Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58544 (KAR)
REVANSIDDA S/O GULAPPA WALIKAR AND ORS v. GULAPPA S/O HANNAPPA WALIKAR AND ORS
RFA/200006/2014 · 2025-09-26
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58544 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58544 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
" $#% "
$#% #
""
&"'" ( )
!"#
$ $
$
!"#
%
#
!"#
$
! !"#
&'
$
"
&$
!"#
&'
$
("
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" $$
"
!"#
) *
+
%
!"#
,! !"#
%
%
$
!"#
) * $ '
'
%- ##%#"
''
- +
'
'
."
' /
'
$ $ !##%
,##
' '
'
'' ' %.#
%. , $
- 3 -
' $
#!#
$
' 0
$
' $1
'
$
2$
2$ $'
*%#
*
2$ +
3456789:;6<465=;>>7;:45<4:7?9@?76 7A=4(@."67;? B4=3
6?769:7;@?(<(?7(<4C4:6(A7?967*+ A3;::7@84@8 =37 D9?8E7@= ;@? ?7A677 ?;=7? !##% >;557?4@
(,##FG=37
??4=4(@;: 7@4(64C4: 9?874D;>9667D7A=4@8=37?7A6774@675>7A=(<=B(4=7E5 (< >6(>76=475 47 (%.# ;@? (%. ;@? >6;G7?=345(96==(?7A677=37594=4@675>7A=(<67D7A=4(@(< ?7A677 4@ 675>7A= (< >6(>76=475 F74@8 (%.# ;@? (%.FG86;@=4@8,=353;67
37 <;A=9;: E;=64H (< A;57 (< =37 >:;4@=4<<5 ;67 =3;= B37@ =37 594= B;5 <4:7? <(6 >;6=4=4(@ ;@? 57>;6;=4(@ >(557554(@>:;4@=4<<(5;@? ;67E4@(65;@?>:;4@=4<<@(" 45=3746@;=96;:E(=376;@?>:;4@=4<<(5;@?%;67=375(@5
- 4 -
(<9:;>>;;:4I;6;@?>:;4@=4<<(45=37?;983=76(<5;4? 9:;>>;;:4I;6 % 37 >6(>76=475 B34A3 ;67 E(67<9::G ?75A64F7? 4@ A37?9:7;67=3677:;@?7?>6(>76=475;@?;67;::;@A75=6;:
D(4@= <;E4:G >6(>76=475 7<7@?;@= ( ;AJ9467? =37 594= 5A37?9:7>6(>76=4754@;<;E4:G>;6=4=4(@F7=B77@34E;@?345 F6(=3765 7<7@?;@= ( B3( 45 ;??4A=7? =( F;? C4A75 ;5 59A367:;=4(@534>F7=B77@>:;4@=4<<5;@??7<7@?;@=(B;5 5=6;4@7?37>:;4@=4<<5A;E7=(I@(B<(6=37<465==4E7 =3;= ?7<7@?;@= ( 3;5 5(:? 594= :;@? F7;64@8 (%.# E7;5964@8 ;A675#89@=;5;@? (%.E7;5964@8" ;A675,89@=;5(<;8;=3;@C4::;874@<;C(96(<?7<7@?;@= (7<7@?;@=(4@=96@5(:?=37594=:;@?4@<;C(96(< ?7<7@?;@= (% F734@? =37 F;AI (< >:;4@=4<<5 37 5;4? 5;:7 B;5 @74=376 <(6 :78;: @7A7554=G @(6 <(6 >;GE7@= (< ;@G ;@=7A7?7@=?7F=B4=3(9=I@(B:7?87;@?F734@?=37F;AI(< >:;4@=4<<5
7<7@?;@= ( 45 @(= =37 7HA:954C7 (B@76 (< ;F(C7 594= 5A37?9:7 >6(>76=475 ;@? =3(57 >6(>76=475 ;67
- 5 -
;@A75=6;:;@?46648;=7?:;@?537594=:;@?5;67<76=4:7:;@? ;@?=3767B;5@(@7A7554=G=(57::=37594=:;@?5GC46=97(< =37;::787?5;:7?77?5?7<7@?;@=5(;@?%@7C76A;E74@ >(557554(@ (< 594= :;@?5 ;@? 37@A7 =37G A;@@(= A:;4E D(4@= =4=:7(6>(557554(@B4=3>:;4@=4<<5
37 67E7?G <(6 ?7<7@?;@= (5 ;@? % ;67 =( (F=;4@ 53;67 (@:G ; <4@;: ?7A677 >6(A77?4@85 ;@? =( ;::(= ;
5>7A4<4A 53;67 4@ 675>7A= (< =37 >:;4@=4<<5 53;67 ;5 =37G ;67 3;C4@8 =37 53;67 (@:G 4@ 675>7A= (< ?7<7@?;@= ( = 45 A(@=7@=7? =3;= 5;:7?77? 7H7A9=7? FG ?7<7@?;@= @( 4@ <;C(96 (< ?7<7@?;@= ( ;@? 4@ =96@ ?7<7@?;@= ( 4@ <;C(96(<?7<7@?;@=(%;67@(=F4@?4@8(@=37>:;4@=4<<5
" 7<7@?;@= (5 ;@? % 3;C7 8(= <9:: I@(B:7?87 =3;= =37 :;@?5 ;67 ;@A75=6;: D(4@= <;E4:G >6(>76=475 ;I4@8 9@?97;?C;@=;87(<F;?C4A75(<?7<7@?;@=(5;:7?77?5 B767 8(= 7H7A9=7? ;@? =37G ;67 @(= F(@; <4?7 >96A3;5765 37 >:;4@=4<<5 3;C7 ;>>6(;A37? ?7<7@?;@= ( (@ ## # ;@? 67J975=7? 34E =( 7<<7A= >;6=4=4(@ ;@? ?7<7@?;@= ( <:;=:G 67<957?
