Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58554 (KAR)

GEERISWAMY v. STATE AND ANR

CRL.A/200290/2023 · 2025-09-19

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#$ %#&## #"" ' (()"*' (** + ! " # $ $% ! &' & $ ! " # $( $% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ')*#% + $ ,&' + #% ' #% *#% &&&& $ '-'$ -&&& ' $, &&& + $ . + &# # . + % /0 122033145 60748 5/0 199:;0< 74 23 1;0 #% & 4 5/0 =730 = 5/0 301>40< <<757413 - 3 - 7;5>795 14< 0;;74; +:<80 #% 1316:>187 7; 7?2:84748 5/0 @:<8?045 <150< &,&' 94A795748 /7? => 5/0 ==0490; 2:47;/1630 :4<0> 09574; '-' 14< ')-#%=4<7140413<0B=>;/>5CDE14<09574 *#% = >509574 = /73<>04 =>? 0F:13 ==0490; 95 & B=> ;/>5 C 95DE 14< 09574 , = /73< 1>>7180 95 &&- 5/0>06G ;045049748 /7? 5 :4<0>8 >78>:; 7?2>7;4?045 => & G01>; => 5/0 ==0490 2:47;/1630 :4<0> 09574 *#% = 95 H75/ =740 = ;&&&&( 5 :4<0>8 7?2>7;4?045 => =7A0 G01>; => 5/0==04902:47;/1630:4<0>09574'-'=H75/=740 =;-&&&5:4<0>87?2>7;4?045=>G01>;=>5/0 ==04902:47;/1630:4<0>09574,=>/767574=/73< 1>>7180 95 &&- H75/ =740 = ; &&& H75/ <0=1:35 ;0450490; 195; = 5/0 91;0 74 6>70= 1>0 5/15 60748 5/0 =15/0> = 5/0 A7957? 87>3 =730< 1 ?7;;748 9?231745 18174;514:4I4H420>;4133087485/155/0A7957?H1; ;51G748 74 5/0 /;503 14< ;/0 H1; ;5:<G748 74 H1; - 4 - ?7;;74814<5/0>0=>0>0J:0;50<5/037905>087;50>14< 55>190/0>99><7483G5/074>7?0 )-& = 181> 3790 51574 1; 20> F*! 91?0 5 60 >087;50>0< :>748 74A0;5781574 5/0 A7957? 12201>0< 60=>05/0379014<74=>?0<5/15;/0H1;I7<41220<6G 199:;0< =>? 5/0 /;503 14< /0 9??7550< 188>1A150< 20405>157A0 ;0F:13 1;;1:35 >020150<3G 14< /0 /1; ?1>>70< /0> 74 1 50?230 15 4145/2:>1 5 7; ;5150< 5/155/0A7957?H1;180<)G01>;155/057?0=7497<045 14< 5/0>0=>0 75 7; 94504<0< 5/15 5/0 199:;0< /1; 9??7550<5/01=>0;17<==0490;6G=73748=7413>02>5 ' 01>40< 187;5>150 5I 9847K1490 = 5/0 ==049099:;0<12201>0<60=>05/0>713:>52301<0< 458:735G14<9317?0<5605>70<>;09:5740F1?740< ; 5 - 85 ?1>I0< F; 5 14< 7<0457=70< 5 - 74 ;:22>5 = 75; 94504574 /0 199:;0< <0470<1335/0749>7?7415748?150>713;1A17316304>09>< 6:5/1;459/;045301<14G0A7<049074;:22>5=/7; <0=0490/0>713:>551I74874594;7<0>15741335/0;0 - 5 - ?150>713;91?055/09493:;745/155/02>;09:5747; ;:990;;=:3 74 