Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58536 (KAR)

LALAPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/201520/2025 · 2025-09-08

Jyoti Mulimani

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #!$$ !! %& ! " #$ % & Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' '% % () ( ( ( " #$ & ! ' ) * ' ' ' ! ' +, -./0120/34 .00. 5620789 :6- 348 ;83.3.608-7 /0< -.4874/<-. $/.74/0=/- :6- 348 -87;60<8037 4/>8 /;;8/-8<.0;8-760 485/;3.608<!-.383.3.60.7:.98<788=.0?/!-.36: /0</@27 <.-853.0? 348 -87;60<8037 36 5607.<8- 348 -8;-87803/3.6076:348;83.3.608-7>.<8008A2-87('/0< /0< .0.3./38 /5B2.7.3.60 ;-6588<.0?7 .0 -87;853 6: 9/0< - 3 - C6/0<C6*6:%.99/?8 /0/?/<<//92=8</@ .73-.53 /9/D2-/?./0<;/C34856@;807/3.60/7;8-3485336 348;83.3.608-7E.34.0/3.@8:-/@8/7:.A8<DC34862-3 48746-3:/537/-834878 3 .7 73/38< 34/3 ;83.3.608-7 36 /-8 348 6E08-7 /0< ;6778776-76:3489/0<D8/-.0?C6*@8/72-.0?5-87 203/7 /0< .3 .7 348.- /05873-/9 ;-6;8-3C 34/3 E/7 8/-9.8- 73/0<.0?.03480/@86:74/@@/!6 /74/;;/:38-<8@.78 6: 74/@@/ 348 7/.< 9/0< E/7 @23/38< .0 348 0/@8 6: ;83.3.608-736/0<3.9936</C3480/@86:348;83.3.608-7 /0<.78038-8<.0348 6:C6* 3.773/38<34/3;83.3.608-7/0</-83486E08-7/0< ;6778776-76:3489/0<D8/-.0?C6@8/72-.0?5-87 F 203/7 34/3 E/7 8/-9.8- 73/0<.0? .0 348 0/@8 6: 488@/@@/ !6/-/7/;;/ /0< /:38- 48- <8@.78 348 7/.< 9/0< E/7 @23/38< .0 348 0/@8 6: ;83.3.608-7 /0< 48 ;83.3.608-7 D8.0? 348 /D769238 6E08-7 /0< ;6778776-7 6: 348 7/.<9/0<7<2836<-/2?43.0348>.99/?8E80336/4/-/743-/ :6-5669.8E6-=/0<5603.028<348.-5669.8E6-=348-8/0<348C 08>8->.7.38<3489/0<7:6-78>8-/9C8/-748C-832-08<36348 - 4 - %.99/?8 76@8E48-8 <2-.0? /0< 348C 5/@8 36 =06E 34/3 -87;60<8037 E.34623 4/>.0? /0C -.?43 3.398 /0< .038-873 6>8- 348 7/.< 9/0< 4/>8 3/=80 2; 56073-253.60 6: 6>8-0@803 67;.3/9 54669 .D-/-C /@2</C/ 4/>/0 /0< !/38- /0= 83548;83.3.608-7560380<34/33487/.<56073-253.60.7.998?/9 E.34623.0.3./3.0?/5B2.7.3.60;-6588<.0?7/0<E.34623;/C@803 6: 56@;807/3.60 556-<.0?9C 348C @/<8 -8;-87803/3.607 D8:6-8 348 -87;60<803 /2346-.3.87 60 >.<8 008A2-87( ' /0< 348-8DC -8B2873.0? 34/3 348C D8.0? 348 /D769238 6E08-7 6:348 7/.<9/0<7 /0< 348 6>8-0@803 .7 .998?/99C 73/-38< 56073-253.60 6>8- 348 7/@8 E.34623 .0.3./3.0? /5B2.7.3.60;-6588<.0?7/0<E.34623;/C@8036:56@;807/3.60 /0< -8B28738< 36 ;/C 348 56@;807/3.60 /556-<.0?9C :6- 348 /5B2.-8< 9/0< ??-.8>8< DC 348 .0/53.60 60 348 ;/-3 6: 348 -87;60<8037348;83.3.608-7/-8D8:6-834.762-3 620789 :6- 348 -87;853.>8 ;/-3.87 2-?8< 78>8-/9 5603803.607 -./0120/34 .00. 5620789:6-348;83.3.608-772D@.37 34/3 348 .0/53.60 60 348 ;/-3 6: 348 -87;60<8037 .0 063 5607.