37 >:;4@=4<<5 ( =( ;67
- 6 -
A(>;6A7@765 (< =37 <;E4:G (< ?7<7@?;@= ( >:;4@=4<< (" F74@8 B4<7 (< ?7<7@?;@= ( B;5 7@=4=:7? =( 7J9;: 53;67 9@?76 (EF;G 5A3((: ;@? =3767<(67 =37G ;67 7@=4=:7? <(6 ,=3 53;67 7;A3 7@A7 >6;G7? =345 (96= <(6 67:47< (< >;6=4=4(@;@?57>;6;=7>(557554(@(<,=353;67 ,
@ >9659;@A7 (< =37 594= 59EE(@5 =37 ?7<7@?;@=5 ;>>7;67? ;@? ?7<7@?;@= ( B3( B;5 =37 395F;@? (< >:;4@=4<< (" 3;5 <4:7? B64==7@ 5=;=7E7@= ;?E4==4@8=37;C76E7@=5(<=37>:;4@=;@?594=>6(>76=475;67 ;:5( ;@A75=6;: D(4@= <;E4:G >6(>76=475 (< >:;4@=4<<5 ;@? ?7<7@?;@= ( 37 >:;4@=4<<5 ;@? ?7<7@?;@= ( A(@5=4=9=7? 9@?4C4?7? 4@?9 D(4@= <;E4:G F7A;957 (< ?4<<767@A7 (< (>4@4(@ 67:;=4(@534>455=6;4@7? F7=B77@ <;E4:G E7EF765;@?37@A7?7<7@?;@=(456754?4@857>;6;=7:G ! = 45 A(@=7@?7? =3;= ?7<7@?;@= ( 45 4::4=76;=7 E4:?;@?4@@(A7@=37F7:47C7559??7@:G(@=37>765(@5B3( A;E7 4@=( A(@=;A= B4=3 34E 7<7@?;@= (5 ;@? % =;I4@8 9@?97;?C;@=;87(<67:;=4(@534>;@?4@@(A7@A7(<?7<7@?;@= ((F=;4@7?=37?(A9E7@=;@?=375;E7B;5F(8955;:7
- 7 -
?77?;@?(F=;4@7?=375;E7FG <6;9?9@?974@<:97@A7;@? A(76A4(@ 37 ?7<7@?;@= ( @7C76 5(:? =37 594= :;@?5 =( ?7<7@?;@=(37?7<7@?;@=(3;5@(?7F=5=(57::=37 594= :;@?5 37 ?7<7@?;@= (5 ;@? % @7C76 A;E7 4@ >(557554(@(<;<(675;4?=B(596C7G@9EF7657<7@?;@=( 59>>(6=7?=37A;57(<>:;4@=4<<5 . 7<7@?;@= (5 3;5 <4:7? ; B64==7@ 5=;=7E7@= ?7@G4@8 ;:: ;C76E7@=5 E;?7 4@ =37 >:;4@= 7<7@?;@= ( ;:5(;?(>=7?=37A(@=7@=4(@5(<?7<7@?;@=(%4@>;6;=( (<B64==7@5=;=7E7@=;@?A(@=7@?7?=3;=?7<7@?;@=(45 =37I;6=;(<4@?99@?4C4?7?<;E4:GF9=?7@47?=37;<(675;4? =B( 4=7E5 (< >6(>76=475 B34A3 B767 5(:? ;67 ;@A75=6;: D(4@= <;E4:G>6(>76=475 # = 45 A(@=7@?7? =3;= ?7<7@?;@= (% B;5 :;B<9:
(B@76;@?37B;54@>(557554(@;@?7@D(GE7@=(<;<(675;4? :;@?5 7<7@?;@= (% 3;5 >96A3;57? =37 5;4? >6(>76=475 <6(E ?7<7@?;@= ( (=3 =37 ?7<7@?;@=5 3;C7 ?7@47? =37 <;A==3;=?7<7@?;@=(45;??4A=7?=(F;?C4A75;@?A(@=7@? =3;=?7<7@?;@=(B;54@;<4@;@A4;:?4<<4A9:=G4@##%=3;=
- 8 -
37B;5F96?7@7?B4=3?7F=54@A9667?<6(EF;@I;@?>64C;=7 4@?4C4?9;:5 7 B;5 =37 (@:G >765(@ B(6I4@8 ;@? 7;6@4@8 7@=467F96?7@(<E;4@=;4@4@8345:;687<;E4:GB;5(@34E;@? F74@8B4=3(9=59<<4A47@=4@A(E7;@?37@A74@(6?76=(E77= :78;:;@?<;E4:G@7A7554=475373;?5(:?;<(675;4?=B(4=7E5 (<=37>6(>76=475:(@8F;AI4@##%
= 45 A(@=7@?7? =3;= (@ ;:: 67;5(@;F:7 ;@? @7A755;6G 7@J946G 678;6?4@8 :78;: @7A7554=G ;@? (@ 5;=45<;A=4(@?7<7@?;@=(3;5@78(=4;=7?7<7@?;@=( (<<767? =37 >6(>76=G <(6 5;:7 ;@? ;8677? <(6 5;:7 A(@54?76;=4(@ (<
5. ### 7@A7 5;:7?77? B;5 7H7A9=7? EE7?4;=7:G (@ 7H7A9=4(@ (< =37 5;:7?77? >(557554(@ B;5 ?7:4C767? 4@ <;C(96 (< ?7<7@?;@= ( 7<7@?;@= ( B;5 4@ >(557554(@ ;@? 7@D(GE7@= (< =37 5;E7=4::375(:?=37>6(>76=G4@<;C(96(<?7<7@?;@=(%(@ !## <(6=375;:7A(@54?76;=4(@(<5#,### 7<7@?;@= (% 3;5 <4:7? B64==7@ 5=;=7E7@= A(@=7@?4@8 =3;= 594= 45 <;:57 <64C(:(95 ;@? C7H;=4(95 =( =37 I@(B:7?87(<=37>:;4@=4<<57<7@?;@=(;A=9;=7?B4=3;@
- 9 -
(F:4J97 E(=4C7 =( 5A67B (9= 5(E7 E(@7G <6(E 7<7@?;@= (%3;557=9>=37>:;4@=4<<5=(<4:7<;:57594=37>:;4@=4<<5 ;67 @;E7 :7@?765 =( =345 <;:57 594= 345 B;5 A6(AI7? ;@?