2>A748 5/0 8:735 = 5/0 199:;0< 60G4< >01;41630<:6514<199><7483G94A7950<14<;0450490< 5/0 199:;0< 1; ;5150< 16A0 0748 188>70A0< 6G 5/0 ;1?05/0199:;0<7;60=>05/7;:>5 * 01>< >7 1;1A13748 1;7 301>40< 9:4;03 => 5/012203314514<>7213I>7;/41 1<1A301>40<78/ :>5 A0>4?045 301<0> => 5/0 >0;24<045 5150 0>:;0<5/0?150>713;4>09>< 4 A70H = 5/0 94504574; :>80< 6G 301>40< 9:4;03=>5/021>570;5/027455/15H:3<1>7;0=>?G 94;7<0>15747; G14;H0>55/016A027457;745/0CD =>5/0=33H748 - 6 - - 57;5/094504574=5/02>;09:5745/15 7;5/0A7957?180<)G01>;?45/;14<H1;;5:<G74874 /730 ;5:<G748 74 1 >0;7<045713 ;9/3 /;503 15 :361>81 4 -&,& 15 && 1? A7957? 74=>?0< 5/01><04=5/0/;5035/15;/07;45I002748H03314< ;/07;874855/0/;27513:6;0J:0453G5/0A7957?H1; 45 5>190< 14< 5/0>0=>0 5/0 =15/0> =730< 5/0 ?7;;748 9?231745>0J:0;57485/037905>087;50>5/091;014<5 74A0;578150 745 5/0 ?1550> :>748 74A0;5781574 5/0 A7957? H1; 5>190< 1; ;/0 91?0 619I 5 /0> /:;0 14< 74=>?0<5/15;/0H1;=>9763G51I046G5/0199:;0<=>? 5/0/;503(5/0GH04550<:?5/0199:;0<85/0>63< ;1?230 9/09I0< 150> 5/0G A7;750< /79I?1813:>: /1>?1;5/131 G;>0 4145/2:>1 ?1>>70< 5/0 A7957? 87>3 9??7550< 188>1A150< 20405>157A0 ;0F:13 1;;1:35 >020150<3G 14< 5/0>06G /0 /1; 9??7550< 5/0 ==0490 /0 A7957? H1; ;:6@0950< 5 ?0<7913 0F1?741574 0> ;5150?045:4<0>09574-*=>H1;>09><0<1; - 7 - 20>FH/0>0;/0/1;=:33G;:22>50<5/091;0=5/0 2>;09:574=50>74A0;57815749/1>80;/00591?055/0 =730< ) /0 2>;09:574 0F1?740< 5/0 A7957? 1; 14< /0> ;5150?045 :4<0> 09574 -* = > H1; ?1>I0<1;F$7957?;5150<74/0>0A7<04905/155/0 199:;0</1<87A0412/405/0>14<;/0:;0<59133/7? A0>2/40/0;5150;5/155/0199:;0</1<5/>015040< /0> 14< 5/0>0=>0 ;/0 H1; 513I748 5 /7? 4 &,&;/09?231740<5/15;/0H1;45I002748H033 14<91?0619I55/0/;503=>?5/033080/15<1G 40/18G1;/>00H1;13;45I002748H033/013;/1< >05:40<55/0/;503/0;17</18G1;/>00/1<74=>?0< 5/0 199:;0< 5/155/0 A7957? H1;45I002748 H033/:; 5/0199:;0</1;91330<5/0A7957?87>3/0199:;0<91?0 5 5/0 /;503 745><:90< /7?;03= 1; 5/0 6>5/0> = 5/0 A7957?87>314<199><7483G75H1;>087;50>0<745/0/;503 087;50> 99:;0< 5I /0> 5 0<:? 14< 85 /0> 63< ;1?2309/09I0<5/0>01=50>5/0GH04551316:>187>? - 8 - 5/0>05/0GH0455/79I?14813:>:746:;/0G;51G0< 741>?H/0>0/09??7550<20405>157A0;0F:131;;1:35 >? 