=8<16@5>=>73:735018<513F =8< F1FD139 7: 501 95=8<48C ?7FF45511 7: 4A=>=6@3 @84?46=;73673=5478 44 01 B7519 ?=95 D> 501 :7;;7248C :7@3 F1FD139 7: =38=5=H= 1C49;=54B17@8?4;8=F1;>. $=' 0466=8=66==F=H=8@3= $D' =C=<1B@551<=3 $?' F5=;H49=8@ $<' =9=850@F=3 90=;;D131?73<1<D@590=;;875D1?7@851< - 8 - 444 01B751997?=9590=;;D1?7@851<=:513:@3501373<139 7:50497@35 4B 01 319@;59 7: 501 1;1?54789 :73 501 6795 7: =>73 =8< 16@5>=>7390=;;875D1<1?;=31<@854;:@3501373<139 :37F50497@35 "* 01 61545478139 48 &7!*! !+ 0=B1 97@C05:732345485018=5@317:J@7&=33=85757<1?;=31 50=5 501 ?7@8?4;739 7: 501 319678<185 7+ 73673=5478 20721311;1?51<0=B1?1=91<57D1?7@8?4;73948B412 7: 875 ?7F6;>48C 501 F=8<=51 7: 1?5478 " 7: 501 =38=5=H= @84?46=; 73673=5478 ?5 ", 5 49 =;97 ?78518<1<50=5=?7F6;=4854850=531C=3<2=9;7<C1<D> 501 6154547813 D1:731 501 73673=5478 =8< 50=5 501 73673=5478 0=9 875 5=H18 =8> 95169 57 ?7894<13 501 E@195478 2015013 501 1;1?51< ?7@8?4;739 0=< 9@DF4551< 5014395=51F1857:=99159;4=D4;45419 01;1=381<?7@891;:73501319678<1857+ 73673=5478 49 875 =D;1 57 31=<4;> 6;=?1 48:73F=5478 D1:731 5049 7@35 =9 57 2015013 501 ?7@8?4;739 7: 501 319678<185 7+73673=5478 0=B1 :4;1< 501 95=51F185 7: =99159 =8< ;4=D4;45419 =9 6319?34D1< @8<13 1?5478 "$ '7:501=38=5=H=@84?46=;73673=5478?5 ", :50=5D197501E@1954782015013501?7@8?4;739 0=B1?1=91<57?78548@1487::4?173875=8<2015013501 73673=5478 0=9 57 D1 0=@;1< @6 :73 875 5=H48C =8> =?5478=C=4895501?7@8?4;739=9637B4<1<@8<131?5478 - 9 - "$*'7:501=38=5=H=@84?46=;73673=5478?5 ", 738750=B157D1?7894<131<485049234561545478 0131:731 D> 2=> 7: =8 485134F 73<13 45 49 <431?51<50=5501319678<1857*90=;;31?73<501B7519 ?=95 D> 501 319678<185 79 57 *" %721B13 501 319@;597:5011;1?54785750167957:=>73=8<16@5> =>73 :73 501 8< 513F 90=;; D1 <1?;=31< 78;> =:513 <49679=;7:5049234561545478 1=381< ?7@891; :73 501 319678<185 7+ 73673=547849<431?51<5791?@3150131?73<931;=548C57 501<1?;=3=54787:=99159=8<;4=D4;45419D>501?7@8?4;739 1=381< ?7@891; 34=8=B18<3= 1<<> @8<135=H1957 =661=3 :73319678<18579" * ****"*+*!* *=8<*, 49578"! !K + 319185;> 1;1?54789 57 501 6795 7: =>73 0=9 D118 01;< 78 ,! ! =8< 1;1?54789 57 501 6795 7: 16@5>=>730=9D11801;<78 !!011;1?54789 0=B1875D118?78<@?51<D>2=>7:91?315D=;;75D@50=9 D118?78<@?51<D>3=4948C7:0=8<9 - 10 - 7<=> =9 613 501 <431?54789 7: 501 7@35 501 6=354?@;=397:50131?73<48C7:501B7519204?02131H165 48=91=;1<?7B130=9D11876181<2450501613F4994787: 501 7@35 =8< 501 ;1=381< <<45478=; 7B138F185 <B7?=51 @678 48953@?54789 9@DF4551< 50=5 501 16@5> =>73 0=9 D118 1;1?51< @8766791< 2450 + B7519 48 013 :=B7@3 2450 87 B7519 =C=4895 5 49 :@35013 9@DF4551< 48 ?=91 7: 501 =>73 =;; 501 :7@3 1FD139 7: 1C49;=54B1 7@8?4;2079134C0557B75149<496@51<D@50=B1B751<48 6@39@=8?17:501485134F73<1397:50497@350=B1?=951< 50143B751=C=48955019@??199:@;?=8<4<=51 8964517:4545 49 9@DF4551< 50=5 501 9@??199:@; ?=8<4<=51 0=9 278 501 1;1?54785750167957:=>73D>91?@348C+B751948049 :=B7@3 =8< B7519 =C=4895 04F 5 49 9@DF4551< 50=5 4: 501 B7519 7: 1FD139 7: 1C49;=54B1 7@8?4; 2131 875 ?7@851< 501 9@??199:@; ?=8<4<=51 27@;< 0=B1 278 D> = <4::1318?17:B75190@9501=>73=8<16@5>=>73 0=B191?@31<B4?5734194331961?54B17:501B7519?=95D>501 :7@31FD1397: 1C49;=54B17@8?4; - 11 - &015013501<49E@=;4:41<73673=57390=B1D118 <49E@=;4:41< 34C05;> 73 2378C;> 49 = 9@DA1?5 F=5513 57 D1 <1?4<1<48501234561545478?0=;;18C1<D>501F%721B13 501> 0=B1 ?78548@1< =9 73673=5739 :73 501 6@367919 7: 45> 73673=5478 4A=>=6@3= D> B435@1 7: 485134F 73<13 7: 5049 7@35 =8< 54;; 50143 <49E@=;4:4?=5478 49 @601;< 48 501 ;4C05 7: 501 485134F 73<139 501> ?78548@1 57 =?5 =9 73673=57390=5<719875?7F1485012=>7:?78<@?548C 1;1?54789 57 501 6795 7: =>73 73 16@5> =>73 0143 <49E@=;4:4?=547873750132491@8<13501?43?@F95=8?190=9 87 4F61<4F185 78 501 1;1?5478 7: =>73 =8< 16@5> =>73 , 73501=:731F1854781<31=9789=8<5=H48C4857 ?7894<13=5478 501 :=?5 50=5 501 1;1?54789 57 501 6795 7: =>73=8<16@5>=>730=9=;31=<>D118?78?;@<1<4549 =6637634=5157<431?5 501 =@507345419?78?1381< 57<1?;=31 5019@??199:@;?=8<4<=519=91;1?51<%18?1501:7;;7248C - 12 - 19678<185749<431?51<57=887@8?1501319@;59 7: =>73 =8< 16@5> =>73 4A=>=6@3= 45> 73673=5478 ?78<@?51<48501F78507:=8@=3>1D3@=3>! 0123456154547895=8<9<496791<7: !+* (') $ 4957 ;7!