<76=4:7F6;4@(<=37?7<7@?;@=(F734@?=345<;:574@4=4;=4(@ (<<;:57:4=48;=4(@4@4=4;=7?=36(983=37>:;4@=4<<53767;67@( F(@;<4?75(@=37>;6=(<=37>:;4@=4<<537>:;4@=4<<("3;5 @(6483==(577I;@G53;6737>:;4@=4<<5;@??7<7@?;@=( ;67 5=;G4@8 D(4@=:G 9@?76 (@7 6((< 7<7@?;@= (B;5 =37 I;6=; (< =37 <;E4:G ;@? =37 C76G A(@=7@=4(@ =3;= >:;4@=4<< (5;@? ;679@?76A;67;@?@7A7554=G(<>:;4@=4<<("45 ;F5(:9=7:G<;:5737C76GA(@=7@=4(@=3;=594=>6(>76=475;67 ;@A75=6;: D(4@= <;E4:G >6(>76=475 ;67 ;:5( <;:57 = 45 ;:5( ;?E4==7? =3;= ?7<7@?;@= ( 45 I;6=; (< =37 <;E4:G ;@? 37 3;?5(:?=37>6(>76=G<(6:78;:@7A7554=G;@?A(@=7@?7?=3;= 37 B;5 4@ >(557554(@ (< =3(57 >6(>76=475 B4=3 7<<7A= <6(E !## '96=376 ?7@47? =37 C76G A(@=7@=4(@ =3;= ?7<7@?;@= ( B;5 ;??4A=7? =( F;? C4A75 ;@? @( 59A3 67:;=4(@534> F7=B77@ >:;4@=4<<5 ;@? ?7<7@?;@= ( B;5 5=6;4@7? 37 ;C76E7@=5 =3;= >:;4@=4<<5 A;E7 =( I@(B <465= =4E7;F(9==375;:7?77?567A7@=:G;:5(A;@@(=F7;AA7>=7? - 10 -
;@?(@:G4@(6?76=(E77==37<;E4:G@7A7554=G>6(>76=GB;5 5(:? % =45A(@=7@?7?=3;=?7<7@?;@=(3;?F(66(B7? :(;@<6(E6;E77@;@I;@?4@(6?76=(A:7;6=375;E737 3;?5(:?=37>6(>76=G4@<;C(96(<?7<7@?;@=(3767;<=76 ?7<7@?;@= (% 5(:? =37 5;E7 4@ <;C(96 (< ?7<7@?;@= (% <=76 >96A3;57 ?7<7@?;@= (% 3;5 7<<7A=7? 4E>6(C7E7@=5 4@ =37 :;@?5 FG 5>7@?4@8 3987 ;E(9@= ;@? (@:G B4=3 ;@ 4@=7@=4(@ =( E;I7 B6(@8<9: 8;4@ 9@D95= 7@64A3E7@= =37 >6757@= 594= 45 <4:7? = 45 ;:5( A(@=7@?7? =3;= >:;4@=4<<5 ;67 @(= 4@ D(4@= >(557554(@ ;@? 7@D(GE7@= ;@? 37@A7 594= 45 :4;F:7=(F7?45E4557? 37 64;: (96= 3;C4@8 A(@54?767? =37 >:;4@= ;C76E7@=5 ;5 B7:: ;5 =37 B64==7@ 5=;=7E7@= (< ?7<7@?;@= (5=(%<6;E7?=37<(::(B4@8455975
- 11 -
!"#
"#
$
$
#
%&'
(
)
*
%&'
(
)
- 12 -
+
,
-
37 >:;4@=4<<5 4@ (6?76 =( 59F5=;@=4;=7 =37 A;57 7H;E4@7?>:;4@=4<<(";5;@?8(=E;6I7??(A9E7@=5 ;5H=(H"
@=37(=3763;@??7<7@?;@=(45 7H;E4@7?;5?7<7@?;@=(5;@?%B7677H;E4@7? ;55;@?%;@?(@7B4=@755B;57H;E4@7?;5;@? 8(=E;6I7?=37?(A9E7@=H=(H
" 37 64;: (96= 3;C4@8 A(@54?767? F(=3 (6;: ;@? ?(A9E7@=;6G 7C4?7@A7 ;@5B767? =37 45597 ( ;5 ;<<46E;=4C7 4@ A(E4@8 =( =37 A(@A:954(@ =3;= 594= 5A37?9:7 >6(>76=475 ;67 ;@A75=6;: >6(>76=475 F9= ;@5B767? 5597 (5;@?%;5@78;=4C74@A(E4@8=(=37A(@A:954(@=3;==37 >:;4@=4<<5 3;C7 @(= >6(C7? =3;= >6(>76=475 B767 @(= 5(:? <(6 :78;:@7A7554=475;@?;:5(=375;:7E;?7FG?7<7@?;@=( 4@<;C(96(<?7<7@?;@=(%B;5@(=B4=34@=37I@(B:7?87(< =37>:;4@=4<<5;@?=375;:7B;5E;?7F734@?=37F;AI(<=37
- 13 -
>:;4@=4<<53764;:(96=B;5;:5(;@5B767? 5597(5;@? ;5;<<46E;=4C74@A(E4@8=(=37 A(@A:954(@=3;=?7<7@?;@= ( 3;? >96A3;57? =37 >6(>76=475 ;5 F(@; <4?7 >96A3;576 ;@?4@=96@?7<7@?;@=(%;:5(>96A3;57?=37>6(>76=475;5 F(@; <4?7 >96A3;576 3(983 64;: (96= A(E75 =( =37 A(@A:954(@=3;=594=B;5B4=34@=4E7F9=86;@=7??7A677(@:G 4@675>7A=(<(=3764=7E(<=37594=5A37?9:7>6(>76=475;@? ?7A:4@7? =( 86;@= 67:47< 4@ 675>7A= (< =B( 4=7E5 (< =37 >6(>76=475B34A33;C7F77@5(:?4@<;C(96(<?7<7@?;@=( ;@?4@=96@=37>6(>76=4755(:?4@<;C(96(<?7<7@?;@=@(% , 74@8 ;88647C7? FG =37 D9?8E7@= ;@? ?7A677 >;6=:G86;@=4@8;@??7A:4@4@8=(86;@==3767:47<4@675>7A=(< =B( 4=7E5 (< =37 >6(>76=475 B34A3 3;C7 F77@ 5(:? =37 >6757@=<465=;>>7;:45<4:7?F7<(67=345(96= !