5/0>0 A7957? 87>3 H1; 51I04 5 5/0 /1>?1;5/131 H/0>0 5/0G ;51G0< => =:> <1G; 150> 5/0G 840 5 G;>0 14< 5/045 14813>0 14< =74133G 5 4145/2:>1 H/0>0199:;0<=>9763G?1>>70</0>=50>?1>>7180;/0 H1; 51I04 5 145>131G1 /0 H1; 13; 51I04 5 /7; >03157A0;D /:;0 14< =>? 5/0>0 =74133G ;/0 91?0 5 181> 3790 51574 0> 21>045; 13; 91?0 5/0>0 1=50> 80557485/040H;14<;/0H1;;04557;5>795;27513=> ?0<7913 0F1?741574 5 7; ;5150< 5/15 ;/0 74=>?0< 5/0 95>16:55/0/7;5>G0>;5150?0451;20>FH1; >09><0< 6G 5/0 301>40< 187;5>150 :>748 9/70= 0F1?741574 A7957? ;5150< 5/15 5/0G 5>1A0330< 74 2:6379 5>14;2>55/>:8/6:;=>?40231905145/0>14< ;/0 40A0> >17;0< 5/0 7;;:0 H75/ 5/0 921;;0480>; /0 ;5150; 5/15 ;/0 H1; /1A748 5/0 ?6730 H75/ /0> 14< ;/0 H1;I4H7485/0?67304:?60>=/0>=15/0>6:5/1<45 91330</7?F '7;5/0 0<790813F1?74157402>5 - 9 - =5/0A7957?87>3>09><0<6G L95>/0A7957? /0>;03=/1;87A045/0/7;5>G60=>05/095>155/0=7>;5 74;51490H/79/>01<;1;:4<0> ! "#$ %&'('%) * + , - , ! , $ - $ + " + " + .* / %0'('%) + - + ! 1 2 3 " ! 3 4 " # 5 5 5 3 #64 $7 ! A04 5/:8/ ;0A0>13 93:?4; 74 5/0 2>7450< =>?15H0>0=7330<746G 5/093:?4>0=0>>0<55/0 94<7574 = /G?04 H1; I025 6314I F * 7; 5/0 02>5199><7485H/79/5/063<;5174;0?7413;5174 14<;20>?15K1H0>045<050950<414G=5/01>57930; - 10 - 0F1?740<F 7;5/0=74132747487A046G 1=50> 51I74874594;7<0>1574/0>?0<79130F1?74157414<5/0 =74<748; 74 >02>5 199><748 5 H/79/ 5/0>0 7; 4 0A7<0490=>09045;0F:137450>9:>;0 , 57;20>57404554505/155/0A7957?H1;180< )MG01>;14<199:;0<H1;G01>;57;56045790< 5/155/0A7957?H1;741/;503:4<0>5/0;:20>A7;74=1 1><04 5/0 199:;0< 91?0 5 5/0 /;503 745><:90< /7?;03=1;5/06>5/0>=5/0A7957?14<A7957?H045H75/ /7? A3:451>73G H75/:5 >17;748 14G <7;2:50 /0>01=50> 5/0G>1?0<1>:4<5A1>7:;23190;5/>:8/6:;/0>0 13;5/0A7957?/1;45>17;0</0>A790/091508>79133G ;5150; 5/15 H/04;/0 H1; 74 5/0 /;503 5/0 199:;0< /1< 87A04 /0> 5/0 ?6730 2/40 14< ;/0 :;0< 5 513I 5/7? A0>5/15?6730 A045/:8/5/0A7957?;5150;15019/ ;51805/155/0199:;0</1;5/>015040</0>14<9>7?74133G 7457?7<150< 5/0 ;1?0 91445 60 1990250< 3I748 5 5/0 94<:95 = 5/0 A7957? 