<8-.0?348-8;-87803/3.607/3008A2-87('/0< /0< 063;/C.0?34856@;807/3.60.7D/<.09/E - 5 - 8A3 48 72D@.37 34/3 348 -87;60<8037 /-8 D620< 36 5607.<8- 348 -8;-87803/3.607 72D@.338< DC ;83.3.608-7 /3 008A2-87( ' /0< /0< .0.3./38 /5B2.7.3.60 ;-6588<.0?7 /0< ;/C 56@;807/3.60 /7 ;8- 348 .?43 36 '/.- 6@;807/3.60 53 :2-348-72D@.77.60.7@/<834/3/7;8-348<85.7.606: 348 60GD98 ;8A 62-3 .0 5/78 348 3/38 .7 D620< 36 .0.3./38 /5B2.7.3.60 ;-6588<.0?7 /0< ;/C 56@;807/3.60 E.34623 /5B2.7.3.60 /0< ;/C@803 6: 56@;807/3.60 -87;60<8037 4/>8 06 -.?43 36 ;23(2; 56073-253.607.998?/99C48-8:6-8348/536:-87;60<8037.7D/< .09/E /739C4872D@.338<34/3/;;-6;-./38!-.3@/CD8.7728< <.-853.0? 348 -87;60<8037 36 5607.<8- 348 -8;-87803/3.607 72D@.338<DC348;83.3.608- -?.0? 78>8-/9 5603803.607 72D@.37 34/3 /0 /;;-6;-./386-<8-@/CD8;/778< 8/-<348/-?2@8037/0<;8-278<348!-.3;/;8-7 E.345/-8 - 6 - ) 48!-.383.3.60.7:.98<788=.0?/72.3/D98<.-853.60 .0 348 :6-@ 6: /0</@27 36 56@;89 348 2D9.5 2346-.3C 36 <.754/-?8348.-73/3236-C6D9.?/3.607 /0</@27.7/12<.5./9-8@8<C.7728<.0348:6-@6:/0 6-<8- :-6@ 348 2;-8@8 62-3 6- / .?4 62-3 36 /0C 56073.323.60/973/3236-C6-/060(73/3236-C/?805C(36<66-36 :6-D8/- :-6@ <6.0? 76@8 7;85.:.5 /53 E4.54 34/3 /?805C .7 6D9.?8<36<66--8:-/.0:-6@<6.0?20<8-3489/E/0<E4.54.7 .0 348 0/32-8 6: / ;2D9.5 <23C 6- / 73/3236-C <23C 3 .7 5607.<8-8</7/-87.<2/-C-8@8<C6:;2D9.59/E3.7/?808-/9 -8@8<CE4808>8-1273.584/7D880<859.08<36/0C;8-760 48 ?-.8>/058 6: 348 ;83.3.608- .7 34/3 348 6>8-0@803 4/73/=80/E/C348.-9/0<73656073-253 6>8-0@80367;.3/9 54669 .D-/-C /@2</C/ 4/>/0 /0< !/38- /0= 835 .0 348.-9/0<7E.34623;-.6-063.586-/0C=.0<6:.0:6-@/3.6036348 ;83.3.608-7 8058 348C @/<8 78>8-/9 -8;-87803/3.607 08 -8;-87803/3.60 .7 </38< /0< 348 7/@8 .7 /3 008A2-8( 348-34-88-8;-87803/3.607/-8</38< /0<3487/@8/-8/3008A2-87('/0< - 7 - 4/>8 ;8-278< 348 7/@8 E.34 23@673 5/-8 48C /-8 -8;-87803/3.60772D@.338<DC348;83.3.608-748-87;60<8037 4/>80635607.<8-8<348-8;-87803/3.6076:;83.3.608-73.99</38 3462?43487/@8088<8<.@@8<./38/33803.6048;83.3.608-7 4/>8/D9836746E3487;85.:.5<8@/0<:6-348:29:.99@8036:/ <23C /0< 348-8 .7 / 7;85.:.5 .0/53.60 6: 348 ;8-:6-@/058 6: / <23C 0 76 :/- /7 348 ;-87803 ;83.3.60 .7 56058-08< 348 -87;60<8037 /-8 48-8DC <.-8538< 36 5607.<8- 348 -8;-87803/3.607 6: 348 ;83.3.608-7 /3 008A2-8( ' /0< /0< <.7;678 6: 348 7/@8 DC ?.>.0? 72.3/D98 -8/7607 .0 /556-</058E.343489/EE.34.034-88@60347:-6@348-858.;3 6:34858-3.:.8<56;C6:34.76-<8-4.762-34/70638A;-8778< /0C6;.0.6060348@8-.376:5/78 * 87293/039C348!-.383.3.60.7 '( %$ !!& $ % .73696))