37 E;4@ 86(9@?5 9687? 4@ =37 ;>>7;: FG =37 ;>>7::;@=5;67=3;==37A(@A:954(@;664C7?FG=3764;:(96= 45 @(= F;57? (@ =37 E;=764;: ;C;4:;F:7 (@ 67A(6? ;@? 64;: (96=3;5=;I7@>76C7657C47B(<=37E;==76;@?=375;E745 >67?7=76E4@7?B4=3;>67D9?4A4;:C47B;8;4@5==37;>>7::;@=5
- 14 -
37674@B34A33;56759:=7?4@E45A;664;87(<D95=4A737(96= F7:(B B;5 @(= ;= ;:: D95=4<47? 4@ 67D7A=4@8 =37 >6;G76 4@ 675>7A= (< =3(57 =B( 4=7E5 (< >6(>76=475 ;@? =37 E;=764;: ;C;4:;F:7(@67A(6?A:7;6:G?45A:(575=3;=5;@?%3;C7 A;=78(64A;::G ;?E4==7? 4@ =3746 A6(557H;E4@;=4(@ =3;= =37G ?( @(= I@(B =3;= <6(E B3(E ?7<7@?;@= ( 3;? =;I7@ :(;@5<(667>;GE7@=<(6B34A3373;55(:?=375;4?=B(:;@?5 =(?7<7@?;@=( . 37 ?7<7@?;@=5 3;C7 ;:5( @(= >6(?9A7? ;@G ?(A9E7@= =( >6(C7 =3;= =3767 B;5 ; <;E4:G @7A7554=G <(6 ?7<7@?;@=(4@(6?76=(>;G=375;4?:(;@373;?5(:?=B( 4=7E5 (< =37 >6(>76=475 37 64;: (96= F7:47C7? =37 (6;:
7C4?7@A7 ;@? ?45E4557? =37 A:;4E (< >:;4@=4<<5 4@ 675>7A= (< =B(4=7E5(<=37>6(>76=475@(B4@;>>7;:3764;:(96= (983==(3;C7A(@54?767?=3767:7C;@=;?E4554(@(<5=( ;@??(A9E7@=;6G7C4?7@A7>6(>76:GB34A3A:7;6:G8(75=( 53(B =3;= ?7<7@?;@= ( ;@? % ;67 @(= =37 F(@; <4?7 >96A3;5765;@?64;:(96=:(5=4=5D9?4A4(95E4@?;@?<4@?4@8 B;584C7@;5;8;4@5==37;?E4554(@53;C4@8;@5B767?45597 (45;<<46E;=4C7
- 15 -
#
= 45 ;:5( A(@=7@?7? FG =37 A(9@57: ?964@8 =37 A(9657(<;689E7@==3;=B37@=376745;5>7A4<4AA;57(<=37 >:;4@=4<<5=3;= ?7<7@?;@= ( F74@8 =3737;? (< =37 <;E4:G B4=3(9= =3767 F74@8 ;@G <;E4:G (6 :78;: @7A7554=G (6 <(6 >;GE7@=(<;@G;@=7A7?7@=?7F=373;?5(:?=37>6(>76=475
=45;:5(5>7A4<4AA;57=3;=37B;5;??4A=7?=(F;?C4A7559A3 ;5 ?64@I4@8 ;:A(3(: 7H7A9=7? 67845=767? 5;:7?77? B4=3(9= ;@G A(@54?76;=4(@ ;@? =3;= =(( =;I4@8 9@?97 ;?C;@=;875 (< 3454::4=76;AG>96A3;57B;5;:5(E;?7;8;4@5==374@=7675=(< =37E4@(65::=3757;5>7A=5B767@(==;I7@@(=7(<FG=37 64;:(96=
37 A(9@57: ;:5( C737E7@=:G A(@=7@?5 =3;= =37 5;:7?77?B34A345>6(?9A7?F7<(67=37(96=;:5(?(75@(= ?45A:(57;@G=34@8;F(9=5;:7B;5E;?7<(6:78;:@7A7554=G
37 A(9@57: ;:5( C737E7@=:G A(@=7@?5 =3;= =37 :7==76B34A34567:47?9>(@FG?7<7@?;@=547H45;:5( C76GA:7;6=3;==3767B;5@(?975;5(@=37?;=7(<7H7A9=4(@ (<=375;:7?77?;@?B37@59A3F74@8=37A;5764;:(96=
- 16 -
(983= @(= =( 3;C7 ?7A:4@7? =( 86;@= 67:47< 4@ 675>7A= (< >6(>76=475B34A3B7675(:? % 37A(9@57:;:5(C737E7@=:GA(@=7@?5=3;=B37@ =376745;A:7;6;?E4554(@(@=37>;6=(<=37B4=@75575=3;= =37GB767@(=;B;67(<;@G:(;@74=376<6(E;@G4@5=4=9=4(@5 (6<6(E>64C;=7>765(@5(983=@(==(3;C7;AA7>=7?=37A;57 (< =37 ?7<7@?;@=5 4@ (6?76 =( A(E7 =( =37 A(@A:954(@ =3;= =37G;67F(@;<4?7>96A3;5765;5@(?(A9E7@=5=(=3;=7<<7A= B767>:;A7?(@67A(6? 37A(9@57:B(9:?C737E7@=:GA(@=7@?=3;=B34:7 A:;4E4@8=3;==37G;67=37F(@;<4?7>96A3;5765;5=(B3;= 7@J946G =37G 3;C7 E;?7 >64(6 =( >96A3;57 (< >6(>76=475 @(=34@8B;5>:;A7?(@67A(6? 37A(9@57:;:5(C737E7@=:GA(@=7@?=3;=H 45C76GA:7;6=3;=>6(>76=G?7C(:C759>(@=37?7<7@?;@=( =36(983;>;6=4=4(@;:(@8B4=3345F6(=376537@59A3F74@8 =37A;57=37C76G67;5(@4@8(<=3764;:(96=45766(@7(95 4@ A(E4@8 =( =37 A(@A:954(@ =3;= ?7<7@?;@= ( 45 ; F(@;