87>3 A04 H/04 ;/0 H1; 51I04 5 - 11 - 5/0 0?230 15 4145/2:>1 14< 5/07> ?1>>7180 H1; 20>=>?0<;/0/1;45>17;0</0>A79018174;55/0;1?0 & 4;7<0>748 133 5/0 16A0 =195; 14< 97>9:?;51490;759:3<6001;73G;5150<5/1514<5/0 199:;0< 60748 5004180>; H0>0 155>1950< 5H1><; 40 145/0> 14< 5/0G /1A0 51I04 21>5 74 5/0 ;0F:13 195; A3:451>73G :6;0J:0453G H/04 ;/0 91?0 619I 5 5/0 /:;0;/0?:;5/1A060G0</0>21>045;587A0186G ?1I748 133081574; 18174;5 5/0 199:;0< 4<0> ;:9/ 97>9:?;51490; 75 7; /1>< 5 60370A0 5/155/0 199:;0< /1< I7<41220< 5/0 A7957? 87>3 =>? 5/0 /;503 51I04 /0> 14< 9??7550< 188>1A150< 20405>157A0 ;0F:13 1;;1:35 >020150<3G A0> 1 20>7< = ;0A0>13 <1G; 0A04 H/730 >1?748 1>:4< 74 6:;0; A7;75748 A1>7:; 50?230; 14< ?1>>G748 /0> 14< 199:;0< ?1G >0J:7>0 ;?0 9:4;033748>081><7485/07>>0;24;767375G<:>7481<30;9045 1804<0>;:9/97>9:?;51490;1?=5/0274745/1575 7; 45 =17> 5 5>015 5/0 87>3 1; A7957? 14< 5/0 6G 1; 199:;0< H/04 75 12201>; 5/15 5/0G 60748 - 12 - 5004180>; /1A0 0J:13 21>540>; 74 5/0;0 195; /:; 5/0 2>;09:574 7; 45 ;:990;;=:3 74 2>A748 5/0 8:735 = 5/0 199:;0<60G4<>01;41630<:65=>14G=5/0==0490; 133080</0>0=>05/0199:;0<7;0457530<=>19J:75513 /1A08405/>:8/5/07?2:840<@:<8?045= 94A7957414<><0>=;045049021;;0<6G5/0>713:>5 5/1;6374<3G1990250<5/0A0>;74=14<2>900<0< 5 94A795 5/0 199:;0< H75/:5 51I748 74 5 94;7<0>1574 14G = 5/0 =195; <7;9:;;0< 16A0 /0>0=>0 5/0 7?2:840<@:<8?045=94A7957414<><0>=;04504907; 371630560;051;7<0 99><7483G 14;H0> 5/0 16A0 2745 74 5/0 C 14<2>900<521;;5/0=33H748 #7% /09>7?74131220137;133H0< #77% ?2:840< @:<8?045 = 94A79574 14< ><0> = ;0450490 21;;0< 6G 5/0 >713 :>5 <150< &,&' 74 23 1;0 - 13 - #% & 7; /0>06G ;05 1;7<0 4;0J:0453G5/0199:;0<7;19J:7550<= 5/0==04902:47;/1630:4<0>09574;'-' 14< ')-#% = 09574 *#% = 5/0 95 14< 09574 , = 5/0 >/767574=/73< 1>>718095 #777% 173 64< = 5/0 199:;0< 14< 5/15 = 5/07> ;:>0570;;/133;514<91490330< #7A% /0 ><0> 21;;0< 6G 5/0 >713 :>5 1H1><7489?204;157455/0A7957?87>3L 7;13;;051;7<0 #A% 7401?:457=14G<02;750<6G199:;0< 7; ><0>0< 5 60 >0=:4<0< 5 /7? 1=50> 12201320>7<7;A0> #A7% 92G=5/7;@:<8?0457;560=>H1><0< 55/0301>40< 0?60>09>051>G7;5>795 0813 0>A790; :5/>75G 1316:>187 => 74=>?1574 14< 4090;;1>G 19574 H75/ - 14 - >081>< 5 5/0 ><0> = 9?204;1574 21;;0< 6G 5/0 >713 :>5 H/79/ 7; ;05 1;7<06G5/7;:>5 087;5>G5;04<619I5/01348H75/92G=5/7; @:<8?045=>74=>?157414<=>400<=:319574 ,' (##* & 7;5 3 '