- 17 -
<4?7>96A3;576;@?4@=96@375(:?=37>6(>76=G4@<;C(96(< ?7<7@?;@=(%
" 37 A(9@57: ;:5( C737E7@=:G A(@=7@? =3;= =37 B4=@75575A:7;6:G;?E4==7?=3;==376745@(;8677E7@=(<5;:7 >64(6 =( =37 5;:7?77? ;@? ;:5( A;=78(64A;::G ;?E4==7? =3;= 5 ###B;584C7@;5;?C;@A7<(6B34A3;:5(=3767B;5@( 67A74>=45597?FG?7<7@?;@=( =45=37A:;4E=3;=(@=37 57A(@??;G5.####B;5>;4?=(?7<7@?;@=(37 J975=4(@ (< 7H7A9=4@8 =37 5;:7?77? ?(75 @(= ;6457 B37@ =3767 B;5 @( ?(A9E7@=;6G >6((< <(6 3;C4@8 >;557? =37 A(@54?76;=4(@::=3757E;=764;:5B767@(==;I7@@(=7(<FG =37 64;: (96= B34:7 67D7A=4@8 =37 A:;4E (< =37 >:;4@=4<<5 7@A74=67J946754@=76<767@A7(<=345(96= , .
=37 A(9@57: ;>>7;64@8 <(6 =37 675>(@?7@=5B(9:?C737E7@=:GA(@=7@?=3;=>;6;86;>3(% (<=37B64==7@5=;=7E7@=<4:7?FG?7<7@?;@=(45C76GA:7;6 =3;= 4= 45 ; A(::954C7 594= ;@? ?7<7@?;@= ( ;?E4==7? =3;= =37 >6(>76=475 ;67 =37 ;@A75=6;: >6(>76=475 45 (@:G B4=3 =37 4@=7@=4(@=(37:>=37>:;4@=4<<5
- 18 -
! 37 A(9@57: ;:5( C737E7@=:G A(@=7@?5 =3;= =37 5;:7 B;5 E;?7 4@ =37 G7;6 ##% F9= =37 594= B;5 <4:7? 4@ # 37 64;: (96= ;:5( =;I7@ @(=7 (< =37 <;A= =3;= ?7<7@?;@=(4@=96@5(:?=37>6(>76=G=(?7<7@?;@=(% ;@? ;@5B767? 45597 (5 ;@? ;5 =37G ;67 =37 F(@; <4?7 >96A3;5765 . 37 A(9@57: B(9:? C737E7@=:G A(@=7@? =3;= =37 ?(A9E7@=H45A:7;6=3;=F7<(677H7A9=4@8=375;:7?77? >;4?=37F;@I:(;@;@?(F=;4@7?=37A:7;6;@A7A76=4<4A;=7 %# 37 A(9@57: ;:5( C737E7@=:G A(@=7@? =3;= B37@ =37 5;:7 B;5 E;?7 4@ =37 G7;6 ##% >(557554(@ B;5 ?7:4C767? 4@ <;C(96 (< ?7<7@?;@= ( ;@? ?7<7@?;@= ( B;54@>(557554(@(<=37>6(>76=G;@?A(@57J97@=9>(@=37 5;:7 E;?7 FG ?7<7@?;@= ( ?7<7@?;@= (% 45 4@ >(557554(@ (< =37 >6(>76=G 37 E;=764;: ;:5( A:7;6:G ?45A:(575 =3;= =37 <6(E =37 ?;=7 (< 5;:7 F(=3 ?7<7@?;@= (5 ;@? % B767 4@ >(557554(@ ;@? =37 >6(>76=G B;5 ;:5( 5(:? <(6 =37 :78;: @7A7554=G FG ?7<7@?;@= ( F74@8 =37 I;6=;(<=37<;E4:G
- 19 -
% 37 A(9@57: ;:5( C737E7@=:G A(@=7@? =3;= =37 E;=764;: A:7;6:G ?45A:(575 =3;= ?7<7@?;@= ( ;C;4:7? =37 :(;@ <6(E F;@I ;@? 37 B;5 9@?76 <4@;@A4;: A(@5=6;4@5 4@ (6?76 =( E;4@=;4@ =37 <;E4:G 54@A7 A34:?67@ B767 >96594@8 =37467?9A;=4(@;@?4@(6?76=(A:7;6=37:(;@(F=;4@7?<6(E =37F;@I>6(>76=475B7675(:? % 37 A(9@57: ;:5( C737E7@=:G A(@=7@?5 =3;= =37 I;6=3; A;@ 57:: ;@A75=6;: (6 D(4@= <;E4:G >6(>76=G <(6 :78;:
@7A7554=G <(6 =37 F7@7<4= (< =37 <;E4:G '96=376 A(@=7@?7? =3;==3764;:(96=3;C4@8(F576C7?;=>;6;86;>3(!=3;= 54@A7 >6(>76=475 A;E7 =( ?7<7@?;@= ( 4@ ; >;6=4=4(@ F7=B77@34E=(345F6(=3765;@?>6(>76=47559AA77?7?9@?76 7A=4(@!(<4@?9 9AA7554(@A=(983=3;C7=(;@5B767? 45597(4@@78;=4C7 %%
@ =37 A;57 (@ 3;@? B37@ =37 5;:7?77? B;5 7H7A9=7?4@=37G7;6##%>(557554(@B;5?7:4C767?;@?;::
(<=37E;673;C4@8I@(B:7?87=3;=>(557554(@B;5?7:4C767? 37@ =37G B767 @(= 4@ >(557554(@ =37G A;@@(= A:;4E =3;= =37G ;67 4@ D(4@= >(557554(@ (< =37 >6(>76=475 9@?76 5597
- 20 -
(5;@? =3;=?7<7@?;@=(5;@?%>6(C7?=3;==37G;67 =37 F(@; <4?7 >96A3;5765 ;@? 37@A7 5(983= =345 (96= =( ?45E455=37;>>7;:
% ;C4@837;6?=37:7;6@7?A(9@57:<(6=37>;6=475 >76957? =37 7@=467 ;>>7;: >;>765 5( ;:5( =37 64;: (96= 67A(6? 37 >(4@=5 =3;= ;6457 <(6 (96 A(@54?76;=4(@ ;67 ;5 9@?76 4+ 37=376 64;: (96= 45 D95=4<47?
4@ ;@5B764@8 =37 45597 ( 4@ <;C(96 (< >:;4@=4<<5 3(:?4@8 =3;= =37 >6(>76=475 ;67 D(4@= <;E4:G >6(>76=475;@A75=6;:>6(>76=475K 44+ 37=376 =37 64;: (96= 45 D95=4<47? 4@ ;@5B764@845597(5%;@? ;8;4@5==37 >:;4@=4<<5;@?4@<;C(96(<?7<7@?;@=(5;@? %K 444+ 37=376;@G4@=76<767@A7;==373;@?5(<=345 (96= 45 67J9467? 4@ =37 D9?8E7@= ;@? ?7A677 >;557?FG=345=64;:(96=K
% (=3=37>(4@=5<(6A(@54?76;=4(@;67;@5B767?;5 <(::(B5 4+ (4@=(
@=37@78;=4C7
- 21 -
44+ (4@=(
@<<46E;=4C7 444+ (4@=(%
@ 78;=4C7 <(6 =37 <(::(B4@8 67;5(@5
%" :: =37 >(4@=5 <(6 A(@54?76;=4(@ ;67 =;I7@ 9> =(87=3764@(6?76=(;C(4?67>7=4=4(@(<<;A=5>7695;:(<=37 >:;4@= A:7;6:G 53(B5 =3;= =37 >:;4@=4<<5 3;C7 @(= 5=;=7? =36(983 B3(E =37 <;=376 (< =37 >:;4@=4<<5 4@3764=7? =37 >6(>76=475 7HA7>= 5=;=4@8 =3;= =37 >6(>76=475 A;E7 <6(E =3746 ;@A75=(65 37 7C4?7@A7 F(=3 (6;: ;@? ?(A9E7@=;6G <;::5 53(6= =( 5=;=7 =37 B;G (< 4@3764=;@A7 =( A(@54?76 =37 A:;4E (< =37 >:;4@=4<<5 =3;= =37 >6(>76=475 ;67 ;@A75=6;:
>6(>76=475 37 ?(A9E7@=5 B34A3 B767 >:;A7? (@ 67A(6? FG =37>:;4@=4<<5A:7;6:G53(B5=3;==37F6(=376(<=37?7<7@?;@= (*<;=376(<>:;4@=4<<5+8(=?4C4?7?=37>6(>76=475F7=B77@ =37E57:C75;@?=37?(A9E7@=5>6(?9A7?A:7;6:G53(B5=3;= 7;6:476=37>6(>76=475F7:(@8=(<;=376(<?7<7@?;@=(FG @;E7 (@@;>>; ;@? 59F57J97@= =( 345 ?7;=3 4@ =37 G7;6 .!=37@;E7(<?7<7@?;@=(;@?(=3765A;E7=(F7 7@=767? 4@ =37 67C7@97 67A(6?5 ;5 >76 H34F4= 4@ $ (", HA7>= =3757 ?(A9E7@=5 =3767 45 @(=34@8 >:;A7? - 22 -
(@ 67A(6? =( 53(B B37=376 =37 <;=376 (< =37 >:;4@=4<<5 4@3764=7? =37 >6(>76=475 =36(983 =37 ;@A75=(65 4@A7 =37 ?(A9E7@=5 >6(?9A7? <;::5 53(6= =( A(E7 =( =37 A(@A:954(@ =3;==37>6(>76=475;67;@A75=(65>6(>76=475(@=37F;545(< =37 ?(A9E7@=5 >6(?9A7? F7<(67 =37 =64;: (96= B3;= A(9:? F7 A(@A:9?7? 45 =3;= =37 >6(>76=475 F7:(@85 =( (@@;>>; ;:4I;6B3(45@(@7(=376=3;@=37<;=376(<=37?7<7@?;@= (;@?86;@?<;=376(<=37>:;4@=4<<5 4@A7=375;4?>765(@ ?47? 4@=75=;=7 =37 >6(>76=475 B767 4@3764=7? FG 345 A34:?67@ 9@?76 7A=4(@! (< =37 4@?9 9AA7554(@ A= . " @?76 =3757 A46A9E5=;@A75 =37 >6(>76=475 F7A;E7 4@?4C4?9;: ;@? 57>;6;=7>6(>76=475(<?7<7@?;@=(;@?(=376?467A=5(< (@@;>>; %, 37>:;4@=4<<54@=3746>:;4@=3;C7A:7;6:G;?E4==7? =3;= =37 <;=376 B;5 ;A=4@8 ;5 =37 ;6=3; (< =37 <;E4:G ;@? =37>6(>76=4755=;=7?4@=37594=5A37?9:73;C7F77@84C7@=( =37 53;675 (< =37 ?7<7@?;@= ( 9@?76 ; <;E4:G >;6=4=4(@ F7=B77@ 34E ;@? 345 F6(=3765 <(6 53(6= (< ?(A9E7@=5 =( A(@A:9?7 =3;= =37 ?(A9E7@=5 A;E7 <6(E =37 ;@A75=(65 4= F7A(E75 3;6? <(6 95 =( ;AA7>= =37 A(@=7@=4(@5 (< =37
- 23 -
>:;4@=4<<5=3;==37>6(>76=475;67;@A75=6;:>6(>76=475B37674@ =37 >:;4@=4<<5 A(9:? A:;4E 6483= ;5 A(>;6A7@765 4@ =37 594= 5A37?9:7>6(>76=475 %! @=37F;545(<=37?(A9E7@=5>6(?9A7?F7<(67=37 =64;:(96=B3;=A(9:?F7A(@A:9?7?45=3;==37>6(>76=475B767 F7:(@84@8=((@7(@@;>>;<;=376(<=37?7<7@?;@=(;@?
59F57J97@= =( 345 ?7;=3 =37G ?7C(:C7? 9>(@ ?7<7@?;@= ( ;@? (=376 5 9@?76 7A=4(@! (< 4@?9 9AA7554(@ A= @ =3757A46A9E5=;@A75=37594=4@=37;F57@A7(<;@GE;=764;:=( 53(B=3;==37>6(>76=475;67;@A75=6;:>6(>76=475(<(@;>>;45 ?7<4@4=7:G @(= E;4@=;4@;F:7 ;@? 45 34= FG 7A=4(@! (< 4@?9 9AA7554(@A=54@A7=37>6(>76=4754@=373;@?5(<?7<7@?;@= (454@?4C4?9;:;@?57>;6;=7>6(>76=475;@?64;:9?87B;5 9@?76=37A(@<954(@B34:7A(@54?764@8=37E;==7654@A7373;? ;@5B767? 45597 ( 4@ ;<<46E;=4C7 ;@?B34:7 ;@5B764@8(=376 455975 5;=7? =3;= >6(>76=475 A;E7 9@?76 7A=4(@! (< 4@?9 9AA7554(@A= %. ?E4==7?:G =3767 ;67 5;:7 ?77?5 4@ <;C(96 (< ?7<7@?;@= (5% ;@? 7<7@?;@= ( 3;C7 59>>(6=7? =37 A;57(<=37>:;4@=4<<5=3;==37>6(>76=475;67;@A75=6;:>6(>76=475
- 24 -
;@? ?7<7@?;@= ( F74@8 4::4=76;=7 ;@? 4@@(A7@= ?7<7@?;@= @( =;I4@8 ;?C;@=;87 (< =37 5;E7 3;5 =;I7@ 345 =39EF 4E>67554(@(@=375;:7?77?B4=3(9=345I@(B:7?87(B7C76 7HA7>=<4:4@8=37B64==7@5=;=7E7@=373;5@(==;I7@;@G;A=4(@ 9@?76 :;B =( 59F5=;@=4;=7 345 A(@=7@=4(@5 4@ =37 B64==7@ 5=;=7E7@= @ 345 A6(557H;E4@;=4(@ 37 3;5 A:7;6:G ;?E4==7? =3;= @74=376 37 3;5 <4:7? ;@G A(E>:;4@= ;8;4@5= =37 ?7<7@?;@= (5 ;@? % @(6 37 3;5 <4:7? ;@G >6(A77?4@85 ;8;4@5= ?7<7@?;@=( #
= 45 (@ 67A(6? =3;= =37 5;:7 ?77? 45 (< =37 G7;6 ##%;@?59F57J97@=:G;5;:7?77?B;57H7A9=7?FG?7<7@?;@= ( 4@ <;C(96 (< ?7<7@?;@= (% 4@ =37 G7;6 ## <(6 ;
C;:9;F:7 A(@54?76;=4(@ 37 594= 45 (< =37 G7;6 # ;@? =37 ?7<7@?;@= ( 3;? I@(B:7?87 (< =37 (< =37 7@=467 594=
EE7?4;=7:G;<=76576C4A7(<=37@(=4A7;537;>>7;67?=36(983 =37A(9@57:;@?<4:7?345B64==7@5=;=7E7@= 5>76=37A(@=7@=4(@(<?7<7@?;@=(3745@(= ;B;67(<;@G5;:7?77?;@?=375;E7B7677H7A9=7?B4=3(9= 345I@(B:7?8737E(E7@=3767A74C7?=3759EE(@5(<=37 594= 37 3;5 @(= <4:7? ;@G A;57 A3;::7@84@8 =37 5;4? 5;:7
- 25 -
?77?5 @?76 =3757 A46A9E5=;@A75 ;5 6483=:G A(@=7@?7? FG =37 :7;6@7?A(9@57: <(6 =37 ?7<7@?;@= (5 ;@? %;@? ;5 3;5F77@37:?FG=37=64;:(96=4=45@(=34@8F9=;A(::954C7 594=<4:7?FG=37>:;4@=4<<5=(?7>64C7?7<7@?;@=(5;@?% (< =3746 :78;: 6483=5 9@?76 =37 5;:7 ?77? B34A3 B767 4@=;A= =4::=37<4:4@8(<=37594=;@?=3767;<=76
3(983=37=64;:(96=3;5A:7;6:G5=;=7?;=>;6;L !(<4=5D9?8E7@==3;=54@A74@C47B=37(<5>7A4<4A>:7;?4@85 =3;==37>6(>76=GA;E74@>;6=4=4(@F7=B77@=37?7<7@?;@=( ;@?345F6(=3765=375;E7A;E79@?76 7A=4(@!(<=374@?9 9AA7554(@ A= ;@? 45 4@?4C4?9;: >6(>76=G ;@? (@A7 =37 >6(>76=G45 4@3764=7? 9@?76 7A=4(@!(< =37 4@?9 9AA7554(@ A=4=F7A(E7534557>;6;=7;@?4@?4C4?9;:>6(>76=G3(B7C76 ;@5B767?45597(4@;<<46E;=4C73(:?4@8=3;==37>6(>76=475 ;67 ;@A75=6;: D(4@= 4@?9 <;E4:G >6(>76=475 =3757 <4@?4@85 ;67 4@A(@8697@=;@?A:7;6:GA(@=6;?4A=(6G=((@7;@(=376>765(@ A;@ ?7;: B4=3 345 >6(>76=475 ;5 >76 345 A3(4A7 B34A3 37 3;? 4@3764=7? 9@?76 7A=4(@! (< 4@?9 9AA7554(@ A= F74@8 345 57>;6;=7 >6(>76=475 37 ?7<7@?;@= @( 3;5 7H76A457? =37 A3(4A7(<;:47@;=4@8=37>6(>76=4754@<;C(96(<?7<7@?;@=(
- 26 -
@(B;8;4@A;@@(=5;G;@?E;I7;A:;4E=3;==375;4?5;:7?77? B;5B4=3(9=345I@(B:7?87;@?45;6759:=(<<6;9?FG?7<7@?;@= ( FG (F=;4@4@8 345 =39EF 4E>67554(@ (@ =37 5;:7 ?77? B4=3(9=345I@(B:7?87;@?>6(>76=475;67;@A75=6;:D(4@=<;E4:G >6(>76=475 @ =3757 A46A9E5=;@A75 4@ ;F57@A7 (< ;@G ?(A9E7@=5 ;@? >6(>76 >:7;?4@8 =37 >:;4@=4<<5 3;C7 <;4:7?
=( >6(C7=3;==37594=5A37?9:7>6(>76=475;67=37;@A75=6;:(4@= <;E4:G >6(>76=475 3(B7C76 54@A7 =3767 45 @( A3;::7@87 =( ;::(=E7@= (< 53;67 B7 ?77E 4= >6(>76 =( I77> =37 ?7A677 86;@=7?=(=377H=7@=(<(=376>6(>76=4754@=;A=376745(@7 E(67 67;5(@ <(6 95 =( I77> 4@=;A= =37 D9?8E7@= ;@? ?7A677 F74@8 (@ =37 >64@A4>:7?(A=64@7 (< 04>5G (;A3E7@1 >(>9:;6:G I@(B@;506483=<(6=37B6(@867;5(@513(983=3764;:(96= 7667? 4@ 67;5(@4@8 F9= A(E75 =( =37 6483= A(@A:954(@ 4@ 67D7A=4@8=37A:;4E(C76=37>6(>76=4755(:? %
@ =37 ;F57@A7 (< =37 >:;4@=4<<5 =( ?45A3;687 =37 4@4=4;: F96?7@ A;5= 9>(@ =37E =( >6(C7 B37=376 =37 594= 5A37?9:7 >6(>76=475 ;67 =37 ;@A75=6;: >6(>76=475 =37 >:;4@=4<<5;67@(=7@=4=:7?<(6;@G67:47<4@=37594=577I4@8<(6
- 27 -
>;6=4=4(@
96 C47B455=67@8=37@7?FG=37>64@A4>:75 (< :;B:;4??(B@FG=37(@1F:7>7H(96=4@=37<(::(B4@8 A;575 / 0120345674895:13&746&7;&:6&<1 <&4 , "!!- &: ;.4 "!!- 1 70= 3&<= 48 24>1:&;;&? &: 470=6< >"<&952&;&:470=6< / <6==1>&<& @61<0& 6&4 @&24 >"< &6&A&&:=>191@&24&:470=6< / B0&2&7 <0&6& C:=&: 706 ?6</ >"< .565<0470&;&:470=6<
@=3757A46A9E5=;@A7B7<4@?@(E764=4@=37 ;>>7;:B34A3A;::5<(6 ;@G4@=76<767@A7 ;==373;@?5 (< =345 (96= AA(6?4@8:G B7 ;@5B76 =37 >(4@=5 <(6 A(@54?76;=4(@;@?>6(A77?=(>;55=37<(::(B4@8
1 . *+ 2 4C4:>>7;:("!, ##!?;=7?#%#"##
- 28 -
4+ 37 >>7;: <4:7? A;::4@8 4@ J975=4(@ =37 D9?8E7@= ;@? ?7A677 ?;=7? !##% >;557?4@
(,##(@=37<4:7(<
??4=4(@;: 7@4(6 4C4: 9?87 4D;>96 67D7A=4@8=37A:;4E(<53;674@594=5A37?9:7 >6(>76=475 <;4:5 ;@? ;AA(6?4@8:G =37 ;>>7;:
45 ?45E4557? A(@<46E4@8 =37 D9?8E7@= ;@? ?7A677(<=37=64;:(96= 44+ ((6?76;5=(A(5=5
+' &" ( %
+' &#( %,+-. 45=( :(